The Inaccurate Portrayal Of George Killing Lennie In The Movie Adaptation

Title: The Inaccurate Portrayal of George Killing Lennie in the Movie Adaptation

Introduction:
John Steinbeck's novella "Of Mice and Men" is a renowned literary work that delves into the lives of George Milton and Lennie Small, two displaced ranch workers during the Great Depression. However, the movie adaptation fails to accurately capture the essence of George's decision to kill Lennie, deviating from the original story. This essay will examine the reasons supporting the claim that the movie adaptation inadequately portrays George's act of euthanizing Lennie through the absence of an Edenic garden, the lack of discovery by others, and the omission of visions involving the rabbit and Aunt Clara.

The Absence of an Edenic Garden:
In the novella, Steinbeck paints a vivid picture of an Edenic setting, emphasizing its lushness and serenity. This imagery serves as a stark contrast to the harsh realities of the outside world and symbolizes a temporary escape for George and Lennie. However, the movie adaptation fails to accurately represent this paradise-like environment. Instead of the vibrant and captivating Edenic garden described in the novella, the movie portrays a mere pond surrounded by brush. This omission undermines the significance of the setting and diminishes the emotional impact of the final scene.

This interaction provides George with empathy and support during a moment of immense guilt and grief. Unfortunately, the movie adaptation eliminates this crucial encounter, isolating George in his anguish. The absence of Slim's presence undermines the emotional depth of George's decision and fails to illustrate the complexity of their