ipl-logo

Surfing For Thinness: Pro-Ana Community Analysis

689 Words3 Pages

“I believe in perfection and strive to attain it. I believe in salvation through trying just a bit harder than I did yesterday. I believe in calorie counters as the inspired word of god and memorize them accordingly. I believe in bathroom scales as an indicator of my daily successes and failures” (“Ana’s Creed”). This is just one example of the literature found on pro-anorexia, pro-ana, websites. This passage as well as many others bear an eerie resemblance to Christian religious texts. The Ana Creed, Thin Commandments, Pro-Ana Psalm and ritual of summoning are popular features in the pro-ana community that take wording from Christian prayers and teachings. Despite the prevalence of this aspect of the pro-ana community, little research has …show more content…

There is a great deal of discussions about why these groups are harmful, possible benefits of these groups and the members within these groups. These ideas are explored in the study: “Surfing for Thinness” in which researchers conducted a study focused primarily on the community members in pro-ana forums (Wilson et al. e1635). In Natalie Boero and C.J. Pascoe’s article, they discuss tensions within the community over status and hierarchy, especially looking at “wannarexics”. They talk about how the hatred of “wannarexics”, and fear of becoming one leads community members to engage in strict group rituals and practices to prove their authenticity and maintain their spot within the community (39). Very few articles discuss the possible benefits of these websites but a study done by Stephen Haas, Meghan Irr, Nancy Jennings and Lisa Wagner suggests that unique support for recovery can be found on some of these sites (44). Although the religious aspect of the pro-ana community was briefly mentioned in many articles, an in-depth analysis of the religion behind pro-ana is a topic that needs further …show more content…

In doing this, I hope to show the relationship between the pro-ana community and the protestant ethic and take the pro-ana community further and suggest that the existence and formation of the group provide an argument against secularization. Using Weber’s idea of the protestant ethic and his theory of religion and society, and focusing on, the certainty of salvation, inner-worldly asceticism, and religious virtuosi I will examine the pro-ana community by, suggesting a “pro-ana ethic” based on Weber’s ideas, and explaining the formation of the group. Using this pro-ana ethic, I will discuss how the pro-ana community shows a deviation from the thesis of

Show More
Related

  • What Is The Tone Of Sam Harris Letter To A Christian Nation

    1356 Words  | 6 Pages

    In the non-fiction philosophical book, Sam Harris, publisher of Letter to a Christian Nation, demonstrates his views of the flaws of Christianity. He contends the many contradictions he finds with the beliefs Christians hold to with their own lives and interactions with others. His goal in the book is to expose these errors to Christians themselves and present the question to them in a challenging tone. Harris does this by painting a vivid picture of the controversies surrounding Christians opposed to non Christians. He goes into great detail about his beliefs against Christianity and covers a broad scope, along with many topics.

    Read More

  • The Anabaptist Story Chapter Summary

    1436 Words  | 6 Pages

    Estep marks the birth of Anabaptism in the first chapter during the Reformation alongside well known reformers such as Martin Luther and Ulrich Zwingli as the first baptism of the Swiss Brethren took place in 1525. He went on to illustrate the disputes that occurred between the Swiss Brethren and Zwingli to help the reader distinguish clearly between the two including the October Disputation in 1523. Estep also points out that the ability to distinguish between the Anabaptists, inspirationists, and rationalists is vital to understanding the Reformation. The role that the key figures like Conrad Grebel, Felix Manz, and George Blaurock played during the development of Anabaptism is thoroughly described in the second chapter. Estep also portrays passion and commitment to truth along with the persecution, imprisonment, torture, and martyrdom that followed the Anabaptists as they began to share and teach the truth of God’s word that they were so dedicated to.

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Impossible Knife Of Memory By Laurie Halse Anderson

    1902 Words  | 8 Pages

    ‘I already ate.’” (Anderson 121). Readers who have suffered through anorexia, or even something as simple as a diet,

    Read More

  • Jennifer Traig Essay

    526 Words  | 3 Pages

    Anorexia applied to every little aspect in her life, which is where it differs from anorexics who are only worried about food. She found herself counting every calorie that came near her body and digging through encyclopedias for every element in her food. Her new coming skinniness didn’t come from her sister’s nickname of “Sister Infinity Fats” that even her parents joined in on, it merely formed on something Jenny considered a hobby. But her “hobby” became more than that after a while, thinking she would be “condemned to hell” for taking up so much room and felt guilty for eating. As Jenny neared college she desperately filled her schedule with every activity she could fit into her schedule from French club to drama club.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Friedrich Nietzsche's Criticism Of Religion

    1287 Words  | 6 Pages

    Critics of Religion Midterm 2. Although Friedrich Nietzsche’s ideas and work have long been associated with atheism and even the antisemitism that would eventually lead to the Holocaust, I think a slightly more fitting description of his point of view in The Genealogy of Morals might be “anticlerical”. While I believe there are good arguments that can be made for both atheism and anticlericalism, Nietzsche seems to focus most of his energy on critiquing religious clergy such as priests as well as organized religion and its impact on morality, rather than critiquing belief in God. The first essay includes an etymology of the words “good” and “bad” and how they underwent a transvaluation at some point due to religious clergy, which ultimately lead to a morality system that he argues is not natural or innate within us.

    Read More

  • Hinduism And Confucianism Analysis

    1451 Words  | 6 Pages

    In his most famous publication, Weber studies the relationship between the ethics of ascetic Protestantism and the emergence of contemporary capitalism. He accounts bureaucracy as a key feature in modern society. This is in no way a detailed account of Protestantism itself but instead an introduction to his later studies such as “The Religion of China: Confucianism and Taoism” or “The Religion of India: The Sociology of Hinduism and Buddhism”. Weber argues that the “spirit” that defines capitalist ideas originates in the Protestant Reformation.

    Read More

  • More Than A Carpenter Summary

    894 Words  | 4 Pages

    McDowell begins the book with an anecdote of his life; a familiar story of the sceptical university Agnostic, ready to fire back a retort at the slightest mention of God, Christianity, and anything (or anyone) within. He recounted the all too common feeling of a meaningless life, the seemingly innate itch of human existence, and how it brought him to various places in his life—until he stumbled upon a particular group of people and was changed forever. This introduction, though short, is crucial to understand, for it sets the stage for the remainder of the book. It tells not only the story of a former non-believer, but the story of everyone—it presents us the life of Jesus Christ, not as a gentle sermon or a feel-good retelling, but as an assertive, rational reply to the accusation: ‘Christianity is a myth, and so is your God.’

    Read More

  • The Anabaptist Vision Analysis

    707 Words  | 3 Pages

    A Summary and Interpretation of “The Anabaptist Vision” In 1944, Harold S. Bender wrote the “The Anabaptist Vision”, which was to reassure the Anabaptists faith, especially during the era of war and poverty in World War II. Violence, hardship, and suffering was felt by the entire world and many people felt lost and restless. Bender encouraged people, particularly the Anabaptists and Mennonites, by retelling the history of the Anabaptist faith which was also full of hardships and suffering. Consequently, it was to explain the origin and reason behind the Anabaptist faith and to possibly remind the people of why they had chosen to become Anabaptists.

    Read More

  • Eating Disorders Argumentative Essay

    1525 Words  | 7 Pages

    Often, they judge their self-worth by their ability to control their weight/shape (Grilo 6). It is no secret that eating disorders are alarmingly common. Especially now, in this culture, where large corporations are “investing” in this industry as a result of their market research which can then only mean one thing – eating

    Read More

  • Mark Jones Antinomianism Analysis

    1247 Words  | 5 Pages

    Thus, the faith in Christ is the most significant for assurance of salvation for Antinomians. Nevertheless, Mark Jones assesses them “Again, this is a classic example of the either-or fallacy.” (p.100) Reformed theologians also agree their argument on the importance of the faith, and their point is certainly true; however, the reformed theologians put stress upon not only the object of faith but also upon the sanctification. The divines believe that the sanctification of believers is essential on the issue of assurance, so they explain that the faith causes the justification and the sanctification both because of the law and the gospel and the complacent love of God. Thus, although the sanctification cannot earn the justification, the justification can cause sanctification.

    Read More

  • Religion Exposed In Thomas Luckmann's Invisible Religion

    450 Words  | 2 Pages

    Its presence communally has disappeared, and it has become a personal matter. The dialectic of religion has broken down owing to a lack of their ‘modernization’ quality. Rosalind Hackett, a theologian, in his article “Hackett on Revitalization” notes that a modern religion is one which is ‘reformative in nature and propagates the traditional

    Read More

  • Norman Rockwell Four Freedom Of Speech Analysis

    554 Words  | 3 Pages

    worshiping according to the dictates up their own conscience that’s the phrase that transcribed at the top of the painting.

    Read More

  • Judgment In David Sheff's Beautiful Boy

    744 Words  | 3 Pages

    Judgements are often made by people without considering past or current situations of others. By putting yourself in one’s shoes and experiencing their situation yourself, an opinion will change. Addiction is a horrible disease that took over Nic Sheff’s life, much to the dismay of his father. Through personal experience of years of anguish, depression, anger, and disappointment, the judgements of Sheff altered. The discomfort of thought and experience ultimately allowed Sheff to construct an enlightened

    Read More

  • The Rich Man And Lazarus Essay

    2456 Words  | 10 Pages

    Due to temptations, ambiguities to the mind of man are growing. Man’s perception to Christian beliefs has changed. Atheism initiates loss of man’s faith to his own faith. People start to question the existence of a God and they begin to question the reliability of the holy

    Read More

  • Trinitarian Creeds To Modernize And Culturize The Trinity

    717 Words  | 3 Pages

    Other Trinitarian theologies fail as the language of our Trinitarian doctrine is changed or adjusted to modernize and culturize the Trinity to our present society. The early Trinitarian Creeds can appear patristic and archaic in style, so a renovation to the Trinitarian Creed should not necessarily be considered taboo or heretical. In spite of nearly two millennia of academic and social achievement, humankind’s vocabulary, capacity for reason, and theology really has yet to compose a creed, which improves upon the language of the historic creeds without detracting from a Trinitarian framework. The difficulty of such a task requires the new theology to maintain orthodoxy in both the ontic and the noetic aspects of the Trinity.

    Read More

More about Surfing For Thinness: Pro-Ana Community Analysis

Open Document