Colleen Bolger Mr. Conway English 4 Honors February 15, 2023 Suffering in The Kite Runner What is suffering? Suffering is the state of undergoing pain, distress, or hardship. In the novel, The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini, there is a tremendous amount of betrayal and suffering which leads to second-guess who is at fault. Amir and Hassan come from different backgrounds which, in Afghanistan, causes a big difference in their lifestyles. Amir is a Pashtun which is the more favorable tribe and majority of the Afghan population, while Hassan is Hazara which is the minority group. Hazaras, who fall into servitude, are seen as inferior to most, aside from Baba.The cultural dynamic is a key role throughout the novel, and we see Amir begin to …show more content…
Assef, the main antagonist in the novel, is the character who physically raped Hassan, joined the Taliban, and held Sohrab hostage. He was the perpetrator that repetitively caused harm throughout the book. “Assef knelt behind Hassan, put his hands on Hassan’s hips and lifted his bare buttocks” (Hosseni 75). Amir had the responsibility of helping Hassan, his best friend while Assef did not. Hassan and Amir were best friends and Hassan always protected Amir when needed. Amir did not follow through with the same treatment and left Hassan in the alley and betrayed him. Assef was known as a bully, and someone who caused harm. Amir was the boy with the troubled upbringing who would have done anything to please his father. He lived with Hassan, growing up with him, reading books to him but he still made the decision to betray him and cause suffering. “Hassan and I fed from the same breasts. We took our first steps on the same lawn in the same yard. And, under the same roof, we spoke our first words” (Hosseini 10). They were close enough to be brothers but Amir let society’s views get to his head and in turn caused Hassan to suffer for many years to come. Nevertheless, Amir was his own person that could have been courageous and chose right over wrong. He knew the decisions that he was making were wrong, yet he continued making them with no consequences except for the guilt that he lived with. Although Assef caused a majority of the physical and emotional suffering, Amir is to blame for causing the suffering of the people he loved. Assef did not have a responsibility to be there for Hassan and Sohrab, but as their loved one, Amir did and he failed to upkeep this
Once Amir found Sohrab, he is not able to take him without a price, Assef wants to fight Amir for the boy. Assef became a leader of the Taliban and once he found that Hassan had a child, he wanted to take him. Amir fought Assef only because it was Assef’s way of keeping his promise and it was Amir’s way to gain redemption. Amir felt like it was time to redeem himself for his actions that night in the alley. In the alley Amir watched Hassan get raped by Assef, he did this because he wanted to show his power.
Hassan was Amir and Baba's servant, and because Hassan was Hazara, Amir always saw him as a servant rather than a friend. Amir even said that Hassan was “…not [Amir’s] friend… He was [Amir’s] servant!” (Hosseini 41). Hassan has always been a good and loyal friend to Amir.
In the book it says, “Mahmood’s laughter was as convincing as Tanya’s smile, and sudden is maybe on some level, their son frightened them.” Reading about Assef made me want to quell his actions, for what he did created havoc in Amir and Hassan’s friendship. Hassan spoke vehemently
This guilt and shame follow Amir throughout his life, causing him to struggle with happiness and personal redemption. Ultimately, Amir finds a way to healthily make amends with his past, finding healing and closure from the past. After returning to Afghanistan, Amir encounters the one person that was capable of causing such unimaginable trauma, Assef. By this time, both Amir and Assef were grown adults but they never moved past Hassan’s assault.
Assef did deserve what he got, as Hassan threatened to hit him in the eye with the slingshot in the past when they were all children, in order to protect him and Amir. Now that they are adults, Hassan’s threat to Amir has in a way, extended, to his next of kin, and Sohrab was like an extension of Hassan’s will to protect Amir, as he shot Assef in the eye when he was assaulting Amir. Assef also assaulted Hassan in the past, and Sohrab shooting him in the eye is a way to avenge his father for how he treated Assef in the past. Amir did deserve what he gets, as he was unable to muster his courage in the past and stand up to Assef, regardless of the repercussions that he may receive. In addition, Amir also distances himself from Hassan after
The realisation that Amir gained was the boost of energy he needed to face the consequences of his past by going back to Afghanistan. This was the first step towards redemption: acceptance. Before this, he never thought of the need to justify his past actions, and so, Amir attempts to purge his guilt by commencing a journey back to Afghanistan, in which he would entirely redeem himself later on. In addition, Amir pardons himself by fighting a person he should have fought many years ago—a boy named Assef. Assef is a malicious, tight-fisted character who assaulted Amir’s friend, Hassan, in an alleyway 27 years ago.
When Amir travels to Pakistan to find Sohrab, he has an unexpected run-in with Assef, the boy who sexually assaulted Hassan in their youth. During their encounter, a fight breaks out between the two. Instead of punching back, Amir starts to laugh. Assef only gets angry, demanding to know why. “What was so funny was that, for the first time since the winter of 1975,1 felt at peace.
He mentions that he and Amir’s group the Pashtuns are the real/ pure breed and Hazaras are the fake/ half breeds. “Afghanistan is the land of Pashtuns. It always has been, always will be. We are the true Afghans, the Pure Afghans,not this Flat-Nose here….” “Afghanistan for Pashtuns, I say.
Unfortunately, Amir, one of the victims, had not been young enough to not understand. As a child, he made the mistake of not helping out his half-brother, Hassan. Even if he could have done something, he didn’t because of his cowardice, which was followed by selfishness. Betrayal made Amir the perpetrator. Due to his act of cruelty, he carried stones of guilt over his shoulder which were never shared with anyone but his own mind.
The author provides the reader with mixed feeling about Amir. In his childhood in Kabul Amir comes off as heartless person. He is this because he has done evil stuff in his life. In the beginning of the story something bad happens to Hassan, Amir says,¨In the end, I ran.
Lastly, Amir sacrifices his life to accommodate for Sohrab, Hassan’s son, after being taken by the Taliban. Amir resembles Baba because he too takes up redemption for the awful things he did. He understands the great danger Sohrab is in. He risks his life to help Sohrab; this shows loyalty to Hassan. Even though Sohrab is not Hassan saving his son shows that Amir is loyal to him.
This event shows irony when Assef used to bully and fight with Hassan and Amir as children and now, as an adult, he is fighting with Sohrab and Amir. These situations are similar yet they mean different things to Amir and show his growth over time. During his childhood, Amir was not a quality
Following the conversation, Amir dwells on one thing, and that is the quote, “There is a way to be good again”(Hosseini 2). Amir travels to Pakistan and learns from Rahim Khan, his friend, a shocking truth. Hosseini depicts the scene,” Did Hassan know? … How could you hide this from me?
While being beaten up by Assef, Amir feels at peace. He feels this ways because he feels that as he is taking the hits from Assef, it shows that he would do anything for Hassan. He is redeeming himself in a way that he is standing up not only for Hassan but also for Sohrab. Amir also stands up for his family, redeeming himself. " Hassan is dead now.
Amir first realizes the depth of his cowardice as he watches Assef rape Hassan in the alley and thinks, “I could step in into that alley, stand up for Hassan—the way he stood up for me all those times in the past—and accept whatever happened to me. Or I could run” (Hosseini 77). He has an epiphany that he could choose to be brave and selfless like Hassan and step up to Assef regardless of any physical consequences. However, despite his understanding that the noble choice would be to interfere and stop Assef, Amir is unable to act on it because his fear of Assef overwhelms him. The guilt that consumes Amir in the weeks following Hassan’s rape indicates that he understands the extent of his selfish behavior and needs to resolve it before he can forgive himself.