Summary Of The Controversial Court Case Of Ogden Vs. Gibbons
Ogden vs. Gibbons was a controversial court case that was debated in 1824 after Aaron Ogden filed a restraint against Thomas Gibbons. Ogden and Gibbons were former business partners in the steamboat industry and for three years they successfully worked together throughout waterways in New York. Unfortunately Gibbons decided to operate another steamboat that came in conflict with Ogden’s steamboat and this is when Ogden filed a restraint against Gibbons. Ogden’s complaint was that he no longer wanted Gibbons to operate steamboats in New York waters. This was an important court case because the court had to figure out who had the power to control navigation in interstate waterways. This court case focused on the Commerce Clause in Article …show more content…
Ogden (1824)). The Court continued to review this case in great detail. Section 8 of Article 1 could be interpreted in many different ways and they wanted to be sure that the ruling would be fair not only to Ogden and Gibbons but to other steamboat operators as well. Chief Justice John Marshall ultimately decided that Congress had the power to regulate commerce in interstate waterways because if each state made its own rules, it would be almost impossible to trade in the waterways. Politically, this court case made it easier for similar incidents to be ruled fairly. Congress was able to make this ruling under the necessary and proper clause which allowed it “to carry out lex Moore 10/12/14 Bill of Rights Essay its enumerated power to ‘regulate commerce…among the several states’” (Landmark Supreme Court Cases – Gibbons v. Ogden (1824)). Culturally, the decision helped steamboat operators be able to understand what they were allowed to do and who would be in charge for any punishment should that ever be needed. Many reactions to the Ogden vs Gibbons case were very positive. There were more steamboat operators just in New York’s waterways alone. Many found it to be in their
United States Involvement In World War II
659 Words | 3 PagesAime Amouzou Period# 7 3/13/14 Although improving economic conditions and the threat to national security causes American support for the Allies, the United States entered World War II in order to preserve democratic values worldwide. As time went on and the war continued in Europe, the threat to national security and democratic values increased, and the United States became closer and closer to entering the war. The war time economy, which existed only on the grounds of preparedness and aid to the allies, was booming, and finally bringing a complete recovery from the depression. The American public clearly favored the Allied powers, and entrance to World War II became inevitable.
Compare Fulton And Livingston Inventions
219 Words | 1 PagesDuring the early 1800’s, Robert Fulton developed the first commercial steamboat with the aid of Robert R. Livingston. This invention “secured American economic stability and influenced everyday life for over a century”. The steamboat made transportation much for efficient by shortening the time traveled, including that of upstream navigation. While Fulton and Livingston are the primary creators for this innovative invention, they do not deserve monopolies. Fulton and Livingston did however, create and extend a monopoly which the Supreme Court declared unconstitutional because of their excessive control of trade.
The Case Of Sovereign Immunity: Seminole Tribe Of Florida V. Florida 1996
676 Words | 3 PagesThe Seminole Tribe sued the state of Florida, arguing that the state's actions violated the IGRA and their tribal sovereignty. The case ultimately reached the US Supreme Court, which ruled in favor of the Seminole Tribe in a 6-3 decision.
Fugitive Slave Case: Ableman V. Booth, 62 US
536 Words | 3 PagesAccording to the Tenth Amendment of the constitution, “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people”. There have been moments in history where Congress has implemented laws that states felt were unconstitutional. The Constitution gave states the ability to counter the federal government’s power through the Judiciary branch of government, when they feel a law is unconstitutional. The Founders of our nation gave Congress enumerated powers to pass legislation that needs to be abided by all states and citizens. At times Congress will overstep its powers by enacting laws that are unconstitutional and the states have the right to challenge those powers.
How Did Transportation Change From 1815 To 1860
468 Words | 2 PagesDuring the period of 1815-1860, a Transportation Revolution swept through America (Murrin pg. 293). The improvements in transportation included more and better roads. steamboats, canals, and railroads (Murrin pg. 293). These new railroads were able to connect old communities with previously isolated areas (Murrin pg. 293). In 1815 the United States was a rural area stretching from old settlements on the Atlantic coast to the trans-Appalachian west, with transportation facilities spanning from primitive and nonexistent (Murrin pg. 294).
Steamboat Law Exposed In The Short Film 'Gibbons Vs. Ogden'
318 Words | 2 PagesIn the brief film “Gibbons vs. Ogden”, the conflict of how New York Steamboat Law seems to interfer with the Federal Coastal Act was adressed. The basics of this case are, The captain of the ship, Bellona, was reported as unlawfully operating a steam boat; he did not have a licenense. Confused, he stated he did have a license to navigate on the United States ocean, the Constable responded with the phrase, New york has jurdiction of the new york waters, Gibbons was furious. In 1789 a New York Steamboat Act was passed, stating, anybody who would be driving through the Waters of New York would need a license from Livingston and Futon. After futher discussion, it was discovered, that the Federal Coasting Act is unconstitutional.
Roger Baldwin's Role In Slavery
430 Words | 2 PagesThis greatly affected the court case because it gave all his arguments a lot more strength then they should have had. This combined with
Nebraska Press Association V. Stuart Case Study
690 Words | 3 PagesThe Supreme of the United States is the body entrusted with interpreting the Constitution in relation to cases whose outcomes will establish precedents with weighty, far reaching legal implications. In many such cases, the conflicting parties may both claim that their actions or (in the case of public officials) rulings, are protected by one or more amendments to the constitution. In reconciling these conflicts, justices must reckon with the intent of laws written centuries ago in relation to contemporary issues. They must also make decisions where the scope of one legally protected right comes into conflict with another. The 1976 case, Nebraska Press Association v. Stuart, provides an example of this nuanced, subtle process and highlights the way in which Supreme Court decisions have potentially monumental, everlasting consqequences.
Lochner V. New York Case
555 Words | 3 PagesHe mentioned that (from 2:12 to 2:37) “this case has become a political symbol and it was made into a political symbol by Teddy Roosevelt when he ran for president in 1912, and it was a symbol about how Roosevelt claimed that the court had overreached and overstepped its boundaries to block progressive legislation from being enacted at the state level.” Besides, Paul Kens, a Texas State University professor wrote a book named Lochner v. New York, thought it was the most controversial decision because of two reasons (from 3:42 to 4:20): “one of those reasons is that it had an economic element to it, a conflict between two different decisions.
A History Of Steam Sustainability
215 Words | 1 PagesThe history of steamboats is quite interesting. Back before cars and trains existed, rivers were used for trasportation. The travels they often took were slow because speed of travel depended on the river current, and manpower. That is, until, the 1800s where steamboats could reach up to speeds of 5 miles per hour. After they realized they could reach such speeds, the men started river travel and trade.
Grand Jury: An Important Role In The Criminal Process
433 Words | 2 PagesResearch Paper Grand Jury plays an important role in the criminal process, but it does not involve finding the guilt or punishment of a party. A grand jury determines whether criminal charges should be brought. If the grand jury returns an indictment, it is referred to as a true bill. If the grand jury refuses to indict the defendant, it is referred to as a no bill. The prosecutor instead works with the grand jury.
The Erie Canal Region
1228 Words | 5 PagesThe Erie Canal region is used as a microcosm to determine the different changes in geography, environment, government, and the economy. The middle class had demanded, and influenced, a change in the way that trade worked the period before the civil war. With this change came the import of new/scarce foods that New Yorkers typically didn 't have access to such as oysters. The transformation of this region as a result of the Erie Canal is organized around six topics, each of which is covered by a chapter. Governor DeWitt Clinton was the pioneer who led this expedition in an effort to show the public that he was dedicated to technological progress for the people of the north.
What Was The Importance Of The Erie Canal In The 1800s
217 Words | 1 PagesIn the early 1800s, the governor of New York, Dewitt Clinton, came up with a plan to support the abundance of the rivers. He decided to dig a 363-mile canal located in New York between Lake Erie and the Hudson River. This canal was called “The Erie Canal”. The Erie Canal provided the best connection between the east coast and the settlements near the Great Lakes. This canal would also be helpful to transporting crops and can also be used as an irrigation system to water crops, etc.
Establishment Clause Test Case Study
921 Words | 4 PagesThe Court has, in previous cases, established three separate tests for determining violations of the Establishment Clause. The Petitioners, in the present case, offer sufficient –though not outstanding – evidence to comply with the requirements of each. The Lemon Test exists as a three-pronged test: 1) Does the challenged action have a secular purpose; 2) Does the challenged action remain neutral (neither advances nor inhibits a religion); 3) Does the challenged action avoid excessive entanglement between governmental institutions and religious institutions. Lemon v. Kurtzman, [403 U.S. 602, 91 S.C.T. 2105 (1971)].
Steamboats In The 1800s: Improvement Of Transportation
372 Words | 2 PagesSteamboats Steamboats in the 1800s were very important in the United states. The development of steamboats, impact on the economy, and how they worked were important to the improvement of transportation. Steamboats in the 1800s in America were very important for the shipping industry. Robert Fulton's first design was in France and his first ship was called the Clermont. This was the first form of steam travel.
More about Summary Of The Controversial Court Case Of Ogden Vs. Gibbons
United States Involvement In World War II
659 Words | 3 PagesCompare Fulton And Livingston Inventions
219 Words | 1 PagesThe Case Of Sovereign Immunity: Seminole Tribe Of Florida V. Florida 1996
676 Words | 3 PagesFugitive Slave Case: Ableman V. Booth, 62 US
536 Words | 3 PagesHow Did Transportation Change From 1815 To 1860
468 Words | 2 PagesSteamboat Law Exposed In The Short Film 'Gibbons Vs. Ogden'
318 Words | 2 PagesRoger Baldwin's Role In Slavery
430 Words | 2 PagesNebraska Press Association V. Stuart Case Study
690 Words | 3 PagesLochner V. New York Case
555 Words | 3 PagesA History Of Steam Sustainability
215 Words | 1 PagesGrand Jury: An Important Role In The Criminal Process
433 Words | 2 PagesThe Erie Canal Region
1228 Words | 5 PagesWhat Was The Importance Of The Erie Canal In The 1800s
217 Words | 1 PagesEstablishment Clause Test Case Study
921 Words | 4 PagesSteamboats In The 1800s: Improvement Of Transportation
372 Words | 2 Pages