Joey Evans Mr. Milroy English 10 Honors 16 March 2023 Big Brother is Watching George Orwell’s envision of a nightmarish dystopian society portrayed in 1984 showcases many of humanity’s worst fears, including a loss of freedom and individuality. Throughout the novel, Big Brother is at the forefront of the society, painted by The Party as the heroic liberator of the people of Oceania. Whether or not Big Brother is real, nobody knows; The Party controls all knowledge and can shape reality to conform to whatever they want. All the people of Oceania know is that “BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING” them and he will never take his eyes off them. Winston Smith seems to be one of the only people left that have yet to be brain-washed by The Party. He knows that …show more content…
They utilize him as a figurehead of power; he is the brave and valiant leader all of Oceania needs. Throughout the first part of the novel, however, it becomes clear that The Party, and therefore Big Brother, have far different motives than those portrayed by Big Brother’s appearance. The repeated slogan, “WAR IS PEACE, IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH, and FREEDOM IS SLAVERY” (4), unveils The Party’s real desire: to obtain and retain ultimate power. The Party does not care about the people; they broke Oceania and created a dystopian society in order to keep hold of power. Big Brother is the ultimate representation of their …show more content…
Winston recognizes the oppressiveness of The Party. Within the first pages of the novel, Winston describes the Thought Police spying on all of the people of Oceania through telescreens: “Any sound that Winston made, above the level of a very low whisper, would be picked up by it” (3). Big Brother is always watching him, among all the other people in Oceania. Big Brother is the wall in the way of Winston’s freedom. Winston later acquires a diary and knows that it is a crime punishable “by death, or at least twenty-five years in a forced-labor camp” (6). Big Brother does not solely control Winston’s actions: he is in control of Winston’s thoughts as well. Winston’s strong desire for individual identity overcomes this fear of punishment, and he embarks on a journey to become his own. Big Brother sees this as a threat, though; Winston’s constant betrayal of The Party eventually leads to his arrest. Throughout Winston’s interrogation, Winston begins to understand the principles of The Party; he knows how to doublethink, and how to defy reason so as to believe whatever Big Brother wants him to. Big Brother has finally taken near-complete control of Winston. However, Winston still hates Big Brother. He is still the enemy of everything Winston believes in: freedom, rights, logic, and individuality. Finally, after long interrogations, Winston breaks: in the last words of the novel, Winston, “loves
In George Orwell’s classic novel, 1984, Winston Smith is a secret rebel, fighting the control of Big Brother, who represents the overpowered, all knowing government. Winston is fighting more than his government though, he is fighting his entire society. Big Brother’s power comes from his ability to manipulate the masses, so influentially, that the masses work towards the oppression of themselves. In questioning Big Brother, Winston is questioning the entirety of known society. Winston meets others that share his views on society and expand Winston’s field of thought, leading him to make conclusions about his society; conclusions that lead to direct rebellion against Big Brother.
Winston went from a strong-willed rebel to a brainwashed Big Brother follower. The party put Winston through so much pain that not even his moral compass could guide him in life anymore. It was almost as if the torque developed Stockholm syndrome in him. Just like every other tortured prisoner his humanity was killed, along with his values. Winston, a man who hated every bit of the party to turned loving the party, he was now one with Big
In this book they talk about some capabilities of Big Brother. “Winston kept his back to the telescreen … it was over though , as he well knew even a back can be revealing.” They surveillance members of the organization 24/7, so Any little move they made was known. Winston’s job was to change the past. “Who controls the past controls the future, who controls the present controls the past”.
Big Brother was never one to be questioned, and he made the consequences known to anyone who did so. Winston clearly expressed his hatred for Big Brother and all of the restrictions placed on members of society in the beginning of the book. Despite this, he constantly hid his facial expressions and thoughts from the telescreens, in great fear that the thought police would catch him. Contrary to that outward conformity, he was always inwardly questioning Big Brother. He directly broke the law by writing in a journal, especially since
Winston conveys the clear message to beware of the ‘eyes’ of the party, enforcing the slogan “big brother is watching you. Winston promotes this awareness towards the other rebels of the party and general people to overall spread his knowledge and hopefully influence revolt. While
Winston continues to disappoint further as because of the lack of his usual paranoia and good instinct in identification of character, he is defeated by Mr. Charrington’s avuncular mask, trusting him even with the notion that the Thought Police and telescreen surveillance is everywhere in the Party’s jurisdiction. His fatalism proves fatal in this scene as he falls with little resistance, allowing Julia to be violently captured in the process, conflicting with what a lover and a hero would normally do. Although unrealistic, it is to my belief that a heroic character would not betray their loved ones as well as themselves, which Winston eventually did as he developed love for Big Brother, detaching the connection he shared with Julia in the final scenes of the
Basically everywhere the character Winston looks, there’s always a slogan saying “Big Brother is watching you”. Big Brother is the leader of 1984’s totalitarian society. By Winston seeing “Big Brother is watching you” everywhere he looks, it shows a common threat to him that he is always being watched and that he has little to no natural rights because of the government. If he were to break the rules, serious consequences would happen to him if he were
As a result of Winston’s neglect of the rules, he was able to maintain his own perspective, as he attempted to defeat Big Brother’s ‘sinister plan’. “You’re a flaw in the pattern, Winston. You are a stain that must be wiped out….when finally you surrender to us, it must be of your own free will,” stated O’Brien (page 255). In the book, free will depicted the Ministry’s truthful judgments of the state of mind, which happened to correspond to Winston’s freedom of beliefs. When O’Brien was torturing Winston, he revealed Big Brother’s notions of simply destroying the rebelling mind of any person who had dared to testify against The Party’s core values.
At the beginning of the novel, Winston made it prominent that he dissented Big Brother and his party’s idea. He wrote in his diary, in Book 1 Chapter 1, “DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER…” (Orwell 18). This shows that Winston dissented his country’s government and was willing to rebel for he knew deep inside that
Men are infinitely malleable’’(273). Winston’s speech ironically suggests that “it is precisely the flexibility of human nature that limits the Party's power”(Smith 433). Winston’s search for freedom is “found” when he is manipulated into thinking Big Brother provides that. If anything, Big Brother was only able to create a facade that makes Winston believe that he is perfectly happy. At best, the Party was only able to stall his progressive ideas from advancing into a successful rebellion, and most definitely did not mold him.
Frequently, Winston questioned the motives of the government and often engaged in thoughtcrime (thoughts that oppose the ruling party). Winston could recognize that the people do not think for themselves, instead they simply believed and thought what Big Brother told them to. “Prodded by his natural need for reflection and critical analysis, Winston finds it hard not to make use of his inborn talents. He starts questioning the wisdom of Big Brother and moves hopefully toward his own liberation” (Nytimes.com). Due to his personality and own freedom of thought, he had the unique ability to recognize the injustice and lack of freedom around him.
One of the most important things Winston had learned, in O’Brien’s eyes, was that he began to change his mind towards the ideals of Big Brother. In George Orwell’s 1984, Winston is a man who is attempting to hold on to his humanity. He is found guilty of thoughtcrime by O’Brien, who is a member of the inner party. Big Brother believes this to be a crime against all humanity and that time is not a continuum. He wants this so people don’t think about their future, so that they will obey whatever Big Brother says.
Big Brother has made it impossible for Winston, or any other human living to think for himself. Therefore Big Brother has
Winston is defiant and rebels against Big Brother and the Party through various illegal actions. After purchasing an empty diary, he continuously wrote “DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER” when the telescreens were out of view (Orwell 21). This simple thought is considered to be a severe crime where Winston lives because it is direct disapproval towards the Party. Winston feels as if Big Brother is controlling every aspect of his life, so this rebellious action allows for him to vent his frustration.
Big brother is ruining a totalitarian government, which is also a form of socialist government. This style of government has a dictator and has little or no freedom. Winston sees that this government can do nothing but spells out bad news, it also do nothing for human rights. O’brien sees it as a way for big brother and the inner party to flex their power to the people of oceania. Winston understands all of the outcomes that their government has so thats why he is trying to stop it