Chapter 1: Diamond’s first attempt at answering Yali’s question begins with another question: did some continents have a head start in civilization over others? The beginning of civilization is traced back to the ape species in Africa about 7 million years ago. They divergence from apes to humans took place from then to the end of the last Ice Age 13,000 years ago. This could have set Africa “ahead” of the other continents. Another major component is when the humans would develop germs, guns, and steel. Due to the Americas’ larger area and more diverse environment, it is possible that they possessed the “head start.” Eurasia could be the more advanced continent because of its artwork and more complex tools. The development of the various continents
In the book, Guns Germs and Steel, Jared Diamond attempts to answer questions of conquest, such as why Eurasia conquered the Americas, and not the other way around. Diamond is a biologist by trade, and both impressed and disappointed the academic world with his new historian side. He believes the answer to western dominance lies in geography and the spread of guns, germs and steel. His theories had led him to be heavily critiqued by historians everywhere, including environmental historian J.R McNeil and Professor of Anthropology and Geography James Blaut. While Diamond provides solid ideas relating to the conquest of the New World, he often uses his scientistic background loosely with unclear supports forgetting other historical factors that
In Guns, Germs, and Steel, Jared Diamond answers Yali’s question, “Why is it that you white people developed so much cargo, but we black people have little cargo of our own?”. Diamond begins his research in Papua, New Guinea where he says people have been living for 40,000 years. In Papua, Diamond discovers that gathering is both more productive and effective rather than hunting. He wonders why these New Guineans did not advance like more developed countries did. Geographic luck is the term that comes into play.
10th grade Advanced Placement World History II Summer Reading Assignment Since the last ice age, civilizations have progressed at different rates. Some developed literate societies with metal tools and innovative farming societies, while others developed illiterate hunting-gathering societies with improvised rock tools. But why has society advanced at such unlike proportions? This question, also known as Yali’s question, is the main focus of the book Guns, Germs, and Steel by Jared Diamond.
Most historians consider many factors to piece together our planet’s past. When looking at the exploration of what was named “the New World,” they often point to the success of the conquistador’s missions and attribute it to their determination, skill, and weaponry. The film “Guns, Germs, and Steel” names the real reasons why the conquistadors were so successful on their missions. The empires of Central and South America did not have access to certain animals and had not advanced as far as the Europeans did in terms of weaponry. Additionally, they had never been exposed to the diseases that many animals carry.
In Episode three of Gun Germs and Steel, Jared Diamond, describes how the European settlers settled in the southern parts of the African continent. Many of the farms animals that the European people brought played very important roles in the process of colonizing. Over time the Europeans developed some kind of refusal against the germs that the livestock carried. The germs and diseases began to spread amongst the Khoisan people which resulted in killing their population. After that happened the European population enlarge in potential and proportions.
Chapter three of Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies by Jared Diamond is a story about how Francisco Pizarro, the Conquistador, brought the end to the Inca civilization with only two hundred men. Diamond uses real accounts from six of the 200 men to tell what happened. The story goes like: Francisco Pizarro by order of the King to travel across New World and conquer the lands and riches for his nation. They had gathered information about an Incan Empire and soon sent their sights on capturing the Incans. The Spanish Conquistadores tried to the Incan leader, Atahuallpa, to convert to Christianity but it failed so Pizarro then captured Atahullpa.
1. In the beginning of the chapter, there was an explosion that occurred. It seems as if there was a battle occurring from afar, but the boys weren’t able to see. I concluded that maybe there was a battle occurring from afar because in the novel, it states “…but there were other lights in the sky, that moved fast, winked, or went out, though not even a faint popping came down from the battle fought at ten miles’ height. But a sign came down from the world of grownups, though at the time there was no child awake to read it.
Burns, Sydney BPQ #2- I see areas of the world, such as Bantu Africa and North America, that didn't generate "civilizations" as different, but certainly not as "backward." Many would consider the Roman Empire an example of an amazing civilization, and although it did have many achievements, Roman society had many undesirable aspects, such as its large scale slavery that "had some 2 to 3 million slaves" (page 231). Bantu Africa did not have slavery, and even "developed gender systems that were markedly less patriarchal than those of established urban-based civilization" (pg 284). Bantu Africa and other similar societies did not lack religion, art, and many other important aspects of culture.
In the book, Guns Germs and Steel by Jared Diamonds, chapter 14, From Egalitarianism To Kleptocracy indicate and explains the political organizations in our society. The nomads who were known as the hunter-gatherers belonged to a group called Fayu. Fayu was made up into four different types of groups that Diamond explains in this chapter, such as; bands, tribes, chiefdoms, and states. Between these four groups they explain the lives of the people in New Guinea. Diamond supports the idea that government is important for the preservation of human society.
In the book, “Guns, Germs, and Steel” by Jared Diamond, Part Three talks about the evolution of germs, writing, technology, government, and religion. Jared Diamond seems to feel like the development of technology helped shape the world as it is today (most importantly Eurasian societies) except, even he had a struggle figuring out how technology was developed. He compares how the Eurasian societies developed technology compared to the Western societies. Technology, in general, helped shape those societies and created many powerful inventions that are used in our world today. Jared Diamond is also interested in answering Yali’s question from Chapter One which makes his curiosity grow on to how everything happened the way it happened.
This new combination of the Old (Europe and Africa) and New Worlds gave rise to the
The countries of Europe began to compete with each neighboring country in order to discover and claim more land than the other. Europe became an indestructible and eventually dominated North and South America, but the results were fatal. European dominance in the Americas opened a new window
Civilizations in Africa and the Americas had very different experiences concerning trade, government and economic opportunities. Axum, emerging at around 50 CE, and Meroe, flourishing in 300 BCE, both appearing on the eastern half of Africa, had connections to the Eurasian empires and large domesticated animals to use in their specialized, imperial economies, while civilizations such as Maya, materializing cultural achievements in 250 CE, and Teotihuacan, developing in 150 BCE, had very little acculturation and no pastoral opportunities. Although Meroe, Axum, Maya and Teotihuacan had several differences including Meroe and Axum’s single, imperial monarch and extensive trading connections in comparison to Maya and Teotihuacan’s elite centered
Firstly, European empires in the Americas as well as Russian, Chinese, Mughal, and Ottoman empires are different in their development because Europe interacted and depended on other regions. The Atlantic Ocean connected Europe, Africa, and the Americas. Strayer states how “these two ‘old worlds’ were joined, increasingly creating a single biological regime, a ‘new world’ of global dimensions.” The reason for this difference is that Europe constructed their empires across the Atlantic Ocean in the Americas, or the New World, unlike their Russian, Chinese, Mughal, and Ottoman counterparts. This resulted in an advantage for the Europeans because they had access to new resources and ideas.
1) The most viable culture was the Incas. In my opinion they were the most developed people because they had big cities, important roads and also factories. They were engaged in agriculture and were able to create aqueducts from the Andes. Above all what really helped them to get prosperity was not fighting with neighbors that created peace.