Social movement and protest usually occurs in society around the world nowadays. But what do they mean? How they occur? Define whether a social movement or protest succeed or fail.
In following part, the definition of social movement, protest will show briefly and making use of example to compare difference between successful and failing social movement and discover the key factor, which affects the final outcome.
Social movements are forms of collective action that emerge in response to situations of inequality, oppression, unmet social, political, economic or cultural demands. They comprise ‘an organized set of constituents pursuing a common political agenda of change over time’ (Batliwala 2012:3)
From the definition we can see that social
…show more content…
In this essay, if social movement can withdrawal the decision that make by government that mean this is a succeeded case, if not which mean it is a failed case.
Here are two examples of social movements that happened in Hong Kong during 2014.They are “Protest over Hong Kong moral and national education” and "Umbrella Movement", also called "Occupy Central".
Protest over Hong Kong moral and national education is a succeeded protest that happens on 29th July 2012. This was an alternative social movement, as the aim of this protest only wants to withdrawal the target policy on setting up the subject of moral and national subject and its target particular subgroups such as teachers, student and their parents, we can see that this did not affect much interest group on public so which only bring limited social change and this help to increases the success rate of this
…show more content…
The current protestors are self-motivated to join the movement; they belong to emergent-norm theory, a subtype of collective theory. They begins as collectives composed of people with mixed interests and motives; given norms are vague and changing, people follow the emergent norms.
(Turner and Killian, 1957)They come out because they see how police clear the protestor. They did not have well-organized plan, without a leader as mentioned that they are self-motivated, they are easily to separate into different zone which show this movement fail to mobilize people towards accomplishing the movement’s goal.
The political goal of umbrella movement, protestors want the right to nominate and directly elect the head of the Hong Kong government, known as the chief executive. They want to change the government structure of Hong Kong, this goal it seems that impossible because this will affect the setting of basic law and the Communist Party thinks this semi-autonomy should be enough for Hong Kong.
The Chinese government rejects on the umbrella movement request, as a result this social movement turn to
Q-1: McAdam and Kloos write a book to try to understand how American politics evolved in the 1950s from a politics of moderation, bipartisan cooperation and relative economic equality to today’s politics of savage partisan divisions and sharp economic inequality. Their first chapter provides an overview of their explanation. Provide in your words a summary of this overview. HINT:
Instead of protesting read and understand the topic and examine how your freedom and persona marginalized and mitigated on a collective unconsciousness
Peacefully protesting for their rights, the leaders of these well-known movements decided to lead their campaigns in a friendly and non-violent manner. By following this tactic, they believed, would
As Oscar Wilde said, “ It is through disobedience that progress has been made-- disobedience and rebellion.” Disobedience during the American Revolution was originally peaceful, but as grievances grew and British rule became harsher, Americans could no longer sit idly by. Radical disobedience to the law was necessary in order to promote change for American society. During the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960’s, a drastic nonviolent movement was necessary to counteract the expectation of violence, reiterating to Americans that peaceful resistance to laws can positively affect a free society. The Civil Rights movement was split by two factions: one was a violent resistance named The Black Panthers and the other was a nonviolent protest led by Martin Luther King Jr.
Which is an example of a civil disobedience movement. People do civil disobedience because they don’t agree with the laws, they want their point proven and people act fast rather than waiting for changes to happen illegal, which also leads in a civil disobedience movement. This is true because many views are ignored by the authorities.
In the events following the shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri sparked huge controversy within the country. By allowing people to demonstrate peacefully helped people to convey their feelings upon the situation at large, freedom of speech to influence policy makers to take note and make changes. If these demonstrations are not handled appropriately by police can turn into violence which is a gateway into looting. After individuals choice to commit civil disobedience which is stated by Pollack (2017) as “the voluntary disobedience of established laws based on one’s moral beliefs” (p. 79). An individual is standing up for what they believe is morally right in society.
Cesar mentioned that, “If we resort to violence…the violence will be escalated and there will be many injuries and perhaps deaths on both sides, or there will be total demoralization of the workers” (Garcia, 77). He created this idea that violence does not solve anything, and will only create bigger problems. However, a nonviolent movement is a protest
The actions of these individuals managed to make their statements without causing harm to others. Nonviolent protests are lasting through today. It can be seen in the modern Black Lives Matter movement, a campaign participated in by members of all ethnicities in protest of institutional racism. January 2017's Women's March was participated in across the globe, with an estimated 1,000,000 marchers of all ages, genders, and ethnicities. The issues we care about and have the right to reject unite us with cause and
Music was also used to communicate, plan, and unify their voices. Protesting was a way for their voices to be heard. For example, the Civil Rights movement of 1964. They protested because they were not satisfied with social and political equalities.
The student Nonviolent Coordinating committee recruited white protesters to work unpaid to run freedom school, register black voters among other thing; But this movement took the life of three volunteers, while churches were being burn. Yet, 75% of the volunteers remained while the rest dropped out saying that “is not for the faint of heart” meaning that work was very dangerous in every possible way but without social media people gather for a great cause even if there were been brutally
Nearly 100 years after the Emancipation Proclamation, African Americans of the Southern States still inhabited a starkly unequal world of disenfranchisement, segregation and various forms of oppression, including race-inspired violence. “Jim Crow” laws at the local and state levels barred them from classrooms and bathrooms, from theaters and train cars, from juries and legislatures. In the year of 1954, the United States struck down the “separate but equal” doctrine that formed the basis for state-sanctioned discrimination, drawing national and international; attention to African Americans’ plight. In the turbulent decade and half that followed, civil rights activists used nonviolent protest and civil rights disobedience to bring about change.
Because of this, others followed her lead, began straying from social bus standards, and eventually boycotted buses altogether. These people challenged the social standards, thus leading to a social change. The refusal to follow the guidelines of the society promotes social progress by causing people to have new ideas. This civil disobedience is also often present in literature. Two major examples of this
Another crucial point that Black Lives Matter movement requires is collaboration and partnership. The movement must reach out to other organizations across the nation to support and stand for Black people. Effective protesters need to have a variety of ways for families, youth and communities to be involved. They need to create partnership with local churches, schools, agencies and organizations and draw on the strength of the community wide collaboration. Social movement is multifaceted; there are different ways to be involved and different levels of involvement.
They wanted a revolution. Although, these demonstrations did partially work, they could have been more effective had they been peaceful .(Chicagotribune.com). Take Martin Luther King Jr.’s protests for example. These were all peaceful yet extremely effective.
One of the main ideas of occupy was that the movement was an active process. No specific demands were made or message was trying to be sent. Rather an alternative reality was discussed (Castells). The movement was criticized my sections of the media for having no clear goals or leadership. This was intended as at the occupy locations the protesters would discuss the situation that had brought them to the site and examine the ways beneficial change was possible.