ipl-logo

The Four Gospel Controversy

1979 Words8 Pages

Before any conclusions can be made regarding the message of the Four Gospels, it is important to consider whether they are historically accurate. Arguments swing between them being either accurate in their portrayal of historical events, or that very few of the events in them took place. Even the central figure of the gospels, Jesus Christ, receives a mixed response from scholars. Many scholars would agree that Christ is a historical figure. The issues that cause controversy are the miraculous events surrounding His life. The best source of information regarding the historical events of Christ’s life are the Four Gospels. The historical accuracy of the setting in these Gospels is crucial to the argument regarding the authenticity of the miraculous …show more content…

These are contradictions within the various texts of the same Gospel, and also variances between the Four Gospels themselves. Within the various copies of each Gospel there are contradictions. These contradictions usually have no impact on the theological message and are usually grammatical, punctuation, or spelling errors. These minor scribal errors do not detract from the overall consistency between the various copies. The greater issue would be the contradictions in events between the Four Gospels. Where the ancient scholarly pursuit was to find harmony, the current scholarly drive is to find discord between the Four Gospels, any small find becomes bloated out of proportion to show the whole work to be fake. One of the main contradictions, that the author is aware of, is the account of Judas’ death. Matthew 27:3-8 has Judas throwing the bribe money away before hanging himself, the priests using the money to buy a field for burial. Acts 1:18 has Judas buying the field with the bribe money and dying in the field from a fall. This historical inconsistency does not affect the consistency of Christ’s theological message. The ancient Eastern minds were not as fixated on an accurate history and timeline as the modern Western world. Even the differences in the timeline for Christ’s movements can be easily explained. The various authors of the Four Gospels grouped some of Christ’s actions around purpose rather than sticking to a strict timeline. When an account is consistent in the Four Gospels this is a problem. When there are some small inconsistencies in the account this is also a problem. It seems as if it is not the consistencies or inconsistencies that are the problem. The problem is scholars looking for problems wherever they can invent

Show More
Related

  • Year 11 World History Essay

    742 Words  | 3 Pages

    3. Constantine was originally a traditional Pagan, but on his way to battle he sees the sign of the cross on the face of the sun. He hears an awesome voice that announces his destiny, and tells him that he is to conquer through the sign of the cross. He realizes that it is through Christ that he will win this battle. He listens and is victorious, and

    Read More

  • Bart Ehrman The New Testament Summary

    1513 Words  | 7 Pages

    Ehrman makes it a point throughout the textbook to emphasize that his approach is consistently from a historical perspective. His apparent goal is to familiarize the student with New Testament writings and early Christian writings by “emphasizing the rich diversity of the earliest Christian literature.” (xxvii) What the reader is left with is a textbook that comes across as being written from an interpretive standpoint where it is apparent Ehrman views his interpretation to be the one true expression of

    Read More

  • David Van Biema's The Gospel Truth

    369 Words  | 2 Pages

    When it comes to knowing and learning the religions of the world one must approach them with a critical mind. One cannot simply just believe every religion and know have their own view points. David Van Biema presents his ideas about Christianity and Jesus in “The Gospel Truth?”. Van Biema’s main point is about how “Matthew, Mark, Luke and John… is notoriously unreliable,” . Van Biema writes about how one cannot be completely sure about whether to believe if Jesus actually said what is written in the bible, he continues to say that Jesus may even be an “imaginative theological construct” .

    Read More

  • The Aeneid And Jesus Analysis

    1721 Words  | 7 Pages

    Seemingly, both men are simply following the wishes of the divine. Jesus has been sent down to Earth by the Lord to “save his people from their sins” [Matthew 1: 21]. His entire life is devoted to spreading the word of God, and he is ultimately crucified so that all have the opportunity to live in the Kingdom of God. Throughout the Gospels, Jesus is constantly giving thanks to the Lord and reminding those around him that the miracles that are being performed are done so out of God’s grace.

    Read More

  • How Does The Gospel Of Luke And Drew Hart's 'Trouble I' Ve Seen

    1077 Words  | 5 Pages

    Scholars have been reading and interpreting the Bible for centuries. Historians and theologians continue to debate the meaning and importance of the journey, miracles, parables, and teachings of Jesus. In reading the gospel of Luke and Drew Hart’s book, Trouble I’ve Seen: Changing the Way the Church Views Racism, similarities can be drawn between the differing portrayals of Jesus and those individuals that Jesus was seeking out. Here, we will take a closer look at who Jesus is through the words of the gospel of Luke, how Hart understands and describes Jesus, as well as where the two cross over. Unlike the other gospels, Luke recognizes Jesus as the universal Christ and compassionate savior.

    Read More

  • Jesus: Fact Or Fiction Or Evidence Of Conspiracy?

    1293 Words  | 6 Pages

    He appears afraid and doubtful in Garden of Gethsemane before his arrest. The writing style of the gospel accounts is not in keeping with the writing style of myths of that era, but rather it is more like what you’d expect from eyewitness reports. And why don’t the separate gospel accounts show evidence of conspiracy? If Jesus’ followers were trying to pull off a hoax, you’d think they would have made sure to get their stories straight.

    Read More

  • More Than A Carpenter Summary

    894 Words  | 4 Pages

    More Than a Carpenter I. Introduction More Than a Carpenter is a Christian Apologetics and Inspirational book written by Josh McDowell with later contributions by his son, Sean McDowell. First published in 1977 by Tyndale House Publishers, the work has sold more than 27 million copies worldwide, and remains to be one of the bestselling books about Christianity and Evangelism. The author, Joslin “Josh” McDowell, is an American Christian apologist and evangelist born in Union City, Michigan in 1939. He has authored or co-authored more than 100 books about Christian Apologetics since 1960, once of which being his highly influential book, Evidence That Demands a Verdict.

    Read More

  • Martin Luther King, Jr.: An Indispensiable Event In Christian History

    269 Words  | 2 Pages

    An indispensiable event in Christian history is Martin Luther King, Jr. enlightening society that there were civil laws that did not appropriately reflect the laws of equality, which were consistently addressed throughout the Christian Bible; therefore, if there was such as abundance of followers of Christianity, during that time, then the dominate class [upper and middle class, Caucasians] were typically not living by the word of God considering the fact that they were denying natural human rights as well as promoting hatred toward someone of different background. One major event that calls into question the entire faith, whether or not it did in fact happen, is Jesus’s resurrection in consideration that he was persecuted by the Roman soldiers,

    Read More

  • The Bible: A Critical Analysis Of The Four Gospels

    2090 Words  | 9 Pages

    The word “critical” often conjures the incorrect image of negativity. If the Four Gospels are to be analysed critically would this study find loopholes only? This need not be the case, as the Four Gospels, and the Bible as a whole, has withstood the test of time. As a stand-alone text, the Bible has proven its accuracy in its portrayal of events, its authorship, and its date of writing. Though scholars have tried to use both textual and literary criticism to discredit the Four Gospels, there are an equal number of scholars, using these same tools, who have proved that the Four Gospels have an accurate portrayal of events.

    Read More

  • Mark's Gospel Describe Jesus

    435 Words  | 2 Pages

    1. Based solely on Mark’s gospel, describe Jesus. Be careful NOT to include any other source but Mark’s gospel (I will deduct points if you do). You may want to skim your reading and lecture notes. Make sure you give me a thorough paragraph in your response.

    Read More

  • Percy Jackson Book Vs Movie Analysis

    500 Words  | 2 Pages

    Another example of this evidence is that in the first movie, Luke, son of Hermes and antagonist throughout the series, was described as having blond hair and blue eyes. In the first movie, he had brown hair and brown eyes. Now all of these points may sound superficial and critical but directors say that they follow the movie as accurately as possible. And yes I know that not all scenes from the book can be added to the movie but the directors should still try.

    Read More

  • Alexander The Great Primary Sources

    721 Words  | 3 Pages

    For example, on page 189, two routes and two battle locations, Arbela and Gaugamela, are both mentioned. There are some deficiencies in this book. It mixes mythologies such as the Dionysus tale and the Amazon tale with the reality, which might let the reader confused. Also, the source inserts phrases such as “It is said” in support of a specific statement for several times, making the evidence not so persuasive. Undeniably, the weaknesses of employing the primary source also exist.

    Read More

  • Inaccuracies In Kingdom Of Heaven

    951 Words  | 4 Pages

    One of the last inaccuracies I saw in the movie, is the weapons they used, some of them were not created yet at this time. In the movie, there are many fighting scenes, with many different weapons used and not all of those weapons had been created yet. During the Kingdom of Heaven, there was a love interest that played a big part in the movie. It was the relationship between Balian and Sibylla, which in real life was not true.

    Read More

  • The Four Gospels

    1084 Words  | 5 Pages

    Everyone knows the gospels are very important to the Catholic Church, But why? We read them at mass every Sunday so they must have a deeper meaning. Well that’s just it. They teach about Jesus’ life on earth, his death and resurrection. They might differ from each other but that is because they were written by four different authors.

    Read More

  • Matthew: The First Gospel In The New Testament

    459 Words  | 2 Pages

    Matthew, the first gospel in the New Testament, utilizes an interesting formula of fulfillment when compared to other New Testament writings. Detractors have lobbed fiery darts at this formula, claiming that it displays bias and inaccuracy. This, however, comes from a misunderstanding of what Matthew is attempting to portray to his audience. Jewish Hellenists were the likely audience that Matthew had in mind when he wrote his account. Resulting from this, he wishes to provide them with insurmountable proof of Jesus Christ being the promised Messiah of the Old Testament.

    Read More

More about The Four Gospel Controversy

Open Document