g room sprawled out on the couch. She then called for her maid, Bridget. Soon after, a neighbor, Alice Russell, came over to comfort Lizzie. The neighbor ended up finding Abby Borden's body upstairs in one of the family’s bedrooms. Abby was said to be killed first, about ninety minutes before Andrew. This was explained by the different body temperatures of the corpses. Abby’s body was cold, which meant that she died first. However, Andrew’s body was still warm, so he had to have been killed last (Trial of Lizzie Borden). After the police investigated the crime scene they were confused. They could not find anything that had blood on it, but when the police looked at the evidence further they realized that the murderer had to have been in the …show more content…
During the interview an Assistant Marshal of Falls River, John Fleet, called Abby Borden Lizzie's “mother” during an interview. Lizzie then responded by saying, “‘she was not my mother, sir’ (Lizzie said) ‘she was my stepmother. My mother died when I was a child’” (Trial of Lizzie Borden). Emma and Lizzie never called Abby Borden mother, “They greeted her as ‘Mrs. Borden’” (Lizzie Borden Biography). The two sisters did not care for their stepmother at all. They believed that she had only married their father for his money. (Trial of Lizzie Borden). However Bridget’s, the Borden's maid, testimony said that Lizzie and her step mother got along together. Bridget said that “Lizzie and her mother always spoke to each other,” but, nobody else reported the same thought (Trial of Lizzie Borden). Everyone else said that Lizzie and her stepmother never got along, and that they would argue with each other often. The day before the murders of Mrs. and Mr. Borden, witnesses saw Lizzie at Smith's Drugstore. The worker at the drugstore claimed Lizzie was trying to buy prussic acid. However, Lizzie claimed she needed the acid to clean a sealskin cape. The worker then refused to sell it to her based on the fact that it was considered a poison (Trail of Lizzie …show more content…
Lizzie never cared for her stepmother and they never were nice to each other and sometimes they would argue. Lizzie did show some emotion at the crime scene, which conflicted with the answers she gave when she was getting interviewed. She got upset when an investigator called Abby Borden her mother and explained that Abby Borden would never be her mother. Confusingly though she never said anything about her father. Lizzie actually loved her father, they had a good relationship. When Andrew was found dead on the couch he had a ring on his finger that Lizzie had given him a long time ago. Which does not explain why she would murder her father. Even though this murder was left unsolved it seems clear that Lizzie Borden Is the one who murdered Mrs. and Mr.
“The barn loft where she said she looked revealed no footprints on the dusty floor and the stifling heat in the loft seemed discouraging for anyone to spend more than a few minutes searching for anything”(Lizzie borden: an account pg 2. This means that she couldn’t have been able to spend a lot of time up there, but evidence showed that it was undisturbed due to the fact that no footprints were left on the dusty floor, so she was somewhere else in the house A second piece of evidence that was recovered was an axe that she claimed that the blood on it was from the farmer killing some pigeons. “He killed some pigeons in the barn last may or June” (Lizzie Rue2 borden's Inquest pg 11). If that were the case that he killed them last june the blood would’ve been dry, but earlier in the documents she claimed the last time he came was in the winter
“August 4, 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden are murdered in their home in Fall River, Massachusetts.” Chery Eddy Lizzie Borden is arrested for the murder of her father and stepmother. ... Lizzie Borden was found not guilty But I think that she was. The first reason, I think lizzie borden was the murderer because of the suspicious behavior before and after the murder. A clean, handle-free hatchet blade was found in the basement, which was the only reason it was suggested murder weapon.
The most plausible theory is Lizzie Borden the daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Borden who allegedly murdered them. To start with, Samantha M. Gavin, a full-time lecturer in Administration of Justice, describes her past relationship with both her father and stepmother,¨Lizzie's relationship with her father and stepmother was unstable¨(Borden, Lizzie 1860-1927). The morose and unstable relationship between Lizzie Borden, her Father, and her Stepmother possibly was the motive for the killings. After the police came, the bodies were found. In an interview with Lizzie Borden, they noticed it had been strange that she showed no signs of grief, and remarked a snarky comment when speaking about her stepmother (Mooney).
The Axe Grinding Mystery of the Borden Murders “Lizzie Borden took an axe and gave her mother forty whacks and when she saw what she had done she gave her father forty one.” These famous words are dedicated to the suspected murderess, Lizzie Borden. Plenty of people feel as if Lizzie was not guilty of the murders, but many think she was. There is evidence for both sides of this daunting mystery, but no one really knows the truth: did Lizzie really commit this crime? Many questions are raised due to the Borden murders, and much evidence connects to the two theories, whether Lizzie murdered her parents or not.
Lizzie is not guilty, and I know this from the several testimonies that i read over. Some of the testimonies prove to themselves about how she is innocent. The small testimonies mostly I see that there is more evidence, the bigger testimonies like Emma Borden’s I believe does not show as much with Lizzie. All of the hidden evidence of Lizzie’s case is not mentioned enough, they grab all the evidence that can be possibly useless and focus on it more.
First of all, Lizzie Borden did not have a close relationship with her stepmother, she sent various people to complete many errands right after the murderers, and she was also accused as a thief by any people. To begin with, Lizzie Borden demonstrated a hateful relationship with her stepmother. She never accepted her stepmother into
I read through all the witness testimonies and Lizzie Borden is guilty let me tell you why. All these testimonies mentioned something that made her look guilty. here’s why, she changed the story way too much, Lizzie Borden burned a really big piece of evidence, she also could have been jealous of her stepmother because her father bought her stepmother Abby Borden a house. Lizzie Borden seems to change her answers a lot in the very last document. Let me explain to you why she is guilty.
At the time of the trial, Lizzie Borden, changed her story multiple times, she was inconsistent. Borden also had a history of stealing from her stepmother and would often blame someone else (Hartselle, 2013). During the trial she showed no emotion about her parents having been murdered (Hartselle,
Police and investigators believed that Lizzie Borden was the murderer because of the fact
For example, She was the only one in the house with the motive to do so so she killed her parents in cold blood. The hatchet was found in the basement downstairs in the secluded part of the house. Why would that just put a perfectly good hatchet head in the basement to go to waste and just rust away. For instanse, Lizzie tried to hide or burn the valuable evidence before she screamed for so she wouldn't be the person everyone looked at first. She was seen trying to burn a dress with red "paint" on it.
She was acquitted however. This verdict still causes speculation, even over 100 years after the trial. Many found the verdict correct, she could not have killed her parents. Lizzie did not fit the cold-blooded type; she was a woman and a regular church goer. Her defendants claim the evidence against her was all circumstantial.
According to my evidence of the Borden sisters’ family friction, Lizzie and Emma’s behavior, Andrew and Lizzie’s feud hold the facts to prove Lizzie and Emma committed this crime. Lizzie and Emma always protected each other like a sister pact. To begin with, Lizzie and Emma had family friction leading up to the murders. (Doug Linder, 2004) The
Have you ever been very upset with your parents and said bad things, like, “I hope you die.” Lizzie Borden was accused in 1860 of killing her father and stepmother. The interesting thing was that she was found innocent but everything pointed towards her committing the murders. Still to this day people are still trying to find out who murdered the two. I feel that Lizzie did commit the murders.
On the date of August 4, 1892 Andrew and Abby Borden were axe murdered in their home, Lizzie should be guilty because she was the only person in the house during the time of the murders in about a 90 minute period of time, The dust in the barn was undisturbed, and she burned the dress ( Evidence). To begin, Lizzie claimed that during the fifteen minutes in which Andrew Borden was murdered in the living room, “Excepting the two or three minutes you were down cellar, where you away from the house until your father came in?” stated in the lizzie borden inquest (Page #5) during her questioning, Yet she said she was in the cellar during Andrew Borden’s death In addition Lizzie claimed “I went out to the barn. I don't know what time he
In the controversial court case of Lizzie Borden the innocent verdict correctly acquitted the suspect because she is did not posses the physical and mental ability to kill her parents, there are many other suspicious suspects that did not get attention, and they had no hard physical evidence that led Lizzie to the murders. People