The United States prison system has seen a significant rise in prisoners over the past few decades. Currently, the rate of incarceration outweighs the rate of new cells being built. Because of this, prisons become more crowded every day. Crowded prisons fester with hate and pent-up aggression. Those who step out of line are met with swift discipline usually in the form of solitary confinement. While many might argue that solitary confinement is the most effective method of discipline, countless studies have shown that this assumption is nearsighted. Though there are some benefits to solitary confinement that must be addressed, solitary confinement causes irreversible damage to the brain and emotions. Solitary confinement must be looked into …show more content…
Additionally, institutions that implement solitary confinement are often housing the worst of the worst. These inmates are prone to violence and will lash out without being provoked. According to Statsia, a statistics-based company, there were “143 homicides in prisons in 2019”(Statsia). To combat this level of violence, prison officials are more frequently using “solitary” as punishment. By arguing that they are taking out the “bad apples” solitary confinement is often used as a justification for systemic racism. While segregating violent offenders might seem like a reasonable solution, much is revealed by looking at the demographics that make up solitary confinement. Although the amount of racism has declined in the US, prison systems are a step behind. According to a study by Yale Law, “45% of the restricted housing program was made up by African Americans”(Williams). Yale law also found whites were underrepresented in solitary due to “racial inequality among guards”(Williams). Because of these discrepancies, it can be reasonably assumed that prison guards are singling out prisoners of minorities that have a negative connotation. Solitary confinement creates a way for prisons to segregate prisoners unfairly based on racist stereotypes. This trend occurs because of the vague rules about who is sent to solitary confinement. Often, who is placed in solitary confinement is up to prison guards who may be biased with racist ideas. Fortunately, if …show more content…
Sitting in a plain room for hours on end with no one to converse with often leads inmates to have psychological breakdowns. This phenomenon is explained in depth in the article “Hellhole” by Atul Gawande. During his time as a prisoner in the middle east, interviewed prisoner of war, Terry Anderson recounts the mental deterioration he faced by being alone for extended periods. In this position, he explains that solitary confinement not only affected his mind but his body as a whole. Terry experienced symptoms such as uncontrolled trembling, headaches, and brain fog(Gaqande). Coincidentally, or not, these same symptoms are mirrored in persons who spend extended periods in solitary confinement back in the US. Long-term inactivation of the brain inflicted by solitary confinement causes permanent damage to the brain. Unlike Terry Anderson, who was placed sometimes with other prisoners of war, inmates often have no one to talk to for years on end. While Terry's symptoms were relieved by communication with others, inmates never receive these breaks from the harsh silence of a solitary cell. These inmates slowly lose a sense of reality and suffer from severe psychological problems. While solitary confinement only holds a small chunk of the prison population, the Prison Policy Initiative has found that these inmates contribute to “half of the yearly suicides” inside the
In “After Years In Solitary, Freedom Hard to Grasp” Kevin Johnson explains that using solitary confinement is an effective way to keep the environment a safer place. Johnson supports this view by looking at statistics and finding people in solitary confinement make up less than 10% of 600,000 felons that are getting released from state each year. He records that the less than 10% that are being released are dangerous and troubles prisoners: murderers, rapists and gang members.
There are three ways to be sent to solitary confinement: the inmate is too dangerous to be around others, for their own
Sadly, the truth is that solitary confinement does take a heavy toll mentally on inmates (Breslow, 2014). The philosophical question the writer seeks is summed up to if solitary makes inmate crazy; the effects on the inmates, and are inmates more dangerous after solitary confinement. The background to the effect of solitary confinement on the mind was conducted in 1950, by psychologist Harry Harlow. The research resulted in that extreme isolation is havoc to the human psyche (Breslow, 2014). Harlow test subjects were rhesus monkeys placed in a special designed solitary chamber.
Jaime Mata CRIJ 2313.03 Correctional Systems and Practices Article review Date submitted: February 4, 2017 Word count: 850-1,500 Kurki and Morris (2001) examine the spread of Supermax prisons and the problems that plague them in the article titled The Purposes, Practices, and Problems of Supermax Prisons. The National Institute of Corrections defines a Supermax as a highly restrictive unit or facility used to isolate those who are considered more of threat than the general prison population (id, p. 388). Though the goals of a Supermax prison are clearly stated they face scrutiny due to their vast amount of problems some of which interfere with what most consider basic rights and morals. This article review provides insight into the use of Solitary confinement as a punishment in correctional facilities.
This study used multivariable logistic regression to adjust for prior mental health conditions, age, gender, disciplinary actions, protective custody, short or long term administrative segregation, chronic discipline, special risk group, or special needs, the total time spent in solitary confinement such as number of days/weeks/months. The findings in this study showed that more than 40 percent of the recently released were found to have symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder and they feel that there should be a larger study done to confirm their
While it is true that prisoners in these facilities are kept in solitary confinement for long periods of time, and their interactions with the outside world are limited, the conditions in some supermax prisons are not as inhumane as they are sometimes portrayed. Many facilities have implemented programs to mitigate the effects of isolation, such as education and rehabilitation programs, as well as regular interaction with staff members. The question of whether the conditions in supermax prisons constitutes cruel and unusual punishment is a complex one. The Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution prohibits cruel and unusual punishment, but the interpretation of this clause has evolved over time. In recent years, there has been a growing consensus that prolonged solitary confinement can amount to cruel and unusual punishment, especially when it is used as a punishment in and of itself, rather than as a temporary measure for security
" If you shout or scream, your time in solitary is extended; if you hurt yourself by refusing to eat or mutilating your body, your time in solitary is extended; if you complain to officers or say anything menacing or inappropriate, your time in solitary is extended. " They overuse their power; they take their job way too personally. To close, prisoner abuse and the disregard for human dignity described in Just Mercy highlight how the urgent need for reform within the correction system is very wrong for those who are in positions of power to prioritize their responsibilities over personal
Solitary Confinement Every day 48,000 inmates are held in solitary confinement for 22 hours or more. These inmates are held in confined spaces for days and sometimes years. This is detrimental to the health and well-being of inmates, and it can leave them permanently disabled. Even though it negatively affects the inmates, many people believe that they deserve this treatment because of their crimes.
Within the United States, approximately 80,000 prisoners are currently in solitary confinement (Nolan and Amico). For countless people, that is 80,000 too many. Encyclopedia Britannica states, “Solitary confinement is a form of incarceration in which a prisoner is isolated from other inmates.” Critics of this controversial practice characterize it as inhumane. However, simultaneously an opposing side of the argument supports solitary confinement.
I agree with Madeline and Julie that the cons of solitary confinement are much larger than the pros of solitary confinement. As the number of incarcerated increases in the US, which is a country with an abnormally high number of incarcerations annually, there are also a larger number of prisoners in solitary confinement. There have been studies shown that correlate lasting psychological damage with the amount of time a prisoner has spent in solitary confinement or isolation. The complete lack of human association and contact for a long period of time can cause severe psychological distress to a prisoner. Solitary confinement was once used as a form of short-term punishment; however, more and more prisoners are now placed in solitary confinement
Solitary confinement is, “Living in a concrete box the size of a walk-in closet. You get tour meals through a slot, you do not see other inmates, and you never touch or get near another human being”(Stevenson 129). Solitary confinement is a punishment not fit for humans. Humans need social interaction to live. We have established how messed up solitary confinement is, but how do we fix it?
In New York approximately 2000 individuals were released directly from solitary confinements to the public every year. During Solitary confinement, prisoners do not get any educational or rehabilitative courses and are therefore unprepared to reunite with society with success. Prisoners also bring the effects of solitary confinement with them to communities, which include violent outbursts of anger, self-harm, and emotional breakdowns. In previous studies it was discovered that solitary confinement increases the rate of suicides in jails, causes negative psychological and psychopathological effects, and raises the levels of violence in prisons and the society that they are situated in.
Some might argue that solitary confinement is actually effective and has its benefits, however this is not the case since this punishment only seems to make criminals much more dangerous when they leave prison than they were before and research shows that inmates who left solitary confinement experience increased anger and end up committing the kind of criminality that society is looking to prevent by using this method of punishment. Thus, solitary confinement ultimately fails as a rehabilitative measure, and as a way to "settle down" problematic
For society to understand the negative effects of solitary confinement further research must be conducted. If changes were to be made, then the change should begin with research regarding those confined in solitude. What I gathered was not sufficient to know the exact number of inmates isolated in solitude confinement. If accurate numbers were to be provided, then I’d be able to know how big of a problem suicide is amongst those inmates. Most importantly, having in accurate count of how many prisoners, female or male, make up the solitary confinement population would give me a clear picture of who is experiencing the most cases of suicide and which population is most prone to suicide.
Imagine being locked away underground, in a room with no window, no source of sunlight, neglected from any source of human contact; it is a terrifying thought, is it not? Now, imagine living in such a manner for days, months, years to decades, this is the haunting reality for numerous prison inmates that are subjected to solitary confinement. Solitary confinement is the act of isolating people in closed cells for 22-24 hours a day, restricted from human contact, for periods of time ranging from days to decades (Solitary Watch, 2012). There are beyond 80,000 men, women, and children imposed to solitary confinement in prisons throughout the United States (American friends service committee, 2010). The negative effects on prison inmates due to solitary confinement are: psychological harm, physical harm, and a greater harm on the individuals in their communities and themselves after they are released.