Between Remembering and Forgetting The book Strength In What Remains by Tracy Kidder, tells the journey of Deo, from his escape from Hutu-Tutsi genocide in the mid-1990s to the United States and back to Burundi. In his journey, Deo struggle’s against his memories of the genocide, he was faced with two different ways of dealing with his memories, to forget or to remember. In the first half of the book, Deo follows the Burundian concept of forgetting about the past, this is due too the unwillingness of victims to recall and, thereby, relive the violence and pain of their recent history. But as he went through his journey, he realizes that although he wants to forget his past tragedies, he was unable to do so. In the second half of the book, …show more content…
Deo was taught by his family since an early age about Gusimbura. Gusimbura is the idea that it is bad to bring up people who have died, or horrible events of the past, because you are forcing someone to relive bad memories all over again. He was also taught not to dredge up the past, the story of “What Killed You, Head?” symbolizes talking about something so unpleasant that discussing it means raising a controversy that will turn back against the teller himself. We were able to see the effects of Gusimbura and the talking head in the early chapters of the book. When Deo was dealing with Sharon, he thought about gusimbura a lot of times, making him reluctant to ask for help. When Sharon asked him to write a brief account of his life “ He didn’t use the real name of anyone in his family, he omitted many details and changed others, and he completely altered the geography of his life” (57). Deo thought that although Sharon’s help can help make his situation better, She was digging up too much of his past, which goes against the idea of Gusimbura and the talking head. He felt that announcing that he is a Tutsi could not only endangers him, but his other relatives or friends in Burundi. We see that although his cultural belief can be an obstacle in thriving on his journey, his belief protected him from talking too much about his private information, as it was dangerous to talk too much about himself when Burundi was still …show more content…
He had seen the extremes of both sides impact his countrymen and himself. While other people might not be able to forgive the Hutu’s for what they have done. Deo was able to let it go, his experience have made him more sensitive to violence rather than vengeful. In the PIH, Deo found a philosophy of preventing. “By all means, let’s do prevention! Prevent people from suffering! Don’t wait for people to feel like their lives are not worth living. Once they feel that way, how are they going to feel about another person’s life?” (155). Through this philosophy, Deo was able to strike a balance between remembering and forgetting. He does not forget enough that he does not learn anything from it, and he does not remember too much to be trapped inside his own memories. This is evident when a woman came to him to apologized to him for something that happened in Deo’s past. “’What happened happened,’ Deo said to the woman. ‘Let’s work on the clinic. Let’s put this tragedy behind us, because remembering is not going to benefit anyone” (259). The Deo in this moment have able to make peace with his past through taking action and helping others. His past memories have stop haunting him, and he realized that dreading of the past would not amount to anything. He was able to focus on his goals of maintaining his clinic to help his
In her brilliant and award-winning book, The Spirit Catches You & You Fall Down, Anne Fadiman skillfully demonstrates the cultural clash between a small county hospital in California, and a refugee family from Laos over the care of Lia Lee, a Hmong child diagnosed with sever epilepsy. Both Lia’s parents, as well as the doctors present, wanted what was best for her. However, the lack of understanding between them led to a tragedy. Fadiman did an outstanding job at demonstrating that cultural understanding is essential but lacking in the modern biomedical system. She successfully illustrated the way hospital bureaucracy often detracts from the desired end results of helping patients get well according to their definitions as well.
Have you ever thought about how difficult it might be to go into a different country knowing absolutely nothing, not even language, and something horrific happened to you or anyone in your family? Don’t you think you would feel so powerless, so helpless, so clueless? This happens commonly and it has never had any attention brought to it, at least not until 1998. Anne Fadiman wrote a book entitled, The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down. This demonstrated a collision of two complete opposite cultures, but they both have the same goal to help the child get better.
Although often used interchangeably, disease and illness differ fundamentally in their meanings and implications. Disease is the commonly thought of concept in which a person suffers due to a physiological or psychological ailment, while illness refers to a culmination of physical, emotional and social suffering of a person. Disease is perceived as the phenomena that affects an organism, while illness affects not only the patient but also their loved ones and community. This distinction is vividly apparent in The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down, in which Anne Fadiman relays the approaches to a Hmong child named Lia’s epilepsy by her family and her doctors as well as the tumultuous interaction between these caregivers. It is interesting to understand how Hmong culture and a doctor’s
“It is impossible to outplay an opponent you can’t outthink.” This quote by Lawson Little can be used to explain how in The Power of One, by Bryce Courtenay, Peekay’s ability to outthink his opponents is what drives him to victory. Furthermore, it does not have to be boxing that he out-thinks his opponents, there are numerous times where Peekay is shown thinking ahead of some situations saving him from misfortune, as well as outsmarting his opponents eventually leading him to victory. Peekay illustrates his intelligence by thinking ahead of situations, which in the end result, benefit him the most. To start off, with the judge on the brink of failing, Peekay “cast [his] mind back to when [he] had done the judges homework, just like that”
In the book Glass Castle, Jeannette and her family don’t let all of the circumstances around them stop them from dreaming any smaller. Perseverance is the persistence of taking action, especially in spite of difficulties. Perseverance is overcoming the tough things in life, and not letting them get the best of you. In fact, for the most part, the Walls’ kids all worked a little harder to reach their goals. Lori, Jeanette, and Brian save up money so Lori can pursue her life outside of Welch, and move to New York City.
There are tons of advice on how to complete a research analysis essay, but I will review the most important ones. To start off with for a research analysis essay there needs to be a lot of reading and research done. A couple of hours each day is needed when finding the right sources. Making sure the resources are appropriate sources. Also making sure ideas are synthesize.
The book left to tell by Immaculée Ilibagiza, is a good example of forgiveness. Immaculee talks about her life and survival of the Rwandan genocide. Immaculée also discussed her personal experiences and what happen with her family before and during the genocide. As history had proven the Rwandan genocide was a horrible event, in which it claimed one million lives in one hundred days. Most of Immaculée family were killed by the Hutu soldiers, but
The United States has not officially had an official declaration of war, within itself or on another country since the second World War in 1941, but imagine what would happen if a civil war or genocide began right here in continental America. In Tracy Kidder’s The Strength in What Remains, the author describes the struggle of Deogratias “Deo” Niyizonkiza, as he finds a way to escape his home country, Burundi, while callous civil war rages on through the mountainous country. In contrast to Deo story, Man’s Search for Meaning, by Viktor E. Frankl, the author and main protagonist, a psychiatrist studying humans suffering, while imprisoned in the dreadful Nazi concentration camp in Auschwitz. Frankl 's theory of the strength that love can have on a struggling person can be connected to Deo’s inner fight to find his way back to his love of helping other people with medicine.
In conclusion, Rusesabagina faces terrible events and terror experienced from the 1994 Genocide of
In a situation where your body is surviving on a thread, your stomach is inflated due to starvation and all the strength you had before is gone, you have to rely on mental and religious strength to carry you through your hardships. In Elie Wiesel’s “Night”, Elie talks about his personal experiences and hardships he faced during WWII and his life at Auschwitz as a young boy. Throughout the story Elie pushes through losing his mother and sister, lashings, seeing babies burned alive and the fear of death but also the hope for it in some situations. No amount of physical strength can help someone survive in the brutal place Auschwitz. Everywhere in the story Elie and other characters show that with mental and religious/spiritual strength, you can push through any hardship you have to face.
This quote is from “Samuel's Memory” retold by Michael J. Rutledge, in “Forgiveness in the Age of Forgetfulness” and this paper was published on October 28, 2013. “Samuel’s Memory” is a story about Samuel’s sorrowful journey on the Trail of Tears through Michael’s narrations. Michael told us about the trail of Indians who were forced to leave their homeland and was kept in stockades for months include his great-great grandfather, Samuel. This is significant because that’s the feelings of all Indians walking on the trail, not only Samuel, they were desperate for the hellish reality. This quote discloses Samuel’s feelings when he was beheld his mother’s death, he knows he will be taken care of by his clan, but he was painful when he has
They released him from the pain of his father’s suicide, the struggles in Vietnam to an extent to where he can live and get by. The mirrors act as a “security blanket” for him, the idea that he is his own audience was comforting. He could control all around him and manipulate objects before his very own eyes. It made him feel that for once, he actually had control of his own life despite the events in the
One quote from the book that exemplifies this aspect of the book is
Deo wanted to understand what had happened to him in his past in Burundi and wanted to question his life in order to find answers by remembering his past and relying on philosophy to help him. As a young boy, Deo understood the importance of cows to his family and the pride it gave to own cows to many families as well. Even though Deo was poor, he lived better than other families and worked hard; he did labor work in order to bring food to the table for his family and himself. As he grew up, he went to school and had eventually become a third year medical student. After a while, his whole world changed when he experienced the civil war and genocide in Burundi.