Talvar Movie Analysis
“Talvar” a movie based on real life events i.e. the tragic murder of a girl name “Aarushi Talwar”. The 14-year old girl’s murder still remains a mystery and a curiosity to many. The movie views a real biased view of the case on the part of Aarushi’s parents being innocent. Aarushi has been referred to as Shruti in the movie.
The movie starts with the opening scene of Tondon’s apartment in Noida. Evidences go hand in hand with each and every incident described below i.e. each and every incident contains evidence. The maid comes for cleaning the Tondon’s apartment and rings the bell. The point to notice is that there are 3 doors in the way from out to the in. The maid thinks the first door from the out to be locked when Nootan Tondon, mother
…show more content…
The report given out by the police investigation focused on a story that started with the motive of both the murders i.e. Shruti and Khempal were found in a compromising position by Ramesh Tondon. It was a case of honor killing and Ramesh killed them both. Furthermore, it was said that Ramesh and Nootan dumped Khempal’s body on the terrace, cleaned the whole room and fingerprints, flushed the surgical instrument and dressed up the room back to normal.
Such an investigation is regarded highly faulty and the case is given to CDI (CDI), where 2 in total reports come into the picture. The first report talks about Kanhaiya and Rajpal coming into the scene. Kanhaiya is the compounder of Ramesh Tondon, whereas Rajpal is the driver of a colleague of Ramesh Tondon. The report said that Kanhaiya, Rajpal and Khempal were together in the Tondon’s apartment, at the night of the murder. Rajpal used to like Shruti. Kanhaiya and Rajpal were drunk and then went to Shruti’s room. They both killed Shruti and Hemraj. This theory had come up with the lead that was given during the narco-analysis test that was done on Kanhaiya and Rajpal. In the test itself they confessed that they had killed Shruti and Rajpal but because of the non admissibility of the this test only a circumstantial inference could be drawn from this test which lead to the primary evidence of Khempal’s blood on the pillow cover recovered from Kanhaiya’s house that led
…show more content…
These tests should be further evolved so that their consistency and correctness can be admissible in the courts. Also, for the current situation, this legal position as mentioned in the above 2 cited cases as well as the foreign law can be used in the future and it would turn out to be very helpful given the meagerness of any evidence and the absence of witnesses. Thus, I would like to conclude this review by stating that had been the psychological tests taken into account in the 2nd investigation of the double murder case, it could have led the C.D.I (C.B.I) to solve the case through some primary form of evidence in the movie.
Bibliography
1. http://www.gnlu.ac.in/Directorate%20of%20Research%20Activities/Research%20Paper%20-%20The%20State%20of%20UP%20through%20CBI%20v%20Rajesh%20Talwar%20and%20Anr%20Case.pdf
2. "CBI official handling Aarushi case moved”. Hindustan Times. 2009-05-09.
3. http://www.scribd.com/doc/122349170/Aarushi-original-autopsy
4. Srivastav, M "The Survivors" http://www.openthemagazine.com/.
5. AIR 2010 SC 1974 “Smt. Selvi v. State of Kerala”
6. Math, B.S., Supreme Court judgment on polygraph, narco-analysis & brain mapping: A boon or a bane. (N.d.). Retrieved from
Rural Home
606 Words | 3 PagesWeaknesses of Theory Assuming the victims knew the suspects based upon the rural area crime scene location would be a sweeping generalization and using inductive reasoning. Inductive reasoning can be too broad to be used for an individual crime. Drawing conclusions from the insufficient evidence is using false precision. The case facts cannot possibly support an absolute conclusion.
Adnan Was Not A Factual Evidence For Hae's Case
713 Words | 3 PagesIn short, all the evidences testified that Adnan murder
A Modest Proposal: Serial By Sarah Koenig
622 Words | 3 PagesThis case has many holes and problems that bug me, one being the fact Adnan was sentenced without any physical evidence excluding call records. Hae’s reason for passing was strangulation which is a violent and personal crime, It doesn't add up to the statements Adnan and others observed about their relationship.
Does Adnan Take A Piece Of Evidence In This Case
923 Words | 4 PagesThrough the investigation where the detectives have been investigating this case
Adnan Syed Case
846 Words | 4 PagesMurder, the unlawful premeditated killing of one human being by another. Premeditated means that the killing of the person was planned out, this helps support that Adnan Syed is not guilty. In 1999 an eighteen year old girl named Hae Min Lee went missing from Baltimore, Maryland. Her ex boyfriend Adnan Syed was accused of murdering her and disposing her body in Leakin park. The problem is that all the evidence used to persecute Adnan does not add up to make a strong case.
The BTK Case
951 Words | 4 PagesMany insufficient technology caused this case to spend many years without being solved until forensic technology became the key factor in this
Summary Of Adnan's Murder Case
868 Words | 4 PagesWhen Mr. S first found Haes body there were a bunch of evidence, but the items that stuck out to me were the empty bottles and the rope, but the bottles and rope were never tested so we didn 't know if Adnan was drinking that night or if the real killer used the rope (Koenig, “Leaking Park”). Another part of evidence that never made sense was the phone booth at best buy (Koenig,”To be suspected”). This phone was used to call Jay to pick Adnan up right before they buried Hae 's body, but a number of people said and the blueprints showed that there wasn 't even a phone booth there so he couldn 't of made the call. A third part is Haes car, they found it in an odd place but they didn 't run any prints to see if anyone else but Andn was in the car (Koenig, To be suspected.) Hae 's car I think was a bad part on the
Arizona Vs Youngblood Case Study
1528 Words | 7 PagesThe state started to build a case against the defendant due to the sexual act that occurred between him and the victim, which lead the criminologist to take samples of the semen and ultimately test for results (Police chief magazine). When time approach for an item to be tested the result came back inclusive due to the technology at that time being used was not qualified to conduct a proper reading on the DNA test. The packet was only able to show if a victim was raped or not (Police chief magazine). After realizing that the technology needed to be updated to better enhance the police investigations (Police chief magazine). The Criminologist worked years to come up with several different ways to test one items by DNA, fingerprints, and/or Hair samples, which resulted in the test be 99.9% reliable when convicting a criminal (Police chief magazine).
Did David Payne Kill Research Paper
335 Words | 2 PagesAlthough this case is unsolved still, it is an important resource for comparing the forensic development we have made as a
Amelia Earhart's Forensics Explanatory Speech Outline
1386 Words | 6 PagesConclusion Restate thesis: As you have learned today, modern innovations and ways of thinking have helped to advance forensic anthropology and trauma analysis. Review main points: We talked about the history of forensic anthropology and trauma analysis, and then I shared with you a case study involving the latter. Memorable closer: So when it’s revealed that Tupac’s skeleton isn’t really Tupac and he’s been alive this whole time, remember to thank forensic anthropology for always improving and getting
Reasons For The Murder Of Jonbenet Ramsey
762 Words | 4 Pagescombined with the fact that JonBenet was sexually assaulted before she had died gives reasonable doubt that this might not have been the first time this child was assaulted. After the above section of the inquiry, the analysis has shed light on various aspects of the murder of JonBenet Ramsey. To further the investigation, a synthesis of all the prior conclusions is necessary. This accumulation of facts will surely reveal the true identity of the killer and solve the case of the JonBenet Ramsey murder.
Los Olvidados Film Analysis
405 Words | 2 PagesIn the wildly popular Mexican film, Los olvidados (1950), Spanish director Luis Buñuel exposes the harsh realities of life in Mexico during the 1950’s. Luis Buñuel’s work on Los olvidados portrays a societal loss for all hope due to crime and violence as an infinitely vicious cycle, coupled with addressing the lack of reform for dilapidated living conditions throughout Mexico. In Los olvidados, Buñuel follows Pedro (Alfonso Mejía) a neglected bastard, and El Jaibo (Roberto Cobo) the leader of a gang of homeless children loitering in vacant lots. For Pedro, and the rest of the cast, a series of unfortunate outcomes have been strung together though common ignorance and a lack of self-control. Luis Buñuel’s use of focal length, editing, and dialogue
Pamela Foddrill Tragic Abduction Case Study
2482 Words | 10 PagesThe former being defined as the evidence collected in order to convict or rule out suspects, and the latter being defined as the way the investigators developed the investigation and how it evolved throughout the ensuing years. In order to evaluate these two different subjects, one needs to examine the similarities and differences between this investigation and theories about how investigation of this type develop, the nuances of this investigation not able to be explained by theory, investigatory elements that
Sankofa Movie Analysis
1284 Words | 6 PagesStudent’s Name Professor’s Name Subject DD MM YYYY SANKOFA – CRITICAL REVIEW Sankofa, a movie by Haile Gerima revolves around the horrors of slavery, revealing the humiliating and torturous experiences people from the African Diaspora had to go through during the Atlantic slave trade period. A film based in Ghana, where the slave trade was rampant for centuries, it highlights the savagery of white people and how internalized the oppression was for the Africans through poetic descriptions of complacency and fear.
More about Talvar Movie Analysis
Rural Home
606 Words | 3 PagesAdnan Was Not A Factual Evidence For Hae's Case
713 Words | 3 PagesA Modest Proposal: Serial By Sarah Koenig
622 Words | 3 PagesDoes Adnan Take A Piece Of Evidence In This Case
923 Words | 4 PagesLizzie Borden Research Paper
2476 Words | 10 PagesAdnan Syed Case
846 Words | 4 PagesThe BTK Case
951 Words | 4 PagesSummary Of Adnan's Murder Case
868 Words | 4 PagesArizona Vs Youngblood Case Study
1528 Words | 7 PagesDid David Payne Kill Research Paper
335 Words | 2 PagesAmelia Earhart's Forensics Explanatory Speech Outline
1386 Words | 6 PagesReasons For The Murder Of Jonbenet Ramsey
762 Words | 4 PagesLos Olvidados Film Analysis
405 Words | 2 PagesPamela Foddrill Tragic Abduction Case Study
2482 Words | 10 PagesSankofa Movie Analysis
1284 Words | 6 Pages