This essay discusses two young women coming of age Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston and Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte. In Their Eyes Were Watching God Janie struggles to grow up in three different marriages. On the other hand, Jane from Jane Eyre does a lot of developing and personal growth through her relationship with the one family. The focus will be on how these girls are similar and different. The reader will see how coming of age is different for every person. When Janie was a young girl she had romance on the brain. She had her first kiss underneath a blossoming pear tree. Her Nanny does not want to her be kissing any boys until she is married (Hurston 18-19). She does not want her grand daughter to be an easy girl. …show more content…
(Meaning she wants to make sweet passionate love). This helps Janie’s character to show imagery with plants and flowers. This helps Janie be looked at as a natural beauty that has a gentle nature and has a readiness attitude for romance. Janie’s belief that loves comes after marriage is a false belief that she learns pretty quickly in her first marriage to Logan Killicks. The reader doesn’t know too much about Logan except that he seems to be a one-dimensional character. What the reader does know is that Logan is portrayed as old and ugly, which is completely opposite of his beautiful and young wife, Janie. She seems him as a violation of her dream of true love. When the reader first meets Logan he speaks in the sweetest way to Janie, which gives Janie hope that this marriage is a good one and she is marrying a great man. Shortly after they are married realizes that Logan is somewhat of a liar because now he only speaks to her in anger and commands her to do things. Logan gets very …show more content…
John, a missionary, for the first time she is the little girl lost in the woods. St. John is very passionate about his work as a missionary in India, which is what he is home prepping for. Once the reader gets to know St. John he is a hard and cold man, who focuses on one thing and that is marrying a beautiful woman and taking her with him to be his missionary wife. This makes the reader and Jane ignore the fact that he is handsome, blonde, and blue-eyed. Now to focus on that Jane came into St. John’s life poor, starving and alone. St. John gets to know her fairly quickly and realizes that she is amazing and beautiful woman. This is why he gets her the job as the governess for Mr. Rochester’s adopted daughter Adele. Jane teaches Adele how to speak English, while at the same time falls madly in love with her father. Who at first glance is not an attractive man by any means. This is a big way that Jane proves herself as a strong and beautiful woman because she never judges a book by its cover. She falls in love with the man that she gets to know on the inside, not by what is on the outside. She falls in love with the man who speaks French to her and tries to spoil her any chance that he gets. Rochester said to Jane “My bride is here," he said, again drawing me to him, "because my equal is here, and my likeness. Jane, will you marry me?” (Bronte, 87). This is one of the sweetest ways for a man to ask a woman, in my
When Janie walks back into the town, she has nothing but overalls on. Everyone sees this and starts to stare in disbelief. By then, people started to talk about her. Asking, “Where’s dat blue satin dress she left in… Where he left her…”(Hurston 18). Everyone is jumping to conclusions.
In the novel Their Eyes Were Watching God love is one of the main themes that is recurrent throughout the novel. Janie struggles a lot since a young age with love and marriage. She goes through many marriages and only finds one man she truly loves and feels herself with. Her first husband Logan Killicks taught her how love is not simply made from marriage; she did not really love her second husband, Joe Starks, because he tended to belittle and isolate her. Both husbands made Janie feel that marriage and love did not correlate and that marriage is mainly for social status.
Throughout life we discover what we desire the most from life, and we do our best to get to where we want to be despite the many difficulties we are forced to face. In Zora Neale Hurston’s novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God, the protagonist, Janie Crawford, endures many hardships throughout her life. Janie faces the many struggles that come along with the role she must follow by being a woman. Also, Janie must go along with the rules set by those who are in control of her life. Nevertheless, Their Eyes Were Watching God is a story of woman who goes from “ … a naive girl to a mature woman” (Bernard, 2).
One of the biggest themes in, "Their eyes were watching God" is Janie’s quest for love and independence. Janie has a goal throughout the novel to find enlightenment within herself and reach the "horizon". She went through several relationships and absurd thoughts to do this, through her grandmother nanny and her three husbands. However, her third husband, Tea Cake plays a less substantial role in the progression of the novel but a significant role in Janie’s quest to reach her dream of love and security within herself.
From a younger age, Janie is immediately pressured into a relationship, specifically with somebody who has plenty of money by Nanny’s standards. However, as much as the grandma could be blamed for this, she also enabled herself to fall into the trap of desperation. The first occurrence seems to be on page 28, when “She saw a dust-bearing bee sink into the sanctum of a bloom; the thousand sister-calyxes arch to meet the love embrace and the ecstatic shiver of the tree from root to tiniest branch creaming in every blossom and frothing with delight. So this was a marriage! She had been summoned to behold a revelation.
Nanny, Janie's grandmother, wants to protect Janie from all the social injustices she has gone through and decides that the only way to keep Janie safe in life is for Janie to avoid love and acquire money through a man. Nanny does not want Janie to feel a sexual desire because she believes that it will make Janie vulnerable to other men. Janie marries Logan Killicks, the man Nanny married her of to. “The vision of Logan Killicks was desecrating the pear tree, but Janie didn't know how to tell Nanny that” (Hurston 14). This pushed Janie closer and closer to leave Logan.
She did shy away from the stereotypical role of what woman should be at that time period. Yet, by the end of the story Janie was still alone like she was at the beginning. The only difference was that she wasn’t the unsure young girl she had been then. This was a brand new Janie. This Janie had evolved into a stronger, more independent woman.
(Hurston 24). Logan does not show any love for Janie. Janie’s unhappiness taught her that love can not be forced upon anyone. Joe prevails as the first man to show, Janie attention and affection. Both, Janie and Joe run off to Eatonville to start a life together.
A LIFE FULL OF BLISS Fitting in is what society is all about, it seems that following what others tell you is more valuable than being your true self. In Zora Neale Hurston’s novel “ Their Eyes Were Watching God” shows that living as who you are brings more joy to yourself. With the main character Janie, we know how living in a society of judgement affected her. From living in Eatonville and being married three times, Janie goes from living in unhappiness to fulfilling herself with what brings joy into her life.
St. John thinks that Jane is “suitable for labor”, which is the only reason he wants to marry her—not because he loves her. He doesn’t see it fit to actually love the person he is going to marry, rather he wants the marriage to be convenient and serve a purpose—there need not be any love involved. In Jane’s case, St. John says that “God and nature intended you for a missionary’s wife.” This speaks strongly to the fact that St. John will only marry Jane because he thinks she is fit to be a missionary’s wife, and he is a missionary. He doesn’t actually love her; the marriage is just convenient for
To simply the question, does she choose the Prince, who is saintly, and on a mission to help others, or does she choose the Beast who hold so much passion, that it is hard to contain? When meeting a stranger you immediately take in their appearance and features, just as Jane does after coming face to face with Mr. Rochester for the first time, noting that he had a “dark face, with stern features and a heavy brow; his eyes and gathered eyebrows looked ireful and thwarted” (Bronte Ch.12). During this encounter it becomes obvious that Rochester is more than a little rough around the edges, being rude and abrupt, while openly judging Jane. Shortly after her encounter with Rochester, Jane realized that the craggy faced man is the wealthy owner of Thornfield Hall.
She lived in a world that deliberate the probability of her prosperity by the level of her marriage capacity, this incorporated her familial associations, financial status and magnificence. Jane however is a vagrant with no fortune, and over and over is portrayed by her creator as ugly, yet she can break with the traditions of her age. Contrasted with other young ladies of her age, marriage is not Jane's principle point in life. At the point when Rochester masked as an old lady ready to advise her future asks her what story she might want to listen, she answers: "Gracious, I have very little decision! They by and large keep running on a similar topic – romance; and guarantee to end in a similar disaster – marriage".
Rochester but since she moved away from that town in which he was in she believed that all of her feelings were simply just a “puppy love stage”. Jane's love with this new guy St. John was so surreal for him and Jane but after sometime Jane had these opposing feelings towards him. Jane wasn’t sure if her feelings were even there for him. It was the complete opposite for St. John, he had enough feelings for Jane that were the cause of his existence to him.
She soon meets a man that she falls in love with, Edward Rochester. The situations that she must endure while living at Thornfield are a testament to Jane’s now unwavering faith. She faces much hardship and temptation, but one of the hardest fights she faces is when she finds that the man she is going to marry is already married. The depth of hurt she feels and the prodding that Rochester does to try to get her to stay with him pound at her like the waves of the sea.
Topic: Marriage in “Jane Eyre” In “Jane Eyre” Charlotte Brontë rejects the traditional role of women subdued by social conceptions and masculine authority by generating an identity to her female character. Thesis: Jane´s personality will bring into being a new kind of marriage based on equality, meanwhile her choice for romantic fulfilment will depend solely on her autonomy and self-government. Introduction Charlotte Brontë´s “Jane Eyre” stands as a model of genuine literature due to the fact that it breaks all conventions and stereotypes and goes beyond the boundaries of common romance in order to obtain love, identity and equality. 1.