He did not know if some suitors did act as a real suitor by their own intention but, some of them could have been faithful to Odysseus by learning from the death of Antinous. Also, after seeing how his kingdom was Odysseus really didn’t care for what he did. In addition, all of the suitors deserved full punishment from Odysseus. The suitors weren’t all the same, for example, there could have been generous suitors that were for Odysseus but none of them really were mentioned in the novel. Penelope and Telemachus both told them that Odysseus was dead, although Telemachus has told them to leave, he did not have to. Lastly, all of the punishment was too severe, but it had to be done with. The suitors should not
These statements illustrate that although the death of the suitors was unfortunate, it was brought on by the suitors themselves. Because the suitors and their kinsmen had been warned beforehand about the possible dangers their actions may bring, there is no reason that they should’ve remained around the home of Odysseus. The many warnings expressed towards the suitors leaves their actions inexcusable and provides evidence as to why Odysseus and Telemachos’ actions reached the severity that they
Compare and Contrast: In The Odyssey Melanthius is brutally killed. “With rustless swords they lopped his nose and ears, pulled out his bowels to be eaten raw by dogs, and in their rage cut off his hands and feet” (Homer 283). He is killed in this manner because he is a wingman of Antinous, the unofficial leader of the suitors. This may symbolize the end of the suitors once and for all. Odysseus is making a statement, one that says he is the leader now.
Leadership can be established in how a hero guides his men and directs them. Numerous warriors from Greek Mythology are lauded for their control and management over their companions in times of difficulty and danger; furthermore, they are a model and an inspiration towards their comrades. Among several brave men, many people considered Odysseus to be incapable of being in charge, but some indications have also shown that his actions for the crew are sufficient. Even though both the controversies of the debate about the topic has information from The Odyssey by Homer, Odysseus is evidently an effective leader. Odysseus demonstrates as an efficient leader when they come across various threatening situations.
Both Odysseus and I have shown cleverness in hard situations that have brought out that cleverness. Homer portrays Odysseus as a man of mind over muscle, although he has enormous strength, he always tries to find a way to get his enemies to make a mistake and exploit it. One such example is when he gets trapped in the cave with Polyphemus and two of his men get eaten. Instead of trying to fight out of anger and his first impulse of “drawing the sharp sword…to stab him,” he thought about the fact that there would be no one to move the boulder for him. As an alternative, Odysseus tricks Polyphemus into letting them free by wounding his only eye with a hot stick and drawing upon all his wits by sneaking out of the cave on the bellies of the sheep.
Telemachus(22.453.487-490). Insisting that these maidservants lack self respect and are disloyal not knowing if they were forced to do something by the suitors. Immediately taking his wife's/mothers side Odysseus and Telemachus brutally hang 12 of the maidservants and they keep the ones that they thought were kind and loyal to Penelope while Odyssseus was
The suitors were very rude to Odysseus, in general, Antinous, they had no respect for him. While Odysseus is talking, Antinous says to him “enough Eat and be quiet where you are, or shamble elsewhere, unless you want these lads to stop your mouth, pulling you by the heels, or hands and feet, till your back is peeling.” (l.1248-1251). Odysseus was attended lowly, like an animal, and the suitors did not attempt to help or stand up for him. They just left him to be looked down upon.
Telemachus has lost all hope that his father is still alive so he believes there is no way of getting rid of the suitors. Telemachus tells Athena, “Yet, were Odysseus to return,
The Suitors exhibit hubris by having no civility when they cause discord at Odysseus’s home and among his family, because they believe because they are of higher social class in Ithaca, they have a right. Athena disguises Odysseus as a worthless beggar, and he travels to his home to beg for his own food, where he an encounter with
Odysseus’s son, Telemakhos discussed the problem of the suitors to Athena. The suitors believed Odysseus to be dead, and decided to try and marry Penelope so they can inherit Odysseus’s wealth and kingdom. Telemakhos realized the suitors intents and the nuisance they have become, when he converses with Athena. “‘... Ithaka’s young lords as
Their jealousy got in the way of what was truly right. When finally landing in Ithaca, he learns that loyalty is something that shouldn't be broken, especially when some of the suitors are from Ithaca, Odysseus' own homeland. This means that the suitors are disloyal to their King because they are courting his wife, stealing all his food, and slaughtering his animals for their feasts. Most importantly, they are plotting to kill Telemachus and Odysseus if he is ever to return to the island. He learns that the only way he can show that he is a firm leader is to reveal to all of Ithaca who he truly is.
Odysseus and Thomas Jefferson: Looking into History to Define What a Hero is Heroes used to be considered people who held great power and always came out on top no matter how high the odds were stacked against them. Today we are more critical of the people we look up to, which I believe to be a good thing. We now realize that the people we consider heroes must be good people, who even though they have flaws, try their hardest to do good for the world. Another interesting question is what it means to be a bad person. Is a bad person someone who is inherently bad?
Of course, the suitors that are there still do not know that the old man is Odysseus, but still he has proven that he is the one to be
These suitors plan to kill Odysseus if they see him. Odysseus expecting this poses as a beggar and sneaks into the suitors contest disguised he is allowed to attempt the challenge he completes it first try before turning the bow on the the men watching and with the help of Telemachus the cowherd and swineherd successfully kills all the suitors.(22.1-129) Odysseus is outnumbered one to a hundred but with his love for Penelope driving him forward to complete this final trial.
It comes to show that the suitors were going too far with their plan to marry Penelope. Even when two of the suitors were begging for their plea to live, Odysseus was kind enough to let them go as stated in the text “Don’t worry he’s saved you. Now you know and you can tell the world, how much better good deeds are than evil. Go outside now you and the singer and sit in the yard.” That shows that even when
Another situation where the moral was shown in the story is the difference between Odysseus and Telemachus’s view towards the suitors. Although they both knew that the suitors had to leave, they had different methods of doing so. “‘And you, if you have any shame in your own hearts,/ you must leave my palace!’”, Telemachus said to the suitors in attempt to remove them from the palace (2.155-56). Telemachus complained about the suitors and threatened them, while Odysseus took another route of action. Odysseus and Telemachus created a complex plan in order to kill each individual suitor who attempted to wed Penelope, Odysseus’s wife (16.298-330).