Should prostitution be legalized?
Having evidences for being “the world’s oldest profession” in all societies, prostitution is a profession which has been prevalent since the recorded history and it has been increasing continuously with time (Prostitution). Prostitution can be merely defined as an act of engaging in sexual activities in order to get paid with some cash or some goods. According to a report from Foundation Scelles, there are 40 – 42 million prostitutes all around the world (Lombard-Latune, Marie-Amelie). Legalizing prostitution in countries or not is the ongoing, debatable matter of concern all around the globe and people have been putting forward their perspectives towards it. Some people take prostitution as exploitation of
…show more content…
But legalizing prostitution does not mean legalizing every brutal act and violence against prostitutes. Legalizing prostitution clearly means that prostitutes should be able to work freely without any persecution and should not be arrested for their job. Laws must be promulgated such that it legalizes prostitution and protects the prostitutes from any kind of abuse and ill-treatment at the same time. For example in Germany, “Prostitutes and brothels undergo closer scrutiny and a new law for the regulation of the prostitution industry and the protection of the sex workers came into action. According to this law, sex workers must register with local authorities and seek a medical consultation from a public health service. Sex without condom is prohibited. Furthermore, clients who knowingly make use of the services provided by people who have been forced into prostitution will be penalized” (Prange, Astrid). “In Germany, sex workers pay taxes and prostitutes have access to health insurance and social security benefits” (Hinrichs, Beate). “In Netherlands as well, the legalization of prostitution made a distinction between voluntary sex work, which is legal, and forced prostitution, which remains a criminal offence” (Outshoorn, Joyce). Also, the traffickers have been thriving as prostitution has been working underground. Only after legalization of prostitution, all the trafficking that is happening can come to an end as the prostitutes and the victims of trafficking can fearlessly address the situation to the police without getting themselves
The sexist origins of the criminalization of prostitution tie into the issue of criminalizing victims of sex trafficking in that the blame has historically been on those providing the service instead of the individuals paying for it; in fact, “young girls are prosecuted at reportedly higher rates than even the men who exploit them” (Annitto, 2011, p.
Prostitution has continuously remained “shielded” from the perceptiveness of society because of its objectionable characteristics. However, the problem still remains and in my opinion, “it will still exist for years to come.” Ultimately, the Bylaws of Canada has not been able to decipher or impede this problem, apart from triggering elusiveness in the acceptance of anything that is lawful and unlawful in relations to prostitution. All over the world prostitution entwines with the economy of every city, with a potential of legal and non-legal revenue.
Sex Trafficking is a form of modern day slavery that exists throughout the United States and globally. It is one of the biggest lies in society (Farley et., 2014). The Vanderbilt Law Review indicates that the majority of prostitutes do not enter the prostitution lifestyle on their own free will choice, but instead becomes a prostitute due to a variety of vulnerabilities that both pimps and traffickers exploit. This explains why young women get blindsided and think they are becoming a prostitute when in reality they are a sex trafficking victim (Elrod 2015). When the United States made prostitution illegal, it did not change the mentality of the johns.
Charlie Bulman’s article “Decriminalize Sex Work” discusses the Amnesty International’s policy to decriminalize prostitution. He uses evidence from sex workers’ life experiences, studies from New Zealand and Rhode Island decriminalization of sex work, and a document from sex workers’ advocacy organizations to support his argument that sex work should be legalized. The International Committee on the Rights of Sex Worker in Europe and other countries drafted a letter campaigning to promote the protection of their rights and from violence and discrimination. The evidence from the life experience of sex workers prove to be filled with exploitation and substance abuse due to their vulnerability from the lack of police protection and regulation.
In the past few decades, a debate has arisen over the legalization of prostitution in America. Proponents of the cause claim that legalizing and regulating it would bring about a reduction in crime, improve public health, aid the poor, boost tax revenue, improve conditions for existing prostitutes, and allow those who willfully choose this path to do so without fear of punishment. Opponents claim the practice to be immoral and believe that permitting prostitution would escalate sexually transmitted diseases, cause increases in human trafficking, and further the oppression of
Prostitution has a strong stigma surrounding it and the people involved but if a successful form of discourse opens up then society can provide a safer space for sex workers, “Stigma was originally conceived by E. Goffman as an interactional phenomenon that played out in social judgment and stereotype infused encounters between “normal” and stigmatized persons” (Bruckert and Hannem, 49). A stigma does not just fall on one group of people but on all those who do not fit the norm of American society. Society picks out the differences in one group of people and creates a false culture and identity leading to the generalization of that group of people. This all falls heavily on sex workers. The hatred of them stems from ignorance and a heavy belief
Prostitution is a widely recognized topic, anyone and anywhere can get involved into this line of work with just one thing, themselves. Do the men, women and children really have a choice whether or not they want to use their bodies to earn a living? Or are they forced by outside influences that make them have no other choice. Preliminary research covered numerous topics about prostitution; When the victims started and why they started was not uncovered by these findings. There have not been a sufficient interviews with these subjects to
Specifically, Amnesty International’s declaration states, “The criminalization of prostitution violates the human rights of sex workers and hinders efforts to protect them from exploitation.” By decriminalizing sex work, the workers’ access to justice and to health and social services will no longer be threatened. Thus, empowering and enabling sex workers to realize their right to work in order to financially provide for themselves and their family. Identically, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights also states that, “Everyone who works has the right to just and favourable remuneration ensuring for himself and his family an existence worthy of human dignity” (UN General Assembly art. 23). This article presents how sex workers/prostitutes should be treated and given the same amount of respect and pay as all the other types of
On the other hand, the appellants agreed that the prostitution laws created risks and safety issues for the well-being of sex workers and interfered with their right to security protected under s. 7 of the Charter. However, they argued that there was no connection between the three provisions and whether the provisions added risks of violence to current and former prostitutes. There was no causal connection between the challenged provisions and the alleged interference with "right to security" (para. 73). In this case, the whole basis of the appellant 's argument was that the Criminal Code provisions do not directly infringe the security of a person and that non-direct contact (the client) is the cause of this infringement of security. By blaming
Prostitution is considered to be one of the oldest professions. Prostitution is an illegal business in many countries of the world and it is considered to be largely immoral. However, its scope is expanding simultaneously with the globalization of business and culture, which is the hallmark of our time. Researchers and activists continue to discuss whether it is possible to consider the purchase and sale of sexual services as an industry. Is it necessary to regulate the activities of prostitutes in a legal way, or should they be provided with legislative and medical protection?
Prostitution Prostitution can be defined as the provision of sexual services for money. The word “prostitute” became common in the of 18th century. During the ancient times this kind of services had been supplied for economic rewards mainly by courtesans, concubines or slaves. Courtesans and concubines often held high positions in traditional societies. The main feature of modern prostitution is that women and men tend not to know each other.
Over the years there have been many controversial ethical issues which are still debated in the 21st century. In today’s modern society one such controversial issue is prostitution. Prostitution can be defined as “The act or practice of engaging in sexual intercourse for money” (Deigh, 2010, p.29). Prostitution is the oldest profession of all. However the ethics of prostitution is still unclear between many societies.
Since the act of prostitution the customers are not arrested and that’s why the law enforcements are against it. The prostitutes are confronted with unequal treatments. From all society pushed into criminal onset on prostitutes. All law enforcement procedures fail because they tent to reduce prostitution but try to remove them from it but they can’t (stated in John
Prostitutes are people, too. Prostitution is such a complex issue; no one ever scratches the surface of sex work. Prostitution is commonly known as the world 's oldest profession yet has been outlawed in forty-nine out of the fifty states in the United States. Legal-prostitution can require all sex workers to practice safe sex as well as get tested frequently to reduce the spread of diseases. Reduction of violence against women starts with the availability of sex.
Firstly, legalization of prostitution leads to the impression that it is socially acceptable which further encourages the recruitment of prostitutes. Although it seems like legalizing prostitution may actually control and reduce the number of prostitutes, the case is actually the opposite. The core idea of legalizing prostitution is to impose a sin tax on prostitution to discourage its continuity and also to boost the country’s economy. However, if we think about it practically, those who are conducting illegal prostitution at present will never pay the taxes once they are legalized. So, there is no outcome of such action.