ipl-logo

The Warren Flew Debate On The Existence Of God Summary

991 Words4 Pages

This book report serves as both a brief overview and an evaluation of The Warren-Flew Debate on the Existence of God, which is the manuscript from the oral debate held between Thomas B. Warren and Antony G. Flew in Denton, Texas from September 20 through September 23, 1976. This debate (as suggested by the title) centered on the existence of God, with Flew affirming, “I know that God does not exist,” and Warren affirming, “I know that God does exist.” The debate took place over a period of four nights; each night the speakers had three twenty-minute speeches that were delivered alternately (the affirmative speaker spoke first), and a one and a half minute rejoinder delivered by the affirmative speaker to close each night. Flew was in the affirmative …show more content…

Warren begins by presenting a chart entitled, “Flew’s Prison”. This chart shows six “barriers” that Flew must overcome in order to “know that God does not exist.” Throughout the rest of the debate, Flew does not overcome any of these barriers, and most of them are completely unmentioned by Flew. Warren uses other charts and a list of questions that he submitted to Flew before the debate to begin laying out his negative case against Flew. One of the major arguments that Warren uses is that of the Nazi Germans. According to Flew’s answer on Warren’s questionnaire, the Nazi soldiers committed objective moral wrong, which implies a higher standard than human …show more content…

Flew poses some difficult questions, but (as Warren accurately observes) he does not fulfill his job as the affirmative speaker by laying out a valid argument. Over the course of the debate, Warren obviously proves his case much more effectively than Flew. During the first two nights in the negative, Warren presented convincing evidence to disprove Flew’s case, and during the second two nights, he forms many sound arguments to prove his affirmation of the existence of God. Flew continues to pose “interesting” questions and hint at certain arguments (such as the “problem” of evil), but he forsakes his duty to function as the affirmative/negative speaker on the respective nights and fails to form a precise

Show More
Related

  • Book Report On Night By Elie Wiesel

    1089 Words  | 5 Pages

    How could German workers and soldiers murder millions of families, then go home to their own families? How did these normal people, justify their cruel and ruthless actions? Many of these people were known as

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Warren Flew Debate

    757 Words  | 4 Pages

    Dr. Flew affirmed in the debate that “I Know That God Does Not Exist” as oppose to Thomas Warren who affirmed that “I Know That God Does Exist.” This is different than other atheist debates who attempt to shift the burden of proof to those who are theist. The theist is given the burden to prove God exists or the atheists wins by default. In this debate, they both were supposed to argue their points of view in the affirmative and later in the second half of the debate brother Warren affirmed “I Know That God Does Exist” and Dr. Flew denied in the

    Read More

  • Hambourger's Argument For The Existence Of God Essay

    829 Words  | 4 Pages

    Hambourger’s argument from design argues for the existence of god based on the perceived evidence of deliberate design in the world/universe. To further elaborate on the concepts he uses, Hambourger uses three main concepts; determinism, chance, and mere hap. Hambourger’s argument from design claims that though many things occur by chance, there are some things which we cannot simply accept to have happened by chance, and must therefore have some common explanation in the causal chain of events connecting the two events. For instance the universe is created by many states of affairs coming together. If some slight changes had occurred, the end result could have been vastly different than it currently is.

    Read More

  • The Civil War As A Theological Crisis By Mark Noll

    796 Words  | 4 Pages

    Many Americans believe the divine wisdom and devoted to Gods holy word; as it provides purpose and give stability to their lives. In Mark Noll’s book entitled The Civil War as a Theological Crisis, the religious leaders of that time leading up to the Civil War were unable to provide answers to some of the most difficult question of that era; does the Bible condone or does the Bible condemn slavery? Americans were at odds over the understanding of God’s divine word as both Northern and Southerners tried to find meaning on this war and what Gods role was in it. How could either side claim to have the support of God through his word for their position? Clashes over the interpretation of the Bible on slavery were matched during the era of the Civil

    Read More

  • What Does Michael Bess And Richard Overy Bring To Study World War II?

    1193 Words  | 5 Pages

    He also wants the reader to better understand and contemplate how these moral decisions impacted the course of the war and postwar era. He asks the difficult moral questions that challenge the moral clarity and high ground that we tend to view the World War II with. Richard Overy begins Why the Allies

    Read More

  • The Sunflower By Simon Wiesenthal Summary

    686 Words  | 3 Pages

    All the orders Nazi soldiers obeyed are crimes that refuse forgiveness because these orders show us how evil soldiers’ hearts were when they killed millions of innocent Jewish people; consequently, we cannot forgive them because this action will go beyond our

    Read More

  • Themes In Night By Elie Wiesel

    1059 Words  | 5 Pages

    When one is being forced to endure the abysmal conditions of those who were imprisoned by Nazi soldiers, one becomes desperate. In times of desperation, the morality of individuals is questioned, to others as well as themselves - whether they realize it or not. Prisoners of

    Read More

  • What Was The Significance Of The Scopes Trial

    837 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Scopes Trial began on July 10th, 1925 in Dayton, Tennessee when John Thomas Scopes was charged with violating the Butler Act by teaching the theory of evolution in his class by saying men have descended from apes claiming that was the theory of evolution. The prosecuting attorney William Bryant was flooded with questions from the bible by defending attorney Clarence Darrow, several he could not answer. William Bryant, a Christian, could not defend the Bible nor his beliefs and the point of being a certain religion is to understand what you believe and why you believe it. Furthermore, what makes this trial significant is that till this day we still have that debate of how were we created, whether it’s from the religion we possess or from

    Read More

  • How Important Was The Scopes Trial In American History

    1161 Words  | 5 Pages

    Dayton, Tennessee July 1925, The State of Tennessee vs. John Thomas Scopes. One of the most publicized trials in American history that held a great impact on the argument between fundamentalists and modernists. The Scopes Trial is still one of the most significant trials in American history. It was actually a case that had a broader importance, rather than a case about evolution in schools and the case has left a lasting impression on America. The State of Tennessee vs. John Thomas Scopes took place in the hot summer of 1925 Dayton, Tennessee and featured the likes of John Scopes, Clarence Darrow, and William Jennings Bryan.

    Read More

  • JL Mackie's Argument For The Existence Of God?

    295 Words  | 2 Pages

    JL Mackie was persuasive in his argument by showing that belief in an almighty God is not rational. He proves this by posing the problem of evil. According to JL Mackie, if God exists and is omniscient, omnipotent, and good then evil would not exist. However, evil exists in this world, sometimes in the form of undeserved suffering (diseases that affect humans, earthquakes, famines ...) and others perpetrated by man (murders, wars ...). If God exists and has the capability to be powerful, good, omniscient and omnipotent, why would he let evil be perpetrated?

    Read More

  • Anselm's Argument For The Existence Of God

    550 Words  | 3 Pages

    Anselm was a Greek philosopher who was born in 1033 in Aosta, Italy. He was a Benedictine abbot in France who went into self-imposed exile to protest King William II of England and he was also a disciple of Augustine and he promoted a lot of Augustine’s teachings and beliefs. Anselm held the office of archbishop of Canterbury from 1093 to 1109, because in 1109 Anselm died. After his death in 1109 he was canonized as a saint, and his feast day is on April 21. Anselm believed that it was not possible to think of absolutely nothing.

    Read More

  • Response To Atheism

    1901 Words  | 8 Pages

    Response to “On Being an Atheist” Ida Hart PHIL 201 – B30 LUO Dr. David Beck McCloskey’s article, “On Being an Atheist” contains arguments that he uses to explain Atheism, the non-existence of God. Using the claims made by theists and attempting to taint the character and nature of the Christian God, he points out what he calls several defects of the arguments. In his introduction he offers a brief reminder to fellow atheist stating the grounds and the inadequacies of these grounds for theism. He later calls them “proofs”, alleging that the proofs do not provide adequate justification for believing that God exists. This only proves that he is among the many that choose to use the arguments in the wrong way.

    Read More

  • Mackie's Evil And Omnipotence

    933 Words  | 4 Pages

    The question that is asked time and time again is whether or not god exists. It is evident that people hold different beliefs. It is evident that through some of the beliefs of J.L. Mackie that it could be argued that God does not actually exist. I find this argument to be more agreeable. In Mackie’s Evil and Omnipotence, he argues many points to support why it should be believed that god does not exist.

    Read More

  • The Evil Genius And The Ontological Argument For The Existence Of God Analysis

    1202 Words  | 5 Pages

    Topic 1: The Evil Genius and the Ontological Argument for the Existence of God The Evil Genius figure created by Rene Descartes offers a claim that such a being could exist. He created such a deceiver in order to prove his own existence and to prove that if a doubt is germinating in his mind then for the doubt to exist he should too. However, Descartes does not provide enough support for his claim of its possibility i.e. the evil genius exists.

    Read More

  • Religious Language Analysis

    638 Words  | 3 Pages

    Religion and how language together helped shaped our nation I found this week’s articles written by Bellah and Rokem a very informative and engaging read. Upon reading the material presented, I contained quite a few compelling things. From Bellah I could detect how our early founding fathers helped shape the constitution with a set of beliefs, symbols, and rituals that according to Bellah, is the American civil religion. Through Rokem, I gained valuable insight into the growing customs of our words including some religious context sometimes provoking violence.

    Read More

More about The Warren Flew Debate On The Existence Of God Summary

Open Document