The Not-So-Model Minority Myth Essay

Sophia Le

Professor Bohn

English 102

3 March 2023

The Not-So-Model Model Minority: The Harmful Truth Behind the Asian Stereotype

I. Introduction

For decades, the model minority myth has been perpetuated in the media, portraying Asian Americans as a successful and high-achieving group that has overcome discrimination and achieved the "American Dream." However, this stereotype not only erases the diverse experiences of Asian Americans but also perpetuates harmful myths that harm their mental health and well-being. Film students have the power to change this harmful narrative by challenging these stereotypes in their work and amplifying the voices of Asian American creatives who have been historically excluded and stereotyped within the film

Harmful Consequences of the Model Minority Myth

The model minority myth has many harmful consequences for Asian Americans. One of the most significant consequences is the erasure of the challenges and struggles that many Asian Americans face. The myth suggests that Asians are successful solely based on their hard work and intelligence and that they do not face the same struggles as other racial minority groups. This erases the experiences of Asian Americans who face racism and discrimination and can make it harder for them to speak out against these issues.

The Asian Model Minority Myth portrays Asian Americans as highly successful, intelligent, and self-sufficient, which erases the experiences of those who face racism, discrimination, and socioeconomic challenges. For example, many Southeast Asian Americans, including Cambodians, Hmong, and Laotians, experience poverty rates that are higher than the national average, and have been historically excluded from the benefits of the "Model Minority" status (ARCC, "The 'Model Minority' Myth About Asian Americans"). The myth can also create a culture of silence and shame for those who do not fit into the perceived "successful" stereotype and can make it harder for Asian Americans to speak out against the discrimination and racism they face. By presenting Asian Americans as successful and high-achieving, the model minority myth hides the experiences of those who have faced discrimination, poverty, or other barriers. This erasure

A study conducted by the National Council of Asian-Pacific Americans found that the model minority stereotype perpetuates the idea of Asian Americans as "perpetual foreigners" and contributes to their exclusion from mainstream American society (Zhou et al., 2008). The study found that "the model minority myth also reinforces the perception that Asian Americans are not real Americans and do not belong in mainstream American society" (Zhou et al., 2008). This perception can lead to discrimination and prejudice against Asian Americans, as well as a lack of representation and inclusion in American politics and culture. This perception has real-world consequences, as it can lead to discrimination, exclusion, and even violence against Asian