ipl-logo

Summary: Should Creation And Evolution Be Taught In Public Schools

1000 Words4 Pages

Warnick proposes two reasons for including both, or as he calls it, “the principle of curricular fairness (Warnick, 2009, p. 306).” The first reason is to promote autonomy for students by providing them with options and room to make their own choices; the second reason is to allow for familial intimacy (Warnick, 2009, p. 306-307). Warnick also leaves the reader with two warnings. The first is that time in the classroom for any subject is limited, especially for biology; every minute devoted to the debate is one less toward science and even if the debate has valid scientific arguments on both sides the point of the course is not to debate but to inform the students about how science works (Warnick, 2009 p. 307). The second warning is that while …show more content…

There are different views on evolution as well as creationism. The student should be exposed to each, not to convert them to any view but to equip them with the exposure to the information they will need if and when they do decide to convert one way or another, the decision will be an informed and well-thought out one. There is a strong demand that Creationism be taught in public schools along with evolution. Important things to consider are why it is allowed in some cases and not others, how it fits with the constitution, and methods for teaching it that fulfill the opportunity to learn about creationism in public schools while remaining consistent with the first amendment. If the school really wants to treat the two as “neutral” they either need to claim both, disclaim both, or neither claim or disclaim both; however this is handled it needs to handle both theories equally; this was not done in this case. Although it claimed to encourage students to open minded and think critically, the required science course belittled evolution as just a theory while suggesting that Intelligent Design also be considered. Intentionally or not, it came across dismissing evolution in favor of intelligent

Show More
Related

  • John Thomas Scopes Monkey Trial

    248 Words  | 1 Pages

    John Thomas Scopes, a teacher in Dayton Tennessee, with a hopeful mind in teaching children about Charles Darwin. Scopes was never a full time teacher, he was an occasional substitute and the high school’s football coach. In Tennessee, they have a law where it is illegal to teach children about Charles Darwin and evolution. This is called the Butler Act.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Edwards Vs Aguillard

    1445 Words  | 6 Pages

    §§ 17:286.1-17:286.7 (West 1982), is facially invalid [p581] as violative of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. ”(Edwards v. Aguillard) The ruling helped many people by deciding several things at the same time. It helped solidify that the States cannot pass a law requiring the teaching of creationism or other religious text that the main purpose is to restrict the teachings of evolution. It also helped by using the lemon test, which wasn’t decided too long before this case, become a more accepted as a way to determine if a law was unconstitutional.

    Read More

  • The Strengths Of Sam Harris's Argument Against Francis Collins

    2665 Words  | 11 Pages

    Additionally, it would turn religious individuals away from theories of science such as evolution. In response, Harris argues that “the goal is to get them [religious individuals] to value the principles of reasoning and educated discourse that now make a belief in evolution obligatory” (Harris). Instead of convincing the religious community to acknowledge the truth behind scientific theories, religious individuals should be able to understand why they are true. In Harris's opinion, understanding the reason behind ideas like evolution and valuing the education they can offer is more important than settling for the religious community to simply tolerate scientific theories. Having religious communities learn to value the reasoning and logic behind science could bring the two communities closer

    Read More

  • John T Scopes: The Guilty Of Teaching Evolution In Education

    1087 Words  | 5 Pages

    In 1925, the Tennessee legislature passed the Butler Act which banned the teaching of the evolution of mankind in public schools. John T Scope, a football coach and, mathematics teacher, was accused of teaching evolution as a substitute biology teacher. In this re-trial, I hold a position as a jury. Several witnesses had supportive arguments and evidences. Harry Shelton from the prosecution side and Henry F Osborn from the defense side presented the most convincing evidences respectively as Harry’s evidence presented was very acrimonious and unpleasing to John T Scopes and Henry F Osborn provided valid and scientific information to us and the judge.

    Read More

  • Scopes Monkey Trail Research Paper

    741 Words  | 3 Pages

    What Darrow meant in his statement is using the Bible as an argument of why evolution shouldn’t be thought to the children in Tennessee schools doesn’t make sense because the Bible is about religion not science. The next argument Darrow makes is the law does not specify what can be taught but the law does say that you cannot teach anything that conflicts with the Bible. Darrow argues that not everyone who reads the Bible is going to have the same concept of the Bible. Everybody has their own understanding of the Bible and its meaning. Therefore people will have a different view of what teachings conflicts with the Bible.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Edwards Vs Aguillard

    572 Words  | 3 Pages

    In this court case, the state of Louisiana made a law that forbade the teaching of the theory of evolution in public schools unless the school were to teach the theory of creationism as well (“Edwards”). Though the law did not require the teaching of either of the theories, it did require one of the other if schools did decide to teach it (“Edwards”). Parents, teachers, and religious leaders seeked to prevent the forcing of this law (“Edwards”). Andrew Koppelman, the author of “Phony Originalism and the Establishment Clause,” says, “States are prohibited from

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Darwin And Kansas State Board Of Education

    584 Words  | 3 Pages

    Today it is “recognized as a leading work in natural philosophy and in the history of mankind” (Landry). Today it seems as if there is a price to pay when talking about this topic in public, especially in school classrooms, as many teachers and parents argue that the Bible’s literal interpretation of human development is supreme. Challenges facing the theory were found relevant in 23 states as well as seven foreign countries. In 2004 a challenge was brought up by the Kansas State Board of Education. Is evolution a matter of a theory or is it the subject of “true scientific controversy” (Tamblyn)?

    Read More

  • How Did The Scopes Monkey Trial Affect Society

    1660 Words  | 7 Pages

    The Scopes “Monkey Trial” changed the way science and evolution are taught in America’s school systems today. The trial came about when John Scopes, an algebra and science teacher, taught evolution as a plausible theory while filling in for a biology teacher at Rhea County Central High School in Dayton, Tennessee. The action went against Tennessee’s “Butler Act,” which prohibited teachers in public schools to “teach any theory that denies the story of the Divine Creation of man as taught in the Bible, and to teach instead that man descended from a lower order of animals.” Scopes, along with others in the community, wanted to change the law so that students could be taught Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution, and the matter was taken to court. The

    Read More

  • Similarities Between The Nye And Ham Second Debate

    829 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Nye/Ham second debate relates to the previous discussion in class about Creationism because of the beliefs discussed in the power point that relate closely to Ken Ham’s views in the debate. Creationism is a belief under the religion of Christianity that humans, animals and earth were created by God. Christians get this evidence from the chapter of Genesis in the Bible. Ken Ham, a born again Christian, created a creationist museum shaped as Noah’ Ark for Christians/ Creationist all over the world to view realistic figures and facts covered by the Bible.

    Read More

  • Scopes Monkey Trial Research Paper

    814 Words  | 4 Pages

    In spite of the fact that some people may not be happy with the teaching of both creationism and evolution in schools, I believe they should both be taught. In the event that only creationism were taught, or only evolution, many people would be seeing red. The Scopes Monkey Trial happened

    Read More

  • Scopes Monkey Trial Essay

    2074 Words  | 9 Pages

    Before the Scopes Trial, the teaching of evolution in public schools was a controversial issue. Some people, particularly those who were religious fundamentalists, believed that the theory of evolution conflicted with the teachings of the Bible and was therefore not suitable for public school classrooms. "The trial created a lasting impact on the teaching of evolution in American schools. After the Scopes trial, evolution was often taught less frequently and less thoroughly, and many textbooks either downplayed the subject or avoided it altogether. " Others, including many scientists and educators, believed that evolution was a scientifically supported theory and was a suitable subject to teach in schools.

    Read More

  • Essay On Scopes Trial

    865 Words  | 4 Pages

    Darwin’s theory contradicted biblical theology in such a fundamental way that it was very near impossible for many people to accept; the drastic difference in the fundamental beliefs between devout Christians and accepters of Darwin’s theory made any kind of compromise between the two groups very difficult. Despite the extreme differences in fundamental beliefs between followers of Christianity and the scientific community, a few compromises have been made throughout history. The most prominent of which were equal time laws. Equal time laws call for teachers to spend, obviously enough, equal time on both evolution and biblical accounts of creation; equal time laws also typically require that teachers make both evolution and Biblical creation stories seem like they have equal evidence to back them and similar support among

    Read More

  • Creationism: Mclean V. Arkansas Board Of Education

    2235 Words  | 9 Pages

    Overall, Creationism sounds like a children’s story while Evolution is very detailed, informative, and educational. Creationism confuses students and lures them away from their educational thinking process. In many circumstances, Creationism has refuted scientific theories and has unraveled the lot that science, in most schools has taught us about human derivation. Evolution and Creation are two of the most common theories of human origin, although numerous religious people believe in Creation, the bible’s timeline does not match up

    Read More

  • Scopes Trial: Teaching Evolution In The 1920's

    1573 Words  | 7 Pages

    If we had to have any laws against evolution the state should regulate teaching evolution because the state is able to regulate teaching evolution better in their state and would be able to understand what their state needs more. In the 1920”s in Tennessee where the Scopes Trial happened there was a new law called the Butler Act. The new Tennessee law, known as the Butler Act, stated that these idea could not be taught in public schools (1A Pg,10). Like stated before evolution was a hard subject to discuss because you never knew who be offended or who would think that you are an awful person and against their religion because you just brought up evolution in scientific terms. Teaching evolution in the 1920’s was a very rough subject to teach because if you tried to teach evolution a student may try to ask like how we got here and tried to relate it to the bible then another student may get offended because it may offend their religion or how they view evolution.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Abusing Science By Philip Kitcher

    576 Words  | 3 Pages

    Philip Kitcher in “Abusing science: The case against creationism” argues about how creationists have motives in which they want to show that the theory of evolution are just lies. They will pick on every theory they find and claim them as untestable. The author states that creationist use tautology objection, which means that whatever the evolution theory is it cannot be tested and is classified as not real science. The author hen states that creationist do not thoroughly understand what their objections borrowed from evolutionist really mean. All they do is get whatever information makes sense to them and turn it around to a point in which will justify their point of view against evolutionist.

    Read More

More about Summary: Should Creation And Evolution Be Taught In Public Schools

Open Document