In this chapter, O’Brien used repetition, a motif, and symbolism to stress the futility of the Vietnam war. First off, the word “Rain” is repeated numerous times throughout the chapter. This repetitious motif symbolizes war, as the war is all around, like how the word is all around the chapter. Furthermore, O’Brien used “Rain” when referring to everlasting events in the story, alongside setting a sad tone (war is never a happy event). For instance, during the hard trek through the waterlogged Song Tra Bong, the rain pounded on the men as they sought out Kiowa. This situation symbolized the unnecessary need for “Rain,” especially while trying to do something already difficult. As Lt. Cross put it, “The rain was war and you had to fight it” …show more content…
In this chapter, O’Brien heavily expressed his ideas through Kiowa’s disappearance and death. In addition to symbolizing a false necessity, the aftermath of Kiowa’s death further exemplifies his point. For example, from pages 162 to 169, the truth behind Kiowa’s cause of death is explained. Basically, the night before he died, all of the men were lying low and remaining incognito. That night was perfectly still, until a fellow soldier shined his flashlight on a picture of his girlfriend to show Kiowa. Kiowa glanced at the image, and simultaneously the young soldier and Kiowa were blown away by enemy artillery. The young soldier knew beforehand that he shouldn’t flash his light at night for that potential reason, but he did anyway and the two soldiers were pelted by the enemy, because of his bad decision. Yet, after the nighttime pandemonium and into the following day, the soldier spent his time trying to locate his lost picture of his girlfriend, instead of Kiowa. Though, on page 165, it is clear that the soldier is wading through slimy, thick waters to find this one little picture. Similar to needles in a haystack, the soldier looked far and deep, “as if something might actually be salvaged from all of the waste,” (pg 165). This part of the story, this line, is implying that the war had no real purpose. Clearly, Kiowa’s death symbolized the unnecessarily wasted …show more content…
Backing up, way before the men found Kiowa, the small platoon, led by Lt. Jimmy Cross, focused particularly intensely on locating him. Although, three men in particular, Norman Bowker, Azar, and Mitchell Sanders, tried to lighten up the mood and their hopes about the search mission. The three passed around comical beliefs about what Kiowa would of thought about the men searching for him at the time. On page 158, Azar flippantly reported, “Man talk about irony. I bet if Kiowa was here, I bet he’d just laugh. Eating sh** - it’s your classic irony.” Norman Bowker replied, “Fine. Now pipe down.” Once again Azar kidded, “Wasted in waste… A sh** field. You got to admit, it’s pure world class irony (Sic).” There are two ways to interpret this communication amongst the men. First, this situation about ”Eating sh**” is exactly what happened to Kiowa, as all through the book, the river is referred to as excrements in smell, look, feel, and so on. In the end, Kiowa did bite it as he died. Kiowa was “folded in the war,” as foreshadowed on page 155. That line may go to show how the war just kept going on in a cycle, in an unnecessary cycle. Another other way to interpret this is to look at the final line “Wasted in the waste.” This line blatantly states that Kiowa’s death was wasted in the war. Kiowa’s death represents false necessities in war, so this line
“On the Rainy River”, an intimate chapter between Tim O'Brien and the reader digs deep within O’Brien’s mind, revealing his extensive fear of going to war and how far he would reach to avoid it. More than 60,000 men avoided the draft for the Vietnam War, O’Brien taking part in that number. Burning draft cards, ignoring “casting” calls and fleeing to Canada grew as young American men were being called to fight a war none had wanted to take part in. Without confronting his parents about the situation from the start, Tim O’Brien fled to the Tip Top Lodge which “jutted northward into the Rainy River”; not quite Canada, but close enough to execute his decision when made(47). Home, a place known to be safe and comforting for O’Brien, where his loved
Final Term Paper: If I Die in a Combat Zone… “Can the foot soldier teach anything important about war, merely for having been there? I think not. He can tell war stories.” -Tim
The Things They Carried is a novel written by Tim O'Brien which follows the daily thoughts, actions, and moments of a company serving in the Vietnam War. The meaning of this work was to depict the gruesome images and effects of war as well as the toll it can take on people. This is executed by utilizing morally ambiguous characters, which are characters whose behavior discourages readers from identifying them as purely evi or purely good. Many characters in the book are morally ambiguous, but one, an unnamed vietcong soldier who was killed in the novel stands out the most.
A novel written about the debatably unnecessary war in Vietnam, The Things They Carried authentically paid tribute to those that served for the United States in the fight against communism. The lives of these soldiers were talked about descriptively by the author of the book, Tim O’Brien as he had a great ton of experience in the war being that he was able to survive long enough to have two different medics in his squadron as well as strongly prefer one over the other. The war veteran showcased the effect the war had on a person with the example of Mark Fossie’s visitor that never left (Mary Anne). She adapted to the war very quickly and gradually became less recognizable by Mark. O’Brien made it clear that war was unable to be explained to
If war and death are closely associated, then it shows how soldiers in the war must have not only been in situations where they could die, but also that in the war, many people suffered and died. War couldn’t be death, if there weren’t a plethora of causalities. This shows how death is physical. While the quote is quite literary, the implicit meaning is that there were thousands of people dying, and that there were many bodies that had to be carried to safe territory, to the hospital and ultimately to their graves. O’Brian implements the theme of death to quantify the number of those who suffered and have their lives in the Vietnam war.
Kiowa’s death was touched upon in several stories, but the insight given to the reader of First Lieutenant Jimmy Cross’s perspective in “In the Field,” is a primary example of this. Jimmy Cross has to write a letter to Kiowa’s father concerning Kiowa’s death and he has to consider the manner in which he will write the letter. He starts off by “just saying what a fine soldier Kiowa had been, what a fine human being, and how he was the kind of son that any father could be proud of forever.” (164) Then he decides: “In the letter to Kiowa’s father he would apologize point-blank.
Rough Draft: The Things They Carried The Vietnam War, was a nightmarish place. It caused paranoia, and made some soldiers insane. Death could come at any moment in any place leaving men in constant fear knowing they could be next. Some men feared it so much they would self inflict wounds in hopes of getting discharged, and others would change their viewpoints on the war and change their actions completely.
Kiowa knows it is wrong to bring war into a place of peace. With this peace of mind, it shows how good of a person Kiowa is. It showed why people like him as a person. In a like manner, O’Brien discusses morality in the chapter “The Man I Killed.”
In The things They Carried, by Tim O’brien in that field there are two people that take responsibility for Kiowa’s death, whether it be directly or indirectly, they truly had not no control of what would happen that night. Jimmy Cross blames him self for the death of Kiowa because he chose the position and listened to the orders from the top. He could have lied and change their location to protect his men but he did not. The other solider who took responsibility was the young boy that was never named. The boy had been distracted and had a lapse in his judgment.
The knowledge of ethos, logos, and pathos develops and improves yourself as an analytical reader by recognizing the appeals the author uses throughout their text for the readers. It helps reveal the author’s approach in their writing, such as appealing to the reader’s emotions, setting themselves as an credible and reliable source, or uses facts and data to back up their approach. It develops a deeper understanding of the text and the author’s way of addressing the audience. The things they carry are both physical and emotional burdens that weigh them down. O’Brien repeats the weight of each physical item they carry: “for a total weight of nearly 18 pounds...the M-60, which weighed 23 pounds...starlight scope, which weighed 6.3 pounds…” (page
1.Guilt is one of the worst things accompanied by death. Guilt plays a huge role throughout the novel. In war, men are constantly dying and these men all become best friends with one another. For example, Norman Bowker felt a tremendous amount of quilt towards the death of Kiowa.
The person had to deal with death and the reality of war under the worst case scenario. Bob “Rat” Kiley was that soldier and one of the many soldiers that left something in the war. He had lost his friend Curt Lemon and that’s the first sign that the war has been turning to be painful for him. This coping mechanism for the death was to write letters to lemon’s sister and he shot a baby Water Buffalo. This coping mechanism is seen in the chapter “How to tell a true war story”, shows how he has been affected and explained the toll the war had taken on him.
The Chicano Movement of the 1960s brought to the forefront of Mexican-American consciousness the need to identify as a self-determined group with unique histories, legends, heroes, triumphs, and legacies (Garcia). This belief in the importance of a renegotiation of Chicano subjectivity and the retrieval of a lost history is embedded in the text of Arturo Islas’ novel The Rain God. Miguel Chico puts forth in this story about a family of sinners—the Angel family—that literature can be utilized as a source of recovery through the acknowledgment of systems of oppression. Miguel, who is the narrator-protagonist of the story, as well as a closeted homosexual, writes, “Perhaps he had survived to tell others about Mama Chona and people like Maria.
In the novel, If I Die in a Combat Zone: Box Me Up and Ship Me, the author, Tim O’Brien, takes the reader through his own personal experience as a soldier during the Vietnam War. Not only did O’Brien describe the disturbing and horrific incidents he encountered in Vietnam, but he also gave his opinion about the war. He strongly believed that the war was both immoral and unjust. “The war, I thought, was wrongly conceived and poorly justified”(O’Brien 1975, 18). Though he believed the war was unjust, O’Brien still served his duty in Vietnam.
Sent by Patriots, Dismissed by Protestors In order to better convey an understandable universal truth in their works, writers will distort factual happening truth by creating a fictional story truth. Tim O’Brien uses fictional characters in the novel, The Things They Carried, to convey the pressure American draftees faced when called to join the military in Vietnam. Recruits of the Vietnam War Draft in 1969 were descendants of World War II veterans, subsequently, military service was an expectation. Recruits who dodged the draft would forever be labeled by America as cowards who would, as Vietnam Veteran, Francis T. Logan states, in the South Dakota Vietnam War Memorial Dedication, “live with,” their national embarrassment along with, “their