ipl-logo

Socrates And Thrasymachus Relationship In Plato's Republic

1559 Words7 Pages

In Book 1 of Plato 's Republic, Socrates and Thrasymachus engage in a passionate, and often acrimonious, conversation regarding the relationship between a ruler and those he or she rules. Their conversation raises substantive questions about both the nature and purpose of government and the motivations and roles of those who govern. The following will address these questions by 1) explaining both Socrates ' and Thrasymachus ' understandings of the ruler-ruled relationship and 2) addressing the merits of each argument and offering my own philosophical position on the matter.
First, with respect to Thrasymachus ' position, he believes that rulers craft laws for their "own advantage," and he considers justice to be the "advantage of the stronger" …show more content…

Socrates uses the allegory of the cave to emphasize the importance of education and pursuit of the Good. The "prisoners" in the cave merely observe shadows and reflections of what actually is, but, with education and the guidance of a philosopher, these prisoners are able to exit the cave, observe reality, and progress towards understanding the Good (520a). With respect to the role of the city and government, Socrates suggests that rulers should be those "in a state of waking," already exposed to reality and committed to returning to the cave to "harmoniz[e] the citizens by persuasion and compulsion" towards the Good (520a-c). In other words, rulers should not be individuals who "fight over shadows," merely interested in the attainment and pursuit of material wealth and resources; instead, Socrates suggests, that rulers should be interested in the pursuit of Truth, and dedicated to gently guiding the ruled towards "fair, just, and good things" (520b-d). Thrasymachus ' vision, however, more closely aligns with the antithesis of Socrates ' position. To Thrasymachus, rulers govern "for the sake of ruling," forming factions to perpetuate their power structure and enrich themselves (520c). For Thrasymachus, a ruler would never voluntarily educate those within the cave unless he recognized a tangible, material benefit from doing so. Instead, a ruler would systematically ensure that the ruled never left the cave, guaranteeing they are never aware of the benefits of education or aware of the pursuit of the "fair, just and good things"

Show More
Related

  • The Matrix, Plato's Allegory Of The Cave

    1897 Words  | 8 Pages

    In the dialogue, Socrates claims that after a prisoner leaves the cave and sees the sun (which symbolizes truth and knowledge), he will not participate in the cave dwellers’ ignorance. Similarly, individuals who chose to become enlightened to the true nature of reality do not partake in the ignorance of humanity; instead they encourage individuals to believe in philosophical knowledge. The cave dwellers believe that the shadows on the walls are real, just like individuals accept the reality of the world with which they are presented; however, they are both illusions, which are perceived. This is because over centuries human perception is merely a shadow of reality and individuals are like the cave dwellers who believe the perceptions created by society (Cleveland). Therefore, humans need to raise past the perceptions governed and taught by society in order to break through ignorance and travel on a path of

    Read More

  • The Mytilenian Debate

    1015 Words  | 5 Pages

    We are now introduced another point of view that differs to that of Cleon. Thucydides introduces Diodotus a man who originally opposed the notion and continues to provide the reasons as to why, “haste and anger are, to my mind, the two greatest obstacles to wise counsel-haste, that usually goes with folly, anger that is the mark of primitive and narrow minds” (p. 218). As a member of parliament Diodotus stresses the fact that as men of government it is their duty to avoid making terrible decisions and as men of government they are the representatives of the law and thus must act according to justice. Diodotus continues to discuss the matters of corruption and deception, for through this the matters of state cannot be fully addressed, “her counsellors will be afraid to speak and will be deprived of their services” (p. 218). He warns the council that although a proposition may seem appealing they must not be fooled by it for a man will do anything to be believed and even though they may not notice the deception the state will not be fooled.

    Read More

  • Plato's Allegory Of The Cave: A Metaphor For Education

    275 Words  | 2 Pages

    Plato’s “Allegory of the Cave” is a metaphor for education, and every object and character represents something in the education system. The cave itself, where the prisoners live, is a question of reality. Furthermore, the cave may symbolize a school, as students learn everything in school like the prisoners learned everything in the cave. The puppeteers are teachers because they teach and control the prisoners like teachers teach and control students. The prisoners are the students because the prisoners are stuck in the cave and learn from the puppeteers like students must attend school and learn from teachers.

    Read More

  • Analyzing Plato's 'The Allegory Of The Cave'

    773 Words  | 4 Pages

    Plato tells us that the prisoners are confused on their emergence from the cave and that the prisoners’ will be blinded once they had been freed from the cave. After a period of time they will adjust their eyesight and begin to understand the true reality that the world poses. The stubbornness to develop a different perspective is seen in much of today’s society. The allegory of the cave is an understanding of what the true world is and how many people never see it because of their views of the society they are raised in.

    Read More

  • Plato's Views On The Allegory Of The Cave

    1377 Words  | 6 Pages

    1) In the allegory of the cave, Plato’s main goal is to illustrate his view of knowledge. A group of prisoners have been chained in a cave their whole lives and all they have ever been exposed to were shadows on the wall and voices of people walking by. The prisoners in the cave represent humans who only pay attention to the physical aspects of the world (sight and sound). Once one of them escapes and sees the blinding light, all he wants is to retreat back to the cave and return to his prior way of living. This shows that Plato believes enlightenment and education are painful, but the pain is necessary for enlightenment and it is worth it.

    Read More

  • Socrates Vs. Unjust One In Plato's The Republic

    643 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Plato’s, The Republic, Book I, Socrates tries to prove to Thrasymachus “whether just people also live better and are happier than unjust ones” (352d). He argues that everything has a predisposed proficiency at a function, and that this functions are performed well by the peculiar virtue and badly by means of its vice (353a-353d) . The point of this paper is to present Socrates argument and evaluate it to the best of my ability. This argument can be categorized as an inductive generalization. Socrates states that the function of anything is what it alone can do or what it does best.

    Read More

  • Comparing Socrates In The Apology, Crito, And The Republic

    802 Words  | 4 Pages

    The version of Socrates presented in both The Apology, Crito, and The Republic could very well be two different versions of Socrates as presented by Plato. However, both versions of Socrates have one thing in common: they both value the importance of philosophy and they both defend philosophy as something that is important to humanity. The Apology is Socrates defending not only himself, but also philosophy as an area of study that could be useful to the city of Athens. Socrates is trying to defend himself and his study and he tries to distance himself from the sophists in that they charge for money.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Arete In Ancient Greece

    1134 Words  | 5 Pages

    What is a good person, and how does one achieve the good life? These were the questions asked by the ancient Greeks. Arete, or excellence, was what the Greeks strove for in everything. In a quest for excellence, the Greeks experimented with new types of politics. Greece was divided into individual city-states that each had their own form of government.

    Read More

  • Socrates And Crito Argumentative Analysis

    1382 Words  | 6 Pages

    Socrates believes that justice benefits the just, but also benefits the city (other people) too. He is faced with a seemingly simple choice, escape Athens or remain in prison and be sentenced to death. Socrates’ central argument against escaping his circumstances is twofold. First, Socrates argues that “one must never do wrong.” (49b)

    Read More

  • Argument Of Justice In Plato's Book 1 Of The Republic

    732 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Book 1 of the republic, by Plato, we are introduced to two central figures in the argument of justice, Socrates and Thrasymachus. Thrasymachus claims that justice is the advantage of the stronger. Socrates then asks if his understanding, that what is beneficial to the stronger is just and must be beneficial to the weaker people, to which Thrasymachus replies that no, this is not so. He explains that justice is that which obtains the advantage of the stronger.

    Read More

  • Thoreau And Civil Disobedience In Sophocles Antigone

    882 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the play Antigone, Sophocles uses duality to explore citizens conflicting obligations, that of one’s inner desires and of social regulation, resulting in the ongoing struggle for balance of freedoms and restrictions in our everyday life. This makes us question the role of our government, whether it is put in place to preserve or restrict our freedoms. Thoreau and civil disobedience True patriots not those who blindly followed their admin, but those who followed their own conscious. He sought to move prestige away from obedience to independent thought.

    Read More

  • Plato's Allegory Of The Cave Education

    313 Words  | 2 Pages

    Plato demonstrates the significance of education. We are accustomed to the knowledge that we already have but do not want the education that we actually need. This is the case because actual learning is painful: it needs dedication and sacrifice but we as humans do not like to face that pain and go for the easier alternative which is the act of being ignorant. Plato’s Allegory of the cave has been separated into three parts: the first part is the part where the prisoners are in a cave, in the cave the prisoners are tied in such a way that they can only face forward, towards a wall with shadows in front of them. The second part is about how the prisoners leave the cave.

    Read More

  • What Is Plato's Unjust Soul

    1385 Words  | 6 Pages

    aligns with reason and resists the desires of the appetite. It is in this part of the soul where the courage to be good is found. In the unjust soul, the spirit ignores reason and instead aligns with the appetitive desires, manifesting as the demand for the pleasures of the body. Plato asserts that the wise and just soul allows reason to govern the other parts, while the unwise and unjust soul allows conflict between the parts.12 Just as there is the appetitive part of the soul—the largest part of the soul—there is the productive class, or the workers, who have souls of bronze and account for the largest part of the population.13 This class includes the general population of laborers, plumbers, masons, carpenters, merchants, and farmers.

    Read More

  • The Noble Lie In Plato's The Republic

    1355 Words  | 6 Pages

    What is justice? This is the crucial question that Plato attempts to answer in his dialogue, The Republic. He conjures up an allegory that justice can be found in a person, and a person can represent a city. Thus, his entire dialogue focuses on this ‘just’ city and the mechanics of how the city would operate. His dialogue covers a myriad of topics about justice in addition to the human soul, politics, goodness and truth.

    Read More

  • Plato's Concept Of The Noble Lie

    2004 Words  | 9 Pages

    Plato proposes that in order to function the noble lie effectively, the citizens must be persuaded to believe that their political role was chosen prior to birth, due to the composition of gold, silver or bronze in their souls . This gives rise to the ‘’Myth of Metals’’ , which states that every citizen is born from the earth and must regard the native soul as their mother. The citizens possessing gold and silver are the most honored and qualified to rule, whereas a workman takes no part in protecting or governing the city and carry on all necessary lines of work. The city state must be ruled by the philosopher kings who belong to the category of rulers and possess a high degree of knowledge and are capable of identifying the activities that promote the welfare of the entire society. The philosopher kings must be chosen from amongst the class of

    Read More

More about Socrates And Thrasymachus Relationship In Plato's Republic

Open Document