Two truths can be contradictory, but that does not make them any less true. The truth is just the way people perceive, or want to perceive truth. Plato, a Greek philosopher from the Classical Greek era, wrote Allegory of the Cave. Allegory of the Cave is a great depiction of perception of the truth, and how the truth can be different for different people. What some people might find to be true can be false to others; however, both truths are as true as people make them. The truth can be different for different people. In Plato’s Allegory of the Cave, Plato paints a canvas with a cave and some prisoners. The prisoners are given a false perception of what the truth is, but to them, their perception of the truth is true. Eventually, one of the …show more content…
In Allegory of the Cave, the still captured prisoners hang on to their belief that they have always known, even though it may not be accurate. This is because all the prisoners have ever known is what they will always hold true until they are convinced otherwise. Two people can make different statements that are completely contradictory; however, that does not make them false in their own eyes. If one has only learned one truth that is false, then one will only find the real truth if one is taught otherwise. People generally turn their own thought or things that they have been taught into the truth, but this does not automatically make those thoughts true. Rather than that, it merely makes people seem oblivious to the actual truth due to lack of their education of their surroundings. This is much like the prisoner who was freed because at first, he had the exact same beliefs as his acquaintances, but later he learned the real truth about the world. After reading Plato’s Allegory of the Cave, one can be lead to believe that Plato was trying to teach that uneducated people are “imprisoned” by their own ignorance. This statement is supported when the prisoners in his allegory don’t believe the freed prisoner. However, if the prisoners had been educated like the freed prisoner, they would have known that there is much more truth to the world than just the shadows that Plato had
Click here to unlock this and over one million essaysShow More
Allegory of the Cave- First Draft The Allegory of the Cave is an extended analogy presented to us by the Greek Philosopher Plato. It is concerned with human perception of knowledge and truth. Plato believed that real knowledge can only be acquired through philosophical reasoning. In the Allegory, Plato portrays to the mistakes of people who mistake empirical knowledge for being the ultimate truth and differentiate them from people who have sought real knowledge. Plato believes that the society is like prisoners in a cave and one can only emancipate from its conventional beliefs by seeking knowledge outside the cave.
Socrates’ description of a philosopher in Plato’s “The Allegory of the Cave” suggests the creation of a new hero. In this text, Socrates portrays the role of a philosopher in the creation of a just society. This philosopher represents a new type of hero, who seeks the Truth through extensive thought and questioning. In “The Allegory of the Cave,” Socrates depicts the prisoner’s journey outside the cave as a journey of the mind and soul toward enlightenment and the absolute Truth. A philosopher must venture outside the cave to experience the authenticity of world outside the one he used to know and be able to separate illusions from reality.
3. In the Video of Plato’s Allegory of the Cave, there is Plato's story of the cave: “It is the task of the enlightened, not only to ascend to learning and to see the good, but to be willing to descend again to those prisoners and to share their troubles and their honors, withier they are worth having or not. And this they must do even with the prospect of death.” (Plato) Please comment on this video and this
What if every known thing in the world turned out to be misguided? What if people within the world learned ways of life and adapted to environments only to find out that it was all a lie? In "The Allegory of the Cave" from Plato's "The Republic", the same questions were considered and analyzed by Socrates, the speaker of the story. The Philosopher Socrates explicates his allegory of great curiosity to Glaucon, a man of whom Socrates shares his wealth of wisdom with. Socrates' purpose in expressing the allegory is to show how the human race may not always see the truth but rather convince themselves that what they see is the truth. In other words, people allow themselves to believe what they would like to believe. As Socrates speaks, he has a questioning, curious and wise tone towards Glaucon, he speaks as if he does not even know the truth himself.
Plato tells us that the prisoners are confused on their emergence from the cave and that the prisoners’ will be blinded once they had been freed from the cave. After a period of time they will adjust their eyesight and begin to understand the true reality that the world poses. The stubbornness to develop a different perspective is seen in much of today’s society. The allegory of the cave is an understanding of what the true world is and how many people never see it because of their views of the society they are raised in.
In chapters 5-7 in the Republic, Plato argues that there is a fundamental difference between appearance and reality, and that there is no true knowledge of appearance. Plato defends his positions best in the Allegory of the Cave, where he distinguishes the differences between appearance and reality, and how appearance does not have true knowledge. In the allegory of the cave, men are chained to in a cave as prisoners and only see shadows and reflections on the walls. The prisoners believe that the shadows and reflections that appear on the walls are entities and perceive them as reality.
The other prisoners refuse to believe him, and threaten to have him killed for wanting to take them out of the cave. There are many obvious allegorical themes in Plato’s story. The prisoners are living in a state of ignorance and denial. This is meant to represent modern society. The cave itself is a representation of the human physical world.
Plato’s Allegory of the Cave and The Truman Show Midterm Movie Paper The “Allegory of the Cave” and “The Truman Show” is a representation of humans believing what they see in front of them is the only truth that they know. The Allegory of the Cave is an ancient knowledgeable philosophical work made by the Greek philosopher, Plato. He emphasizes the significance of humans achieving wisdom, intellectual insight, knowledge and education as a metaphor in his story (Plato, 246-249).
One can argue that knowledge is too elusive to put into words, but as indicated through the story, the prisoner could identify the forms because he was educated of them through the shadows, but not through living characteristics. Along the lines of intelligible and sensible knowledge, mathematics a heavily emphasized aspect implied by Plato, since he believed that mathematics drew us toward the intelligible realm beyond the realm of sensible specifics. When we move beyond applied mathematics and begin to contemplate numbers in themselves through correlation, then we begin to move from the
The good is not knowledge but it is knowledgeable. It is the cause of all good because it is independent. Light and sight are said to be like the sun, but not actually being the sun, and science and truth are said to be like the Good, but not actually being the Good. Therefore, by this discussion, the Good is beyond ALL being and is the cause of most of existence. The “Divided Line” is a bit more complex than the sun analogy because there are so many more parts that culminate to form this topic.
In Plato 's theology, our soul exist before we are born with all knowledge, and though life experiences, people are reminded of this pre-existing knowledge, and they gain this wisdom. Once people use their senses to observe this recollecting experience, and by using others to influence further critical thinking, knowledge is gained. In his story of the cave analogy: "picture humans beings in a cave like dwelling underground, having a long pathway open to the light all across the cave. They 're in it from childhood on with their legs and necks in restraints, so that they 're held in place and look only to the front, restricted by the neck-restraint from twisting their heads around.
While accepting it, Plato questions whether or not you will fully be able to grasp the concept entirely, comparing the light of knowledge with the darkness, or ignorance, of the night. As found, Plato jolts “And he will see the stars and the spangled heavens: and he will see the sky and the stars by night better than the sun or light of the sun by day? Certainly.” To clarify, Plato says that even if enlightened and beholding the knowledge in front of us (the light), we will never be able to see it as clearly as the night, representing the narrow-minded ignorance that has been fed to us beforehand by the government (or marionette players). So that after being released from the cave and the restrictions that feed us blurred illustrations, we become faced to the light, a.k.a truth, that becomes a painful, complex process to
The allegory of the Cave is presented by Plato, as a dialogue between Glaucon and Socrates, the latter being the narrator. Socrates paints a picture of the allegory for readers, as he asks them to imagine prisoners trapped in a cave all their life, facing a wall and unable to move their heads. The allegory can be summed up in three main parts, which are the imprisonment in the cave, departure and return to the cave. The prisoners are misled by the shadows, which they believe to be reality. This is clear as Socrates says, “Then the prisoners would in every way believe that the truth is nothing other than the shadows of those artifacts” (515c).
The ‘Allegory Of The Cave’ by Plato is a metaphor concerning human perception. Plato claimed that knowledge gained through the senses is nothing more than opinion and, in order obtain “real” knowledge, we must use philosophical reasoning to gain it. “The Allegory of the Cave”, begins by depicting a dark scene where prisoners have been chained and bound since infancy and their heads can only see the stonewall in from of them. Behind them are a fire that has burned continuously and a walkway that produces shadows from the people outside. The shadows that were cast onto the wall were seen and perceived as real objects.