ipl-logo

Supreme Court Case Of Bethel School District V. Fraser

481 Words2 Pages

Bethel School District v Fraser is a pivotal case heard by the United States Supreme Court in 1986. Broadly, the case involved the freedom of speech provided by the First Amendment to the US Constitution, its exercise and its limitation within the boundaries of a public school. The whole matter started during a school meeting organized by the Bethel School District (high school) in Washington State . On the 26th April of 1983, a student by the name of Matthew Fraser, 18 years old, gave a nomination speech to support the candidacy of one of his friend Jeff Kuhlman. The later, was seeking an elected position within the school student government board. During his speech, Fraser made explicit, graphic and allegoric sexual allusion in describing Jeff Kuhlman and called the audience to vote for him. Among others Fraser said about Jeff Kuhlman that he …show more content…

Following this public speech qualified as disruptive, vulgar and obscene, according to the school’s rules, Fraser will be suspended for two days and his name will be removed from a graduation ceremony speakers’ list. Based on these aforementioned facts, Fraser’s father, supported the American Civil Liberty Union (ACLU) will file a lawsuit against the school for violating the First Amendment right to freedom of speech of his son, Matthew Fraser, and will ask for a monetary reparation against the prejudice. As a consequence of this lawsuit, the issue will be discussed, first, before a Federal District Court. Over there, the judge will give a verdict favorable to Fraser on the ground that the

Show More
Related

  • What Is Charles Lawrence On Racist Speech In Chronicle Of Higher Education

    160 Words  | 1 Pages

    Charles R. Lawrence III is a professor at Georgetown University that publicized an article inside “The Chronicle of Higher Education” and later on in the “Duke Law Journal” which was headlined “On Racist Speech”. Ever since Charles Lawrence was young he was quite the anarchist on the matter of the first amendment protecting racial slurs. He encourages University’s to stand up and reprimand such absurd speech with a reinforced approach without completely throwing out the first amendments rights. Charles Lawrence uses Brown v. the board of education as an example, the discrimination is causing psychological effects that are turning an educational environment into an environment of destruction. As he then goes on to explain that if racial speech

    Read More

  • Case Study: Joseph Frederick V. Juneau-Douglas High School

    514 Words  | 3 Pages

    : Joseph Frederick a high school student filed suit in District Court under 42 U.S.C. §1983, alleging violation of his First Amendment rights by the school board and Deborah Morse, the principal of his high school. The District Court granted summary judgment for the school board and Morse. Frederick appealed to the Ninth Circuit and the District Court’s decision was reversed. Morse appealed and Certiorari was granted. Facts: On January 24, 2002 the Olympic Torch Relay passed through Juneau, Alaska while school was in session.

    Read More

  • Kevin Swanson Case Study

    1816 Words  | 8 Pages

    Principal Belding suspended Maria for five days and was prohibited from running for student body president the next year. Maria then sued Principal Belding alleging that he had violated her right to free speech protected under the First Amendment. In the courts, the District Court found in favor of Maria, while the Court of Appeals reversed the ruling of the District. This case will soon be heard at the Supreme Court.

    Read More

  • Jonathan And Oliver Case Study

    1042 Words  | 5 Pages

    He made a mockery out of an exercise in citizenship, shocked the school community, and exceeded the boundaries of appropriate speech for a school setting. The use of sexual references was hostile to the educational process. Speech is limited even for adults, and no one can claim that all high school students are adults. Therefore, schools must be provided with the means to discipline children who use offensive language. Fraser was not punished for the political nature of his speech, but rather for its sexual obscenity.

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Court Case Of Skinner Vs. Hoover High School

    708 Words  | 3 Pages

    Kuhlmeier (1988) and Tinker v. Des Moines School District (1969). Which implies that schools must set high standards for their students’ speech as long as it is disseminated under their auspice and reasonably related to legitimate pedagogical concerns. If a student poses a distraction that impacts other students’ ability to learn and perform, the school has the duty and right to discipline that particular student. In the case of Colleen Copernica v. Jane Skinner, Colleen feels that he has the right to kneel during the National Anthem during a football game, which he feels is his form of Free Speech, due to Morse v. Frederick (2007). Which extended the first amendment right to student speech, and states that punishing a student because of their message.

    Read More

  • How Does Mr. Jackson's Speech Cause Disruption In Schools

    833 Words  | 4 Pages

    Jackson’s First Amendment right against school’s disruption, court should consider the nature of Mr. Jackson’s speech, by evaluating “manner, time, and place” in which speech occurred. Melzer v. Board of Education, 336 F.3d 185, 199 (2003). In Mr. Jackson’s case, it would be hard to argue that school had an interest in controlling Mr. Jackson’s freedom of speech. This is because the speech was held outside of school on a topic that was not related to Middleton High School. CT 4.

    Read More

  • Elonis V. US Supreme Court Case Study

    618 Words  | 3 Pages

    Frederick case where a student got punished just for holding up a sign saying “bong hits for jesus” in a school event. This would of have been perfectly fine if he was outside of school but since he was at school the court ruled in favor of Morse because the students do have freedom of speech but not to a point where they are promoting drug use in a school is allowed. Some say that the ruling was not fair because it violates the first amendment but another case had already set a precedent where students in school only have limited freedom of speech instead of the belief ultimate freedom of speech where you can say whatever you want with no

    Read More

  • On Racist Speech: Brown Vs. The Board Of Education

    766 Words  | 4 Pages

    He cites a number of arguments, but Brown v. The Board of Education, the First Amendment, and the distinction between free speech and hate speech stand out as the most important. Being an American legal expert, Charles R. Lawrence is familiar

    Read More

  • Board Of Education Vs. Fraser: Freedom Of Speech In Schools

    825 Words  | 4 Pages

    Fraser was a Supreme Court case in 1986 involving whether or not the First Amendment prevents schools from getting a high school student at an assembly in trouble for giving a speech that is offensive in any sexual way. At aa school, a student known as Matthew Fraser gave a speech to nominate one of the students that went to that school for elective office. As Fraser gave a speech, members of the audience felt that he was using graphically sexual metaphors. The school didn’t tolerate this so they prohibited his use of offensive language and suspended Fraser from school for two days.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay: The First Amendment Rights Of Students

    1815 Words  | 8 Pages

    Schools have a responsibility to provide a safe and orderly environment for learning, but they must also respect the rights of students to express themselves and engage in political and social activism. The controversies surrounding students’ First Amendment rights have been apparent in our world for a long time, and the controversies are only growing with the growth of technology. There have been and still are many questions surrounding what the students are allowed to do and not allowed to do under their first amendment rights and that is what we are going to dive deeper into through the perspectives of many cases based on students' first amendment rights. There have been many famous court cases over the years in which students have taken school boards to court after they had felt that the school board or administration violated their first amendment rights at the school that they are attending. When it comes to students' first amendments there are many things that

    Read More

  • Court Case Board Of Education Of Hendrick Hudson Central School District V.

    321 Words  | 2 Pages

    Individuals with disabilities have always had difficulties trying to get fair treatment. In the 1970’s the court case Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982). There was a deaf first grader by the name of Amy Rowley was rejected for a funding of an interpreter to attend class. Amy’s parents took the case to federal courts, and won later that ended up changing everything. The standard was set for what is a Free Appropriate Public Education, provided children with disabilities access to public schools that provided a basic opportunity.

    Read More

  • Freedom Of Speech In College Essay

    905 Words  | 4 Pages

    The idea of free speech on college campuses and the complications of it stem from those on campuses expressing views that don’t align with popular views. Implications for students who use the idea of free speech as a method for hateful actions and comments should be reprimanded, but the question remains as to whether schools should enforce tougher limitations. The freedom of speech on college campus expands to the freedoms of religion, assembly, press, and protest as well. Freedom of expression allows students to show their own political, social, and cultural views. Removing freedoms of speech and expression have consequences deeper than surface issues.

    Read More

  • Heckler's Veto Speech

    1199 Words  | 5 Pages

    The Court held that in arresting and convicting the students, South Carolina infringed upon the student’s freedom of speech and freedom of assembly

    Read More

  • Campus Free Speech: Freedom Of Speech

    1018 Words  | 5 Pages

    Freedom of speech discord on campus has been around for years but today it is different. Erwin Chemetinsky (2017), the dean of Berkley law school, explained that in the past many students wanted to speak out, hold demonstrations but, felt silenced by the campus administration. On today’s campuses the controversy is often about offensive speakers like the “Radical leftist” (Chemetinsky, 2017) protest group known as Antifa. Antifa has made many headlines in the more recent years for their

    Read More

  • The Tinker Case

    259 Words  | 2 Pages

    Today's students know that the right of freedom of speech and expression at school is more complex then it once was. The rules have not changed since the Tinker Case. The Tinker Case was groundbreaking in letting students know the rights they have at school. They do have the right to express themselves but only if it is not a distraction to others at school (“Student Right to Freedom of Speech” 1) . Schools now have student handbooks of the limit to which students can express themselves.

    Read More

More about Supreme Court Case Of Bethel School District V. Fraser

Open Document