ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Head Transplant Surgery

445 Words2 Pages

Recently, I have been following the “head transplant surgery” proposed by a neurosurgeon, Dr. Canavero. He plans to severe the head of a quadriplegic and transplant it onto the body of a brain-dead person. If the operation is successful, the patient will gain full motility in a year. When I first learned about Dr. Canavero’s plan, I quickly dismissed it as an impossible feat since the spinal cord was never successfully reconnected in a test animal, let alone in a human. However, Dr. Canavero recently took me by surprise by managing to severe and reattach a mouse’s spine; in merely a month, the mouse gained partial motor functioning. Dr. Canavero will perform the surgery at the end of the year. He predicts a success rate of a lofty 90%.
I was as excited by his confidence as I was skeptical. A successful testing on an animal does not always translate into …show more content…

Although we do not know whether this is even plausible, the notion of immortality does not seem so far-fetched anymore. However, before I delved into the complex science of this crazy idea, I considered how it would potentially affect the society. Of course, such a surgery would be extremely costly, and so, only rich people will be able to afford it. The poor will have to face their inevitable death. Such a society will be unfair, unstable, and utterly bizarre. An image of a 80 year-old-man with a 20 year-old body is disturbing to say the least. Regardless of these “side-effects”, should the surgery be allowed to extend people’s lives?
We always try to make advancements in technology, but before we do so, we must always consider the ethics and the consequences they would bring. I believe this seminar will be a perfect setting to discuss both the scientific and ethical sides of discoveries and advancements being made in the field of

Show More
Related

  • Human Cadaver: Stiff By Mary Roach

    1690 Words  | 7 Pages

    Throughout history, it has been shown that research on cadavers has led to major scientific breakthroughs. For example, “They allow doctors and surgeons to develop or learn new techniques without risking injury to patients. They allow researchers to develop new medical devices, like artificial joints or implantable drug delivery systems, and to test how they work before using them on the living. They help physicians and researchers understand how diseases like cancer or Alzheimer’s progress inside the body so that they can find better ways to treat or cure those conditions” (“Human Cadavers Shape”). This shows the amazing impact that cadavers can have on the world and without them, certain surgeries or treatments for illness may not exist today.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Young Blood, By Jess Zimmerman

    1059 Words  | 5 Pages

    She points out facts about different methods of curing human imperfections, such as ageing, impotence and organ failures, and how the idea of ageing has evolved over the years: “old age was so rare in less-developed societies that people who achieved it were granted a certain amount of status and even a mystical cachet. Later, the elderly might have been mocked or isolated, but age was still not seen as an illness. It’s only in recent centuries, as old age has become more and more commonplace, that we have started to venerate youth; ageing is now associated not with fortunate longevity but with decrepitude and disease.” These facts introduce and support the idea that ageing is certainly a problem now compared to earlier in life and is in need of a cure. Zimmerman continues by presenting the effort of others, who are credited, who have put there life work into finding ways to better the effects of ageing, such as the San Quentin prison experiment involving the implanting of executed prisoners’ testis to promote “youth, health and vigour (Zimmerman 2014).”

    Read More

  • Brave New World Science Quotes

    1489 Words  | 6 Pages

    (7.22) In eliminating the aging process, science has destroyed a very basic element of the human experience. Mustapha comments that old age is dangerous for the community – not because of physical

    Read More

  • The Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks

    1657 Words  | 7 Pages

    In nature, success is measured by fitness-- or the ability to pass on one’s genes to the next generation. Passing on genes to the next generation ensures a type of immortality; humans do not live forever, therefore, their genes continue on for centuries through their lineage. Henrietta Lacks, however, was the first person to become immortal outside of reproduction-- through cells. As discussed in The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, Henrietta was an African-American woman whose cancerous cells were extracted to create the first immortal cell line, more commonly referred to as HeLa cells. HeLa cells would become an asset in medicine and continue to exist in labs all around the world, long after Henrietta’s death (Skloot, 2010).

    Read More

  • Comparing Daniel Callahan's 'Aging And The Ends Of Medicine'

    581 Words  | 3 Pages

    Callahan wants us to understand a new perspective of old age; we must know the meaning of the human life cycle and have limits when spending money in addition to programs to prolong life with no value (Callahan, p.592). Extended life shouldn’t be the worry, the worry should be the quality of the elderly person’s life and how one can make it better now and as painless as possible. The goal that should be in mind is to give meaning to elderly life by making it a “decent and honorable time” (Callahan,

    Read More

  • Leon Kass Ambiguity

    1446 Words  | 6 Pages

    Those with illnesses that may have brought their lives to an end years ago can now receive treatment that will allow them to live longer. Leon Kass, author of Life, Liberty and the Defense of Dignity, devoted chapter 9 of his book to engaging the discussion of humanity’s pursuit of immortality through medical technologies. In this chapter, Kass challenges that this use of medical technology is not a good idea. Kass seems to believe that, mankind abuses biotechnology as it has now become a means to distance humanity from death. For Kass, the distancing of death is

    Read More

  • Animal Testing Rhetorical Analysis

    563 Words  | 3 Pages

    Within Holder’s speech there were instances of multiple fallacies. One specific fallacy is the generalizations Holder makes in his speech, much like the ones that were used for deductive reasoning. These generalizations were often subjective and not backed up with evidence, which leads to hasty generalizations. Holder states that those who are against animal testing are mainly youth, which infers that all youth are against animal testing. However, it is not just youth who are against animal testing and not all youth are not against animal testing.

    Read More

  • The Adoration Of Jenna Fox Analysis

    625 Words  | 3 Pages

    If people had Albert Einstein, Mozart, and Tesla live up to 260 years our world would be a lot better. With Biogel people could eliminate diseases and illnesses passed down through genes. people can reduce the death rate from cancer. people don’t have to worry if people have a cure or not for someone illness because people can save them with biogel. people should be able to live forever because if people still had some valuable famous people could expand in culture.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of 'Why Immortality Is Not So Bad'

    817 Words  | 4 Pages

    Fisher begins to distill williams discussion for analyzing models of immortality. In order to be attractive to an individual the model must posit a future scenario in

    Read More

  • Plastic Surgery In Brave New World

    1571 Words  | 7 Pages

    Plastic surgery is the rigorous medical process of altering the human body through means of reconstruction, the removal of tissue, and the addition of tissue for cosmetic purposes. People see it every day and do not even question it. People’s faces and bodies are augmented in ways that humanity sees so regularly that viewers have become blind to it. Seeing faces and bodies perfectly sculpted by knives for sharp cheekbones, fuller lips, larger breasts, and a slimmer waist has tricked society into forgetting what the average person actually looks like. Consumers have become so blind to this constant fake image that humanity does not notice the difference until an unaltered, natural image is forced down our throats.

    Read More

  • Thesis Statement On Bionic Technology

    1861 Words  | 8 Pages

    Bionic is improving in the coming years leading to a much more better discoveries. "These powerful but simple ideas are meant as medical aids to help human regain function, most specially those who are in military but there might be limits to how far we can augment humans" (Locke, 2014). Science has been changing the world and nature. Human imagination All of these robotic and futuristic discoveries raise ethical questions, that human augmentation in any point can be wrong. This thing, however, can be exploited.

    Read More

  • Should Animals Be Used In Flowers For Algernon By Daniel Keys

    465 Words  | 2 Pages

    There is much controversy over whether or not animals should be used to test new procedures and medications. I personally believe that animal testing is crucial to scientific development. Every life lost is a tragedy but as seen in the story, Flowers for Algernon, by Daniel Keys, it will help us determine what will happen to a human test subjects without human losses. In this essay I will support my belief that animal research is important to human survival and is worth the risk. Animal research has played a vital part in nearly every medical breakthrough over the last decade.

    Read More

  • Radish Seeds Lab Report

    360 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this experiment, scientists, Emily Yau and Mona Howell, conducted an experiment that tested how acidity and radiation affects germination of radish seeds. ​We had hypothesized the seeds that microwave for 5, 10, and some of the 15 second seeds will grow. The radish seeds in the 1 and 2 teaspoons will sprout. We should accept our hypothesis because in the most part, it was correct. Although most of our data supports our hypothesis, some of our data contradicts our hypothesis.

    Read More

  • Dalai Lama Analysis

    1246 Words  | 5 Pages

    At first surgery was implemented to help patients who are sick,but now with the advancements in cosmetic surgery people are able to change their physical appearance to meet the demands of society. Society forces people to neglect moral values when considering cosmetic surgery because the media portrays men and women as beautiful and that beauty is the most important aspect of a human being. The main claim for the support of cosmetic surgery is that the patient are happier and more confident after having cosmetic surgery. Even though cosmetic surgery makes the patient supposedly feel happier and more confident many health risks arise from cosmetic surgery. The Dalai Lama in his essay “Ethics and the new Genetics” ponders the effects of genetic engineering

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Organ Transplants

    1215 Words  | 5 Pages

    The life of someone can be saved by the help of just one kind person willing to make a sacrifice of his or her own to save that one person. However, the question is whether or not there are enough people with these characters in the world, willing to help others in need just because it is just and the right thing to do. Normally the answer points to no because in reality, people are generally selfish and will not do something for others unless they are compensated for their actions. This is the exactly why people in need of an organ transplants suffer greatly, some of which actually end up dead because there are not enough people who are willing to simply donate their organs. Kidneys are an example of an organ that many citizens need in order

    Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Head Transplant Surgery

Open Document