"The failure of being a king" What should a king be avoid of in order to keep his or her power? The great philosopher Machiavelli had summed up his philosophy, with reference to the ancient kings. There are some elements that will definitely cause the failure of a king. Both the novel, Macbeth, and the film, The Lion King, show the fall of the kings. Neither Macbeth nor Scar is suitable to be the king because three reasons: they are not legitimate candidates of the king, they are not appreciated by people and they are telling lies and injuring people. A king should have a legitimate crown. Therefore, the first fault of both Macbeth and Scar are their illegitimate crowns. Before they …show more content…
If you concentrate on what you don't have, you will never, ever have enough." (Oprah Winfrey) A King should control his or her desire of trying to be perfect. After Macbeth and Scar gain the power from murdering the previous king, the unsuccessful maintenance of the power twist the situation and cause the failure. They do not stop doing bad towards others, instead, they fall into the road of no return by killing more people who might become a threat and cheating others. If a man told a lie, he will make more lies to make the situation looks true. Once a lie begins, it will never cease. That is, one lie leads to another. Macbeth and Scar probably are such, they murder their king to get the property of the country, but also have to kill more people to maintain this position. Macbeth killed Banquo, Macduff's son and wife, he tries to hide his evil plan under people's eyes. In order to persuade Hyenas to help him, Scar lies to them that they are allies and friends. "Things bad begun make strong themselves by ill."(Macbeth; 3.2.57) In another aspect, Macbeth and Scar cannot turn back to the right path. "I am in blood Stepp'd in so far, that, should I wade no more, Returning were as tedious as go o'er." …show more content…
According to the Prince, a prince must gain the favor of the people to make the people remain loyal. The people’s goodwill is always the best defense against foreign aggression. Unfortunately, Macbeth and Scar are not appreciated by people, moreover, they are hated by people. Machiavelli emphasizes that a prince must avoid being hated; he must guard himself with friends to battle internal conflicts and an army against external strife. The goal of the kings is gathering as much allies and friends as they can, whereas Macbeth and Scar do not pay much attention to this statement. Macbeth gives neither fine-speeches nor uses political instrument to ensure the stability of his reign. He does not have supporters on his side. He is lacking of strategies to capture people's hearts; it results in Macduff and Ross's disagreement with accepting Macbeth as their king. He should strive to gain a positive reputation, such as "brave and remarkable" and demonstrate that he appreciates those who have brilliant
The tragic hero, Macbeth, and the antagonist in Lion King, Scar, reach the same ambition by different means, but finally they both failed. First of all, Macbeth 's motivation is different from Scar 's, but different motivations cause them to do similar things, that is to usurp the throne. Three witches told Macbeth a prophecy that he will become the king, as they said,"All hail, Macbeth! Hail to thee, Thane of Glamis! All hail, Macbeth!
We see Macbeth develop characters who are ambitious and greedy for power. All they see is a throne and a castle, what they are missing is the murder, deceit, and enemies that will follow when seeking these things. “My thought, whose murder yet is but fantastical, / Shakes so my single state of man / That function is smothered in surmise, / And nothing is but what is not.” ( Macbeth Act 1 Scene 3).
The natural drive and ambition in an individual can be a great strength. If it goes unchecked, however, it can cause people to do things they would never have originally done leading to bad consequences. In Wiliam Shakespeare's play, The Tragedy of Macbeth, there was a successful kingdom in Scotland; it had lucious land and mostly good people. King Duncan was a gracious leader. He loved reward and praising his loyal subjects.
The play entitled Macbeth by William Shakespeare portrays Macbeth, a loyal and brave thane to the king. When a prophecy reveals he will become king, Macbeth is overcome with ambition and greed. Convinced of this prophecy and the encouragement from his wife, he is able to kill the king and take the throne. Although Macbeth was able to obtain the throne, he was was overwhelmed by power and guilt leading to internal conflict, which suggests that success is not desirable through cheating and corruption and ultimately cost more than its actually worth, Macbeth`s reckless pursuit of killing and becoming the king is representative of the power he has and what he is able to do with the power he's gained; therefore. His relentless ambition for king reveals the guilt behind power.
It is human nature to want power, to be at the top of the pyramid, to be king/queen, but that comes at a price as shown in Macbeth. In the play, Macbeth and Lady Macbeth will do anything to have absolute power and nothing stands in their way. From killing to going completely mad, they will become the next king and queen at all costs. The ambition and the want for power is so high that they kill many, they do whatever they can to be one step closer, and they go completely insane, all because they want that absolute power.
When we are first presented with the character of Macbeth he is pictured as a noble and loyal warrior. However, once his future is presented to him by the witches saying that he, Macbeth, is to become the next great King of Scotland, he begins to lose focus and makes the wrong decisions. Macbeth begins to only make choices that will benefit only himself and to gain power. Becoming almost unrecognizable to the person he once was. After confronting his wife, Lady Macbeth, he isn't the only one with a lust for power.
Macbeth was the Thane of Cawdor but he wanted to be king more than anything. The witches had told him that he would one day be king but he did not know how long that would take so when King Duncan had been invited to stay the night at his house he exclaimed that “My thought, whose murder yet is but fantastical,/ shakes so my single state of man/ that function is smother 'd in surmise,/ and nothing is but what is not”(1.3.52-55). He felt that if he were to kill King Duncan that he would have a better chance of becoming king. Though the witches had never told him that someone would need to get murdered for him to become king, his ambition tempted him to quicken this process the only way he felt he could. This was the beginning of the murderer that the witches had created with the fortune telling.
He has found a way to manipulate words and lie to hide the fact that he was the one who murdered the king to seek his power. Macbeth states ”Tis is not for you to hear what I can speak, the repetition, recurrence in a woman's ear, would murder as it fell” (A2, S2 93-95). Macbeth has found a way to lie around the death of King Duncan, he uses a rhetoric language which helps manipulate and persuade the audience to believe what he is trying to get across. To continue, in the film “The Lion King” Scar has tendencies to use rhetoric language to help him betray, manipulate and gain power as king too. Scar manipulated Simba, the king’s son by using an effective rhetorical strategy to make him go to the “Elephant Graveyard”.
Taking over as the new king has been quite the task. The king before me, Macbeth, turned our whole Kingdom around and not in the way we should want. He killed anybody in his way to become the new king, including my father. Macbeth was eventually stopped and killed, but was it too late as we have already lost a great amount of people. Now, as the new King, I also must try to regain the trust of my people.
Macbeth failed to show devotion to his kingdom when he murdered Lady Macduff and her children. Scar failed to show his devotion to his kingdom when he allowed the resources of the kingdom to become scarce. Macbeth failed to show patience when he visited the witches’ cave, demanding for answers. Scar failed to show patience when yells “Silence!”
Macbeth’s impatience for power leads to drastic actions. He murders the king in the belief that “this blow might be the be-all and end-all” (1.7.5). This assassination could never “trammel up the consequence” (1.7.2-3), as Macbeth believes, but only leads to more trouble. Although Macbeth seizes the throne, Macbeth had to betray his loyalty to the king whose “virtues will plead like angels” (1.7.18-19), and his morality has paid the price. Macbeth has now lost all sense of what honor is by using such dishonest ways to become king.
Greed for power leads corrupt leaders to pursue power through ruthless and violent ways, putting their countries in an unstable state. Macbeth commits murders and violent acts to earn his absolute power, but his corrupt mindset of yearning power leads to instability in the Scotland. After hearing from the witches, Macbeth admits that, “My thought, whose murder yet is but fantastical/ Shakes so my single state of man/ That function is smother'd in surmise /and nothing is but what is not.”
At the beginning of William Shakespeare’s ‘Macbeth’ the protagonist Macbeth is described as ‘brave’, ‘noble’ and ‘honourable’, however Lady Macbeth’s and Macbeths desire for power consumes them. Macbeth’s ambition overrides his conscience and transformed his greatest strength into his greatest weakness. Macbeth’s inability to resist temptations that led him to be greedy for power, Macbeth’s easily manipulative nature which allowed his mind to be swayed, Macbeth having no self control and his excessive pride was what allowed him to renew his previously honourable and celebrated title into one of an evil ‘tyrant’. Macbeth is led by the prophecies of the witches after they foretell he will become the Thane of Cawdor. Not only the witches, but also his wife easily manipulate Macbeth as she attacks his manhood in order to provoke him to act on his desires.
Twisted by power, Macbeth is a thrilling tale revealing just how far a man will go to retain his rule. “Upon my head they placed a fruitless crown And put a barren scepter in my grip, Thence to be wrenched with an unlineal hand, No son of mine succeeding. If ’t be so, For Banquo’s issue have I filed my mind,” Macbeth stated, showing his deteriorating mental state, and immense hunger for power. This play was a work of fiction, nevertheless the reality of the issue is all too real. This disastrous tale was written in 1606 by William Shakespeare, and was designed specifically for King James, who was renowned for hunting witches throughout his life.
In the story “Macbeth”, Macbeth was considered a very well-respected warrior. He was known for being chivalrous as well as ambitious. Although ambition is typically a good thing, Macbeth turns it into the complete opposite. He lets his ambition get the best of him and it ruins Macbeth entirely. He was given the title Thane of Cawdor and, due to greed, he continued to push for more.