ipl-logo

Gender Roles In The Return Of Martin Guerre By Natalie Zemon Davis

1592 Words7 Pages

Society thinks of someone’s identity as a stagnant object that is un-swayed by the environment around them. However, there are many factors that go into what someone’s identity is. The novel “The Return of Martin Guerre” by Natalie Zemon Davis, discusses how gender roles and identity can affect a person. Both topics, gender roles and personal identity, have individual issues as well as compound issues in today’s society. They exist on their own but additionally, they influence each other. The environment and people that surround a person can also influence who these people end up being. These issues are major topics in “The Return of Martin Guerre” and the story of Bertrande. Gender roles are something that people in today’s society struggle …show more content…

I believe that Bertande was given a great chance, planned or not, after she married Martin. I wonder what would have happened if the woman in “The Yellow Wallpaper” were given the same situation as Bertrande. The woman’s husband was very controlling and over bearing. However, he was a doctor, a man of power and rank, he was this woman’s best option. He locked her away and kept her drugged because she was suffering from post-partum depression. Because of his actions towards her, she ended up becoming mentally unstable and presumably killed herself, the ending of the story is ambiguous as to what exactly happens. Bertande was given the chance to live her life for a great time while being first married to Martin. She could finish being a child, she didn’t have to become a mother just because she reached the child-bearing age. She was given freedoms that the other woman never had. They both became prisoners to their assigned roles in their relationships and societies, however, Bertrande must have been able to work the system in order to create the best life for her. Her allegiance to the “fake” Martin leads me to believe that she understood how good it was to be attached to higher ranking people, than to just be seen as a daughter. In addition, I believe the other woman understood her role as a wife to this doctor was better than being a divorced woman in her society. They both must have understood at one point, they were choosing the lesser of two

Show More
Related

  • Return Of Martin Guerre Quotes

    1027 Words  | 5 Pages

    With Martin, she only ever stuck to the duties a woman normally sticks to, but Arnaud is a merchant. When a woman’s husband is a merchant, she is allowed to engage in merchant activities as well, thus with Arnaud Bertrande’s sphere of freedom expands. She gets more opportunities to experience the world around her aside from the normal confinement a woman has to her house. Bertrande seizes this chance for independence to the fullest, and “What Bertrande had with the new Martin was her dream come true,” (44). For not only does she get more freedom with him by being a merchant, but she also fulfils her previous more mature independent desire for a partner she genuinely likes.

    Read More

  • Patriarchal Society In Janet Lewis's The Wife Of Martin Guerre

    1067 Words  | 5 Pages

    Topic: Bertrande’s position as a woman in a patriarchal society makes her choices impossible. Discuss. Janet Lewis’ novella, The Wife of Martin Guerre presents a hierarchical society that disregards the voice of women in society who seek justice. Throughout the novel, Bertrande is depicted as a strong, independent women however, her ability to express her objections is restricted due to feudal system being an important part of the 16th century. Furthermore, although the French parochial lives under the patriarchal system, Bertrande is able to strongly express her decisions when taking the case of Arnuad du Tilh in court.

    Read More

  • Mrs. Bergmeier's Ethical Dilemma In The Prison Camp

    447 Words  | 2 Pages

    Mrs. Bergmeier is obviously a very caring woman, who made a very hard ethical decision while in the prison camp. She knew that the decision she made would spark controversy, but made the choice in order to reunite with her family. She committed an act that many would call cheating, or adultery. Yet, at the end of the day this probably had no influence on her, as at the end of the day she was the one laying in bed with her husband, and children just a couple rooms away. She made a decision that not only allowed her to contribute to the upbringing of her children, but also brought in a new one.

    Read More

  • Edna Pontellier In Kate Chopin's The Awakening

    1059 Words  | 5 Pages

    (Chopin 5). Léonce is set in the traditional ways that women are to be the caretakers of the household. By her not directly getting up to check on the children, he disapproves that she does not immediately recognize her duties. “In short, Mrs. Pontellier was not a mother-woman” (Chopin 8). According to her husband’s beliefs, it was bad that his wife did not naturally assume this role.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Foreshadowing In Desiree's Baby

    286 Words  | 2 Pages

    Desiree’s Baby Foreshadowing In the fictional story “Desiree’s Baby” by Kate Chopin is a tragic love story, but with dark ending. Armand a young, wealthy, and well known man believed that he had found his soulmate, and married a woman named Desiree. The newlyweds had now became a family with a birth of a baby boy. As the baby was at 3 months their fate could have end in many ways.

    Read More

  • The Squid And The Whale Analysis

    1366 Words  | 6 Pages

    His wife, Joan meanwhile, discovers a literary talent of her own and has recently begun publishing her own work, which only increases the growing tension between them. It is interesting to note that the two of them are completely different from each other in terms of their personalities and it left me wondering what made them hold on for so long! There is evidence of fierce competition between the couple which is obvious from the

    Read More

  • Identity In The Return Of Martin Guerre

    1559 Words  | 7 Pages

    Bertrande de Rols does this by not remarrying and living with standards, demonstrating her respect for the social graces and even for her reappeared husband. She is seen as loyal while living with her mother and even later as she stands by Arnaud’s side, cleansing him as he is sentenced to jail. In this impactful novel, one’s identity is a necessity to finding true purpose in life. To become part of the community, the people of this society must leave the label of an outsider since “Outsider status affected community identity but could be overcome.

    Read More

  • Comparison Of Loving V. Virginia And Desiree's Baby

    784 Words  | 4 Pages

    Armand’s father had brought him home from paris, when he was eight, after his mother died. He came from a wealthy family. According to the Armand’s father thought of Desiree didn’t seem like he was happy because the way he grew up, he wanted someone from the same wealth as them. After they had gotten married and they were expecting a baby, the day had come of the birth of the child Mrs. Valmonde was surprised about the baby when she saw it because perhaps the kid didn’t look like one of the parent’s. “ Marriage, and later the birth of his so had softened Armand Aubigny’s imperious and exacting nature greatly.”

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Desiree's Baby And Desirees Baby

    913 Words  | 4 Pages

    But, when son was three months, Armand had changed in mood since the baby was born, to which he wouldn’t even look at her with the same respect. As Chopin describes Armand to Desiree, “When he spoke to her, it was with averted eyes, from which the old love-light seemed to have gone out.” , it’s clear as though something had struck Armand, giving him the feeling of not wanting to see Desiree anymore, and the love he showed was no longer there anymore. When in ‘Lamb to the Slaughter’, it was made clear that the husband, Patrick, did in fact show her a lot of love and respect. When Patrick came home from work, as a police officer, Ms.Maloney, the

    Read More

  • Desiree's Baby Theme

    778 Words  | 4 Pages

    If it weren’t for Armand’s racism, this story would have turned out with a much more positive ending. Because of Armand racist world views, he was unable to be a decent human and take responsibility for the child he conceived with Désirée. His racism causes him to act unkindly towards his wife, child, slaves, and I think to himself now that he knows he himself is part

    Read More

  • Desiree's Baby Literary Analysis

    1283 Words  | 6 Pages

    The irony of this short story was that it was Armand who was of mixed raced and not his wife. He was the one who tainted the baby, he found out after fining a letter from his beloved mother that was written to his father (Chopin). Irony is a surprising interesting twist at the end on a story. I am sure that after he read this letter that he soon figured out why his father was so kind to the slaves and how it was wrong of him to treat his wife the way he did and immediately regretted his choices. Thus, she was no longer there and he could not get her back, he thought she went back to live with her stepmother, and if he goes to look for her or the stepmother went to look for her and the child they would both find that Desiree never went to her original destination.

    Read More

  • The Refashioning Of Martin Guerre Analysis

    1270 Words  | 6 Pages

    Strength and Weakness I believe that there is no perfect work. That is to say, every work has its own flaws; Davis’s book is not an exception. It is not an obscure that Davis’s work has few flaws. First, there is an exaggeration of using conjecture; while reading the book, I have noticed that Davis says words, such as “almost certainly,” "clearly," or "must have.”

    Read More

  • Foreshadowing And Allusion In Desiree's Baby By Kate Chopin

    1203 Words  | 5 Pages

    As the child was three months old, Desiree notice a difference in Armands behaviour, he was distancing from Desiree and the child. Desiree was getting axitions and mad of what was Armand behavior thoughts her and the child. Desiree was sad and wrote to Madame Valmonde. Madame Valmonde told her to come home with her child. Desiree talks to Armand if she is allowed to go back home.

    Read More

  • Desiree's Baby Literary Analysis

    225 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the fictional story Desiree’s baby, written by Kate Chopin, Desiree marries a rich man after falling in love with him. Unfortunately their marriage ends abruptly, and in a tragic way. Desiree’s desire to die foreshadows the theme of suspense to develop an engaging plot. Early in the story, the reader learns that the baby looks much darker than Desiree. In a way, Armand ignoring Desiree subtly hints at Desiree wanting to take her life, especially when she begins to feel unhappy.

    Read More

  • Themes And Symbolism In Desiree's Baby By Kate Chopin

    1463 Words  | 6 Pages

    “And yet the mere fact of her racial history causes Armand to reject her and the baby, to cease to see her as the woman he loves and instead to see her as simply black and therefore beneath him”(Champlin 1). Even though Armand once loved Desiree, it all changed just because of her background. Desiree’s finds out her baby is mixed, Armand tells her to leave because she brought shame to his family name. “And yet the mere fact of her racial history causes Armand to reject her and the baby, to cease to see her as the woman he loves and instead to see her as simply black and therefore beneath him”(Champlin 1). Even though Armand once loved Desiree, it all changed just because of her

    Read More

More about Gender Roles In The Return Of Martin Guerre By Natalie Zemon Davis

Open Document