ipl-logo

The Sentence: Case Study

466 Words2 Pages

Do you agree with: the Decision/Held in the case, the Sentence?
I think that the Defendant Ms Flett is guilty and I agree with the decision of the judge in this case. The sentence for Ms Flett is that she received life imprisonment for each count of manslaughter that is being served concurrently, along with six months for the charge of arson, which is also being served concurrently, and weapons prohibition for life. Ms Flett will be eligible for parole after seven years, if she is granted parole she will be under community supervision for the rest of her life. I agree with the judge’s decision because Ms Flett’s actions killed five people, acted unreasonably, and had said herself that she wanted “to scare” her targets. Ms Flett could have acted differently given the circumstances of the situation, since she acted recklessly and irrationally caused the death of five innocent people. Though considering that Ms Flett had been drinking before she committed the crime, this could explain some of her actions due to a reduced intellectual capacity, however, cannot make them excusable. …show more content…

People with disabilities are not just physical but include mental, social, and emotional conditions. Since Ms Flett suffered from mental illness she the judge would have paid attention when giving her the sentence, since he must be aware of the reasons as to why she must have committed the crime (done through the psychologist) and accommodate her punish accordingly. Likewise, the Canadian court can request a pre-sentencing and bail hearing report when considering sentencing an offender of Aboriginal background under Section 718.2(e) of the Criminal Code. The conditions that Ms Flett had suffered when growing up on an Aboriginal reserve had contributed to her mental health issues, for this reason the judge had to recognize when sentencing Ms

Show More
Related

  • Sample Case Scenario

    1080 Words  | 5 Pages

    On 02/28/2017 at approximately 0330 hours, deputies were dispatched to 624 N. Market in Caldwell, KS. Dispatch advised a physical disturbance had just occurred between a mother and her son, the son left the house on foot. All of the doors were locked at the house so he could not get back inside. When I arrived in the area I parked to the south of the house and waited for backup to arrive. Deputy Marks #134

    Read More

  • Death Of Azaria Chamberlain Essay

    1233 Words  | 5 Pages

     Case Assessment  Click on the link below to view my case assessment in Word Format  Personal View :)  I believe that Lindy was innocent from the start. If proper forensic tests were performed then the jury probably would of arrived at this decision as well.

    Read More

  • Was Andrea Yates Criminal Or Guilty

    172 Words  | 1 Pages

    This was a more fair verdict to me. Yates was mentally ill, She needed treatment and not a torture place like jail. Yates attorney stated “ She committed the murders because, of psychotic delusions and postpartum depression” (Chan). Yes, Yates was guilty because, they were her actions but, she was mentally ill and was a very religious woman.

    Read More

  • Marleen Bird: Secondary Victim

    1190 Words  | 5 Pages

    Marleen bird was a 50-year-old aboriginal woman from a northern reserve in Saskatchewan. Bird suffered from substance abuse issues and homelessness. In 2014 Bird was viciously attacked and set on fire in a parking lot in Prince Albert Saskatchewan. As a result of the attack Bird lost both of her legs and much of her eyesight (Canadian Press, 2017). Bird suffered from years of victimization due to the injuries she suffered from the attack, the constant news articles reporting on the attack and the subsequent trials.

    Read More

  • Sergeant Luis Walker Case

    574 Words  | 3 Pages

    While serving his time Walker at Fort Leavenworth he committed suicide in 2014 just two years after being convicted. My opinion on this is clear. I agree with his punishment because he not only physically assaulted her but she “suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder” (New York Times). She has to carry that tragic memory and be traumatized for the rest of her life.

    Read More

  • Youth Crime In Canad Article Analysis

    545 Words  | 3 Pages

    She was reported to be using cruise control and had an illegal blood alcohol level of .07. She was also texting and over the speed limit by 20 km /h. The family of the teens feel that they were not given justice. The Crown demanded 5 years in an adult sentence, but instead she was given the harshest possible sentence under the YCJA.

    Read More

  • Case Study Brent Small Case

    79 Words  | 1 Pages

    In regards to the Brent Small case, I personally believe that Mr. Smalls shouldn't be found guilty due to the lack of evidence. Although there was a witness who saw what happened, the evidence isn’t consistent with the case. The vehicle did match the description but the witness was unsure of the license plate and the damage to the vehicle isn’t significant to the crime committed. I don't believe that the evidence is strong enough to convict Mr. Smalls.

    Read More

  • What Typology Of Rapist Would Best Describe Parker Ray?

    801 Words  | 4 Pages

    Argue your position (should she or should she not have faced prosecution for her role in the crimes?) I don’t believe that this deal should have been taken. The evidence against him was so strong that no doubt he was going to be convicted and sentenced to the maximum penalty. I feel that his daughter was an intergral part of these crimes.

    Read More

  • Hurst's Sixth Amendment Essay

    1820 Words  | 8 Pages

    I am writing separately because I do not believe Florida’s sentencing scheme violates Hurst’s sixth amendment. I agree with the dissent that Apprendi and Ring should be overruled in favor of something more in line with Walton and our precedent prior to the new millennium. I concur in the judgment, however, because the jury’s role in Florida’s capital sentencing scheme is unconstitutional. Florida does not require unanimity or a feeling of responsibility by the jury in the death sentencing scheme. Also, Florida only requires a simple-majority vote to render its verdict instead of one that is unanimous.

    Read More

  • Anthony V. State Of Florida Case No. 5D11-2357

    416 Words  | 2 Pages

    The verdict in this case generated an epidemic of outrage throughout the world. I agree with the not-guilty verdict on the murder one and two charges; however, the evidence is not as incontrovertible as some have suggested. I also agree that there was some mischaracterization around the 31 days; yet, to trivialize this behavior as simply immature is inaccurate. The way Casey handled the death was inexcusable.

    Read More

  • Evan Miller Case

    1038 Words  | 5 Pages

    The Court relied on distinct “strands of precedent” to justify its Miller conclusion. According to the Court, the two classifications for proportionality challenges are the length of term-of-years, accounting for the attendant circumstances; and categorical restrictions when imposing the death penalty (Darden, 2014). There were five factors introduced with Miller’s case by the Supreme Court. The five characteristics or consequences of juveniles’ immaturity relevant for mitigation of

    Read More

  • What Is The Case Of R. V. Bann-Verdict Rationale

    1822 Words  | 8 Pages

    R. V. Bann - Verdict Rationale In the case of R. V. Bann, Bobbie Bann, the defendant, was charged with second-degree murder. Around the 14th day of June, the year 2015, in the City of Mariposa in the County of Missinaba, Mr.Bann committed second-degree murder on Fallon King, who was in the bathroom when she killed by gunshots. During the trial, it was a little confusing, the defense side was making objections almost the entire time, and it is a little difficult to follow, however, I did manage to found some evidence that indicates that Mr.Bann has murdered and caused the death of Ms. King.

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Robert Xie Case

    616 Words  | 3 Pages

    In this case, the cases R v Dean, R v Baker and R v Villa, were cited and used as a precedent stating that “where multiple murders are committed by the one offender, the offender’s culpability for each murder is informed by his culpability for all the murders”. Due to the similar situations in which multiple murders occurred in those cases, it was used as a referral for the sentence given. STATUTE Section 19A (1) of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) states that life imprisonment is utmost punishment for murder. This was a main factor that contributed to his sentence – life imprisonment. The other reason for this was Section 61(1) of the Crimes (Sentencing) Procedure Act 1999 (NSW) (“the Sentencing Act”).

    Read More

  • Agatha Christie's And Then There Were None

    751 Words  | 4 Pages

    She was often sick, which could have been a bigger influence. Since there are multiple influences on a person, this judge should not be able to determine if an influencer should have consequences or not. People should be responsible for their actions; however, due to an infinite amount of influences on a person’s life, not everyone should have repercussions. Likewise, only people who committed an act of murder should have consequences created by an unbiased court and not the morals of one man. Although the justice system cannot get every case completely correct, using a court builds a standardized procedure in order to obtain the most accurate results.

    Read More

  • Piggy Palace Murders Case Study

    692 Words  | 3 Pages

    The state also withdrew countless evidence from the jury as a means of reducing prejudice against Pickton, and only focusing on the murders. The Vancouver Sun wrote in 2010, eight years after Pickton’s arrest on the “tremendous amount of damning evidence… that the jurors deciding his fate did not hear during his year long trial” (Culbert 2010). Pickton is in prison for life, but due to the states significant withdrawal of evidence, to protect Pickton’s character, the jury “found Pickton not guilty of first-degree murder in the deaths of [the] six women, but guilty of the lesser charge of second-degree murder” (Culbert

    Read More

More about The Sentence: Case Study

Open Document