ipl-logo

Simon Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

1098 Words5 Pages

Often times, there are people who were raised the same way but tend to act differently given the same situation. Lord of the Flies explores the savagery and evil that underlines humanity. In the midst of a war, a group of young British boys find themselves stranded on an island with no supervision. Without proper authority or civilization around these boys, they threw out any moral compasses they had and carried out their evil instinct that was lurking within them. From these groups of boys emerge two boys named Ralph and Simon. Ralph is perceived as a natural born leader who can easily persuade the littluns and the rest of the boys on the island to act civilized. Meanwhile, Simon embodies kindness and is considered to be a Christ like figure at the end. Unlike Ralph, though, Simon is too shy to be a leader so he finds comfort in being more of a free-thinking follower. Overall, though, Simon and Ralph are both perceived as "good" characters, differing in the type. This essay will compare and contrast the different types of goodness Simon and Ralph embody.
Ralph's goodness is a reflection of what he has learned from growing up alongside adults, and …show more content…

Ralph and Simon are similar in the way that the both of them realize the need for the boys on the island to obey rules and behave like civilized people. This is particularly obvious when Ralph undertakes the building of huts/ shelter early on. All the boys promise to help, but most of them run off to play soon enough. Only Simon and Ralph remain to finish building the shelters. Furthermore, Simon is one of the few people who shares Ralph passion in seeking a way home. When the ship passes them by because jack let the signal fire out, Ralph gets really depressed. Then when the boys go hunting for the beast, Simon tells ralph that he will get home

Show More
Related

  • How Does Golding Present Ralph From Lord Of The Flies

    505 Words  | 3 Pages

    The mannered and civilized boy, Ralph, shows excellent survival skills. He uses logic and strategic planning to gain durability in an unfamiliar environment. For example, when the group of boys crashed into the deserted island, he commenced the first meeting and started a bonfire. Another example would be how the boys would come up with assumptions and superstitions of an actual beast that exists in the island, he investigates to find out that it was actually a dead paratrooper, and uses that as evidence to tell everyone to keep calm, (although they didn't believe in him). These events all imply on how Ralph is a natural leader in any given situation.

    Read More

  • Lord Of The Flies: Was Ralph A Good Leader?

    892 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ralph was handsome and had fair hair which made him seem like a more leader like figure to the others. He also showed some initiative by blowing the conch to get all the stranded boys’ attention. At another time when Samneric spotted the “beast” (the parachutist) going through the air and land on top of the mountain no one but Ralph, Simon, and Jack volunteered to go investigate it. This showed that Ralph was somewhat brave and he showed good initiative. Out of all the boys I think that Ralph was probably the most sane.

    Read More

  • How Does Ralph Change In Lord Of The Flies

    1661 Words  | 7 Pages

    In the beginning of the novel we are introduced to two boys, Ralph and Jack, who both are english school boys. The boys both come from tightly wound civilization and have always had adult supervision. From the beginning it is clear the boys both have different personalities, where Ralph is a leader because he is obligated to be and Jack is not but fights for power. In the third chapter Ralph, along with the help of Simon, is building huts on the beach for survival. This shows Ralph wants to have civilization on the island and doesn't want to live like savages.

    Read More

  • How Is Simon A Christ-Like Figure In Lord Of The Flies

    884 Words  | 4 Pages

    As Ralph and Simon are working hard, Ralph, a hard-working and righteous leader, informed, “All day I’ve been working with Simon. No one else. They’re off bathing, or eating, or playing” (Golding, Lord 50). Simon could have joined the other boys that were having fun; nevertheless, Simon was kind to help Ralph build shelters. He stayed to assist Ralph because he cared for the welfare of the group.

    Read More

  • How Is Ralph Presented In Lord Of The Flies

    929 Words  | 4 Pages

    In general you can observe that these characters are adult-like because of their maturity and caring personality towards the other boys. Simon really shows this amazing personality because, he is portrayed as a christ-like figure. In many parts of the book Simon reassures Ralph and the other boys from fear by saying, “You’ll get back to where you came from” (111). This quote is significant because it shows that Simon cares about Ralph, he assures Ralph and lessens the fear of never leaving the island.

    Read More

  • Eulogy For Lord Of The Flies

    334 Words  | 2 Pages

    Ralph has noticed a drifting between the boys, due to both of him lacking leadership, and to the hunters’ growing free-spirited but crazy morals. He noticed the longer they were away from home, the more sanity they loss. Within the last few weeks, Ralph lost his two only friends due to the horrid actions of the hunters. Seeing Stanley killed for the humor of a hunter, and glimpsing at Simon being stabbed and torn apart both made Ralph realized that not only the voice of reason and justice is gone, but also their hope of redemption, to be rescued. Even after counseling and therapy, Ralph himself felt like those mere five weeks were dreading, endless years, as if he matured throughout time spent on the

    Read More

  • Piggy Lord Of The Flies Summary Chapter 1

    347 Words  | 2 Pages

    Ralph, leader of the group, is attempting to control everyones behavior and maintain it at what is considered “acceptable” for young boys. He appears to know what is right from wrong despite of his young age. “Ralph, looking with more understanding at Piggy, saw that he was hurt and crushed.” (p. 25)This demonstrates how he recognizes that

    Read More

  • Quotes From Lord Of The Flies Quote Analysis Essay

    1458 Words  | 6 Pages

    1. But a sign came down from the world of grown-ups . . . (95) The significance of this quote is that a warning sign was sent to the island (plane, helicopter, or some flying vehicle) but none of the boys were awake so the “grownups” were unaware about their whereabouts. The fire had died down and so did the smoke (at this current point) for the grownups to see if anyone was stranded on the island.

    Read More

  • Lord Of The Flies Chief Quotes

    955 Words  | 4 Pages

    As time passes by, he changes from a civilized person to a total and complete savage. However, Ralph, on the other hand, was more polite; he was civilized and responsible. He gave the kids, specially the small ones hope of being rescued. Since he was holding the conch, everyone felt that he would be a strong and empowering leader.

    Read More

  • Ralph's Loss Of Power In Lord Of The Flies

    1088 Words  | 5 Pages

    Upon arriving, Ralph’s primary ambition is to get off the island safely, considering the expected immaturity in reaction to the boys’ sudden loss of authority. He manages to maintain this intention regardless of his job or worth in society among the boys. As evil challenges his capability to retain this quality by the irony of the fire, breaking of the conch, and overall destruction of civilization, demonstrates his level of mental strength considering all of the odds against his favor. Having the, “voice of someone who [knows their] own mind,” and instituting an independent attitude towards his goal, Ralph displays competence and trust in his capabilities rather than depending on that of others. As displayed in his immediate need for order, Ralph establishes a plan to get off of the island.

    Read More

  • How Is Simon Presented In Lord Of The Flies

    636 Words  | 3 Pages

    This is shown through his kindness to the boys, his encounter at his own personal, mysterious area, his peace and vision, and his saintly Christ-like characterization. When Ralph first encounters Simon, it is when he faints while under Jack Merridew’s authority. Ralph describes Simon’s eyes “so bright they had deceived Ralph into thinking him delightfully gay and wicked.” (Golding 67).

    Read More

  • Evil Is Within Everyone Lord Of The Flies Analysis

    902 Words  | 4 Pages

    Even though Simon warns them about the evil inside them, their actions still reflect their inherently bad human nature. As the time on the island goes by, the boys kill Simon and Piggy, along with a mother pig, and a well-timed rescue is all that prevents Ralph’s death. Even if people can act good, there is still greed, selfishness, and evil within everyone. It is only through the influence of civil society that the worst of human nature is kept in

    Read More

  • Power And Manipulation In Lord Of The Flies By William Golding

    1702 Words  | 7 Pages

    Being under a dictatorship can demolish any kind of sanity one has. Now Ralph has realized what power and manipulation can do to one person. He never intentionally plans on becoming a savage, and unfortunately, he misses his dignity. In response, Boyd comments, “It is rather the coming of an awareness of darkness, of the evil in man’s heart that was present in the children all along” (Boyd 27). His elaboration explains how the beast was not only in Ralph but in all of the young boys.

    Read More

  • Human Nature In Lord Of The Flies And The Hunger Games

    835 Words  | 4 Pages

    In Lord of the Flies, Ralph was one of the most civil characters, he was level-headed and recognized the need to be rescued, as well as the need for a leader. Which is why he accepted to be the

    Read More

  • Character Development In Lord Of The Flies By William Golding

    1397 Words  | 6 Pages

    Ralph is first introduced as the fair boy who is a natural born leader. He applies Piggy’s intelligence to think of a way to summon the other survivors on the island. Ralph follows through with Piggy’s idea and uses the conch which emits a loud sound that can be hear through the island. The sound eventually lures the group of boys towards them. His leader instincts are best portrayed when he’s able to side with Jack after offering to share his power: “The suffusion drained away from Jack’s face.

    Read More

More about Simon Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

Open Document