ipl-logo

The Myths We Live By Mary Midgley Analysis

556 Words3 Pages

Critique of Midgley Although I agree with Mary Midgley’s holistic argument that knowledge has many sources and can be viewed from multiple perspectives, I argue against her flawed, overriding assumption that knowledge is reality that can be discovered. In an excerpt from her book The Myths We Live By, Midgley portrays the world as an aquarium with “a number of small windows” to suggest that ultimately, knowledge can be acquired “if we patiently put together the data from different angles” (Midgley 40). In addition, she points out the dogmatic ignorance that comes with “[insisting] that our own window is the only one worth looking through” (Midgley 40). By making this analogy, Midgley emphasizes the concept of scientific pluralism, which recognizes multiple sources of knowledge. Her argument is sound regarding the different roots and lens through which knowledge can be explored, but I find the representation of the complex world/reality in its entirety as observed knowledge still very questionable. Following her problematic implication that knowledge is reality, everything that does not readily exist, at least not yet, cannot be considered knowledge. In other words, everything unknown to humans is not knowledge. However, since certain material is unknown, shouldn’t people be more compelled to not …show more content…

From the DNA example, it can be safe to assume that reality today will continue to evolve and expand. Because of this, perceptions of what is unknown will also continue to change over time. Research brings about so many new questions and insights that have people regularly questioning how much of what is known knowledge. Even though a lot is still not certain right now, what is certain is that people are making gradual, but steady progress toward true

Show More
Related

  • Sor Filotea De La Cruz Analysis

    990 Words  | 4 Pages

    There is no way to know everything there is to know. This means that knowledge will always be inherently limited by numerous different factors. According to DesCartes, knowing can only be applied to what one has clearly observed to be true (111). Observable knowledge can be limited by things such as background and sex. However, the greatest limitation may be lack of skepticism, whether it be questioning oneself or an authority.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Blink By Malcolm Gladwell

    1611 Words  | 7 Pages

    Today's world is primarily based on facts. People believe that anything that has higher factual and scientific data has more legitimacy than the data with limited information. The legitimacy of any claims is totally based on the extent of information related to the field. However, that may not always be the case, and sometimes higher level of information related to any subject may cause the person to be confused and makes it harder for them to take any decision. In Blink, author Malcolm Gladwell brings the same concept in his book.

    Read More

  • The Invisible Woman Analysis

    1362 Words  | 6 Pages

    Stacy Davis, self-proclaimed activist for feminism and womanism, is a “scholar trained in feminist theory and African American biblical hermeneutics” (Davis 23). In her article, The Invisible Woman: Numbers 30 and the Policies of Singleness in Africana Communities, Davis argues for a prominent place for single woman (specifically those who have never married) in biblical scholarship, and as leaders in the church, with questions of their sexuality left alone. Davis argues this viewpoint from the perspective as an unmarried black woman. Davis establishes the foundation for her argument in Numbers 30, a text that altogether omits reference to single woman, rather each group of women mentioned in the text about vows refers to them in relation to men (21). Thus, Davis establishes the omission of single women in the Hebrew Bible as the invisible women.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Engaging In Scientific Conversation By Fontenelle

    1398 Words  | 6 Pages

    Engaging in Scientific Conversations This Essay is a close reading of the passage number 3 in Bernard le Bovier de Fontenelle’s Conversations on the pluralities of worlds. After reading the passage selected in-depth, I believe it was Fontenelle’s goal to demonstrate that anyone can be an active participant in scientific discussions. This was shown through his use of respect and reciprocity of ideologies between the Marquise and the Philosopher, the encouragement of both parties to engage in conversations and the attention to detail to ensure all of the ideas are understood. Fontenelle uses the mechanics of language of dialogue through the Marquise and the Philosopher as an example of how scientific conversations should be held between men

    Read More

  • Technology In Fahrenheit 451 By Ray Bradbury

    543 Words  | 3 Pages

    “ But our way is simpler and, we think, better. All we want to do is keep the knowledge we think we will need, intact and safe. We're not out to incite or anger anyone yet. For if we are destroyed, the knowledge is dead, perhaps for good.” (Bradbury 145)

    Read More

  • Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Dwight Macdonald

    1425 Words  | 6 Pages

    Knowledge is power. But can knowing too much information damage you? In “Reading and Thought”, an essay written by Dwight Macdonald, argues how individuals are too focused on obtaining knowledge that isn’t useful to them. Macdonald insists that people are too “well informed” (Macdonald 548) and such a trait impairs an individual’s ability to logically think.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Our Story Begins By Tobias Wolff

    2229 Words  | 9 Pages

    In Tobias Wolff’s Our Story Begins: New and Selected Stories, lies a gem in the rough called “Soldier’s Joy,” which is a short story about a Vietnam War veteran named Hooper who is adapting to life on the base post-war. Hooper is trying to get his life together little by little, but nothing is going back together the way it should in his mind. This was a problem for a lot of Vietnam War veterans post-war because of all the things they saw firsthand and they had no idea how to handle the things they saw on their own. They had no idea how to handle all of the destruction, chaos, and death they saw, so most of them took to their own ways of coping with everything they saw or even did during the war.

    Read More

  • Doubt: A Parable By John Patrick Shanley

    406 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the play Doubt: A Parable, by John Patrick Shanley, Sister Aloysius is a representation of traditionalists as she constantly resists change and progression. Her traditionalist values are highlighted in her scene two conversation with Sister James. She says, “I’m sorry I allowed even cartridge pens into the school. The students really should only be learning script with true fountain pens. Always the easy way out these days” (9).

    Read More

  • Jane Harrison Rainbows End Essay

    1102 Words  | 5 Pages

    Discoveries can be fresh, meaningful and extremely influential in the emotional, intellectual, physical and spiritual realms. This compels individuals to introspect, whilst formulate anew their perceptions and values towards the world, leading to an altering of individuals understandings on themselves and others. Discoveries can be influenced by one’s personal, cultural and historical context, leading to a challenging of previously formulated perspectives. Additionally, the experience of a discovery, whether it be positive or negative, can be intensely meaningful and paramount for an individual. Furthermore, discoveries can be triggered by the uncovering of fresh and unique information that challenges one’s predilections.

    Read More

  • Writing For The Morning By Edward Thomas Analysis

    371 Words  | 2 Pages

    It is three in the morning and he is working on an essay that he has been writing for the past four days now. Thomas feels his paper is not good because he compared to one of his buddies and his friends was a lot better and claimed Thomas “wrote weird.” He threw away his paper but then realized he could just revise it and make the perfect essay. He began to make notes on the paper to then be able to rewrite and create a better essay. His main fault is that he speaks and writes like an old person, using long rambling sentences that are boring.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Charles Mills's Article 'White Ignorance'

    906 Words  | 4 Pages

    Not asking and refusing to know would create a level of trust where the unknown is voluntarily

    Read More

  • Benefits Of Facing The Unknown By Gov Lindbergh

    1052 Words  | 5 Pages

    Facing the unknown is risky because it produces an outcome that is or is not expected, which is why many people in the modern world tend to avoid it. In contrast, author Anne Morrow Lindbergh supports the idea of exploring the unknown, stating that “its disappointments and surprises that are the most enriching.” Exploring the unknown is seeing and taking on ideas or topics that is not understandable, and finding something new from it. She believes that the unknown will be the only way people can improve and advance as a society, and she is correct. By exploring the unknown and discovering new ideas that has not yet been addressed in the past, society can improve, develop, and obtain major revelation in studies that can profoundly change lives,

    Read More

  • Tom Regan Animal Rights Summary

    1543 Words  | 7 Pages

    Opposing this claim, humans strive to search for new knowledge. It is in our nature to diligently try to discover new things, new ideas and new solutions to our problems. Only when rights are violated is when we should give up on what we are searching for if an alternative is not

    Read More

  • Truth By Gwendolyn Brooks Analysis

    486 Words  | 2 Pages

    The poem Truth, by Gwendolyn Brooks, has a lot of symbolism in it. Different things throughout the poem both represent parts of the Civil Rights movement as well as things that we can relate to our lives today. She did really well with her literary elements used, especially personification. This makes her writing more relatable and realistic in our minds to grasp. Truth is a wonderful poem full of all sorts of different literary elements.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Epistemology

    1389 Words  | 6 Pages

    Every research project provides a link between a paradigm, epistemology, theoretical perspective, and research practice. A paradigm is identified in any school of thought – the integrated worldviews held by researchers and people in general that determine how these individuals perceive and attempt to comprehend truth (Fitzpatrick, Sanders, & Worthen, 2003). Furthermore, a paradigm includes an epistemological belief as well as an ontological belief that, when combined together, govern perceptions and choices made in the pursuit of scientific truth. In practice, individuals’ epistemological beliefs determine how they think knowledge or truth can be comprehended, what problems – if any – are associated with various views of pursuing and presenting knowledge and what role researchers play in its discovery (Robson, 2002). Different epistemologies offer different views of researchers’ relationships with their object of inquiry.

    Read More

More about The Myths We Live By Mary Midgley Analysis

Open Document