ipl-logo

The Wife Of Marin Guerre Analysis

441 Words2 Pages

As a feminist growing up in a increasingly feminist society, The Wife of Marin Guerre struck a note for me more so than the movie. Love is beautiful, however, when someone gets a love they don’t deserve from someone they don’t deserve, that lacks justice, and justice occurs naturally around us through the principle of karma. Bertrande is a strong and empowered woman. This wasn’t an ordinary personality trait for women in the 1500’s. In fact, in countless towns, it was frowned upon. Feminism wasn’t even a potential idea yet let alone a movement. Regardless, realistically, Bertrande would not have stuck around with the man who left her “in the full beauty of her youth” (Lewis, 26). It wouldn’t be reasonable for her to do so. She was alone for …show more content…

The sisters tell Bertrande that the truth “is only the truth for you, not for us…you would destroy us all. We shall never be happy again. The farm will never prosper again.” (Lewis, 76) The sisters ask Bertrande to lie only to save them. They don’t question whether that will be a just decision or if it is an appropriate move for Bertrande’s future. They just desire to maintain their wealth and reputation. Bertrande debates whether it is a smart idea to turn Arnaud in because that would make her out to be an adulteress. Every thought, every word, and every action is followed through with in a selfish manner. This isn’t the proper way for a community to function. If the definition of community is “A group of people living together in one place, especially one practicing common ownership” (Oxford English Dictionary or even simply “A body of nations or states unified by common interests” (Oxford English Dictionary), then this group of merging families aren’t a community. They are working separately together, and that’s bound for failure. A community must work together and listen to one another to even consider themselves a community. Otherwise, they’re just a group of people

Show More
Related

  • The Return Of Martin Guerre By Natalie Zemon Davis

    921 Words  | 4 Pages

    Davis depicts the marriage between Martin Guerre and Bertrande de Rols as a miserable attempt by both parties to better secure personal wealth and status. For Davis, Martin is an impotent and apathetic husband who abandoned a family for whom he cared little for, and Bertrande is a cunning, deceptive peasant woman who maneuvers to better her condition and retain her honor in the male dominated society of the time. The Martin Guerre imposter, Arnaud du Tilh is in Davis’s view an opportunist seeking a better life, who falls in love with the wife of the man he proclaims to be. Davis proposes that a woman such as Bertrande could not have been fooled by the skilled acting of the Martin imposter, especially after three years and the conception of a child. For Davis, Bertrande and Arnaud where accomplices in the deception, Bertrande accepted the imposter has her husband to escape the troubles of living as an abandoned wife.

    Read More

  • Martin Guerre Case Study

    663 Words  | 3 Pages

    1. Describe the possible factors that provoked Martin Guerre to leave his wife. What factor is the most important?

    Read More

  • Themes In The Wife Of Martin Guerre

    876 Words  | 4 Pages

    TWOMG has been described as a classic 16th century love story. Refer to specific stylistic features to argue for/against this. In the wife of Martin Guerre, Janet Lewis uses a range of stylistic feature to create a story that has love as one of the central themes, but that not a “classic love story”. These features include the fairly constant inner monologue of Bertrande, the context surrounding Martin’s relationship with Bertrande, and language choices.

    Read More

  • Bertrande De Rols-Research Essay

    767 Words  | 4 Pages

    As well as underestimating the piety that Bertrande had, Davis may also have overestimated the magnitude of freedom granted to a peasant woman in this place and time period. Women were not yet granted nearly as much freedom as men, and in comparison to today’s standards were under oppression. It is highly unlikely that Bertrande would act with as much freedom as Davis portrays. Bertrande was a young housewife in a peasant village, who may or may not have had the sort of feminist capacity and knowledge required for acting in the way Davis portrays. The women at the time were probably taught to unconditionally obey the man of the house and could do little to improve their circumstances merely on their own.

    Read More

  • Women In Yvain And The Magic Ring

    1456 Words  | 6 Pages

    Chivalric romances are often centered upon the efforts of gallant knights seeking to achieve a concept known as “true knighthood” which involves embarking on quests or adventures to obtain honor, love, and Christian virtue. The brave knights of these stories are met with many obstacles to overcome, commonly in regards to rescuing or protecting a lady. In other words, the typical role of women in this period is that of the damsel in distress or a helpless, dependent lady in need of a hero. However, the stories of Chrétien de Troyes’ Yvain, the Knight of the Lion and Friedrich Heinrich Karl La Motte-Fouqué’s The Magic Ring strays from the typical role of women as the damsel in distress.

    Read More

  • Similarities And Differences Between Anne Bradstreet And Mary Rowlandson

    1438 Words  | 6 Pages

    During the Puritan times gender roles in the society were very anti-feminist. Women were required to act as housewives and do womanly duties such as cook, clean, and take care of their children. Women had very little freedom as far as their rights were concerned also. Puritan writers, Anne Bradstreet and Mary Rowlandson both experienced the struggle of the anti-feminist movement. From their writings we see that they both were against anti-feminism and they tried their best to abandon the whole idea.

    Read More

  • An Analysis Of 'Puppy, By George Saunders Puppy'

    732 Words  | 3 Pages

    How the woman thinks and treat their husband 's also varied because Marie’s life is very exciting, fun, and filled with compassion for those around her. Callie has a tougher outlook on life as she sees no wrong in teaching her children natural selection and pleasing her husband even though the relationship may

    Read More

  • Feminism In The French Revolution Jane Abray Analysis

    244 Words  | 1 Pages

    In her 1975 article, “Feminism in the French Revolution,” Jane Abray provides a dismissive view of women’s movements during the Revolution. In the article, Abray emphasizes the failures of revolutionary feminism. In her opinion, the most compelling reason for revolutionary feminism’s failure was that it was a minority interest that remained inaccessible to the majority of French women who accepted their inferior status to men. Abray suggests additional reasons for the movement’s “abject failure,” including its inability to garner support from the male leaders of the Revolution, the disreputable characters of the feminist leaders, the strategic errors made by the movement’s leaders, and a “spirit of the times” that emphasized the nuclear family

    Read More

  • The Theme Of Love In Edith Wharton's Ethan Frome

    763 Words  | 4 Pages

    However, Wharton does not leave the reader without another question and alternative answer. Despite Mattie’s passionate insistence that death is the only remedy, Wharton is clearly claiming through Frome’s rational consideration of divorcing his wife is the rational alternative to

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Mary Rowlandson And Anne Bradstreet

    1438 Words  | 6 Pages

    During the Puritan times gender roles in the society were very anti-feminist. Women were required to act as housewives and do womanly duties such as cook, clean, and take care of their children. Women had very little freedom as far as their rights were concerned also. Puritan writers, Anne Bradstreet and Mary Rowlandson both experienced the struggle of the anti-feminist movement. From their writings we see that they both were against anti-feminism and they tried their best to abandon the whole idea.

    Read More

  • The Return Of Martin Guerre By Natalie Zemon Davis

    1189 Words  | 5 Pages

    Through this, she herself had stated she invented parts of the story to fill in the spaces. “I did my best through other sources from the period and place to discover the world they would have seen and the reactions they might have had. What I offer you here is in part of my invention, but held tightly by the voices of the past.” She partially invents aspects of the story for lack of evidence. For example, during the marriage or the original Martin Guerre and Bertrande before he leaves, they are unable to have child for several years.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Wife's Story By Ursula K. Leguin

    740 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Wife’s Story Ursula K. Leguin is a short story describing a wife retrospective of her husband who she thought of as a loving and caring father and husband a somewhat perfect person always gentle. Yet he had a fatal flaw that led to his death that the wife failed to recognize until it was too late. Throughout the story, the wife recounts important events that led to his deaths events that should have been clues to aid her to recognize the flaw within her husband. In the story, Leguin shows us how the wife’s perception was deceiving her. She was looking at her husband but couldn’t see him for whom he really was.

    Read More

  • The Awakening And Story Of An Hour Analysis

    822 Words  | 4 Pages

    In Kate Chopin 's novel The Awakening and the short story “The Story of An Hour” feminist beliefs overshadow the value in moral and societal expectations during the turn of the century. Due to Louise Mallard and Edna Pontellier Victorian life style they both see separating from their husband as the beginning of their freedom. Being free from that culture allows them to invest in their personal interest instead of being limited to what 's expected of them. Chopin 's sacrifices her own dignity for the ideal of society’s expectations. Chopin 's sad, mysterious tone seems to support how in their era, there was a significant lack of women 's rights and freedom of expression.

    Read More

  • Le Retour De Martin Guerre Analysis

    2009 Words  | 9 Pages

    Comparison of Vigne’s Film Version with Davis’s Interpretation of the Martin Guerre Episode It is very interesting to note that Martin Guerre’s scandal represents a complicated enigma, especially in the sixteenth-century as it has been said “truth is stranger than fiction”. Therefore, this case grabs many artists’ and historians’ attention to reflect it into literature and historical works. Many works have been written to describe this incident, including but not restricted to Davie’s book and Vigne’s movie, the two works will be examined in this research; they are based on a famous case of the identity theft that took place in the sixteenth-century, France. The film was produced in 1982 under the title Le Retour de Martin Guerre

    Read More

  • What Role Did Women Play In The French Revolution

    1446 Words  | 6 Pages

    Firstly, feminist militancy and activism was very present in the French Revolution. The prime example of this was the March to Versailles of October 1789. Two important womens’ rights activists were Pauline Léon and Théroigne de Méricourt. They called for the permission to protect the Revolution by allowing women to carry pikes, pistols, sabres and rifles.

    Read More

More about The Wife Of Marin Guerre Analysis

Open Document