ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of California Sanctuary State Law

900 Words4 Pages

Understanding various sides to California’s Sanctuary State Law (Wendi)
California Sanctuary State Law
The California Sanctuary State Law has complicated the concept of sanctuary cities in California. This law limits cooperation between local officials and federal immigration enforcement, especially in deporting undocumented immigrants who face no criminal charges. Measures range from treating schools, courthouses and hospitals as “safe zones” to restricting the ability of local police to detain people on behalf of federal immigration. The law does nothing to curtail the ability of federal agents to come into the state and deport people or carry out raids, but it does make such actions more difficult for agencies with limited resources (Steinmetz, …show more content…

For Oakland, it is about trust and citizenship. Oakland’s Mayor Libby Schaaf informed her constituents of ICE raids in the Bay Area before they happened. She believed the threat was imminent and therefore was an obligation to give fair warning. Undocumented immigrants may be more likely to report crimes or otherwise cooperate with the police if they do not fear deportation. For others it’s about protecting the rights of immigrants in the state. Immigrants contribute to both the economy and culture of California. They find the actions of ICE verge on unconstitutional and may violate provisions in the Bill of Rights. Others point to the positive impact immigrants have on the state. Immigrants typically fill much-needed jobs in California, particularly in agriculture. Without access to an immigrant workforce, many California farmers would have trouble harvesting their crops. The people believe that California can best determine who is a threat to the state and who is …show more content…

While citizens of Fresno may identify with the needs of immigrants, the city of Fresno needs money. Fresno is in conflict with the sanctuary state law because now they become a target for federal retaliation. President Trump has threatened to limit federal grants, particularly in areas of law and order (Kopan, 2018). For example, in 2016 California was awarded $30.5 million from the Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance grant program, which is administered by the Department of Justice. The Justice Department has used this fund to try to pressure sanctuary cities into cooperating. On the other hand, because Fresno is poor, cooperating with ICE potentially puts a strain on their budget and resources. From their perspective, if the federal government wants more active immigration enforcement, they should hire more ICE agents and conduct their own immigration status checks (Hess,

Show More
Related

  • Racial Fault Lines Analysis

    1871 Words  | 8 Pages

    In order to protect the white working class, racial laws were created and directly targeted towards Chinese immigrants to protect their whiteness. Chapter seven explains the new threat of the arrival of Japanese immigrants in California. During the beginning of the anti-Chinese sentiment and white working-class racism, Japanese immigrants were also under the romanticized belief of

    Read More

  • How California Became Unforgivable Summary

    709 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the article, “How California Became Unforgivable” by Jerry Roberts and Phil Trounstine, they basically describe six key factors that made California impossible to govern. They claim that California wields a "power with the damaged machinery of a patchwork government system that lacks accountability, encourages stalemate and drifts but cannot be steered." Basically, elected representatives in California have no authority, yet still hold responsibility. The six factors mentioned earlier include Proposition 13, budget initiatives, gerrymandering, term limits, boom or bust taxation, and the two-thirds vote. But how do these factors make California impossible to govern?

    Read More

  • Sanctuary Cities Case Study

    242 Words  | 1 Pages

    Thank you for contacting me about Sanctuary Cities. I appreciate knowing your thoughts on this issue. The concept of sanctuary cities received widespread public attention when Juan Francisco Lopez-Sanchez, an undocumented immigrant and repeat drug offender, murdered Kathryn Steinle in San Francisco. Currently, an estimated 340 cities across the country permit illegal immigrants to stay in the United States without the possibility of being arrested or deported back to their home country.

    Read More

  • Why Central Valleyrooms Should Read Esperanza Rising

    1544 Words  | 7 Pages

    A migrant worker is a person working outside of their home county. Some move from different places doing seasonal work while others remain in one place. Most migrant workers find jobs in the agriculture related industry. The Central Valley in California is home to many migrant families. “Unemployment rates remain high in much of the valley despite strong job growth because of the cyclical nature of employment in one of the valley’s key industries (agriculture)”

    Read More

  • Summary Of Migra ! A History Of The US Border Patrol

    1267 Words  | 6 Pages

    Huntington’s article is an example of how the inequity and racisms in the history of the border that Hernandez discussed has been carried out and resulted in immigrant bashing and ethnic prejudice being mainstreamed. Huntington’s article is composed of six factors of concern: contiguity, scale, illegality, regional concentration, persistence, and historical presence. When looked at carefully and analyzed, Huntington’s article is nothing more than hate disguised as academic media. Huntington refers to and talks about these immigrants as the main “suspects” of illegal immigration and the cause of many issues in the U.S. Huntington holds a Anglo perspective on the issue of immigration, the same perspective and ideas that the border patrol officers of the past had, explained by Hernandez in her book. Huntington states, “ Anglo protestant values built the American dream” (Huntington).

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Sanctuary Cities

    609 Words  | 3 Pages

    Let me start off by explaining what a sanctuary city is. A sanctuary city is a jurisdiction who has limited their cooperation with their national government’s effort to enforce immigration laws. In the United States, many cities nationwide have transformed into sanctuary cities. Many of these cities have become sanctuary cities to gain the trust of their people and to protect them. According to many reports nationwide, there have been several crimes that have taken place involving undocumented immigrants that were

    Read More

  • Race Nation And Culture By George Sanchez Sparknotes

    873 Words  | 4 Pages

    In their work, both George J. Sanchez and Kelly Lytle Hernandez discuss race as well as the black-white paradigm in which Latinos do not have a solid place. In Race, Nation, and Culture in Recent Immigration Studies, Sanchez argues that the future of immigration history depends on the field’s ability to incorporate insights of race, nation, and culture that develop. Meanwhile, in Migra!: A History of the U.S. Border Patrol, Lytle Hernandez discusses how the border is controlled, race, and the racialization of migration control. They both cite past immigration laws in their work and discuss the experiences of whites, blacks, and Mexicans in the United States.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Sanctuary Cities

    1080 Words  | 5 Pages

    Sanctuary cities, which can be found as certain cities and states in the United States, are places where the local government has agreed to work with low-priority illegal immigrants to shield them from the federal immigration laws. To some Americans, sanctuary cities may seem as if they are doing nothing but good deeds, and vice versa. However, there are many other factors at work that help a person decide whether or not they support the concept of sanctuary cities. For example, republicans, (who have a more conservative point of view) tend to disagree with the idea of sanctuary cities, arguing that the illegal immigrants coming into the United States should not receive support from the nation, and that Americans should not have to pay taxes

    Read More

  • Peace Corps Accomplishments

    484 Words  | 2 Pages

    My father immigrated from Guatemala when he was 19 to support his family back home. My mother, from El Salvador while fleeing the revolutionary war. They have worked hard, exceptionally hard, for me not to pursuit my dreams of joining the Peace Corps. This is a I considered filling out an application to join the Peace Corps straight after college but glad I waited. I have gained experience, but more importantly, I have matured mentally and emotionally and I am capable of understanding what it would require of me to leave my family, home, and career for two years and I am ready.

    Read More

  • Latinos: Racial Profiling And Border Patrol

    87 Words  | 1 Pages

    The amount of Latinos in federal prison is constantly increasing. Other forms of social control used against Mexicans and other Latinos are often racial profiling and Border Patrol as a technique to control their population in the U.S. "The perceived or actual immigrant status of many Mexicans and other Latinos also means that they are subject to forces of border control, while the growing population of Latinos is threatening to some Anglo-Americans who fear competition for jobs and the decreasing primacy of Anglo-American culture"(Bosworth and Flavin

    Read More

  • Crimes Against Latinos

    74 Words  | 1 Pages

    “In recent months, police chiefs in Los Angeles and Houston have said that reports by Latinos of certain types of crime are down in their respective cities. Both chiefs blamed the declines on heightened fear of deportation among undocumented immigrants, a majority of whom are Latino. They say the trend is concerning because police departments rely on members of the community — regardless of their legal status — to report crimes when they occur.”

    Read More

  • The California Dream

    1121 Words  | 5 Pages

    California is the “beauty of the eye of the beholder” since all people who come from different background, race, and religion are able to set their own dreams without being criticized. People especially immigrants have viewed California as the “land of opportunity,” which influenced them to leave everything behind in their hometown, to sacrifice their time and to focus on their dreams. Despite the fact that California was lauded as a utopian society, people soon found out that they were going through endeavors and couldn’t overcome them quickly as possible. In fact, Mr. Rawls wanted to express the grievances, struggles, and success that people endure in their rise to the California dream in his short essay, “California: A Place, A People,

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Illegal Immigration

    1938 Words  | 8 Pages

    There are a lot of controversial issues surrounding this country. Whitin all those controversial issues there 's the “issue” of illegal immigration. I 'm sure we 're all familiar with the term “illegal immigration”. We’re always told about how bad it is. Don 't get me wrong, it is bad but it 's not done with the intention of hurting someone else but to try and change their future.

    Read More

  • Immigration To California Essay

    1565 Words  | 7 Pages

    America has come such a long way to be known as the Melting Pot. The reason behind this is that America is extremely diverse and has many different people. Many of immigrants, both legal and illegal, from around the world, are migrating to here, in California. For some, this is an advantage. Economically, this means there are more consumers- more people to take advantage of the opportunities and resources that this state has to offer.

    Read More

  • Undocumented Immigration Essay

    1078 Words  | 5 Pages

    Throughout the history of the United States, immigration has and continues to be an issue that is present today. Undocumented immigrants face many hardships living in our country with limited access to attain a lifestyle as any other American. These limitations affect undocumented immigrants in their daily lives and they face downward social mobility. In the workplace along with anywhere else, immigrants face fear of deportation and exploitation due to their ‘illegal’ immigration status, therefore they remain living in the shadows and in extreme distress. If opportunities such as a work permit was granted to immigrants, their chances of succeeding in the labor market would be rewarding.

    Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of California Sanctuary State Law

Open Document