Sentencing the Victim Throughout Sentencing the Victim, Joanna Katz was victimized more than once. During Joanna Katz process with the criminal justice system, she showed courage and strength. According to Joanna’s father, “When sentencing the offender, the victim gets sentenced too because as long as they are locked up, we are sharing that sentence with them.” On numerous occasions Joanna gets victimized from the actual criminal acts, to going to court every year for each offender. There were many problems address in the video that has lasting affects on not only the victim, but also the victim’s family. One of the main reasons why this video was called sentencing the victim was essentially because every year Joanna and her family had to travel from Charleston, South Carolina to Columbia, South Carolina to each offender’s parole board. This sentenced her family and her in numerous ways such as, having to relieve that moment every time it was time to go to these parole boards. The drive to Columbia from Charleston is at least two hours, so I can only imagine how she felt throughout the ride. Another way Joanna and her family was victimized by going to these parole boards was just the thought that these offenders may be released one day, could put her on edge. She goes …show more content…
When Joanna first got away from her offenders, she passed by a taxi driver who just drove pass her. He did not stop to see what was wrong with her or if she would be okay to get home alone. It was only when the next person saw her that they decided to call the police. Once she got with the police to try to find her friend, the police did not believe that her friend was in the car, until the driver drove off. This, I’m sure of, made her lose trust in the criminal justice system. Throughout the course of Joanna telling her story for this video, she was victimized. She had to relive the entire tremendous life changing event all over
Sentencing disparity within the American Judicial system is a problem that exists across the nation. According to Merriam Webster’s dictionary, disparity means the markedly distinct in quality or character. Many times, disparity is used in conjunction with discrimination as if the two words mean the same, but they do not. Disparity will include a difference in treatment or outcome but is not based on an opinion, bias or prejudice.
Teagan Farmer Ms. DeLong Practical Law 7 February 2018 Cyntoia Brown Juvenile Justice Case Cyntoia Brown was just a sixteen year old girl when her life suddenly came spiraling out of control. “According to years of local media reports, a 2011 documentary about her case and court documents detailing Brown’s own testimony and that of a juvenile psychiatrist, Brown suffered from Fetal Alcohol Syndrome, grew up in an abusive home and had ran away from her adoptive parents’ house prior to becoming involved in prostitution in Nashville” (Willingham, 2017). According to Brown, the “victim,” Johnny Allan, picked up her up at the local Sonic and drove her back to his house after hiring her as a prostitute. She claims there was gun cabinet in the bedroom
One of the most famous examples of a sentencing circle in use was the tragic case involving the death of two little girls in 2008. Christopher Pauchay, the father, was intoxicated when he took his two little girls out into the freezing cold barely dressed, and as result both froze to death in the harsh Saskatchewan climate. This case drew a lot of attention towards the community’s growing issues with alcohol abuse. The community, YellowQuill First Nation reserve, requested a sentencing circle be held to deal with these issues in a traditional Aboriginal fashion bringing the victim (in this case the mother), the community (which included elders and others), and the offender together. This request was highly controversial, considering the nature
Innocence Project Report on the Case of Curtis Jasper Moore Tommy Warrick Drake University According to the Innocence Project one of the greatest causes of wrongful conviction is due to eyewitness misidentification. They state that 72% of cases where defendants have been exonerated eyewitness misidentification played a role. Even though eyewitness testimony has been proven inaccurate numerous times, it can still be the decisive evidence in a court of law. This is because the law views the human memory as a camcorder which can record and repeat whatever it sees.
“The Correctional Service of Canada (CSC), as part of the criminal justice system and respecting the rule of law, contributes to public safety by actively encouraging and assisting offenders to become law-abiding citizens, while exercising reasonable, safe, secure and humane control (CSC Values Statement, 2016). In regards to the CSC values mission statement, in this general case, they did not fully succeed in what their value missions statement had said. Often in this Ashley Smith case it will always refer back to CSC’s values mission statement to see if CSC actually followed through with what their expectations were in the Justice System and how they could of handled Ashley Smith in more of a humane approach. This case within the Justice
On September 21st, I attended an event featuring guest activist and author Susan Burton. The event started at 2:00pm as the room overflowed with people eager to hear Susan 's voice. There were people occupying every space of the rather small Whitsett room. Ms. Burton first talked about the traumas she suffered as a child and later, as an adult. Susan 's son was tragically ran over and killed by a police officer, which led to alcohol and drug abuse and her eventual incarceration.
Sentencing Guidelines are a set of rules used by judges in the criminal justice system in the United States. The sentencing guidelines were first established in Massachusetts in 1994. When the sentencing guidelines were established, its main goal was to "promote truth in sentencing by developing a set of guidelines that was appropriate in consideration to the crime the individual had committed." (Massachusetts Sentencing Guidelines, February 1998, the Honorable Robert A. Mulligan, Chairman). There are ten steps that are included in the sentencing guidelines.
I chose a clip from Family Guy called Quagmire’s Sister is Submissive The video is about Glenn Quagmire’s sister Brenda, who is in an abusive relationship with her boyfriend Jeff. Quagmire cares about his sister and wants her to get away from Jeff, but she is blind from the abuse. She thinks that Jeff is just upset about other things and corrects her when she messes up.
Obviously a topic considering people who harm their kids in sexual abuse is a extremely sensitive matter. So the video did give tribute for the victims of the false enjailment. It also showed a well respected side of how people would normally react to this event. People were more willing to believe that these parents did this horrible act rather than coming to the realization that they did not do it as they said. These people would rather believe that the mom and dad would hurt their children without a single shred of physical evidence.
Inadequately trained facilitators/probation officers may cause victim offender mediation or a family-group conference to fail. Poor facilitation may thus lead to parties abusing each other. In addition, grossly disproportionate conditions may be set and even recommended to the court.[98][99] Davies et al116 highlights another valid concern, namely that role-players working with the child offender[100] may find it difficult to accept their role in relation to the victim as
Elizabeth Sheehy has been teaching at the University of Ottawa in the Law Faculty since 1984. She holds three degrees; a Bachelor's in law from Osgoode Law, a Master’s in Law from Columbia University and a Doctorate, an Honoris Causa, in Law from Law Society of Upper Canada. She currently holds the Shirley E. Greenberg chair (2013-2015), and previously held it from 2002 to 2004. The chair is awarded to “qualified faculty members.” Individuals in this position are “committed to women’s equality through law;” they encourage more women to be a part of the legal profession; and “further law reform and research” as it impacts women” (Shirley Greenberg chair).
What would you do if you had a gun pointed at your head by your spouse several times? Or beaten twice a week? Leslie Morgan Steiner, has been though domestic abuse and creates a speech to answer a question most people ask, “Why does she stay?” (Steiner). In the speech logos, pathos and ethos are used to make her point proven on how domestic abuse is an important issue and why it need to be spoken about.
As I watched the documentary “Road Beyond Abuse,” I experienced a whirlwind of emotions. From disgusted and disappointed to impressed and joyful, I felt it all. It truly disturbed me to hear about the experiences both Michael McCain and Johnnetta McSwain endured. I was disgusted that no one protected these innocent children from being verbally abused, beaten, raped, and left to fend for themselves. It was shocking to hear that these children withstood this amount of abuse from their family members until they were teenagers.
In the story by Martin Gansberg, 38 Who Saw Murder But Didn’t Call The Police the author describes the horrific acts of 38 people. In the story Martin Gansberg explains how little it takes for one person to impact someone else’s life. In the murder of Kitty, whom was stabbed a total of three times at a period of 35 minutes it proves how one single person could have made a difference. Catherine was stalked and hunted one night after her shift at a bar she worked at ended, it was after three am when this incident happened although with crime rising around the country and people becoming more involved with the civil rights movements it is shocking how nobody bothered to reach for help until after Catherine was dead.