“Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” Analysis In the article “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” by Amy Chua. Mrs. Chua explained in her essay how Chinese mothers use tactics of obedience, discipline and etc. to raise their children in a way that differs the way western parents do. In the beginning of this essay, the readers are told that the author Amy Chua, Is a professor at a university called Yale Law School and she has two daughters that she raised in her Chinese way. Furthermore, the audience read that Mrs. Chua sees herself as a so-called “Chinese Mother” (Chua, Para 3). The word Chinese mother do not necessarily need to be of Chinese decent because some like Korean, Indian and other groups can be as strict of a parents like the Chinese, …show more content…
Her children cannot have “play dates and sleep over” (Chu, para 2) and other things that is considered fun in this generation. Instead of having “fun” the children have to be extra focus on the studies and their academic skills such as being at the top of their school and being able to play the piano. People might think that this is abusive, harsh, and strict, however Chua argues that if the child know how to be good at something they will have fun doing so. Amy Chua has a list of examples on what her children shouldn’t do in a regular basis. “1. Attend sleep overs. 2. Have a play date. 3. Be in a school play. 4. Complain about not being in a play. 5. Watch TV or play computer games. 6. Choose their own extracurricular activities. 7. Get a grade less than an A…” (Chua, para 2). She uses examples to give the audience an idea on how to raise their children with a strict parenting method so the kid would have a bright future. That is what she is saying in this essay. Amy Chua is real good in engaging with the readers. She did this because of how she uses examples, where she believes that because of giving the examples western parents can learn from this and apply it to how they raise their children. This method help Chua grab the …show more content…
Contrast is what Amy Chua used to show the other group that the way she run things is smoother and better than theirs. The author contrast Chinese parents and Western parents. She wants to show that Chinese parents are better than Western parents and this sparks a controversy among the readers. According to her, Chinese mothers can get away with saying that Western parents wouldn’t even dare to do. An example of this statement she uses a memory of her childhood. When Amy Chua was a little girl she disrespected her mother, which resulted in her dad calling her “garbage.” (Chua, para 9) this caused Chua to feel pathetic about herself, ashamed, and regretful for doing what she had done. Whenever her children act disrespectful to her she uses this kind of word choice to show authority in the family. To Amy Chua this perfectly normal and not abusive at all. She is happy that she can say what she wants and no one is there to tell her it’s wrong. “Chinese mothers can say to their daughters, “Hey fatty- lose some weight.” By contrast Western parents have to tiptoe around the issue, talking in terms of “health” and never ever mentioning the f-word…” (Chua, para 10). She is saying Western parents are soft and Chinese parents are more assertive. Amy Chua is successful in using contrast because she captured he audience, assuming that the intended audience is a Western parent. This made her essay very exciting to
Alice presents the idea that the relationship between Chinese children and their parents is one quite different from that of Australian children and their parents. ‘These were questions Chinese children never asked their parents.’ (Page 144) She suggests that different etiquette and customs are undertaken and that the bond between them differs. Alice alludes to the idea that these differences in the home are the foundation for the differences Alice perceives socially.
There daughters were always ashamed of and resented their mothers, especially while they were young. The daughters felt this way because of the way their mothers raised them. The mothers were very hard on their daughters, and pushed them towards successful, sometimes causing their daughter to feel overwhelmed. The mothers wanted their daughters to keep their Chinese heritage and culture, but also take advantage of the opportunities they have in America. The daughters were often ashamed of their Chinese heritage, and the way that their mothers acted.
The mother in “Fish Cheeks” wants her daughter Amy to not wish to be someone she is not. She tells Amy, “You want to be the same as American girls on the outside. But inside you are always Chinese” (Tan, 176). Amy’s mother doesn’t want Amy to have childish desires to be an American girl, and instead embrace her Chinese qualities like an adult. While Amy’s mother encourages adult maturity through pride and self-esteem, Richard’s mother teaches him to grow up with a stern and violent method.
This is the classic story between parent and child in Amy Tan’s “Two Kinds.” The theme of this story revolves around a mother who wants nothing but the best for her daughter. Mrs. Woo, the mother of Jing-mei, is a struggling immigrant who had lost everything in China and believes in the American dream by stating, "My mother believed you could be anything you wanted to be in America” (639). She puts Jing-mei into various activities to figure out what she could be good at.
Amy Chua’s intense Chinese mother style is extremely hard on children. The author begins explaining how many stereotypical Chinese children become successful.
She wrote the article keeping parents in mind, by telling stories and shedding light on the true points that every parent experiences. Parents were her target audience who she wrote to show them all the benefits of this new type of parenting while letting them know that she understands the overprotective urge. She presents her own opinions without pushing anyone to believe them, but she makes sure they are stated clearly. The article was well thought out and composed to bring awareness that it’s acceptable for young kids to be allowed freedom to
This language is evident on page 6 in which Maxine asks her readers, "Chinese-Americans, when you try to understand what things are in you are Chinese, how do you separate what is peculiar to childhood, to poverty, insanities, one family, your mother who marked your growing with stories, from what is Chinese?" (Kingston, 6). This quote from the beginning of the book demonstrates the struggles around being the ideal Chinese American Maxine's mother envisioned her to be. From the young age at which Maxine's mother began telling her stories, Maxine had to equip and absorb the Chinese manners her mom forced upon her. Accordingly, it was crucial for Maxine to fully understand and execute expectations these stories unveiled, due to how significant they were in shaping her identity.
As many Chinese-Americans grew up in the 1960’s, one women described it best in her multiple literary works. Bestselling, Chinse-American writer, Amy Tan in her autobiographic essay, “Fish Cheeks”, illustrates her humiliating experience at a Christmas Eve dinner at the age of fourteen. Tan’s purpose is to interpret the idea of how her mother cared for Tan deeply and wanted her to be proud of her Chinese heritage and family. She adopts a nostalgic tone in order to engage relatable thoughts and feelings in her adult readers. Even decades after the essay had been written, readers can still relate to the embarrassing situation that Tan had to face.
The book and the movie possess similar qualities. First, in both the movie and the book, all the mothers left their old lives in China for a new one in America. ” My mother could sense that the woman of these families also had
Throughout the entire novel, the mothers and daughters face inner struggles, family conflict, and societal collision. The divergence of cultures produces tension and miscommunication, which effectively causes the collision of American morals, beliefs, and priorities with Chinese culture which
In this story by Gish Jen's called “Who’s Irish?" it tells a story about an elderly Chinese woman living in America as she and her family struggle with issues concerning the correct way to raise a child, and cultural differences between the two families. She is an old fashion elderly lady who migrated from China. When she came to America she had a hard time and struggled to adapt to the new lifestyle. Having a daughter that's married to an man who is not Chinese and having a mixed granddaughter made it more complicated for her to adapt emotionally as well.
The Woman Warrior is a “memoir of a girlhood among ghosts” in which Maxine Hong Kingston recounts her experiences as a second generation immigrant. She tells the story of her childhood by intertwining Chinese talk-story and personal experience, filling in the gaps in her memory with assumptions. The Woman Warrior dismantles the archetype of the typical mother-daughter relationship by suggesting that diaspora redefines archetypes by combining conflicting societal norms. A mother’s typical role in a mother-daughter relationship is one of guidance and leadership. Parents are responsible for teaching a child right from wrong and good from evil.
Read this quote from the text. “There I was, a ten-year-old orphan.…six years I lived like this…She told me about American men who wanted Asian wives. If I can cook, clean, and take care of my American husband, he’ll give me a good life. It was the only hope I had. No one understood me, and I understood nothing
Because the narrator is a Chinese-Americans, she saw unique Chinese culture toward women. I heard that women with small feet were considered to be pretty in ancient China. However, I did know that Chinese women suffered from the society’s bigotry like Maxine Hong Kingston's aunt. The narrator has expressed her deep concerns about the distressing women’s humanitarian situation in China. China Chinese women and her family had to suffer from harsh criticism by society.
These qualities fit the standards of a good mother. First, Amy, a stubborn Chinese “tiger” mother, is willing to make changes for her daughters. Those really unreasonable parents can always insist on very strict rules they believe are beneficial and never make a compromise. Amy indeed is strict to her daughters, but she is not unreasonable and sometimes she would break her rules for her daughters. The most obvious change she mentions in her book is allowing Lulu to give up practicing violin.