The Similarities And Differences Of Walt Whitman And Herman Melville's Poetry
One’s view of poetry is extremely personal. With over fifty-five different formal styles of poetry to choose from (Kennedy & Gioia 681-717) no two individual’s tastes will coincide, the same can be said for poets. No one will argue that Walt Whitman and Herman Melville have vastly different techniques for chronicling the events they experienced. This is especially true for the author’s interpretations of events leading up to, throughout, and after the American Civil War. Although they approached their subject from the same vantage point, that of the Union or Northern Army, both author’s writing styles could not be more different. Melville and Whitman’s family history, personal experiences, professional interactions and literary notoriety all factor into their chosen poetic style and content. The following is a critical analysis of these similarities and differences using select works from Melville’s Battle-Pieces and Aspects of the War and Whitman’s Leaves of Grass. The list of recommended poems is not sufficient to adequately fulfill this requirement. For thoroughness, additional poems …show more content…
Preparation for war and the optimism and exuberance of youth ultimately leading to a predetermined end, death and discouragement, is the theme of the poem. The rhythm or meter is predominately Iambic Tetrameter with occasional Trochaic Tetrameter, a foot comprised of one stressed followed by an unstressed syllable. Almost every line of the piece is terminated with end rhyme with occasional oblique rhyme as in lines 16 & 17 “call & prodigal” and eye rhyme in lines 18 & 21 “wooed & neighborhood”. The poem has no set style; a Cinquain five line stanza, a Sestet six line stanza, three Couplets, a Quatrain four line stanza, a Couplet, two non-rhyming lines, a Tercet three line stanza, another Couplet, finished with another
A Brief Summary Of All Quiet On The Western Front
2138 Words | 9 PagesShort Summary of Book: The book offers various poems talking about the Civil War. It tells how the war has changed people and the things they had to endure. A very informational text about the war from different perspectives. Brief Evaluation of quality: I think this book presents original ideas in a poetry format. It is relevant to students because it gives them information about the civil war.
Comparing Heroism In The Works Of Abraham Lincoln And Frederick Douglass
329 Words | 2 PagesIn the White House Funeral Sermon Gurley gave, he speaks about how Lincoln pushed forward in life and how his heroism shall be remembered and incorporated into the post-Civil War country. Similarly, it is shown in Whitman’s poem, “O Captain! My Captain!”, that
Comparing Carl Sandburg's Grass And At The Un-National Border
874 Words | 4 Pages“Only the dead have seen the end of war.” This quote by renowned Spanish-American philosopher George Santayana immaculately encapsulates the core message that is conveyed in both the poems “Grass” and “At the Un-National Monument along the Canadian Border.” The two poems employ disparate writing styles and divergent methods to describe the atrocities of war and violence, however both poems do ultimately condemn these inexcusable acts. Furthermore, beyond denouncing war, both poems greatly emphasize a part of war that is often neglected; how we choose to remember wars and how we must not allow ourselves to forget these brutal lessons of the past. Carl Sandburg and William E. Stafford both lived through numerous periods of violence, epochs where
Herman Melville's Impact On American Literature
975 Words | 4 PagesHerman Melville and his Impact on American Literature “He who has not failed somewhere… that man cannot be great.” This is a quote by Herman Melville that he lived by throughout his life as he struggled to harness a steady income and share his thoughts through literature. Herman Melville’s writings influenced America mainly after his death as we discovered the underlying beauty and validity of his literature, developed from his years of experience as a seaman. There are many reasons why Herman Melville is considered one of the most decorated literary authors of his time. Melville learned to work from a young age when his father passed away shortly after going bankrupt in the fur business(“American Experience”).
The Accomplishments Of Frederick Douglass
1053 Words | 5 PagesFrederick Douglass' compositions reflected numerous American perspectives that were impacted by national division. Douglass was an exceptionally effective abolitionist who changed America's perspectives of bondage through his compositions and activities. Frederick Douglass had numerous accomplishments for the duration of his life. Douglass was conceived a slave in 1817, in Maryland. He taught himself and ended up noticeably resolved to get away from the barbarities of bondage.
I Hear America Singing And I Too Essay
835 Words | 4 PagesIn the two poems the reader can see many examples of figurative language. In the poem, “I Hear America Singing,” Whitman
Comparing Dickinson And Whitman's Poetry
932 Words | 4 PagesTo begin, it’s important for the two poets to led the readers to understand the context about death behind their poems and how it has inspired them to write about it. Throughout Dickinson’s life, she has experienced death in many ways and forms: with that, death has made a great impact in her writings. In Dickinson’s poem, “I heard a Fly buzz – when I died –,” Dickinson looks into the physical procedure of dying and how it affects not just herself, but others as well. When Dickinson was dying on her deathbed, she describes the fly as a figure of the theme death itself, as the wings of the fly basically cuts off the speaker of the poem. For Whitman, he has experienced death in the time of the Civil War.
The Wound Dresser By Walt Whitman Analysis
914 Words | 4 PagesWalt Whitman captures his audience’s attention with his realism poetry and free verse poetry throughout much of his life as a poet. Whitman was a man of the civil war era and in his poem “The Wound-Dresser” shows his life experiences in the war come full force in the way he conveys his contribution in the civil war. His view of the war as a wound-dresser and he describes some of the most horrendous scenes imaginable from the eyes of an everyday man. His poem “The Wound-Dresser” doesn’t show the war from a distance, but from right on the battlefield in its unedited version as written by Whitman. The way Whitman conveys his poems of the everyday man’s life in his time-period is presented by utilizing his realism style to connect to the audience and his gruesomely descriptive vocabulary.
Similarities Between Emily Dickinson And Walt Whitman
1279 Words | 6 PagesBoth poets are very similar to each other in a way that both of them lived in the nineteenth century. "The two giants of 19th-century American poetry who played the greatest role in redefining modern verse are Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson (Burt)". Both Emily Dickinson and Walt Whitman are considered as the founders of today’s modern American poetry, whose they put the keystone, and which was further developed by other poets over the years. The poetry has been redefined. The modern poetry becomes more discreet which uses the topics of everyday life.
Change In American Literature
970 Words | 4 PagesThis poem was written with clear and distinct points of view involving a conflict and resolution. American Literature emerged into a different theme before the end of World War II due to the major changes happening in the south. This movement birthed two extraordinary writers, William Faulkner and Zora Neale Hurston that spoke of the south
American Literature: Literature Changed Over Time
1749 Words | 7 PagesIn this poem Henry Longfellow describes a seaside scene in which dawn overcomes darkness, thus relating to the rising of society after the hardships of battle. The reader can also see feelings, emotions, and imagination take priority over logic and facts. Bridging the Romantic Era and the Realism Era is the Transcendental Era. This era is unusual due to it’s overlapping of both the Romantic and Realism Era. Due to its coexistence in two eras, this division serves as a platform for authors to attempt to establish a new literary culture aside from the rest of the world.
War Is Kind Poem Analysis
740 Words | 3 PagesThis all helps to result in the patriotic theme of the poem by giving us a representation of how unpatriotic the war was. To conclude the poem “War is Kind” By Stephen Crane includes three universal themes commonly seen in many examples of civil war literature. The themes of warfare, war on the home front, and patriotism occur in the poem as well as many other pieces of civil war literature. The overall theme of the poem is how war is cruel and unkind making the poem seem like mockery to those who believe war is
Comparing Moby Dick And The Scarlet Letter
267 Words | 2 PagesIn Herman Melville’s lifetime his writing was not popular or well known. It wasn’t until after his death that his literacy work showed more and more promise to who he was at a writer. While knowing that he wanted to be a writer, Melville did not write about the things that interested his surrounding society. Instead he wrote about the adventures he had on his voyage and wrote about the elaborate experiences he endured.
Critical Analysis Of Walt Whitman's Song Of Myself
938 Words | 4 PagesIn Walt Whitman’s “Song of Myself’, one can appreciate the poem properly by understanding the poem’s voice, imagery, figures of speech, symbols, word choice, and theme. To understand it though requires a great deal of thought to arrive to the meaning behind the writing. Especially since this poem was written in the nineteenth century and is written in a very loose structure and free verse. Firstly, the speaker of the poem is an individual, Walt Whitman himself, as seen by the repetition of “I” in the poem.
Analysis Of The Last Laugh By Wilfred Owen
1730 Words | 7 PagesA heroic couplet structure within the poem provides a degree of clarity while still asserting the chaos and cruelness of war. Once again, it can be inferred that Owen himself serves as the speaker. However, this time his audience is more focused on young soldiers and families rather than plainly the public in general. In contrast to the previous work, this poem is set primarily in a World War I training camp, signifying the process young soldiers go through prior to deployment to the front line. The tone of this poem is more foreboding and condemnatory, not only describing the training soldiers but outright degrading their forced involvement as morally wrong.
More about The Similarities And Differences Of Walt Whitman And Herman Melville's Poetry
A Brief Summary Of All Quiet On The Western Front
2138 Words | 9 PagesComparing Heroism In The Works Of Abraham Lincoln And Frederick Douglass
329 Words | 2 PagesComparing Carl Sandburg's Grass And At The Un-National Border
874 Words | 4 PagesHerman Melville's Impact On American Literature
975 Words | 4 PagesThe Accomplishments Of Frederick Douglass
1053 Words | 5 PagesI Hear America Singing And I Too Essay
835 Words | 4 PagesComparing Dickinson And Whitman's Poetry
932 Words | 4 PagesThe Wound Dresser By Walt Whitman Analysis
914 Words | 4 PagesSimilarities Between Emily Dickinson And Walt Whitman
1279 Words | 6 PagesChange In American Literature
970 Words | 4 PagesAmerican Literature: Literature Changed Over Time
1749 Words | 7 PagesWar Is Kind Poem Analysis
740 Words | 3 PagesComparing Moby Dick And The Scarlet Letter
267 Words | 2 PagesCritical Analysis Of Walt Whitman's Song Of Myself
938 Words | 4 PagesAnalysis Of The Last Laugh By Wilfred Owen
1730 Words | 7 Pages