ipl-logo

The Constitution Pros And Cons

906 Words4 Pages

During and immediately after the Revolutionary War, the founding Fathers of America sought to establish a republic on a scale never seen before and to do so had to experiment with new laws and political ideas. Though it was obvious that the first law of the land, The Articles of Confederation, were too weak for the new nation, the development of the new constitution in the late 1780s sparked fierce political debates over the power of the new central government. Even during the debate over the new constitution, it was merely political factions fighting over ideas of government. It would not be until Washington’s first term in office that actual political parties emerged. It was the differences between Secretary of Treasury, Alexander Hamilton, …show more content…

When the US was just starting off as a new country, Hamilton had created a financial plan that every other founding father thought was crazy. This plan called for the assumption of states’ debts onto the federal government, tariffs, and a national bank. This plan outraged Jefferson. He disagreed with Hamilton because his home state of Virginia had already paid off majority of its debt. As this plan was passed it created tension between the two opposing founding fathers. Also, Jefferson believed that a national bank would be unconstitutional. He might have thought this would be good for our country but since he was a strict interpreter of the Constitution, he did not think it would be allowed. Hamilton thought this national bank would be good for our country in times of financial need and would provide economic stability. Hamilton, being a loose interpreter of the Constitution, fired back at Jefferson with the Elastic Clause. The Elastic Clause was Article I Section VIII under the Constitution which states that the federal government can do anything that they see as “necessary and proper”. These differences in interpretation would begin to shape the first political parties of America with the Democratic Republicans strictly interpreting and Federalists supporting implied …show more content…

One of the first foreign issues was the French Revolution. The US was supposed to be in a never ending treaty with France that said that they agreed to help each other if they needed it. France was on the verge of war with England in 1793. The US was faced with a difficult decision of deciding if they should provide aid. Jefferson believed that the US should provide aid to France. Hamilton disagreed with this. He thought that the young country was still too weak to get involved in foreign affairs that would have probably caused them to be in even more debt. Washington, being president at this time, sided with Hamilton on this issue and wrote the Neutrality Proclamation of 1763. This said that the US would remain neutral during this disagreement between France and England. This problem was evident later on when the political parties emerged. Though the Federalists had war-hawks they were also pro-British in foreign affairs which shows why Hamilton would not want to get involved in this

Show More
Related

  • What Are The Pros And Cons Of The Us Constitution

    1195 Words  | 5 Pages

    United States Constitution Ever since 1787, the U.S. constitution has remained one of the most influential and important documents in the history of the United States. It set the foundation for which this great nation could be built upon, and there have been more than one hundred countries that have used it to model their own constitutions upon (Constitutionfacts.com, n.a.). There were a lot of very critical elements and circumstances involved in its creation. The Revolutionary War (1775-1783) that we fought against Great Britain resulted in the Treaty of Paris being signed, which gave the U.S. the authority to govern itself in 1783.

    Read More

  • How Does Alexander Hamilton Solve The Foreclosure Crisis?

    1010 Words  | 5 Pages

    Independence can be expensive. While the American Revolutionary War very costly casualty-wise, it left a young, new nation with millions of dollars of domestic and foreign debt. This staggering debt, at the time, totaled 77.1 million dollars, 1.27 billion in today’s american dollar. Debt was divided throughout the colonies, since there was no umbrella organization, like the government, to pay off the tax as one tax rather than haphazardly dealing out twelve different recompenses. Alexander Hamilton feared this debt and drafted his plan of action to keep the debt at bay and to repay the tax in a simple way--or so it seemed.

    Read More

  • Differences Between Thomas Jefferson And Alexander Hamilton

    879 Words  | 4 Pages

    as well as the states, which were very separate from each other in many aspects, so with the creation of a national bank Hamilton sought to address all these issues. The way Hamilton planned to do this was by assuming having the national bank assume the debt of all the states, resolve the concerns over fiat currency that was issued by the continental congress and raising money. So, by doing this Hamilton was not only getting the states to feel invested in the government, but also the speculators since they needed the government to pay off the bonds that were issued, and by paying the money owed to foreign creditors, the U.S. would start becoming a reliable partner; in other words, yes, the national bank was essential, a necessity to the well-being of the

    Read More

  • Differences Between Hamilton And Thomas Jefferson

    123 Words  | 1 Pages

    President Washington appointed Alexander Hamilton as the Treasury Secretary, and Thomas Jefferson as the secretary of state. Within the government, two opposing views emerged as possible ways to improve the economic state of the country. Hamilton believed in strong federal government, hence, proposed that the federal government would assume the debts of the individual states, assume the Confederation’s debts at par, and establish a national bank. In contrast to Hamilton’s proposal, Jefferson felt that the states should hold bigger authority than the federal government, since the states were nearer to the people and were less likely to exploit their power. These two views emerged as the two political views, and eventually formed the basis

    Read More

  • To What Extent Was Alexander Hamilton's Creation Of Federal Government

    569 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many states in the South had already repaid most of their debt and they wanted to restrict centralized power, they opposed the notion; while Northern states that were still carrying heavy debt loads supported the notion. He also pointed out the country incurred a debt as whole in order to secure their independence which is what lead to the creation of a federal government in the first place. The nation’s finances were a wreck due to the Revolutionary War. Hamilton understood that in order to win the respect of the citizens of the United States as well as foreign nations, he had to prove to them that the United States could be trusted and

    Read More

  • Jefferson Vs Hamilton Debate Essay

    463 Words  | 2 Pages

    There were many people who wanted to redo the Confederation's national debt/pay Hamilton insisted on a full payment and also a plan so that the federal government could take over the unpaid debts, that were due for the states which had happened in the Revolution. Hamilton also made sure that congressional legislation for the Bank for one of the United States was very secured. When the Bank of England acted as the nation's main institution it managed other branches in different parts of the country. Hamilton decided to sponsor a national print and argued in favor of tariffs, saying that protection of firms could be used to help keep the development of competitive national manufacturers. These measures took place of the credit for the federal government on a good foundation and gave it all the fixes and help it needed.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The Beliefs Of The Colonies In The Late 1700s

    622 Words  | 3 Pages

    Jefferson believed that because the Constitution did not directly state that the Federal government could create a bank then it was not allowed. Hamilton, on the other hand, believed that because the constitution gave the Federal government the right to coin and distribute money that the government could also create a bank.

    Read More

  • Leaving The Treaties According To Hamilton In 1793

    625 Words  | 3 Pages

    Hamilton however disagreed with Jefferson’s position of keeping the treaties with France. Hamilton saw the British as a natural ally to the United States and wanted the United States to align with Britain and cut treaties with France. France had established a new government during this time, which Hamilton used as his reasoning to pursue President Washington to void treaties with France. According to Hamilton, the United Sates would not have been dishonoring its treaties because the United Sates had made treaties with the previous French government only. As a result all treaties could have been voided because there was a new French government.

    Read More

  • What Is Alexander Hamilton Necessary?

    961 Words  | 4 Pages

    Alexander Hamilton, the first Secretary of Treasury of the United States, had a lot going for himself being a man that came from poverty to success, and he was a man “all powerful and fails at nothing which he attempts” admitted a congressman in 1791 (Tindall and Shi). Born in the Caribbean in the West Indies, abandoned by his father and orphaned at the age of 13 by his late mother who had died. Later moved to New York, became a lawyer and transitioned to nationalism thus giving him the important role of handling the weight of the debt America had accumulated $54 million deep after the Revolutionary War (Digital History). Hamilton saw the need for some financial credit to be given to America and he had the right idea by proposing a National Bank to his first president George Washington. Word dispersed of that proposal leading a

    Read More

  • Alexander Hamilton First Report On Public Credit

    858 Words  | 4 Pages

    Hamilton made it clear that some debt was essential for economic sustainability because debt encouraged people to borrow money - to spend. However, he knew that in order to be an independent nation the United States needed to find a way to be economically self-sustainable. Hamilton “made two sweeping proposals:”, (Brookhiser, 2016, p.2) in his first credit report, he suggested that the new federal government would pay off their own debt and the debts of the states as well. His second suggestion was the debt would be paid at the same common rate for all states, there would not be inequality amongst states being one paying more than the other. Not only was this was a very controversial matter because the states that stayed on top of their dues felt very little empathy for the less fortunate states that didn’t meet up to pay their dues but in order to pass the ⅔ rule in congress.

    Read More

  • Partisan Politics: Political Parties, The Federalists And The Republicans

    923 Words  | 4 Pages

    Partisan Politics: Republicans In early America, there were two essential political parties ,the Federalists and the Republicans, who challenged each other on numerous ideological and political disputes from 1790-1810. The Federalists were a group of individuals who supported a strong national government, a broader clarification of the Constitution, and diplomatic ties with Great Britain. However, the Republicans focused on the issues of controlling federal power, supporting states rights, having a strict explanation of the Constitution, and broadening popular participation in terms of politics. The Republicans were first an alliance of opponents of Hamilton’s policies, and they feared a rise of an urban aristocracy in a republic like the

    Read More

  • Slavery In Joseph J. Ellis's Founding Brothers

    946 Words  | 4 Pages

    The topic of the night was the national debt crisis. Alexander Hamilton, a strong supporter of federal assumption, and James Madison, a loyal Virginian, were among the guests of this carefully calculated soiree. Personal motivations of wealth and power guided their conversations. Hamilton’s economic plan was devised to benefit the urban elite, who were, in his mind, the keystone of American economics. States like Virginia that had managed to pay off large amounts of their debt, now risked being charged more in new taxes under Hamilton’s plan.

    Read More

  • Jefferson Vs Hamilton Research Paper

    283 Words  | 2 Pages

    Political parties, Democratic Republicans and Federalists, started in the U.S. because of differing views of Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson, and the influence of newspapers. Jefferson’s and Hamilton’s different ways of thinking(mostly on issues that was beneficial for the country) played a huge part in the start of political parties. They fought about economy. Jefferson liked farming while Hamilton preferred manufacturing and trade. Interpretation of the Constitution was another thing they fought upon.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of The Us Constitution

    668 Words  | 3 Pages

    1. Personally, I believe the constitution was the better document because it had more power. The articles of confederation gave the states more power than congress had, and because of this states either did was it said or did not. Because of the states having more power over Congress, the states did not focus on the needs of the whole country but only cared for their own state and what is best for their people. The constitution is better because it was easier to make changes and amendments to it.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of The House Of Representives

    829 Words  | 4 Pages

    After the war the United States was in debt that caused Hamilton to come up with the idea of a national bank. In call for the House of Representives, Hamilton wanted to be supported by them to obtain public credit. Hamilton wanted to reduce the national debt and stabilize the nations national currency even by increasing it .Hamilton ’s report on the bank was seemed to be a financial prosperous administration to finance and help improve the publics credit .Hamilton seen this as a great idea and then began to acknowledge the advantages of the bank . Hamilton saw that the bank could potentially not only just help the government but could help the citizens in their personal lives as well.

    Read More

More about The Constitution Pros And Cons

Open Document