The Myth Of American Exceptionalism Analysis
The Myth of American Exceptionalism
Godfrey Hodgson, author of “The Myth of American Exceptionalism,” critics the concept of American exceptionalism throughout the book. Hodgson’s states that his purpose is not to ‘’minimize American achievements or to demean the quality of American civilization.” (16) He says he admires the idea of a country ruled based on popular sovereignty, equal rights and the questioning of a government that was created for the people. However, he also criticizes the concept of American exceptionality through the notion that the United States’ superiority and “uniqueness” has been greatly exaggerated by misguided interpretations of American history, as well as to warn the audience, not only Americans, about the dangers of “self-praise” build around “unreal and hubristic assumptions.” (16)
Geoffrey Hodgson starts off by exposing several occasion where the idea of America’s superiority has been altered and often exaggerated by misguided interpretations of the past; for example, he remarks the interpretation of the Mayflower contract by the sixth president of the United states, John Quincy Adams, who said, “perhaps the only instance in human history of that positive, original social compact, which speculative philosophers have imagined as the only legitimate source of government.” (5) To debate the radical claim made by president Adams,
…show more content…
He mostly disagrees with the idea of American exceptionalism when it plays against his own believes. His critiques are mostly directed towards conservatives and neoconservative’s exceptionalism rather than liberals; “By 1990’s the background to the growing obsession with Iraq among neoconservatives was exceptionalist sentiment. Neither Saddam Hussein nor any other foreign leader must stand against the high historic mission of the United States to bring democracy to the Middle East.” (171) Hodgson constantly attacks George W. Bush’s presidency and conservative political
Pros And Cons Of The Articles Of Confederation
3023 Words | 13 PagesThe British monarchy’s control over the American territory had left a flavor of distrust for power in the palate of Americans. The British set the precedent for the American political system. After the colonial period, the colonies agreed that there was nothing to fear more than the government, or in this case the king. Britain over the years has held its unitary form of government, which in this case means that all governmental power resided within the hands of a single branch. In this type of system, the legislature has all the power to create and enforce legislation.
Dbq John Adams And The Federalists
1438 Words | 6 PagesTowards the end of the 17th century US relations with foreign nations such as France and GBR depleted to the cries of war. Luckily Mr. Adams considered the US’s condition financially and never asked congress to declare war, especially with France. Though during the election of 1800, Adams became no match for the Republican Party as the Federalists, represented by John Adams during the election, stabbed Adams in the back as Alexander Hamilton, a prominent High-Federalist always creating problems for Adams, cried to many southern voters of the Presidents inability to hold office. In fact, Hamilton composed a pamphlet “Letter Concerning the Public Conduct and Character of John Adams.”
Summary Of The Myth Of The Weak American State By William Novak
705 Words | 3 PagesWilliam Novak presents an argument on how the history of American government has been told upside-down for many years now. Novak depicts a mighty American state, capable of a great deal and responsible for some of the most important narratives in American history. However, there were many people, of whom had great interest in the founding fathers, were irritated by Novak’s argument. The main group of people being referred to here were people from the Tea Party political movement.
Similarities Between Westward Expansion And American Exceptionalism
999 Words | 4 PagesWestward Expansion and American Exceptionalism From the very first settlers in America, there has always been a keenness for land accumulation. In the 1800’s, America began an expansion. Whether it was for the salvation of the natives, Manifest Destiny or the hope for more opportunity, Americans developed a mindset that they had a unique role to pursue in spanning the new nation. Numerous documents of the time insisted Americans were superiors of the human race and had a special destiny designed by God in worldwide history.
Aroostook War Essay
1326 Words | 6 PagesCountless citizens in the 1840s and 1850s, feeling a sense of mission, believed that Almighty God had “manifestly’’ destined the American people for a hemispheric career. They would spread their uplifting and ennobling democratic institutions over at least the entire continent. Land greed and ideals—“empire’’ and “liberty’’—were thus conveniently conjoined. 14. What political party cost Henry Clay the popular vote in the state of New York, & what is ironic about Polk’s election in 1844 regarding this party’s position on Texas?
Recovering America's Exceptionalism Analysis
1071 Words | 5 PagesFamous French historian Alexis de Tocqueville once said, “America is great because she is good. If America ever ceases to be good, she will cease to be great.” (qtd. in Carson 651.) In “Recovering America’s Exceptionalism,” Ben Carson explains how we are losing touch with the values that once made America a great country.
Elements Of American Exceptionalism
956 Words | 4 PagesThe Elements of American Exceptionalism 1. The four elements of American Exceptionalism are its location, philosophy, and qualities of the American people and how the political system works. 2. Industriousness: the activity or manufacture. 3.
Gordon S Wood Creation Of The American Republic Sparknotes
1224 Words | 5 PagesWhy did we need a revolution? In a manner that is clear and very comprehensive, Gordon S. Wood explains this to us in his book, The Creation of the American Republic, 1776-1787. Furthermore, he goes into detail on how the thirteen colonies came together to create one of the most durable systems of government ever created, and how we got the political system we currently live under. According to a Brown University profile on Gordon S. Wood, where he is currently the Alva O. Way University Professor Emeritus, he has been the recipient of a Pulitzer Prize in History and has received numerous other accolades throughout his scholarly career, including 2011’s National Humanities Medal presented to him by President Barack Obama.
Why Is America Justified Dbq
706 Words | 3 PagesThroughout the annals of American history, the advocation for freedom, and the absorption of ideals such as life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness have been at the forefront of the American belief. These beliefs were implemented in 1776, through the Declaration of Independence. This document was ratified by recalcitrant Americans who would not tolerate subjection to tyrannical rule. The American people hoped this document would seal their fate in relation to Europe, and prove to Europe, and frankly the entire world, that they were a separate, sufficient nation. But as the years unfolded, the realization that America would continue to be considered an inferior nation arose.
Native American War
1321 Words | 6 PagesToday, the United States of America is analogous with the terms freedom, liberty and prosperity. Throughout its existence, the nation has come to represent a unique melting pot of ideals, races, and cultures, which have recurrently exhibited the perspectives of freedom and equality in regards to not only daily livelihood, but also free trade. Although the United States continues to stand as an immense representation of hope and prominence in reference to opportunity, it is almost impossible to ignore the dark aspects of its history. For a nation that was founded by the ideals of assuring freedom for those who arrived at its shores and ports, a majority of the early stages of American history were flooded with an immense amount of prejudice
Hertsgarrd The Oblivious Empire Analysis
1208 Words | 5 PagesIt seems to be easier for an American citizen to name quotes from movies or lyrics from popular songs than to explain the United States of America’s effect on the world. The Oblivious Empire written by Mart Hertsgarrd discusses how America’s society seems to not comprehend how our government treats other countries and seems too naïve on the reasons why other countries or groups of people do not like us. Hertsgarrd discusses how the United States truly treats countries around the world and the consequences our actions have caused. An analysis of Hertsgarrd essay shows strong points on how our society is oblivious to the world outside our country and do not truly know how our government affects the world. Throughout Hertsgarrd essay he describes how the United States government tends to believe they have the right to be the judge on how other countries’ treatment of their citizens and
Summary Of The Republic Of Nature By Mark Feiige
1475 Words | 6 PagesThe history of the United States of America is vast and complex, encompassing thousands of events that all helped form it into a modern day superpower. When reflecting on the history of America, many historians remind us of major events that changed the course of the country's development. Many authors of these works analyze American historical events through the perspective of the people living through that event or through a 21st-Century viewpoint. However, there are fewer authors who are able to successfully illustrate more about an event than what can be visibly seen or inferred by a reader. Mark Feige, a history professor and writer, is one of the few authors who is able to uncover additional information in American history.
Henry David Thoreau's Civil Disobedience
1371 Words | 6 PagesIndividuals lay the foundation of America. The Founding Fathers of this unique nation broke their allegiance with Great Britain to create an improved governing body. They desired an individual-centered authority as opposed to Britain’s monarchy, which ruled with tyranny. These Founding Fathers experienced a neglectful democratic monarchy that cared little about the ethical treatment of its people. The domineering actions of Britain challenged these historic individuals to form a new cultural identity.
American Exceptionalism Tocqueville Summary
1362 Words | 6 PagesAmerican Exceptionalism was coined by Alexis de Tocqueville in his book Democracy in America. To illustrate how the American way of thought is superior to the other ways of the world, Tocqueville expresses that the American way of thought is distinctively unique and special. This distinction is exemplified through liberty, egalitarianism, individualism, populism, and Laissez-Faire Economics. These qualities prove America’s exceptionality and difference from other countries. Although American Exceptionalism originated in the early 1800s, the idyllic values Tocqueville paints in his book can be seen throughout American history.
Anna Quindlen's A Quilt Of A Country
492 Words | 2 PagesThe author of the short story “A Quilt of a Country,” Anna Quindlen, used many effective tactics and arguments to demonstrate her opinion that “America is united, despite all of the diversities and tragedies that she has faced and had to overcome.” Anna Quindlen demonstrated in examples and analogies her argument and used them to her advantage in her persuasion and and effective points. Anna Quindlen also proves in the point that America is different from any other country. In contrast, Anna Quindlen does use the counter strategy not to defame her original arguments, but instead to help to better her ideals and points. For example, the first main example and point used to explain her argument that America is diverse, is the quote by the historian Daniel Boorstin, which reads “[O]f all the nations in the world, the United States was built in nobody’s image.”
More about The Myth Of American Exceptionalism Analysis
Pros And Cons Of The Articles Of Confederation
3023 Words | 13 PagesDbq John Adams And The Federalists
1438 Words | 6 PagesSummary Of The Myth Of The Weak American State By William Novak
705 Words | 3 PagesSimilarities Between Westward Expansion And American Exceptionalism
999 Words | 4 PagesAroostook War Essay
1326 Words | 6 PagesRecovering America's Exceptionalism Analysis
1071 Words | 5 PagesElements Of American Exceptionalism
956 Words | 4 PagesGordon S Wood Creation Of The American Republic Sparknotes
1224 Words | 5 PagesWhy Is America Justified Dbq
706 Words | 3 PagesNative American War
1321 Words | 6 PagesHertsgarrd The Oblivious Empire Analysis
1208 Words | 5 PagesSummary Of The Republic Of Nature By Mark Feiige
1475 Words | 6 PagesHenry David Thoreau's Civil Disobedience
1371 Words | 6 PagesAmerican Exceptionalism Tocqueville Summary
1362 Words | 6 PagesAnna Quindlen's A Quilt Of A Country
492 Words | 2 Pages