Sioux Nation Case Study
United States v. Sioux Nation of Indians, 448 U.S. 371 (1980) is a case that involves the Sioux Nation and the United States government, and it regards the United Stages Government authority to reneged a treaty and reclaimed land given to the Sioux Nation Of Indians, and if congress violated the separation of powers clause when it amended the Indian Claims commissions in 1978.
The Sioux nation was a collection of tribes united in a confederacy in the States of South Dakota, North Dakota, Nebraska, and Minnesota. In 1868 the Sioux Nation signed the Fort Laramie treaty that granted them the Sioux Nation reservation in South Dakota, including the Black Hills, but took away all of their lands positions outside of the reservation. The United
…show more content…
This was believe by the Sioux nation to be a complete violation of the treaty of Laramie in 1868. In 1920 the Sioux Nation argue in the United States Court claims the Act of 1877 was unconstitutional because it violated the treaty of Laramie, and the 5th Amendment because the compensation that the Sioux nation received were unjust. The claimed was dismissed in the United Stated court of claims because the court claimed that it did not have subject matter jurisdiction under the 1920 ACT to asses if the compensation given to the Sioux Nation for the Black hills was adequate.
However, In 1946 under the Indians Claims Commission the Sioux Nation resubmitted their petition that claim that the Sioux Nation were entitle to just compensation under the Just compensation clause of the 5th amendment. The Indian Claims Commission found that the Nation was not barred from submitting claim under res judicata and were entitle to de novo trial. The Indian Claims Commission decided that the Sioux Nation were entitle to 17 million dollars of just
Mississippi Band Of Choctaw Indians Case Study
313 Words | 2 PagesThe United States Government formally recognizes over five hundred tribes within the fifty states. These recognized tribes are qualified for funding and other various services through grants and contracts with the government along with other sources. The Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians represents one of the federally recognized tribes in the United States. Located in eight reservation communities throughout Mississippi, it consists of almost 10,000 registered members. Throughout the past couple of years, the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians has faced several financial burdens regarding funding for the tribe.
The Case Of Michigan Vs. Bay Mills
1718 Words | 7 PagesMichigan vs. Bay Mills is a recent case that was decided by the Supreme Court in 2013. I chose to research this case for my judicial process class because I found it interesting. It is interesting because I do not know much about the United States federal government, states and Native American tribe’s current relationship. I have always thought that Native Americans act on their own government system with no interference from the United States almost like they are a separate country/ nation just residing within the United States. However, after researching the Michigan vs. Bay Mills court case I now understand that its relationship is more complex.
Standing Rock Sioux Reservation Case Study
760 Words | 4 PagesIn 2014, President Obama visited the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation. While there, he read aloud these words from Chief Sitting Bull: “Let’s put our minds together to see what we can build for our children.” Today, it is the children of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe who have put their minds together to help envision a safe future for themselves and who are leading an international campaign to protect their drinking water — and the drinking water of 17 million people downstream — from the threats posed by the Dakota Access oil pipeline, which would cross the Missouri River less than a mile upstream of their reservation. What you need to know about the Dakota Access pipeline protests Embed Copy Share Play Video3:08 Perhaps inspired by these young people, thousands of people, predominantly from tribes around the country, have gathered in peaceful demonstration and prayer near the pipeline construction site while the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe pursues legal options to protect itself.
Sioux Warriors Research Paper
336 Words | 2 PagesThe Sioux warriors were well armed they fought using a variety of weapons ranging from spears to guns. In the past, they used clubs, tomahawks, shields bow and arrows, spears and axes. Once the Europeans arrived in the Great Plains they brought to the Indians guns and horses to get them around and guns to hunt more efficiently. Individual Sioux warriors took part in warfare for a number of reasons. Plains Indians went on raids and went to war for a number of reasons such as to steal horses, to get revenge or to destroy their enemies.
The Second Version Of The Fort Laramie Treaty Of 1868
653 Words | 3 PagesThis version surrendered additional land for the Indians, promised Sioux tribes land from the Missouri River to the Black Hills and prohibited entry of white men onto Indian Land, as said in the treaty, “and the United States now solemnly agrees that no persons, except those herein designated and authorized so to do, and except such officers, agents, and employees of the government as may be authorized to enter upon Indian reservations in discharge of duties enjoined by law, shall ever be permitted to pass over, settle upon, or reside in the territory described in this article,….". The purpose of this treaty was to abandon the Bozeman Trail and guarantee the Indians control of the Black Hills that were scared to the Lakota Sioux. This version did offer many good things for the Indian tribes but it also proposed other conditions that the Native Americans must follow, such as, “…they will withdraw all opposition to the construction of the railroads now being built on the plains. 2d. That they will permit the peaceful construction of any railroad not passing over their reservation as herein defined.
Pros And Cons Of The Indian Removal Act Of 1790
1501 Words | 7 PagesThe Act led to an array of legal and moral arguments for and against the need to relocate the Indians westward from the agriculturally productive lands of the Mississippi in Georgia and parts of Alabama. This paper compares and contrasts the major arguments for and against the
Essay On Declaration Of Independence And The Constitution
1077 Words | 5 PagesTo begin with, in Source E, it shows the map of the Indian Territory in Oklahoma, and it describes what went on. It states "Tens of thousands of Native Americans previously living east of the Appalachian Mountains were removed from their homes and ancestral lands by the United States Army and were forced to walk hundreds of miles at gunpoint to 'Indian Territory. " This goes against everything written on those two documents because they are literally forcing tribes from east of the Appalachian to all move into one state, because they want to claim all of the land for the American people. Firstly, not all of the tribes maintain peace with each other and now they being crammed into one state all together which probably would not turn out good.
Effects Of The Battle Of Little Big Horn
104 Words | 1 PagesThey were very upset with the whites’ intrusion into their lands in the Black Hills. The Second Treaty of Fort Laramie gave the Indians exclusive property possession of the Dakota Territory. Then there was a discovery of Gold on the land, causing many intrusions.
How The Devastating Effects Of The Trail Of Tears
484 Words | 2 PagesThe Trail of Tears was named so because of its devastating effects to the Cherokee nation. They were removed for one main reason, so their land could be used by the white men. Nobody had the right to take away their land. The land had been theirs since before the Europeans came and now they were being forcibly removed from it. On top of that, soldiers forced them to travel in the winter, causing thousands of Native Americans to die.
Essay On Navajo Code Talkers
947 Words | 4 PagesThis policy was meant to decrease the federal government’s involvement and financial responsibility for Indians in hopes that they would be more welcomed into modern American society (Lavin, 73). Therefore, the federal government established the Indian Claims Commission (ICC) in 1946 (Lavin, 73). The ICC created a federal court specifically designed to give the tribes an opportunity to sue the government for damages or lost land (Lavin, 73). This policy proved to be a success as the Navajos were able to elect chairmen and make much needed improvements in their communities (Lavin,
The Black Hills War
1158 Words | 5 PagesThe Black Hills War, also known as the Great Sioux War of 1876, was a series of battles fought from 1876 through 1877, between the forces of the United States and their allies (Shoshone, Pawnee, and Crow) and the Sioux (Lakota, Dakota, Cheyenne, and Arapaho). Taking place under two presidencies and resulting in hundreds of casualties on both sides, The Black Hills War made great impacts that would continue to affect Natives for generations. The United State’s extensive relationship with the Native Americans has its intricacies to say the least. With the arrival of English settlers at Jamestown in 1607, there were undoubtedly uncertainties amongst the Native people as to whether or not these settlers would resemble the Spanish settlers who
Dakota Access Pipeline Benefits
812 Words | 4 PagesThese issues can still improve through cooperation and understanding, however, and reaching a satisfactory decision about the Dakota Access Pipeline provides a perfect gateway to uplifting improvement of the reservations’ lifestyle. If the government agrees to give a little, a great opportunity arises for them to get a little as well. In the last decades, lack of funding has led to blatantly subpar education for the majority of Native American students, even when the government made an attempt to intervene due to an understandable inherent distrust of Government interference. Through a monumental compromise via the Dakota Access Pipeline, the government could prove its decency, transparency, and trustworthiness, which would advance the relationship of Native Americans and the United States Government brilliantly. The newfound trust could easily apply to areas such as financial welfare, educational support, and government-run health clinics.
Why Is Indian Removal Act Wrong
209 Words | 1 Pages4,000 Native American Cherokees died on the dreadful, around 1,000 mile journey to the Oklahoma territory. The United States forced them to move out west. But why wasn’t the U.S government justified to do this? There were two main reasons the Indian Removal Act was wrong.
The Impact Of Westward Expansion On Native Americans
847 Words | 4 PagesThe treaty the US government signed with the Indians in 1851 granted the Indians to have an extensive territory, which means the Indians can get more land, but eventually that did not last(doc 3,4). One of the most important and well-known wars was the Sand Creek Massacre. On November 29, 1864, John Chivington led 700 troops in an unprovoked attack on the Arapaho and Cheyenne villagers. There they killed over 200 women, children, and older men. US Indian Commissioner admitted that :We have substantially taken possession of the country and deprived the Indians of their accustomed means of support.”
What Effect Did Manifest Destiny Have On African Americans
364 Words | 2 Pages16,665 Native Americans had signed a petition to prevent the loss of
More about Sioux Nation Case Study
Mississippi Band Of Choctaw Indians Case Study
313 Words | 2 PagesThe Case Of Michigan Vs. Bay Mills
1718 Words | 7 PagesStanding Rock Sioux Reservation Case Study
760 Words | 4 PagesSioux Warriors Research Paper
336 Words | 2 PagesThe Second Version Of The Fort Laramie Treaty Of 1868
653 Words | 3 PagesPros And Cons Of The Indian Removal Act Of 1790
1501 Words | 7 PagesEssay On Declaration Of Independence And The Constitution
1077 Words | 5 PagesEffects Of The Battle Of Little Big Horn
104 Words | 1 PagesHow The Devastating Effects Of The Trail Of Tears
484 Words | 2 PagesEssay On Navajo Code Talkers
947 Words | 4 PagesThe Black Hills War
1158 Words | 5 PagesDakota Access Pipeline Benefits
812 Words | 4 PagesWhy Is Indian Removal Act Wrong
209 Words | 1 PagesThe Impact Of Westward Expansion On Native Americans
847 Words | 4 PagesWhat Effect Did Manifest Destiny Have On African Americans
364 Words | 2 Pages