Sociological Approach To The American Frontier
Kyuhun Whang T.A.: Nazar Bagci
Reading Response One
Main Idea: U.S Frontier is worthy to be studied seriously and variously.
- In contrast with the other nations’ development (advancing in the limited physical area, with already existing ideologies), U.S. enlarged its territory and advanced from the nature to complicated society at the same time.
- In contrast with European frontier (densely populated, civilized), U.S. frontier is the intersecting point of the savage and civilization.
- Study of the disease and microorganism was activated in frontier, but the sociological approach to the frontier was not carried out by researchers.
- Frontier made its own culture, by mixing the European culture and Native American culture.
Main Idea: Frontier is a key factor that forms U.S. history.
- Frontier is where the Democracy deeply considering private freedom has originated.
- The trait of the U.S. citizen, bravery, innovativeness, and entrepreneurship is from the Frontier.
- Frontier is turned to village and village is turned to commercialized town;
…show more content…
He states that slavery itself does not have significant meaning. Moreover, he mentions the events occurred with the Native American people just as a means for earning more free territories (Turner 3). If he had really wanted to explain about “the significance of the frontier in American history”, he should have pondered about the impact of struggling with Native American and Slavery on American history. His writing is not an academic essay but biased propaganda to make people believe U.S. as the superior nation.
As a scholar, one should not be biased by one perspective or tendency; since we are human, it is hard to maintain objectivity always. Fredrick was so focused on the impact of frontier in the shoes of U.S. citizens and believed the superiority of American history that he lost the
Abuction On The Texas Frontier Sparknotes
1406 Words | 6 PagesIn the novel, “The captured: A True Story of Abduction on the Texas Frontier” written by Scott Zesch narrates the story of the Indian captives to address the experiences of Texas Pioneers. The story of Adolf Korn and the others who were captured by tribes brings forward the different cultures. The book explains a series of kidnapping and how the Indians force the children to adjust to their costumes. Zesch describes what the experiences of those abducted reveal about Native American culture and pioneer culture. The author pinpoints the reasoning as to why the Comanches took captives and portrays how the stories from both the captives and the captors fit into the history of the United States West.
Summary Of A Place Of Extremes By Susan Rhoades Neel
1070 Words | 5 PagesSusan Rhoades Neel - A Place of Extremes: Nature, History, and the American West In her essay, Susan Rhoades Neel examines the significance of the environment of the American West when shaping western history by referring to and analyzing regional approaches claimed by Webb, Limerick, Worster, and White in order to deemphasize Frederick Jackson Turner's frontier thesis. In fact, most historians may regard Turner's theory as the most influential and adequate one in attempting at giving meaning to the mythical territory of western America as it offers a common sense for the entire American nation. Nonetheless, because of the particular emphasis on nature and the human - nature relation, new approaches have been developed in order to outline
Summary Of Before The Railroad By Gregory Wigmore
930 Words | 4 PagesThese sources are used to provide the reader with evidence to verify that the contents of, “Before the Railroad: From Slavery to Freedom in the Canadian-American Borderland” is factual. Both primary and secondary sources are also used to acknowledge the findings of previous historians and to give them credit. Wigmore does not necessarily challenge the work of other historians, but agrees and contributes to their already established
Summary Of Get A Dog But Get Rid Of Guns By Molly Ivins
1019 Words | 5 PagesIvins gives the fact that the United States has changed in its history and that we are no longer a civilization that needs to hunt for food, or be on constant lookout for danger. This point moves to discredit traditionalist thinking of sticking to old-fashion American values that we are still a frontier country. Through bringing up and immediately knocking down opposing arguments Molly Ivins’ own argument appears more intelligent and thought out. At the same time her opposition’s argument loses credibility and seems less believable or
1491-1607: A Comparative Analysis
1139 Words | 5 PagesThe college board’s decision to shift to a consensus perspective more accurately reflects the era of 1491- 1607, because both Europe and North America were homes to complex and diverse societies with their own distinctive cultures. Therefore, each group adopted and improved aspects of each other’s culture, skills and interacted from the beginning. Even though they both had unique and individual ideas and beliefs about gods, they still shared some similarities. Misunderstandings and differences between the Europeans and Native Americans resulted in years of interaction. Each continent was diverse, different and unique on it’s own.
Dbq Turner's Frontier Thesis
692 Words | 3 PagesFrontier needs and ideas were conditioned for American nationalistic system to legislate internal improvements in tariff and land. Frontier conditions worked against sectionalism both economically and socially. Promotion of democracy was its vital effect as was individualism. “Professor Herbert L.Osgood, in an able article, has pointed out that the frontier conditions prevalent in the colonies are important factors in the explanation of the American Revolution, where individual liberty was sometimes confused with absence of all effective government. ”(Source 1).
What Was The Frontier In The Late 1700's
372 Words | 2 PagesThe frontier in the late 1700’s was a place of disagreement, this political and social unrest helped mold America. The village of Paxton was a few miles east of Harrisburg in eastern Pennsylvania, it became a place of racial and political unrest during Pontiac 's Rebellion. It was considered part of the frontier in the 1760s, the area was populated by many hardened Scots-Irish immigrants who had grown weary of their vulnerability to attack. Requests for soldiers or guns, powder and lead at the very least were ignored by the legislators, many of them were Quakers.
Mexican Americans Dbq
275 Words | 2 PagesNo other transformation was more measurable in the west was the Assault on Indian way of life caught by miners and settlers who grasped their homes and federal Government extortion, (Doc C) by the 1890s Native Americans reservations had been the aftereffect on Most Indians, natives effortlessly combated to preserve their assets. Bison and buffalo had been their Linked article commonly utilizing it for food, clothing and trade. Promptly of the millions of
Essay On Manifest Destiny
1098 Words | 5 PagesIntro: The wild west or west Texas, land coveted by the Americans who believe in Manifest destiny, but guarded by natives who wish to keep their homeland. On this frontier is a series of stories worthy of Shakespeare filled with bravery, danger, tragedy, and confusion. These are those stories. Will: Before the Civil war the frontier was practically owned by the white man, and the Native Americans were almost driven out.
Rhetorical Analysis Of Learning To Read And Write By Frederick Douglass
743 Words | 3 PagesHe points out personal facts about how he feels when he says, “I often found myself regretting my own existence, and wishing myself dead; and but for the hope of being free, I have no doubt but that I should have killed myself or done something foe which I should have been killed”. The words that he uses explains the emotions that he was going through and to build an appeal to emotions. Throughout the time that he has been expanding his knowledge he runs across the word “abolitionist” which means it’s a movement to end slavery. He was always eager for someone to speak about it and he was ready to listen he says, “I did not dare ask anyone about its meaning, for I was satisfied that it was something they wanted me to know very little about”. He says this because he realized that the word is spoken very rarely and he knew if he spoke that word and someone heard him, he could get penalized.
Late Nineteenth Century: Contrast To The American West
842 Words | 4 PagesThe contrasts between the American West and East in the nineteenth century range from a new start to the adventure of the living in the Wild West. The east had become overcrowded and did not allow much opportunity for people of lesser wealth. “In 1893, the historian Frederick Jackson Turner gave a celebrated lecture, “The Significance of the Frontier in American History,” in which he argued that on the western frontier the distinctive qualities of American culture were forged: individual freedom, political democracy, and economic mobility. The West, he added, acted as a “safety
The Trans-Mississippi West
784 Words | 4 PagesAlthough the success is credited to the hardy individualism of settlers and pioneers, the reality is that nothing would have been possible without federal
Stereotypes Of Native Americans
316 Words | 2 PagesOther common stereotypes that have been used negatively to describe Native Americans are the following ones: All Indigenous people are alcoholics; Native Americans are lazy or all Native Americans live in reservations; just a few to mention. Native Americans have also been seen as “nomads”. The reason of this perception is, some of the Euro-Americans believed that Indians wandered aimlessly as hunters and gatherers. The consequence of this perception, was that Europeans occupied the space with the excuse of Indians did not used the lands for any productive purpose. But what people does not know is the following “All Indians, even the Labrador hunters, the tribes of the Buffalo-covered plains, and the Eskimos, lived in villages.
Frontier Myth In American Culture
1594 Words | 7 PagesA view of Americans as a special, exceptional people because Americans had progressively taken over the West and conquered primitive societies was firmly established in the minds of Americans by frontier myth. One of problems is that the frontier myth is a story, and “all stories are partial; that is, in creating narrative coherence, they leave things out, and emphasize other things”. They are not necessarily false, but neither are they history. As the society evolved, the concept of the frontier is consequently redefined as a space of social and cultural interaction and replaced by the terms “contact zone” by Mary Louise Pratt in her 1992 book Imperial Eyes. Contact zones are “social spaces where disparate cultures meet, clash, and grapple with each other.”
Crevecoeur's Impact On The American Identity
1756 Words | 8 PagesDe Crevecoeur explains these individuals stating, “The Americans were once scattered all over Europe; here they are incorporated into one of the finest systems of population which has ever appeared” (Horwitz 27). De Crevecoeur believes that the frontier played a big role in the formation of the American identity because of the melting pot of different races, ethnicities, beliefs and cultures that was Americans then and are today. John Wannuaucon Quinney was a Native American and leader who highly supported Native American tribes. Quinney was very vocal about the negative impact the frontier played on the formation of American identity.
More about Sociological Approach To The American Frontier
Abuction On The Texas Frontier Sparknotes
1406 Words | 6 PagesSummary Of A Place Of Extremes By Susan Rhoades Neel
1070 Words | 5 PagesSummary Of Before The Railroad By Gregory Wigmore
930 Words | 4 PagesSummary Of Get A Dog But Get Rid Of Guns By Molly Ivins
1019 Words | 5 Pages1491-1607: A Comparative Analysis
1139 Words | 5 PagesDbq Turner's Frontier Thesis
692 Words | 3 PagesWhat Was The Frontier In The Late 1700's
372 Words | 2 PagesMexican Americans Dbq
275 Words | 2 PagesEssay On Manifest Destiny
1098 Words | 5 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Learning To Read And Write By Frederick Douglass
743 Words | 3 PagesLate Nineteenth Century: Contrast To The American West
842 Words | 4 PagesThe Trans-Mississippi West
784 Words | 4 PagesStereotypes Of Native Americans
316 Words | 2 PagesFrontier Myth In American Culture
1594 Words | 7 PagesCrevecoeur's Impact On The American Identity
1756 Words | 8 Pages