The death of Eric Garner, the second major case of the Black Lives Matter movement, gave the movement more momentum, even more so because it concerned the police department commonly either recognised as famous or infamous-- the NYPD. On the afternoon of 17 July 2014, in Staten Island, New York, Eric Garner was publicly executed by the NYPD-- including the murderer, Daniel Pantaleo. The video begins with Eric Garner raising his voice at a police officer who he says repeatedly “harasses” him and will not leave him alone. Eric Garner says that he “wants to just be left alone.”. After a faded cut in the video, the officers converge on Garner and grab him arms to which Eric asks for them not to touch him. After resisting their grabbing, Garner is …show more content…
While still keeping Garner on the ground, handcuffed, the officers sat mindlessly around him waiting for an ambulance (“”). The NYPD has since stated that the chokehold was completely illegal and against the Police Department’s policies (“Of Course It Happened Again”). This event, non-officially being fourth recorded death of the Black Lives Matter movement, and the second (non-official) key case in the movement as a whole, came with a lot of controversy when Daniel Pantaleo was not indicted for the murder. The case was also under fire when a judge decided that the transcripts and details of the case would not be released (Eisenberg; Vorhees). Many think that the reason for this is just what the judge said, that is was to prevent outside influence on the case, but many also belief that it was to keep secrecy in between the case and the people in order to get away with an unfair investigation (Vorhees). This being the second “major” killing of the Black Lives Matter movement, especially due to it being recorded, there was nationwide outcry after death and after the decision to not indict
On October 3, 1974, Memphis police officers Leslie Wright and Elton Hymon were called to a burglary. Officer Hymon went to the back of the house and saw someone running away. That person running away was 15 year old Edward Garner. Garner approached a chain link fence. He stopped.
Police Officer Pantaleo arrested Garner “for allegedly selling loose cigarettes” (www.npr.org). During the arrest, Officer Pantaleo had put Garner in a chokehold position which caused Garner to suffocate. There was a video posted on YouTube of Garner saying he was not able to breathe while he was being held in a headlock. The man died because of the chokehold, but the grand jury, back in December of 2014, did not charge Officer Pantaleo. People protested in reaction to the officer not being charged for the death of Eric Garner and that led to the launch of the civil rights investigation for this case by the Justice Department (www.npr.org).
In the article Philando Castile shooting: Dashcam video shows rapid event by Jay Croft. Croft explores the issue of police brutality. Specifically, he takes about the fatal shooting of an African American man Philando Castile who was killed by Minnesota police officer Jeronimo Yanez. This caused an uproar in the African American community because once again a man of color was fatally shoot because the officers assumed that he was going to pull out a gun. Moreover, the role of police officers is to protect members of society from threats.
Daniel Pantaleo should, at the very least be charged with involuntary manslaughter. Daniel Pantaleo clearly broke NYPD policy by using a chokehold to “restrain” Eric Garner. It has been very argued that what Pantaleo used to restrain Garner was not a chokehold but in this photo, obtained from the NYPD, there is a clear difference between a chokehold and a submission hold.
On July 17, 2014, 23 old, Ramsey Orta recorded the public killing of Eric Garner. The recording displays a six foot three inch, three hundred sixty pound unarmed black male being boxed in between a convenience store, located on a busy New York street and uniform as well as plain clothed officers. You can hear multiple offices persistently questioning Garner before the tattooed officer on his far right wearing a black fitted baseball cap takes charge of the situation. All though out the recording Garners body language shows him to be deeply vexed by the officers, however, not aggressive. The next scene depicts the officers on Garners far left attempt to put Garner in handcuffs without verbally warning Garner what he was doing before making the physical contact.
Castile’s family have no faith with the system Castile’s family decried the court’s decision to acquit Yanez. Castile’s mother said that: “The fact in this matter is that my son was assassinated, and I will endure to say assassinated, because where in this earth can you tell the truth, and you be frank, and you still be killed by the police of Minnesota.”
A combination of a chokehold by an officer, the chest compression, and poor health at the same, Garner has unfortunately died just an hour after being taken to hospital. The first thing worth mentioning is the police said they did not use chokehold on Garner. Later, the medical examiner concluded that Garner's death was caused by chokehold during physical restraint by police. After the Staten Island grand jury did not indict Pantaleo, people in New York City gathered to protest and made many speeches. Surprisingly, the number of protesters increase to more than 300 people.
The Ambitious Truth “I can’t breathe” were the last words Eric Garner spoke. Eric Garner was killed by NYPD officers that used an illegal choke hold to be attained. At the time he was committing no crime, but had a previous record. Eric is one of many to be killed due to police brutality.
Recently, many people have forgotten why the United States of America was formed, for freedom and independence from a king and state. Some of us even have trouble remembering what rights we do have, due to the gradual but continuous media and educational focus on more current distractions. Few have taken notice, or been able to see through the daily fog of which Iphone to buy or what flag offends who. There is still discrimination everywhere we look being race, body type, the religion we follow. More and more police are being caught on camera shooting unarmed citizens, throwing bombs into cribs during no-knock, warrantless entries, and causing the general public to lose faith in a system of governance originally set up to protect and serve.
New York City— NYPD officer Peter Liang reacts on February 11 as a guilty verdict is read during his manslaughter and official misconduct trial for fatally shooting an unarmed black man, Akai Gurley, in a darkened public housing stairwell in 2014. The verdict meant the rookie cop was automatically fired from his job and could face up to 15 years in jail. Nationwide, outrage over police shootings and interactions with minority communities has spurred protests and turned the Black Lives Matter movement into a presidential campaign
Neil Cavuto, anchorman for fox news, reported on this story on December 3, 2014. In his report, he interviews Rod Wheeler, former homicide detective, and they discuss the decision of the grand jury. This report is drastically different from the other three news sources, and was not filled with as much information. The incident of Garner was only briefly touched on and then the focus was shifted completely. Most of their discussion was about the potential rioting of citizens in New York.
Black Lives Matter started in 2012 after Trayvon Martin was shot and killed by George Zimmerman in his hometown of Sanford, Florida while walking home from the convenience store after purchasing a can of iced tea and a bag of skittles. Zimmerman told police that he shot Trayvon in self-defense after following him for a few minutes because he was acting suspicious. On the night of the crime, Zimmerman was held at the police station for only five hours before being discharged. He was charged with second degree murder but eventually found not guilty of his crimes. The case gained national attention soon after Trayvon died, when his family created an online petition to have George Zimmerman arrested.
(Lowery. Paragraph 52.) “In early July 2016, two killings reawakened the movement. Videos circulated on social media of the police shootings of two young men, Alton Sterling and Philando Castile. Among the cities that hosted major protests was Dallas, where the police had gone to great pains to support the protesters, cordoning off areas for demonstrators and posing for photos next to signs calling for reforms and justice.
Recently in American politics, the Black Lives Matter movement has been publicized at large. There is a lot of controversy around BLM because many people believe that it is a hate group targeting all police officials and white citizens. The group’s goal is to address a problem in America, like racial profiling, asking why people who are white that shoot innocent church goers are arrested and taken into custody while a black teenager jaywalking across the street is shot, and racism in the everyday part of their lives. Black Lives Matter wants to open the eyes of people who do not see a problem and hopefully fix a broken system. Racism is a touchy subject for many people because they do not believe racism is as detrimental to society since
I turn on the news, my fingers trembling and my heart beat pounding inside my ears. Another death. Another ‘one of us’ as a statistic. Another victim of a racist and cruel police violence. Another Black Man dead, my dad says as he shakes his head with disappointment.