ipl-logo

The Use Of Cochlear Implants In True Biz By Sara Polish

531 Words3 Pages

Sara Nović’s novel True Biz is, at its core, a depiction of the struggle between the Deaf community and its hearing counterpart. Much of the book is spent describing how hearing people who fail to understand the Deaf community have mainstreamed their deaf children through the use of ASL deprivation and the use of cochlear implants. Nović feels pride about the Deaf community and wants to teach us about it so that we in the hearing world can better help to prevent its destruction. Unfortunately, in doing this, Nović has painted a one-sided picture regarding the use of cochlear implants by failing to include examples of successful ones, her depiction of Austin's family struggle around the issue, and most importantly, by glorifying the destruction of the bionics lab. …show more content…

So Yeon Kim, Dr. Min Bum Kim, and Dr. Won-ho Chung, over 18 years (2001-2019), 4.6 percent (43 out of 925) of patients with cochlear implants experienced failure of the devices of some kind. In other words, more than 95 percent of the devices are successful in the long run. This information makes the lack of a main character with a successful implant all the more confusing. Nović has, in failing to include a character like this, created a one-sided depiction of the Deaf community without much of the nuance surrounding this complicated issue. The undue focus on implant failure, the most glaring example of which is when Charlie’s implant fails on stage, causing her to feel like “her mouth was cottony thick, jaw tight” and like "her body was a hummingbirds thrum” (320). While it is, of course, critical to show the harms of cochlear implants and include examples of cases like Charlie’s, experiences like that are the minority, and depicting only experiences like Charlie’s is not accurate

Show More
Related

  • Cochlear Implants In Deaf Culture

    664 Words  | 3 Pages

    Sound and Fury centers two families who faced a challenging decision on whether to get a cochlear implant for their deaf child. Peter and his wife Nina are both deaf and gave birth to three deaf children. Neither Peter’s brother Chris nor wife Mari are deaf but one of their twin boys was born deaf. Peter and Nina are proud of being part of the Deaf community therefore they’re not as open to the idea of cochlear implants. On the contrary Mari and Chris, although having deaf in their families, are not involved in the Deaf culture and have a more positive outlook on cochlear implants.

    Read More

  • Charlie's Hearing Loss In Speak To Me By Marcia Forecki

    1134 Words  | 5 Pages

    When her family got tired of her excuses they tried to convince her that there was, in fact, an issue with Charlie’s hearing they took every occasion to demonstrate Charles's poor response to noises. When her parents spoke to Marica about setting up an appointment for Charlie’s hearing she became very defensive. But seeing as to how she needed the support of her family to reestablish her single life she chose to compromise and an appointment was

    Read More

  • Cochlear Implants In The Film Sound And Fury

    644 Words  | 3 Pages

    On October 25th in the year 2000, a film was release that tackled the difficult topic, that at the time, broke family ties and rattled an entire culture from a single procedure. In Josh Aronson’s film, “Sound and Fury”, the topic of cochlear implants was fought about between an extended family, who both had Deaf children. The families thought very differently about the cochlear implant procedure and this lead to many arguments and even splitting of the families for some time. The cochlear implant procedure threatens Deaf culture and was considered very offensive to the Deaf community. Throughout the documentary, these topics were debated back and forth, about whether the benefits outweighed the risks.

    Read More

  • A Journey Into The Deaf World Chapter 1 Summary

    1384 Words  | 6 Pages

    As well as the challenge of many professionals encouraging put in hearing aids, making their child “hearing impaired”. Hearing parents are usually unsure of what to do, and end up following the path the professionals recommend. The book really helps emphasize the importance of not doing that. Instead, exposing a the child into the Deaf community would be the best option. They’ll be welcomed with wide arms, and it will help them feel most true to themselves.

    Read More

  • Cochlear Implants Video Summary

    546 Words  | 3 Pages

    From watching the video I've learned a lot of interesting things. Some Deaf people although there's a implant called cochlear implant that would basically give them hope of hearing wouldn't want to do it because some of them said that they're so used to the Deaf culture and that it wouldn't really change how they are as a person. Some said they wouldn't want to undergo cochlear implant because hearing wouldn't change anything and that they're happy of how they are born, and that they love their language they don't care about having an implants. There is a guy in the video and he said that Deaf people are normal, although they have some accommodations to be made to survive in a society where it's dominated by hearing people, but at the same time, if a hearing person come into the room and it would be full of Deaf people then that hearing person would need the accommodation as well which is true, I felt that when we came into few of the Deaf events.

    Read More

  • Ted Talk By Keith Nolan Ethos Logos

    807 Words  | 4 Pages

    Nolan can speak on and about this issue due to his experience of being deaf while trying to join the military. Due to his experience, he can now persuade the readers and audience by demonstrating credibility. Nolan shares three main facts to support his argument about the deaf joining the military. "The first being the Israeli defense openly accepts deaf soldiers. The second is the US Military has accommodations for retaining their disabled soldiers.

    Read More

  • Cochlear Implants: The Deaf Community In Sound And Fury

    1336 Words  | 6 Pages

    In the documentary, Sound and Fury, the daughter of Peter and Nita, Heather, wanted a cochlear implant, but in the end, her parents decided not to get her the implant although three years later, Heather received the cochlear implant. Although Heather was about ten years old when she finally received the cochlear implant, she was able to learn to speak and listen without previous exposure to sounds before the surgery. In the documentary, a group of Deaf people were shocked by Chris and Mari’s decision to implant their son who was only an infant at the time. While the Deaf community may be somewhat showing some acceptance towards the cochlear implants now, issues about when to implant a child remains and if the decision should rest solely on

    Read More

  • Summary Of A Lens On Deaf Identities By Irene W. Leigh

    911 Words  | 4 Pages

    He says that after coming out as both gay and HIV positive, he says that he hopes to be a role model for Deaf youths: “It is important for learners to know that I am both Deaf and IV positive as Deaf learners do not have any HIV positive role models… In the Deaf world, HIV is still highly stigmatized and there are no Deaf people that I know of besides myself who are publicly out as HIV positive. ”5 Meltese has gone on to become a largely prominent HIV/Aids activist in both Hearing and Deaf communities, even through his initial depression and shock after learning he was positive. However, we also learn that while Meltese has worked to both accept and see his

    Read More

  • Cochlear Informative Speech

    137 Words  | 1 Pages

    Have you ever thought why cochlear implants are a controversial issue? Some people tend to say that the cochlear implant is a great idea to give the child a chance in the future while others (a.k.a the deaf world) say that the cochlear implant will only make the child to not be interested in the deaf culture. Well to begin with, a cochlear implant is mainly an electronic device which replaces the function of the damaged inner ear. Unlike hearing aids, cochlear implants are planted inside your head to actually send sound signals to the brain through the device. The cochlear implants will only help the child and not change their identities because there are meant to help the child, improve their future, and to be able to be part of both the hearing

    Read More

  • Harrison Bergeron Figurative Language

    1138 Words  | 5 Pages

    In the world of “Harrison Bergeron '' the society craves a standardized population in order to avoid self-disparaging emotions which in turn foster competition. One way that they enforce this is the use of various handicaps, one being earpieces. One protagonist, George Bergeron is described as having a higher than average intelligence. To ensure George isn’t able to use his brain more than the rest of the population, the government forces him to wear an earpiece that plays sounds at ear splitting volume. About the earpiece, Vonnegu writes that it is “required by law” and that the loud noises are necessary to prevent “people like George from taking unfair advantage of their brains,” (Vonnegut 872).

    Read More

  • Essay On Cochlear Implants

    941 Words  | 4 Pages

    At both sides of the argument, cochlear implants are a sensitive topic amongst the deaf community and those trying to further advancements on the cochlear implant device. The deaf community views the implants as a sense of false hope, false information and a long, disappointing

    Read More

  • Inside Deaf Culture Summary

    1036 Words  | 5 Pages

    Inside Deaf Culture Inside deaf culture is a very strong book written by carol Padden and tom Humphries in this book authors have tried to give a tour of the most important moments that has shaped the Deaf culture. Book starts by showing how much power hearing people have had over the deaf population in the past and how they saw death people almost the same as criminals and also how they tried to get rid of them by placing them into asylums and intuitions and how this was a beginning of first schools for the deaf and how much power and control they had over the children under their care also there was a lot of rumors of how children were molested in these schools and because they

    Read More

  • Cochlear Implants Persuasive Essay

    692 Words  | 3 Pages

    The down fall of cochlear implants is the implants may not work for the patient receiving them. It’s not guaranteed they will work. There could be a chance of infection with the implants as well. Even when implanted it may only improve up to a point even with therapy. For older people the implants are less likely to work than for a child or new born.

    Read More

  • Deaf Like Me Essay

    795 Words  | 4 Pages

    From taking my first-ever ASL class to a Deaf culture class, I have learned a lot about a community that is right under my nose. Reading this book has also changed my outlook for the better on the Deaf culture. Many people stereotype Deaf culture, to be weird or not useful. As a hearing person who has never had to daily communicate within the community, I find myself learning more and more every day about customs and the way of living by the Deaf. I think of the saying some people use “Deaf and Dumb” and I think to myself how this even came to be.

    Read More

  • The Power Of Ruben In The Film The Sound Of Metal

    1216 Words  | 5 Pages

    The honesty that an individual has toward others expresses what they mean or are going through is a hard accomplishment. The accomplishment of being honest with other people is a strength that helps accept the harsh reality of truth in contrast to optimism. In Darius Marder's film The Sound of Metal, the character Ruben has lost his hearing and has been adopted into a deaf community. Ruben has the optimism that a cochlear implant would restore his hearing and allow him to resume his life as a metal drummer, but he soon learns the harsh truth that he won't be able to hear the same.

    Read More

More about The Use Of Cochlear Implants In True Biz By Sara Polish

Open Document