Tiananmen Square Movement Analysis
Keetae Kim
Professor Larson
East Asian Studies
14 April 2015
The Parallelism between the Revolution of 1911 and the Protest of 1989 China had experienced waves of instability from the numerous events from the 20th century. Countless revolutions and protests have forged China into what it is today. The 1911 revolution, also known as the Xinhai revolution, was one of the major revolutions in 20th century China that acted as a stopping force that cut the Qing dynasty short of its path. The Tiananmen Square protest in 1989 also remains as a landmark rebellion in China that steered china into its democratic reform. The Xinhai revolution and the Tiananmen Square protest were both events that took place in order to counteract the current form of
…show more content…
The 1911 revolution was initiated by an accidental bomb explosion in the Hubei province that sparked suspiciousness from the government to the soldiers. The soldiers became increasingly rebellious as the government started to invade and inspect into their actions. Meanwhile, the government made a big mistake in deciding to change two private railways into the nations property. However, the people of the Sichuan province were not going to give the railways away without a fight because many people had invested their fortunes into the railways. This angered the government and decided to take action against the civilians by arresting and killing numerous people which created a total bloodbath. Similarly, the government took action against the Tiananmen Square revolution of 1989 by using tanks and guns to open fire on those who got in their way. Hundreds of people were killed and the amount of wounded people were in the thousands. Many people still stood strong against the military such as Tank Man who blocked a whole line of tanks by himself. These continuous acts of military brutality were violent and unnecessary and only contribute to enraging the civilians to heightened …show more content…
The protest did not replace the form of government but instead left only the dead bodies of many that tried to over throw the government. The United States showed their depreciation of China by cutting off military sales and implementing economic sanctions. On the other hand, the 1911 Xinhai revolution brought great success after Sun Yat Sen and many other influential people such as Yuan Shikai led the protesters of China to overthrow the Qing dynasty and brought an end to Puyi’s time in his throne. This gave hope and dreams to many people and was a bench mark for the civilians of
Similarities Between Revolutionary And American Revolutionary War
1291 Words | 6 PagesPolitically, although the Americans wanted independence politically, they did not want a country ruled by white men, but a country led by themselves. Therefore, although they advocated the use of violence to liberate the people, they did not advocate the establishment of a bourgeois democratic republic but hoped to realize the freedom, equality, and democracy of the country through the people's democratic dictatorship. The revolution of 1911 was led by the feudal monarchy. Therefore, although the revolution was a success, it was impossible to lead the whole Chinese revolution to victory because of the limitations and reactionary nature of the leading class at that
Dbq Essay On The Communist Party
959 Words | 4 PagesWilliam Hinton, a born member of the Chinese communist reform force, states how peasants were challenging landlords and money lenders, and how “This increasingly explosive force transferred land from the landowners to the peasants”, as shown in Document 6. After the communist party advocated anti-Japanese sentiment, the peasants subsequently found the confidence to challenge landowners with the knowledge that the Japanese had been successfully defeated in part to the power the peasants held, and in part by communist motivation. This led to the breaking down of Chinese land owning infrastructure as peasants revolted. Hinton’s account of the events is very descriptive and as detailed as someone who lived in China during the time of the peasant revolts. Yet, as an American, he was not part of the peasant class and thus would not have been part of the revolts.
Chinese Civil War Dbq
768 Words | 4 PagesThe revolution in 1911 known as the Double Tenth overthrew the Manchu dynasty, and the new Republic produced from that Revolution did not succeed in taking hold of China. China continued to be abused by foreign powers. These foreign powers forced China to agree upon unequal treaties and the reason they did was because they noticed the corruption, inflation, and financial chaos from high ranking powers. They lacked a strong central government. The Chinese Civil War was fought between two opposing forces – the communists and the nationalists – to see who would reassemble order and regain control over China.
Compare And Contrast The Tang And Song Dynasty
296 Words | 2 PagesAs China grew with population and technologies, so did their government. Their military was weak but they had the idea to make iron and steel weaponry. The increase of weapons allowed the Chinese military to have more power over the people. Yet, the downfall of their era was their tactics in controlling their army and the rebellious citizens. As China’s economy and population grows, so does the growth of politics and Urban life styles.
Haiti And China's Nationalist Movement Essay
582 Words | 3 PagesAfter China lost the Opium War against England, a sense of discontent swept the nation and rebellions broke out. These nationalist movements wanted the government removed in place of a new one. The largest one was the Taiping Rebellion, which encompassed almost all of China and caused 20-30 million deaths. In the end, the Chinese Qing government won, with the aid of the British and the French. The Self-Strengthening Movement was then put in place by the Qing government, to try and help with the sense of shame after losing more territory.
Compare And Contrast French Haitian And American Revolution
708 Words | 3 PagesThe French, Haitian, and American Revolutions were all sparked from the minds of the colonists, slaves, or lower classes who were treated with inequality by their own governments. In each location, there was a noticeable trend of mistreatment between government and people. In Haiti, slaves brought over by the French who captured the island, and forced them into brutal labor in what was the most valuable and wealthy are at the time. The government and leadership in France was corrupt as they were in much debt. King Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette lived in Versailles far from the other forms of government, abusing the country wealth.
Differences Between Mao And Deng Dbq
586 Words | 3 PagesGrace Fair April 20th, 2023 Mr. Selitto World History China DBQ Mao and Deng both transformed China in similar and different ways. Mao tended to be harsher, wanting everyone to conform to his idea of the cultural revolution of China. While Deng wanted people to have more capitalistic ideas, allowing people to run things themselves without harsh control from the government. This DBQ will discuss how China ran under the similar and different political, diplomatic, and economic rules of Mao and Deng.
Key Causes Of The Serbian Revolution
1061 Words | 5 PagesThe Serbian Revolution lasted for 13 years during 1804 to the year 1835. The revolution was both a national and social revolution which resulted in Serbia 's departure from the Ottoman empire as well as the forming of its own constitutional monarchy. The revolution was inspired by the French revolution. A cause of the revolution was the rise of poetry and literature which inspired a renaissance. Throughout the Ottoman empires reign, works or literature was composed and passed through which focused on the glorious history of Serbia before the Ottoman rule.
The Cultural Revolution Of China's Healthcare System
868 Words | 4 PagesThis eventually led to the decision of Chinese leaders to implement anther reform to eliminate the instability and return a comprehensive healthcare system to the people of China, leading to it’s healthcare system today (Blumenthal,
Tiananmen Square By George Orwell Analysis
551 Words | 3 PagesIn this essay “No one died in Tiananmen Square” by William Lutz, it is evident that the events displayed confirm the warnings that Orwell shared in Nineteen Eighty – Four. This essay resembled the novel by George Orwell in many different ways, both exploit the government to manipulate the mind of an individual over the actual reality and both governments overuse and abuse there powers. In “No one died in Tiananmen Square” the government uses violence to stop the peaceful protesters. This is similar to 1984 because the totalitarian government in Oceania uses violence if they do not obey the rules of Big Brother. A quote from 1984, from part 2 of chapter 10 displaying violence for commenting thought crime is “One of the men had smashed his fist into Julia’s solar
Tiananmen Square
1117 Words | 5 PagesTiananmen Square is a city located in Beijing, named after the Tiananmen located to its north, separating it from the Forbidden City. In 1989, there was a “massacre” of mostly college students from the government, due to protests attempting to overrun the one-party system and make it a democracy. The government claims nothing happened and wants to keep it like that. The book “1984” written by George Orwell in 1949, is a book representing the ideas of a totalitarian government coincidentally relating to some of WWII era’s axis governments. In the article “No One Died in Tiananmen Square” by William Lutz, Lutz argues that people actually died in Tiananmen Square through the use of repetition, through examples of government manipulation, and communist governments, much like how it is seen in “1984”
Differences Between The Roman Empire And The Han Dynasty
1525 Words | 7 PagesThe Han Dynasty in China and the Roman Empire shared many similarities and differences when it came to political rule and the nature of their political authority. The most significant difference between the two is how the Han dynasty enacted policies that were shaped to counter the wrongdoings of the previous Qin dynasty, whereas the Roman Empire enacted policies shaped to create and promote peace and stability. The difference in the two empire’s coming to power was to account for their variance in political rule. After the Qin dynasty, the Han ruled China for four centuries, enacting numerous political changes and governing one of the most efficacious dynasties in Chinese history.
Mexican Revolution Propaganda
1019 Words | 5 PagesBoth revolutions had an immediate change in government. In the end, feudal-style society ended and the power of nobles decreased. There were other similarities, but these were a few that stood out between these two famous
Examples Of Satire In The Handmaid's Tale
1472 Words | 6 PagesAtwood parallels the Cultural Revolution in China to the how the Gilead government gains power and control over the United States. The Chinese communist leader, Mao Zedong launched the Cultural Revolution to assert his control over the Chinese government. Zedong ordered the nation to cleanse themselves of “impure” aspects of Chinese society. This was done by shutting down schools and a massive youth mobilization. The students formed groups called the Red Guards, they attacked and harassed members of China’s elderly and
Mao Zedong Impact
1319 Words | 6 PagesSecondly, the Cultural Revolution and the chaos and disaster this had on the Chinese population, especially through the “Down to the Countryside movement” and finally, the Cult of Mao and what the idolisation and glorification of Mao meant for the future of China. Mao’s introduction of the Great Leap Forward policy and the impacts and effects this had on the Chinese population as well as its role in the introduction of the Cultural Revolution played a key role in shaping China into what it is today. The plan’s failure lead to Mao’s loss of power, which resulted in Mao introducing the Cultural Revolution in China. Unfortunately, Mao’s five-year plan was a disaster, and caused the death of an estimated twenty to forty
More about Tiananmen Square Movement Analysis
Similarities Between Revolutionary And American Revolutionary War
1291 Words | 6 PagesDbq Essay On The Communist Party
959 Words | 4 PagesChinese Civil War Dbq
768 Words | 4 PagesCompare And Contrast The Tang And Song Dynasty
296 Words | 2 PagesHaiti And China's Nationalist Movement Essay
582 Words | 3 PagesCompare And Contrast French Haitian And American Revolution
708 Words | 3 PagesDifferences Between Mao And Deng Dbq
586 Words | 3 PagesKey Causes Of The Serbian Revolution
1061 Words | 5 PagesThe Cultural Revolution Of China's Healthcare System
868 Words | 4 PagesTiananmen Square By George Orwell Analysis
551 Words | 3 PagesTiananmen Square
1117 Words | 5 PagesDifferences Between The Roman Empire And The Han Dynasty
1525 Words | 7 PagesMexican Revolution Propaganda
1019 Words | 5 PagesExamples Of Satire In The Handmaid's Tale
1472 Words | 6 PagesMao Zedong Impact
1319 Words | 6 Pages