ipl-logo

The Man I Killed Critical Analysis

1061 Words5 Pages

Brooke Lynch
Advanced English 3
Working Draft 2
05 March 2018

Psychological Burdens Soldiers Have During and After War
The themes of shame and guilt is constant through this book. Soldiers had feelings of obligation to go to war. While there were many reasons, the most prevalent was the fear of embarrassing either themselves, their parents and family members, or the town they lived in. Running from the draft or not going could make all those around them ashamed of their actions, or embarrassed of associating with them. Even social obligation had an impact on the shame and guilt piled on the individual man. Many of the men in O’Brien’s stories had a pressure to fulfill their obligations as citizens and soldiers because it was their ‘duty.’ …show more content…

In “The Man I Killed,” O’Brien threw a grenade into the path of an unknown man. This obviously killed him. Although he did not know him, O’Brien attempts to bring that man back to life by creating a history and future for that man in detail. A story for the life of the man that he had ended so quickly. After watching his friends and fellow soldiers die one after another, the guilt causes him to see that the man he killed is a man just like himself, and everyone else. It forces O’Brien to truly see what he is doing. The life of the man being taken is similar to the death of Lavender. Both men died to the hands of an enemy soldier who will never know them. Where their lives were taken without knowing their past, or their future. He sees how he has taken countless lives without thought. This realization causes him to live with that very guilt that Jimmy Cross lives with - for the rest of his life, and for the rest of O’Brien’s. This is something he had not felt in the context of the war zone he was …show more content…

It had not been their plan or their goal. Yet there was no escape from it. O’Brien tried to run to Canada, yet his feelings of guilt brought him back. He came back not because he wanted to, but because he had to. If he had the choice, he never would have gone to Vietnam or be in the army. The same was true for most of the men around him. The hell that they were in blurred the concepts of right and wrong. Every man there had been sent to fight a war they had no qualm in. The grenade that O’Brien threw to kill the unknown man, killed a piece of himself

Show More
Related

  • Things They Carried By Tim O Brien: A Literary Analysis

    1292 Words  | 6 Pages

    In the short story, “The Man I Killed,” O’Brien focuses on this to show that everyone fighting in a war has a story. He spends the story describing the man he killed and searching for justification of his actions. He carries around guilt with him because of it, and his fellow soldiers try to help him justify and come to terms with his action by saying things like, “You want to trade places with him? Turn it all upside down= you want that? I mean, be honest,” (126) and “Tim, it’s a war.

    Read More

  • Spin By Tim O Brien Rhetorical Analysis

    791 Words  | 4 Pages

    O’Brien creates this backstory for this boy. How he grew up listening to stories of his ancestors protecting their land and that it was a tradition to die fighting for your own land. But O’Brien could see that this boy was weak and tiny and young. He could see that his face was smooth with no facial hair and fingers were thin. This brought so much more guilt onto him.

    Read More

  • A Marker On The Side Of The Boat Analysis

    813 Words  | 4 Pages

    O’Brien tells the readers about him reflecting back twenty years ago, he wonders if running away from the war were just events that happened in another dimension, he pictures himself writing a letter to his parents: “I’m finishing up a letter to my Parents that tells what I'm about to do and why I'm doing it and how sorry I am that I’d never found the courage to talk to them about it”(O’Brien 80). Even twenty years after his running from the war, O’Brien still feels sorry for not finding the courage to tell his parents about his decision of escaping to Canada to start a new life. O’Brien presented his outlook that even if someone was not directly involved in the war, this event had impacted them indirectly, for instance, how a person’s reaction to the war can create regret for important friends and

    Read More

  • Guilt Quotes In The Things They Carried

    423 Words  | 2 Pages

    1.Guilt is one of the worst things accompanied by death. Guilt plays a huge role throughout the novel. In war, men are constantly dying and these men all become best friends with one another. For example, Norman Bowker felt a tremendous amount of quilt towards the death of Kiowa.

    Read More

  • The Things They Carried: An Analysis

    688 Words  | 3 Pages

    War was so much more than just war to O’Brien and he able to share this through his writing. " But this is true: stories can save us. ... in a story, which is a kind of dreaming, the dead sometimes smile and sit up and return to the world." (page

    Read More

  • Fiction And Reality In Tim O Brien's The Things They Carried

    1413 Words  | 6 Pages

    Hidden somewhere within the blurred lines of fiction and reality, lies a great war story trapped in the mind of a veteran. On a day to day basis, most are not willing to murder someone, but in the Vietnam War, America’s youth population was forced to after being pulled in by the draft. Author Tim O’Brien expertly blends the lines between fiction, reality, and their effects on psychological viewpoints in the series of short stories embedded within his novel, The Things They Carried. He forces the reader to rethink the purpose of storytelling and breaks down not only what it means to be human, but how mortality and experience influence the way we see our world. In general, he attempts to question why we choose to tell the stories in the way

    Read More

  • Gore And Violence In The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien

    1161 Words  | 5 Pages

    Contrary to people thinking the United States should not interfere, too many young men were being drafted, and the war was pointless, O’Brien still pointed out that soldiers were still fighting in the war and facing the possibility of not knowing whether they would live to see another day. He described the gruesome memories that he any many other military figures were bringing back home. One scene describes his friend Norman Bowker after coming back home, driving around a lake eleven times thinking about his friend Kiowa drowning in a field of sewage which represents the ability to cut right to the heart of the matter; soldiers coming back from war in emotional hardships. Bowker goes on to write O’Brien only to hang himself a couple years later showing the impact the war had on soldiers and the lack of help they received after the war due to many people not accepting the war. His expresses his opinion by stating, “If you don’t care for obscenity, you don’t care for the truth; if you don’t care for the truth,

    Read More

  • The Things They Carried Internal Conflict Analysis

    845 Words  | 4 Pages

    This is evident when Mr. O’Brien says, “I would go to the war – I would kill and maybe die – because I was embarrassed not to,” (pg. 57.) In the end the author realized what he must do and went back home, so he could fight in the Vietnam

    Read More

  • Emotional Burdens In The Things They Carried

    2482 Words  | 10 Pages

    O’Brien reinforces this idea when he states, “There was no real peril … Even now I haven't finished sorting it out (O’Brien 95).”Because they all had the mindset to be courageous and brave at all times, O’Brien shows that he was at complete shock as he reacted instantly. In addition, Tim O’Brien suffers internally with his guilt when he claims that there was no actual danger, but because he threw the grenade ending that young man’s life, he now has to carry the guilt for the rest of his life. O’Brien makes it clear that the young man wasn’t a threat, but he still decided to end the man’s life who he predicts would have possibly have had a bright future ahead of him. Knowing the fact that the man was an innocent victim, the man exposes the

    Read More

  • Silent Scream In The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien

    1097 Words  | 5 Pages

    In the chapter “Ambush,” O’Brien especially digs into the psychology of a veteran. By addressing himself as a veteran, who was ambushed by his little daughter with the question, “Did you kill someone?” This might be the scariest question that any veteran could get asked. When we look at what happened in Vietnam, we know that O’Brien’s intention was not to kill, but it was just a classic soldier instinct. On the other hand, after O’Brien killed the slim young soldier, he was in complete regret.

    Read More

  • PTSD In Tim O Brien's The Things They Carried

    1504 Words  | 7 Pages

    This quote epitomizes the trauma caused by war. O’Brien is trying to cope, mostly through writing these war stories but has yet to put it behind him. He feels guilt, grief, and responsibility, even making up possible scenarios about the life of the man he killed and the type of person he was. This

    Read More

  • Moral Confusion In The Things They Carried

    645 Words  | 3 Pages

    (p. 126). Though he does not see him as the enemy, O’Brien reacts as he had been taught to in war; to forget most of your morals and shoot before you can be shot first, a fact Kiowa points out to him. “Later, I remember, Kiowa tried to tell me that the man would 've died anyway. He told me that it was a good kill, that I was a soldier and this was a war, that I should shape up and stop staring and ask myself what the dead man would ' ve done if things were reversed” (p. 127). Soldiers are expected to forget their morals and act as a soldier should.

    Read More

  • Thesis For The Things They Carried

    999 Words  | 4 Pages

    Over all, this story allows us to observe changes within the mentalities of army officers. First, the trauma of living in a war zone can add a significant amount of intangible weight into someone’s life. In “The Things They Carried,” we discover that Cross’s men “carried all the emotional baggage of men who might die (443).” Given that the majority of humans have experienced some form of trauma, we can understand how some men were driven to suicide and others into

    Read More

  • Doing The Right Thing In The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien

    465 Words  | 2 Pages

    Being a soldier was well respected in his conservative hometown, and not fighting would cause disgrace to fall upon his family. Despite his morals being against it, O’Brien decided to go war and fight, “I survived,” he explained, “but it’s not a happy ending. I was a coward. I went to the war” (O’Brien 79). Although O’Brien was against fighting in the war, he still fought because he was ashamed and afraid that he would be scorned if he did not.

    Read More

  • Ambiguity In The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien

    249 Words  | 1 Pages

    O’Brien confuses the text ,when he talks about “the man I killed” with an image of himself being the killer, but later in the chapter a mention telling the man to “run” but the grenade blows up before he could say run. The man dead did not affect him at the moment it

    Read More

More about The Man I Killed Critical Analysis

Open Document