The case between Tom Robinson and the Ewell’s seemed to have a predictable ending considering that it is very rare for a black man to win a case against a white man. But considering the great lawyer Tom Robinson was given, the outcome could go either way, in favor of the Ewell’s or saving Tom Robinson from going to jail. I was sitting in the front row ready to be bored to sleep by the jury but, instead I was surprised by the questions asked by the lawyers and the responses delivered by the four given testimonies from Heck Tate, Bob Ewell, Mayella Ewell and Tom Robinson.
During Prosecutor Gilmer’s examination he asked Heck Tate what he had seen during the case, and the date. Heck Tate responded by saying, “ It was the night of November twenty-first. I was just leaving my office to go home when B- Mr. Ewell came in, very excited he was, and said get out to his house quick, some raped his
…show more content…
Up till this point everyone in the courtroom learned that Tom Robinson’s left arm is crimped and is way too weak to even scratch the girl, let alone hold her down and attack her. As Mayella kept stating that somehow Tom Robinson was the one that hurt her he finally asked, “ How?”(Lee 249). The question left the whole room in suspense to wait to see if Mayella’s response would be valid. It truly seems that Atticus has this case in the bag. But, that was not the end of Atticus. He asked, “What did your father see in the window, the crime of rape or the best defense to it? Why don’t you tell the truth, child, didn’t Bob Ewell beat you up?”(Lee 251). It is very evident now that Atticus is very suspicious of Bob Ewell. Mayella did not respond to the question but she did insult the whole jury. Every word that girl said can not be trusted based on how unsure she is. It seems evident that she is lying. Last but not least, Tom Robinson approaches the
The fear of her father and her nervousness clouded her judgement and, seemingly, she desired the jury’s pity. Mayella addressed Atticus, saying, “Won’t answer a word you say long as you keep on mockin’ me.” At Atticus’ puzzled expression, “Mayella looked from under lowered eyelids at Atticus, but she said to the judge: “Long’s he keeps on callin’ me ma’am and sayin’ Miss Mayella. I don’t hafta take his sass, I ain’t called upon to take it” (207). Bob Ewell’s oldest daughter knew exactly what had happened between herself and Tom Robinson, and essentially, she was completely aware that Atticus might be able to wheedle the truth from her.
Oh yes that would make it her right. It was her right eye, Mr. Finch (Lee 192). This evidence shows that Mayella had all the bruises on the right side of her body which means Tom Robinson would have to use his left arm, but his left arm was useless because he got it caught in a cotton gin. BASIS OF GUILT On November 21, 1935, Tom Robinson was accused of beating and raping Mayella Ewell because Sheriff Heck Tate had a poor investigation of the case.
To Kill a Mockingbird is a book that is full of life lessons. The book opens with Jean Louise Finch, better known as Scout, telling of their family history. One day, while outside playing, they find a little boy named Charles Baker Harris, also known as Dill. These three start to get into many shenanigans, including investigating the mystery of Arthur "Boo" Radley; he hasn't been seen in years. There are a lot of theories surrounding him and why he doesn't come out, but we finally find out why at the end of the book.
Gentlemen, in the 30 years that I have been practising law in Maycomb, I have never seen a case so complicated, and so simple at the same time. Complicated because of the circumstances; a white woman’s word versus a black man’s word. Simple because of the facts; clearly no one in this courtroom is guilty besides the defendant himself, Tom Robinson. There is undoubtedly more evidence confirming the fact that Tom Robinson is guilty rather than innocent.
The racial tension in the United States was very high. Black people were killed by the Ku Klux Klan, lynching and other racially triggered violence were very strong in the south. People of color would receive poor education and have to be segregated from white people. Martin Luther King Jr. stood up for equal rights and was killed trying. From the 1850s up was hard years for colored people.
During the trial, Atticus reveals that since Mayella was hit on the right side of her face, the one who abused her must have been left-handed. Later, Scout describes an observation she makes about Tom and says, “His left arm was fully twelve inches shorter than his right, and hung dead at his side. It ended in a small shriveled hand, and from as far away as the balcony I could see that it was no use to him” (Lee 211). This observation that Scout describes adds more evidence to Atticus’s claim that Tom Robinson was falsely accused of raping Mayella Ewell. Scout’s observation also compares Tom to a mockingbird because he is physically disabled, which fits the description Miss Maudie gives of a mockingbird in the book.
Is integrity really being pursued as it is supposed to? In Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird, this topic of justice is mentioned multiple occasions. The main character, Atticus, tries to solve a rape case. The defendant, Tom Robinson, is assumed as the rapist due to his race.
In the novel To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee, the story is set in the 1900’s, Maycomb, Alabama. During this time there was racism in the south and segregation which separated the whites and blacks from everything. There was also the Great Depression, the whole country was poor and people living in the country had to trade and do other jobs for people to either pay them off or to buy something from them. The trial in this book is about Mayella and Bob Ewell, two white people, claiming and arguing that Tom Robinson, a black person, raped Mayella Ewell. This trial is really important because at that time in the south, white people took advantage of black people and their kindness and thought they would take that or shut up just because they were black.
Everyone in the courthouse on the night of the trial knew that Tom Robinson was innocent. But at the end of the trial, that didn’t matter. Tom Robinson was a black man, and because of this difference that should not make a difference, he had no say over the family of whites, the Ewells. Tom Robinson was wrongly convicted of raping and beating Mayella Ewell. The evidence of the case leads to the conclusion that Bob Ewell, Mayella’s father was responsible for this misfortune.
Despite these facts, and the fact that MayElla Ewell basically admitted to perjury, Tom Robinson was still convicted and later murdered brutally in the same way that Rodney King was beat brutally. Ultimately, black-white trials were a series of back and forth situations, he-said-she-said encounters, whose word is more valuable than the other paradoxes. And whether or not an African American individual being tried with a crime was actually guilty, if they were put up against a white person, their word would automatically be unavailing (or futile) in comparison. No matter what they said, they were still black and that was enough for most juries to
The jury came to the conclusion, with no evidence the offense happened, that Tom Robinson was guilty. Based on the grudges and resentments of those men, Tom Robinson was never going to receive a fair trial with the jury given. ANTICIPATE THE DEFENSE
During the trial, Mayella feels like Atticus is mocking her with the ma’am and miss Mayella when he is showing her the proper respect because she is a young woman. The town knows that Bob Ewell likes to drink and when he does he becomes aggressive, the town has had several incidents with Bob Ewell. During the case Mayella claims, “He does tollable, ‘cept when-” (Lee 208) To which Atticus replied, “Except when he’s drinking?” (Lee 208) Atticus knew that Bob was aggressive, and he knew that he drinks and that when he drinks he gets physical, and since there is no one to take it out on he takes it out on his children.
To Kill a Mockingbird Rough Draft The State's Attorney has decided that Bob Ewell, of Maycomb County, Alabama, will be tried on the charge of first degree murder of Tom Robinson. Although, Bob Ewell did not physically murder Tom Robinson, his actions lead to Tom Robinson's death. The definition of first degree murder is a willful and unlawful murder that is premeditated.
Tom Robinson is crippled on his left hand which was caused by getting his hand stuck in a Cotton GIn when he was 12 years old, as Tom recalled "I got it caught in a cotton gin, caught it in Mr. Dolphin Raymond's cotton gin when I was a boy....almost bled to death....tore all the muscles loose from my bones." (Lee pg 186)”. This shows that Tom Robinson couldn’t have choked her and beat her with one hand so it would have been almost impossible to do any of this. Atticus wanted to make sure the jury had no qualms about acquitting Tom Robinson. Another reason this is an important fact is, because right when Tom brought up the fact that he only had one hand the expressions on Mayella's face turned from sad to surprised or like if she committed
In the novel To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee, Tom Robinson and Arthur “Boo” Radley are two characters who represent the mockingbird. In the midst of finding who Boo truly is, Atticus Finch explains to his children, Jem and Scout, that it is a sin to kill the bird because they don’t do anything but make music. As the story progresses, and the two “mockingbirds” are being accused and attacked both verbally and physically, the identity of the mockingbirds surfaces. Tom Robinson was a crippled African American man whose left arm was a foot shorter than his right, where it was caught in a cotton gin.