The Case Of Students For Fair Admissions V. University Of North Carolina
Introduction
The case of Students for Fair Admissions v. University of North Carolina is currently before the U.S. Supreme Court, and centers on the University of North Carolina's use of race in its admissions policies. The petitioner, Students for Fair Admissions, have brought claims alleging that the university's use of race discriminates against Asian American applicants in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and federal civil rights statutes, including Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The legal issues before the Supreme Court include whether the university's use of race in admissions decisions is constitutional under the Equal Protection Clause, whether the university has a compelling interest
…show more content…
Bollinger. Following precedent, the University of North Carolina does not violate any federal civil rights statutes. A diverse student body enriches the educational experience for all students. To achieve this interest, the University of North Carolina's admissions policies consider race as one of many factors in a holistic evaluation of each applicant. The university's use of race in admissions decisions is narrowly tailored to achieve its goal of promoting diversity on campus. Furthermore, the University of North Carolina's admissions policies do not discriminate against Asian American applicants. The university's holistic admissions process considers a wide range of factors, including race, and does not rely on quotas or predetermined targets. The university points to evidence showing that Asian American applicants continue to be admitted at high rates and that their enrollment numbers have increased in recent years. The petitioner’s claims under federal civil rights statutes are without merit. The University of North Carolina's use of race in admissions decisions does not discriminate against any particular racial or ethnic group, and its policies are consistent with Supreme Court precedent that allows for the limited use of race in college admissions to achieve diversity. The petitioner's statistical analyses are flawed and do not …show more content…
Congress recognized that education is one of the most important areas in which discrimination can occur and included education institutions as recipients of federal funds under Title VI. The Department of Education has issued regulations interpreting Title VI to require schools that receive federal funding to take affirmative steps to promote diversity and prevent discrimination. Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex in education programs and activities that receive federal financial assistance. The Department of Education has interpreted Title IX to require schools to take affirmative steps to prevent discrimination and harassment based on sex, including sexual harassment and sexual violence. The Supreme Court has also recognized that Title IX's prohibition on sex discrimination extends to discrimination based on gender stereotypes and sexual orientation. By prohibiting discrimination and harassment based on sex, Title IX promotes a safe and inclusive learning environment for all students, which is essential to achieving the educational benefits of diversity. The use of Title IX also has a compelling interest in promoting diversity on campus has been recognized by lower courts, including the Sixth Circuit in the case of Doe v. University of
Case Study: Grutter V. Bollinger
379 Words | 2 PagesThough in Grutter v. Bollinger we deal with the 14th amendment of the Equal Protection Clause and racial classifications too, the way race is used is slightly differs. In this particular case, the court had to decide whether the use of race at the Univeristy of Michigan Law School during the admissions process violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th amendment. Barbara Grutter, a Caucasian applicant, applied to the University of Michigan in 1996 with a 3.8 GPA and a score of 161 on her LSAT. Grutter was placed on the waitlist, but was subsequently denied admission to the school. Grutter claims that she was only denied because of her race, as the University uses race as a factor in the admission process.
Supreme Court Case Study: Fisher V. University Of Texas
591 Words | 3 PagesFisher, but they held the the Court of Appeals did not hold the University’s admission policies to a standard of strict scrutiny so the judgement was incorrect. In previous judicial precedent in cases dealing with minority admissions, the Court has held that they are reviewable under the fourteenth amendment, these such cases must be held to a standard of strict scrutiny to determine whether the policies are precisely tailored to serve a compelling governmental interest. If the policy does not meet this standard, then race can not be considered in any admissions process. The Court stated the it was the job of the reviewing court to verify that the University policy in question was necessary to achieve a more diverse student body and the any race-neutral alternative would not achieve the same level of diversity. The Supreme Court said the lower courts did not conduct a sufficient strict scrutiny examination in this case.
Supreme Court Case Regents Of The University Of California V. Allan Bakke
721 Words | 3 PagesThe U.S. Supreme Court Case Regents of the University of California v. Allan Bakke was officially decided June 28, 1978. The case addressed the issue of use of affirmative action in university admissions processes. Affirmative action, also referred to as positive discrimination, was a result of the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s, and was intended to ensure equal entry to educational institutions or employment entities to certain groups that “have historically suffered invidious discrimination” (Janda et al., 477). However, sometimes this method causes discrimination of other groups, through establishment of racial quotas. University of California employed the process of affirmative action and instituted racial quotas in its admissions
A Brief Note On The Supreme Court Case University Of California V. Bakke
820 Words | 4 Pagesn the Supreme Court case University of California v. Bakke in 1978, Allan Bakke, a white applicant, was denied admission to the University of California, Davis Medical School because he was white, although he had great MCAT, GPA, and test scores he was denied twice, because the school was using “racial quotas” during admission and had “reserved 16 out of 100 seats in its entering class for minorities, including "Blacks," "Chicanos," "Asians," and "American Indians"’’("Regents of the University of California v. Bakke. " West's Encyclopedia). Bakke sued the University of California for using “racial quotas” as well as claiming that the schools admission processes was a violation of “Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Fourteenth
A Brief Case Of Regents Of The University Of California V. Bakke
960 Words | 4 PagesIn the case of Regents of the University of California v. Bakke, Allan Bakke a white male was rejected from regular admissions into California University. He was rejected twice; meanwhile, minority students with lower grade point averages were being admitted into the same school under a special admissions program. After his second rejection, Allan Bakke was very upset, so he filed a law suit to the Superior Court of Yolo County, California. He wanted the chance to be admitted into medical school through the special admissions program. The University said that their admissions program was important and it ought to be kept in the University.
The Case Of Abigail Fisher V. University Of Texas
1052 Words | 5 PagesIn fact, 2008 was one of the most competitive years for colleges ever. Accepting an admission was not easy at that time and only the top 10% of the high school graduates, with high GPA’s and high SAT scores would get accepted. That number dropped to 7%. That shows how hard it really is to get accepted (qtd in Liptak). This shows that she was rejected from UT because of her inadequate grades and not for her race.
Fisher II Case Study
1060 Words | 5 PagesThis standard requires universities to demonstrate that the inclusion of race furthers a compelling governmental interest, and is narrowly tailored to achieve that interest. Of particular importance to the Court is whether “the means chosen ‘fit’ th[e] compelling goal so closely that there is little or no possibility that the motive for the classification was illegitimate racial prejudice or stereotype.” Put differently, universities must demonstrate that including race in the admissions process is necessary to enroll a diverse student body, and is accomplished through means that are reasonably calculated to achieve the educational benefits of
Case Study On Jackson V Birmingham Board Of Education
906 Words | 4 PagesTitle IX clearly states that, “No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.” (Title IX, 1972). The constitutional question regarding the case lies in the fourteenth amendment, “Does Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 allow suits for retaliation for complaints about unlawful sex discrimination(ITT Chicago-Kent College of Law.)?” The District Court dismissed Jackson’s case because they said Title IX does not expressly include retaliation, and the Eleventh Circuit agreed(Jackson v. Birmingham Board of Ed., 2005). This case would make its way to the U.S. Supreme Court in 2005, and Jackson would be allowed to bring evidence against the Birmingham Board of Education to sue the board for retaliation for saying that his high school’s athletics department gave unequal treatment to the girls’ team based on
Review Of 37 Words: Title IX And Fifty Years Of Fighting Sex Discrimination
1319 Words | 6 PagesAfter Title IX was passed into law, schools and colleges were required to take action to make sure that they were not engaging in sex discrimination in any area of their operations, including athletics, admissions, and hiring. In cases where people felt they had been discriminated against, the law also established ways for them to make complaints. The passage of Title IX is a significant turning point in the struggle for gender equity in
HBCU Research Paper
157 Words | 1 PagesHistorically Black colleges and universities (HBCUs) are institutions of higher education in the United States founded primarily for the education of African Americans. Prior to the mid-1960s, HBCUs were virtually the only institutions open to African Americans due to the vast majority of predominantly white institutions prohibiting qualified African Americans from acceptance during the time of segregation. As such, they are institutional products of an era of discrimination and socially constructed racism against African Americans (Joseph, 2013). Successfully, millions of students have been educated in spite of limited resources, public contempt, accreditation violations, and legislative issues. The purpose of this research paper is to discuss
Gutter V. Bollinger
276 Words | 2 PagesThe civil rights area of the 1960s is over. Affirmative action policies based on racial quotas or preferences have been struck down by the Supreme Court, yet states have an interest in college admission that are diverse and reflect their general population. The University of Texas finds itself defending policies intended to conform to recent court rulings yet merely mentioning race as a factor in a holistic review has drawn a challenge. The University of Texas process of admissions aligns with Gutter V Bollinger. The facts of this case are in keeping with previous court precedents.
Plessy Vs Ferguson Research Paper
688 Words | 3 PagesIn Regents of University of California v. Bakke (1978), the Supreme Court ruled that a university 's use of racial "quotas" in its admissions process was unconstitutional, but a school 's use of "affirmative action" to accept more minority applicants was constitutional in some circumstances. " The college was asked to at least consider blacks in the admittance of college and they were asked to not use quotas in the admission
Abigail Fisher Discrimination
319 Words | 2 PagesPublic colleges and universities in the United States use a variety of factors to determine which students will be accepted. Universities often want a student body with diverse academic interests, talents, and backgrounds. They consider factors such as applicants’ grades, standardized test scores, community service, athletic or musical ability, and geographic location. Sometimes, universities also consider an applicant’s race or ethnicity. This case is about whether the University of Texas-Austin’s admissions policies violate the Fourteenth Amendment and its guarantee of equal protection.
Essay On How Title IX Is Fair To Men And Women
354 Words | 2 PagesTitle IX is a great law that help women get the same rights in education as men. Title IX has been active for over forty years and has been helping women achieve equality. Title IX is a law that stops sex discrimination and helps break down the barriers that women once had difficulty getting passed. This essay will be showing how Title IX is fair to men and women. This essay will show how Title IX is fair and show the claims on Title IX.
Standardized Testing Bias
1523 Words | 7 PagesHowever, there’s a certain perversion to admission policies like this, policies like UT’s “top 10” program. These policies leverage their racial diversity via neighborhood, and thus public high school, segregation. As Jamelle Bouie write in a Slate article on the
More about The Case Of Students For Fair Admissions V. University Of North Carolina
Case Study: Grutter V. Bollinger
379 Words | 2 PagesSupreme Court Case Study: Fisher V. University Of Texas
591 Words | 3 PagesSupreme Court Case Regents Of The University Of California V. Allan Bakke
721 Words | 3 PagesA Brief Note On The Supreme Court Case University Of California V. Bakke
820 Words | 4 PagesA Brief Case Of Regents Of The University Of California V. Bakke
960 Words | 4 PagesThe Case Of Abigail Fisher V. University Of Texas
1052 Words | 5 PagesFisher II Case Study
1060 Words | 5 PagesCase Study On Jackson V Birmingham Board Of Education
906 Words | 4 PagesReview Of 37 Words: Title IX And Fifty Years Of Fighting Sex Discrimination
1319 Words | 6 PagesHBCU Research Paper
157 Words | 1 PagesGutter V. Bollinger
276 Words | 2 PagesPlessy Vs Ferguson Research Paper
688 Words | 3 PagesAbigail Fisher Discrimination
319 Words | 2 PagesEssay On How Title IX Is Fair To Men And Women
354 Words | 2 PagesStandardized Testing Bias
1523 Words | 7 Pages