ipl-logo

The Controversy Of Interpreting Shakespeare's Sonnets

1327 Words6 Pages

William Shakespeare is more than just a household name. For many, he’s an icon, a writer that cannot be fully praised for his genius, and a talented storywriter remembered forever due to the far reach his plays enjoy. For that reason, it is only natural that the worth of his sonnets within school curriculum would be called into question. Is it possible for sonnets, which are composed of only fourteen lines, to rival the well-deserved acclaim his plays receive?
If not, it would make perfect sense for the editors of a world anthology to strike his sonnets from their next edition. Thankfully, they do not need to. In this essay, I will argue that removing Shakespeare’s sonnets would be a great disservice to students that wish to study Shakespeare …show more content…

It is likely that Shakespeare never intended for his sonnets to be published (Neary). The sonnets appear to be written from a first-person perspective, which, according to the perspectives of varying students, can either be reflective of his own personal thoughts or a way that he expressed his muse in ways he kept away from his plays. With the nature of some of the sonnets referring to men so beautiful that they simply must reproduce, and dark women that are beautiful and demonic at the same time, it invites positive scholarly debate about the truth and fiction behind these sonnets. Additionally, it is valuable for a reader to feel connected to the author in some way; it helps generate interest and personal, vested intrigue in the work at hand. Many sonnets may echo sentiments that students themselves feel they have experienced, which helps foster the connection between a work of the past and the reader of …show more content…

If a student looks at the sonnet mentioned in the previous paragraph, he will find similarities in the play Measure For Measure. This play also showcases the peril that a country and its citizens can face when the person that is meant to protect and guide the people is the one that is led astray and embraces corruption. When Angelo propositions Isabella with the compromise of sex in return for her brother’s life, he shows the purest form of power leading to near immediate corruption. It is shown in this play that when “weeds,” such as Claudio, are rotten, it is a drop in the ocean; however, when a “lily,” like Angelo, is rotten, it rocks the sea itself. (Shakespeare) “Lilies that fester smell far worse than weeds.” Sonnets can provide great value when viewed as more than just a standalone piece of writing. They can connect to the plays and be used in conjunction with other works from Shakespeare explored in the curriculum and may serve as excellent primers to the morals and lessons discovered

Show More
Related

  • Ap Euro Chapter 9 Essay

    1216 Words  | 5 Pages

    He holds the ultimate title of unparalleled genius producing the greatest examples of English Literature. The English language and the Western world’s adaptation of the way literature is written today is mainly attributable to Shakespeare’s literary writings. His writings include comedies, tragedies, romances, histories, sonnets, plays and other poems. His formation of an acting company supported many writers, musicians and artists who shared his passion and ideas during that time. He introduced “the English sonnet”: quatrains (four-line stanzas) with alternate rhymes, followed by a concluding couplet) (Fiero 151).

    Read More

  • Hamlet, Act 3, Scene III, Line 87, No.

    743 Words  | 3 Pages

    To Quote Hamlet, Act III, Scene III, Line 87, “No.” (A discussion on my three favorite sonnets of Shakespeare) It is ordinary, everyday knowledge that Shakespeare was a renowned playwright and author. Despite this, many people do not recognize that the illustrious Shakespeare was also a poet, and wrote over a hundred sonnets in his lifetime. In fact, he penned exactly one hundred fifty-four sonnets, with fourteen lines each, and totaling in two thousand, one hundred fifty-six lines. These multitudinous verses have perplexed scholars and readers for centuries, as the meaning of some of the sonnets is unclear.

    Read More

  • Comparing Love In Sonnet And Harryette Mullen's Dim Lady

    956 Words  | 4 Pages

    Throughout the ages, sonnets represent thematic messages of love and immortality while also following a strict, rigid structure of fourteen lines with a varying rhyme scheme depending on the type of sonnet. One of these sonnets, Shakespearean, was created by none other than William Shakespeare. For example, his sonnet “My mistress’ eyes are nothing like the sun” focuses heavily on loving a woman despite her ugly features; however, many modern poets break this strict structure, such as Harryette Mullen’s take on Shakespeare’s sonnet where she places a modern twist on the speaker’s view of a woman. Although both sonnets focus on the traditional theme of love, Mullen’s “Dim Lady” breaks away from the typical conventions and structure of a sonnet

    Read More

  • Dim Lady Analysis

    605 Words  | 3 Pages

    Structurally “Dim Lady” has little to do with the firm guidelines of true sonnets, however this choice gives Mullens a greater degree of creative liberty when it comes to the rescripted Sonnet 130. The more contemporary style of free verse rather than structurally rigid helps to create the more modern feeling of the overall work and in turn allows Mullens to shape Shakespeare's work in a new

    Read More

  • Deception In Shakespeare Sonnets And Plays Analysis

    1226 Words  | 5 Pages

    The use of deception to gain advantages in Shakespearean Works Sonnets and plays are dramatic pieces of arts that have many instances of deception among the characters, specifically the leaders that they used in the hope of gaining some distinct advantage in life. The deception governs the relationships between the different characters, as well as drive the plots. It is the several acts of deception, both intentional and unintentional that offers the dramatic devices that will inform the action. There are several instances of deception demonstrates by characters in many sonnets and plays, particularly by Shakespeare that gives the characters a clear advantage in the society. In the world of Shakespeare, for example, characters used deception,

    Read More

  • Forbidden Love In William Shakespeare's Sonnet 18

    774 Words  | 4 Pages

    During the seventeenth century, William Shakespeare was a man who was beyond his time and showed his ability through his writing. Shakespeare was clever with working around forbidden love and making readers question him and the knowledge he had about the golden man, Henry Wriothesley. Shakespeare was a true master of fantasizing love that was frowned upon and making his works come alive through his writing. In Sonnet 18, William Shakespeare uses diction, imagery and rhyme to speak of the golden young man to show that some love is forbidden. Shakespeare’s diction is a puzzle of why and how he mentions certain pieces in his poem.

    Read More

  • Sonnet Dialectical Construct

    120 Words  | 1 Pages

    A sonnet is fundamentally a dialectical construct which allows the poet to examine the nature and ramifications of two usually contrastive ideas,emotions, states of mind, beliefs, actions, events, images, etc., byjuxtaposing the two against each other, and possibly resolving or justrevealing the tensions created and operative between the two. O. K., so much for the fancy language. Basically, in a sonnet, youshow two related but differing things to the reader in order to communicatesomething about them. Each of the three major types of sonnets accomplishesthis in a somewhat different way. There are, of course, other types of sonnets,as well, but I 'll stick for now to just the basic three (Italian, Spenserian, English), with a brief look at

    Read More

  • Comparison Between The Acting Unit And Shakespeare Class

    240 Words  | 1 Pages

    Next, we did sonnets. Sonnets are poems of 14 lines with 10 syllables per line. We did textbook work which about the dawn of theatre which is where we dove into the Shakespeare era. Shakespeare is considered one of the great early playwrights. We watched

    Read More

  • How Does Petrarch View The Beloved?

    1582 Words  | 7 Pages

    Even though the sonnet is instinctively attributed to the literary accomplishments of the wordsmith William Shakespeare, Francis Petrarch played an ancestral role in the development and lifeblood of the sonnet, offering Shakespeare a foundation upon which he built his legacy of the Shakespearean sonnet. Despite this interrelationship, the way in which Petrarch views the beloved is in considerable contrast with the way in which Shakespeare views the beloved within his sonnets. The difference in approach to the beloved is what this essay will be concerned with, as it is this difference that answers the question of who wields the most power in Shakespearean sonnet- the poet or the beloved? This essay will look at the thematic features of Petrarchan

    Read More

  • The Analysis Of Timon Of Athens And Sonnet 99

    1687 Words  | 7 Pages

    To clarify, both Queen Elizabeth I and Shakespeare had inspired many people and both made their own great histories. Queen Elizabeth I supported arts, music, and Christianity while Shakespeare created masterpieces of great plays, and sonnets that no one can overcome. This paper is to inform about the backgrounds of Queen Elizabeth I and William Shakespeare, and also to discuss about one of his plays; Timon of Athens, and one of his sonnets; sonnet 99 respectively. To begin with, the Elizabethan era or so-called “Golden Age” took place between the year of 1558-1603.

    Read More

  • Shakespeare Metaphors

    1321 Words  | 6 Pages

    Shakespeare and I have never really gotten along. Let me rephrase that, Shakespearean plays and I have never really gotten along. I love Shakespearean sonnets, because they are poems and I enjoy trying to figure out the metaphors behind his words. Shakespearean plays, although filled with metaphors contain difficult to understand characters. The different situations that the characters often find themselves in are unbelievable and unrelatable.

    Read More

  • Sonnet 71 Figurative Language

    1351 Words  | 6 Pages

    William Shakespeare’s sonnets are closely related in the idea that the theme as well as the subject of the poem remain consistent. A distinctive factor among Shakespeare’s sonnets however, is that they each contain somewhat varying tones. Two specific sonnets that prove this are “Sonnet 71” and “Sonnet 73” respectively. Both sonnets refer to the same subject, what is seemingly the speaker of the poem’s lover or mistress. The theme of death and dying are ones which remain present throughout each text.

    Read More

  • What Does Shakespeare Sonnet 29 Mean To Me

    452 Words  | 2 Pages

    Growing up I was homeschooled and not just school at home, but I received extremely restricted and censored schooling. Prior to eleventh grade when I dual enrolled at a local state college, I had only ever heard of Shakespeare. Like most people, I heard of Shakespeare’s most popular work, the story of Romeo and Juliet, but I never had the opportunity to read it. My parents believed it was sinful and inappropriate reading in their Christian household. Sonnet number 29 was one of the first works of Shakespeare I read in my course at the state college.

    Read More

  • Comparing Wordsworth's 'The World Is Too Much With Us'

    160 Words  | 1 Pages

    There are two different kinds of sonnets, the Petrarchan and the Shakespearean, in the English language. “The World is Too Much with Us” by William Wordsworth falls under the category of the Petrarchan sonnet, named after the Italian poet Francesco Petrarch. Unlike its counterpart, this form of sonnet contains two parts: an octave, consisting of eight lines, and a sestet, consisting of six lines. A conflict or thought is illustrated in the octave, and it is brought to a resolution in the sestet. Petrarchan sonnets also have a different rhythm compared to Shakespearean sonnets (Lee).

    Read More

  • What Makes A Great Sonnet

    480 Words  | 2 Pages

    Sonnets are a beautiful way of organizing and telling and short story. They might look easy to write but they really aren't. They take time to make with so many steps involved. But it wasn't all bad and it was a little worth it because I ended up making a great sonnet. If you ever think about writing a sonnet listen to what I had trouble with.

    Read More

More about The Controversy Of Interpreting Shakespeare's Sonnets

Open Document