ipl-logo

Pennington's Essay 'From Elfland To Hogwarts'

1805 Words8 Pages

In "From Elfland to Hogwarts, or the Aesthetic trouble with Harry Potter," Pennington argues that "there seems to be nothing particularly original about Rowling's borrowings" (82). Nonetheless, in the article, he borrows quotes from ten different scholars - in addition to numerous references to books, TV series and movies. However, Pennington's "fuzzy set of influences" (82), is the true masterpiece of his essay. Throughout his eighteen-page essay, he mentions, with the same easiness and expertise, Tolkien and Carroll, Roland Barthes and Acocella, Harry Potter and Nancy Drew. Notably, Pennington's bravura resides in building his arguments through quotes from area-specific intellectuals: the essay is crafted so that, for example, Kathryn Hume …show more content…

Notably, Pennington quotes, from chapter 39 of "The Goblet of Fire", the battle between Harry and Voldemort where "the two enemies are described as "hissing" (e.g. 644, 646)" (Pennington 86), thus exposing not only how J.K. Rowling tends to use the same verbs, but also the lack of distinctiveness between two characters that should be completely different. However, as Pennington states, "The Goblet of Fire […] [has] 734 pages" (86) and, in his essay, he only substantiates his assertions with examples from six different pages - "for Snape also hisses (e.g. Goblet 470, 472, 516), as does Ron (e.g. 513)" (86) - which, statistically, accounts for a negligible 0.68% use of the verb "to hiss" in Rowling's book. Furthermore, to illustrate Rowling's descriptive style, Pennington proposes a comparison between two extensive descriptions, one from Harry Potter and one from LeGuin's "Wizards of Earthsea". His argument is that the citations, which are 122 and 119 words respectively, are the reflection of an increment in length in Rowling books which accounts for her books' increasingly sloppier language and insignificant depictions. However, the logical connection between these two quotes -virtually identical in length and taken from different books - and Rowling's prose is preposterous. Additionally, in this particular case, Pennington does not even give any example of stylistic differences between the quotes, leaving the task to the astute deductions of the readers. Thus, this paucity of examples and quotes is a symptom of the global lack of credibility of Pennington's claim that "Harry Potter […]

Show More
Related

  • Red Fern Grows Movie Vs Book

    496 Words  | 2 Pages

    Looking at the two different quotes you can see that they are a lot different. Looking at the books’ quote it is a lot more detailed and described

    Read More

  • Quotes From Harry Crew

    789 Words  | 4 Pages

    The first main idea comes right from the first sentence. Harry states, “[as] young as I was, I knew it was all a lie.” This is a very important thing to keep in mind of how a boy at a young age is able to know that this is not real. This shows that he is an intelligent child. That is until the next line in which he reveals his naïve personality.

    Read More

  • Harry Woods Essay Questions

    574 Words  | 3 Pages

    From the movie of Laramie project, I realized the theme of Harry Woods interview was a lot more powerful when performed than reading it in the play. The interview mentioned the homecoming parade that touched Harry Woods heart, people were walking for Matthew, breaking the prejudice in Laramie. It was memorable because I did not have an idea of a scene of the parade, it’s not clear when I read that in the play. Homecoming has always been a tradition thing that goes on in America, but not so much in Canada, therefore it is quite unclear for me of what it should look like in real life. But seeing it on a screen and knowing how different it is from my imagination, it has touched me and I got the understanding of what Harry Woods had.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Plagiarism In Malcolm Gladwell's Something Borrowed

    1107 Words  | 5 Pages

    The third and last point Gladwell brought up about plagiarism is that writers evolve as time continues and from that, they must have some point of inspiration when writing. Writing can almost be impossible to create a piece that is original or using words that have not been used before which in turn makes it hard for people to not use others work as a foundation for what they are trying to bring to the reader. Plagiarism is a topic in all schools that are discussed among students that it is never all right to use someone else’s work as your own. It sounds simple enough but, it can be hard to write on a topic that is an original piece. Even though plagiarism is not

    Read More

  • Pros Of Banning Books

    1074 Words  | 5 Pages

    This article will also be talking about the book series Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone it was written by J.K. Rowling, this book will be used to prove

    Read More

  • Essay On Piggy In Lord Of The Flies

    406 Words  | 2 Pages

    Author, William Golding, in his novel, "Lord of the Flies," follows a group of British boys who are stranded on an uninhabited island and try to govern themselves. One of the boys, Piggy, is constantly bullied and considered a nuisance by the power-hungry boys on the island. Golding's use of an isolated setting in the midst of the other boys illustrates Piggy's struggle to liberate himself from their oppression. However the need to survive reveals Piggy's inventiveness and rational mindset.

    Read More

  • Lord Voldemort's Army Of Death Eaters In Harry Potter

    876 Words  | 4 Pages

    Sharp analysis and research on Rowling’s books and the acquisition of a deeper understanding

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Jk Rowley Speech

    877 Words  | 4 Pages

    Rhetorical Analysis – J.K. Rowling “The Fringe Benefits of Failure, and the Importance of Imagination” The author of the famous Harry Potter series - J.K. Rowling held this speech during a graduation ceremony at Harvard University. The speech was to the Harvard graduates from June 5, 2008 and was held outside in the famous ‘Old Harvard Yard’ as a tradition. The purpose of the speech was to celebrate and congratulate the graduating class.

    Read More

  • Witchcraft In Christianity Today

    313 Words  | 2 Pages

    However, some people go even a step farther in their opinions on the novel. In October of 2000 Christianity Today made this comment: “Though the parallels (between drinking rat poison and Rowling’s books) are hardly exact, this is what we’re talking about regarding the Harry Potter series. We’re taking something deadly from our world and turning it into what some are calling ‘merely a literary device.’ Regardless of how magic is portrayed in the series, we need to remember that witchcraft in real life can and does lead to death —the forever and ever kind” (). This comment was not uncommon at this time and it was comments like this that fueled similar feelings among the Christian population.

    Read More

  • The Witch By Roald Dahl Essay

    845 Words  | 4 Pages

    Emily Garner Mrs. Yoder English D115 November 14, 2017 Why The Witches was Censored Roald Dahl has written at least 40 books that can be enjoyed by all age groups. At one point in his career he was known as one of the most well known children’s authors of all time. The Witches, a popular book by many was written by Roald Dahl and was published in 1983 around the time of his other book, The BFG, also one of his popular book. The Witches is a fantasy book that caught the attention of young readers around the world as they would enter a spooky land full of creatures only found in scary stories.

    Read More

  • Essay On Diary Of A Wimpy Kid Cabin Fever

    461 Words  | 2 Pages

    Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Cabin fever is about a wimpy teenager named Greg Heffely. The book acts as a diary for Greg. In this diary, Greg writes about the everyday struggles that he endures. In this particular book, he writes about the struggles he endures close to the times of the holidays. These are few of the things about the book.

    Read More

  • The Hobbit Literary Analysis Essay

    663 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Hobbit Literary Analysis Would you be able to step out of your comfort zone for the sake of adventure and a promise of treasure? This was the predicament Bilbo Baggins is unexpectedly presented with one sunny afternoon. Thirteen dwarves appear at his door and put forward their offer. Bilbo is a little apprehensive at first but soon comes to the realization that in his ordinary life of a Hobbit in the Shire he will never get another opportunity like this again. When reading The Hobbit, being able to step out of your comfort zone is a major key.

    Read More

  • Sacrificial Love In Harry Potter And The Sorcerer's Stone

    996 Words  | 4 Pages

    When hearing the words ‘Harry Potter’, the first image that comes to mind is of wizards and witches on broomsticks, and a particular boy with a scar on his forehead. Biblical ideas are automatically assumed as against the principles presented in the famous novels, many times due to an outcry by groups of Christians, thus resulting in the two rarely being associated. However, biblical themes run rampant throughout J.K Rowling’s Harry Potter series- especially of the Holy Trinity, the idea of worthiness, and sacrificial love.

    Read More

  • Harry Potter Marxist Analysis

    1484 Words  | 6 Pages

    In this essay I will discuss Marxism in relation to the book series Harry Potter written by J.K Rowling. Even though The Harry Potter series is a children’s book series, when they are read carefully, the readers can see aspects of Marxism in it. One of the aspects that I will be focusing on in this essay is the idea of the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. For the purpose of this essay I will be looking at the Harry Potter series but focusing on the last book, The Deathly Hallows as there are more examples of the ideas Marxism.

    Read More

  • Gender Roles In Harry Potter And The Philosopher's Stone

    979 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Harry Potter series have been an interesting series for me ever since I have enrolled in Professor Fox’s class. I personally have not read any of the Harry Potter series during my childhood, but once I have enrolled in Professor Fox’s class I have recently just finished Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone. Throughout my readings of these two books I have had many observations on certain aspects of the story that I would not have noticed when I was younger. These three aspects that I can’t imagine as a child noticing is how the Dursleys abused Harry, the stance on gender, and prejudgement based on appearance.

    Read More

More about Pennington's Essay 'From Elfland To Hogwarts'

Open Document