ipl-logo

Tim Meeker's Injustice In My Brother Sam Is Dead

881 Words4 Pages

War. Is it a necessary injustice? Does it leave us in triumph or with shattered dreams? War can bring brutality and death to many innocent people, but it can also create unity and result in freedom. The repercussions of war rely on war itself. It can end in peace and victory, or it can cast a shadow of depression over the people involved. War can have many different views to it. In My Brother Sam is Dead, the American Revolution takes place,where you can be risky and fight for the Patriots, a team devoted to freedom and principle, or you can stay safe with the Loyalists, who favor the king and the British government. Though many colonists chose to stay neutral, others found that they agreed with one side more than the other. Tim Meeker, a …show more content…

The main subject the Patriots stand for is freedom, but, sadly that only applies to white, landowning men. If the Patriots truly believed in freedom they would fight for all races. But, the Patriots are not the only ones discriminating blacks, the British killed innocents simply because of their color: “‘There are some damned blacks in here, what shall we do with them?’ ‘Kill them,’ the officer yelled. He charged through the door waving his sword… Ned's head jumped off his body and into the air. I never saw it fall...I didn’t feel much like being a Tory anymore” (144-145). Just because of his skin, Ned was stabbed and beheaded. Another ironic part of his death is that he was neutral. The hatred and brutality inflicted upon different races is simply unfair and both sides had unreasonable causes for doing what they did. The Loyalist killed many African-Americans and the Patriots excluded a race that desperately needed freedom. Seeing how each side discriminated people because of the color of their skin made it basically impossible to side with either of them. The unfairness of this whole situation horrified Tim into going …show more content…

Before his father’s death, Tim was torn between the Patriotic views of his brother and his father’s Loyalist opinions, he had no idea which side he agreed with. However, right after the kidnapping of his father, he realized that he considered himself as a Tory. But, months later the remaining members of the Meeker family found out what had happened to father and how he died: “… he’d been sent to a prison ship in New York. there was one funny thing about it, though-it wasn’t a Rebel prison ship, it was a British one” (164). Even though Life was a faithful loyalist, he was not rewarded for it, he was ignored. They didn’t care who was on their ship, they just wanted to win. Tim would expect that the British would try to save their own supporters, not throw them on a prison ship and let them rot away. The support the Loyalists once got from Tim had disappeared. With the Patriots capturing Tim’s father and the the Loyalists allowing him to grow more ill and die on their prison ship, Tim finally understood that neither side would benefit

Show More
Related

  • A Narrative Of A Revolutionary Soldier Summary

    700 Words  | 3 Pages

    Not only does the book highlight the positive reflection on the events of the American Revolution, but gives an overall unbiased insight of the happenings on through Martin eyes. Martin has been successful in portraying the truthful picture of the American Revolutionary War that includes the flawless character and moral perfection coupled with the problems and burdens that befell the army, and how they took it In the initial events of the book, Martin enters the war as a young boy who is anxious to protect his country and experiences noteworthy adventures along the way of his dream. He fights against the

    Read More

  • My Brother Sam Is Dead By John Collier

    1024 Words  | 5 Pages

    Against The War 1775 “Have you ever seen a dear friend lying in the grass with the top of his skull off and his brains sliding out of them like wet oats?,” The authors of the book “My Brother Sam Is Dead” believe that they are against war. They clearly state reasons why they are against war. The book shows how war divides loyalties within a family. It also shows how war cause huge arguments of generation and the principles versus reality as well. In this book, although both sides of the war are shown, author's Collier and Collier ultimately argue that war is futile.

    Read More

  • Loyalists Affected The Course Of The American Revolution

    1094 Words  | 5 Pages

    Thomas Jefferson tried to speak up for the colonists in the Declaration of Independence as they should be allowed the rights for equal liberty, life and pursuit of happiness . Loyalists affected the war as the added more numbers on the British Empires side. About 10 percent of Americans became active Loyalists and the number would have been higher but the Patriots constantly threatened, punished, harassed and had their property seized which persuaded them not to become Loyalists. There were about 80, 000 black Loyalists that escaped and were given the opportunity for their freedom when they joined the British army . They were put through a painful process of being stripped, covered with hot tar, splattered with feathers, then the Loyalists were forced to walk the streets, this was called “Tar and Feathering.”

    Read More

  • My Brother Sam Is Dead By Christopher Collier

    676 Words  | 3 Pages

    War is an evil that can destroy nations, but without it, there is the potential for even more chaos in our imperfect world. Many wicked and corrupt institutions throughout history have been stopped by wars, further advancing society. Detrimental repercussions of combat, such as destroyed homes or lost lives, are justified by the anticipation of a better future. In the novel My Brother Sam is Dead, by James and Christopher Collier, Tim Meeker must decide if war is worth the bloodshed and loss to secure freedom for himself, and for America’s posterity. By the end of the story, the ironic deaths of Ned, Life, and Sam contribute to Tim’s decision to remain neutral.

    Read More

  • My Brother Sam Is Dead By Mr Collier

    707 Words  | 3 Pages

    The result of any conflict should never be war. Separation and heartbreak are all devastating effects of warfare. Additionally, the brutality of war is certainly immense. Most of all, a war can be cruelly unfair to both sides of a battle. Collier and Collier, authors of My Brother Sam is Dead, essentially agree that war is fruitless.

    Read More

  • Revolutionary War Dbq Essay

    1043 Words  | 5 Pages

    The beginning of war, is the ending of life. The reason that war is death, is that the war of Valley Forge caused many to be deceased, and deceived. I have decided to not re-enlist into the Colonial Army because of sickness (Doc. C+A), Housing (Doc. D+B), and supply shortage (Doc. C+B). These reasons listed are big reasons that caused death, and sadness taking away loved ones and friends. This document about the Revolutionary War, will bring you to the place itself, living through the damages and sad doings this war brought.

    Read More

  • Essay On My Brother Sam Is Dead

    910 Words  | 4 Pages

    Some people still wonder if war can be justified by its principles or cause. It can be argued that war can be justified due to the principles of freedom and justice that soldiers are willing to die for. However, many argue against this saying that war should be avoided at all costs due to collateral damage and the massive loss of innocent life. In the book My Brother Sam is Dead by James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier, Tim faces the biggest dilemma of his life when he has to decide whether to side with his brother who believes in the principles of war or his father who believes war should be avoided at all costs. When the novel comes to a conclusion, Tim decides that he is neutral and does not agree to either argument due to the irony contained within the deaths of

    Read More

  • Themes In My Brother Sam Is Dead

    844 Words  | 4 Pages

    The majority of people during the American Revolution fought for liberty without realizing the actual cost and brutal reality of war. In the novel My Brother Sam is Dead, the Meeker family consisting of a Father name Life, a Mother named Susannah, a rebellious teen named Sam, and a conflicted teen named Tim, journey through the life of colonists owning a tavern during the Revolutionary War. Sam departs from his family to fight alongside the Patriots going against his Father, a Tory. War brings a lot of terrible things, but some examples are families splitting, clash of generation, and an overall theme of principle vs reality. The soldiers who fought in the war thought they were fighting for liberty, when really they caused havoc and awfulness.

    Read More

  • In Blood Rites By Ehrenreich Summary

    604 Words  | 3 Pages

    When talking about war, there are many books with few answers to what war truly is. Barbara Ehrenreich brings forth not only the possibilities towards understanding war but also the passion people from history have had towards it. One key issue she brings to light is humanities love for war, so much so that people would use excuses like holy wars to justify their need to fight in a war. She declares that war is as muddled as the issue of diseases and where diseases came from around 200 years ago. More so than that she even goes further on to state that these rituals that date back to prehistoric times are the cause of human nature during times of war rather than human instinct.

    Read More

  • The Meeker

    545 Words  | 3 Pages

    Sammy joins up with the Continental Army to fight against the English, and that 's that. To make matters worse, Sam steals his dad gun (named the Brown Bess). Now that 's just putting salt in the wound. Since his big bro is gone, Tim spends a lot of time wondering which side he should be on. Should he be pro-America, like his brother?

    Read More

  • My Brother Sam Is Dead Essay

    916 Words  | 4 Pages

    War is one of the most controversial and fascinating aspects of human life, which includes sacrifice, argument, and worst of all human death. The argument of war is whether or not the sacrifice of human life is necessary or not. The authors of My Brother Sam Is Dead are totally against war; they are neutral and they give Tim the same idea as them in the novel. They even show the irony and cruelty of war in the book by the punishing and ironic deaths of Ned, Sam, and Life. This novel is based in Redding, Conneticut during the time of the Revolutionary War.

    Read More

  • Decisions In On The Rainy River By Tim O Brien

    721 Words  | 3 Pages

    When Tim first got the draft letter in the mail he was unsure of what to think and thought “[he] was too good for this war”(P.39), so fleeing to the Rainy River would give him a break to truly listen and connect with his body and make a decision. Although there was a moment in the story when he wanted to go to Canada and be able to see freedom for the first time in a long time it also “separated one life from another. ”(P.45) The separation between his two lives was the breaking points the made him realize what his choice had to be; however, he didn't fully understand what his choice was until he was on the boat with Elroy Berdahl, the owner. Without Elroy having to say anything he realized that going to fight in the war would be the best thing for himself and everyone around him, as a result, that was how he was influenced to go to the war instead of

    Read More

  • My Brother Sam Is Dead Chapter 1 Summary

    1281 Words  | 6 Pages

    My Brother Sam Is Dead Chapter 1: Page 1-22 Sam is Tim Meeker 's older brother. Tim always looks up to his older brother. Sam then comes home in a uniform at the tavern during April. He starts out by saying "We 've beaten the British in Massachusetts," which sparks up a fight between him and his father which is a loyalist (someone who respects the government and the king). Sam has a discussion with the guests at their tavern and his family on how the Minutemen had surprise attack on the "Lobster backs" (the British) in Lexington.

    Read More

  • On The Rainy River Critical Analysis

    1184 Words  | 5 Pages

    In “On the Rainy River” Tim struggles to make a decision on whether he should fight for his country in the war or flee to Canada. Tim did not believe in the war. He was an innocent young man, freshly graduated from college with a naive view of the world. “Both my conscience and my instincts were telling me to make a break for it, just take off and run like hell and never stop.” (Page 3/Paragraph 8)

    Read More

  • Mark Twain's Essay: The War Prayer

    528 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout human history, war has been a common solution to settle conflict or disagreements between people. War has and will always be apart of this world, because no matter how much death it causes humans will never change. Some people have come to see the idiocy in war and have even written about it in poems, short stories, etc. One of these people, Samuel Clemens, better known as Mark Twain, has mocked this absurd and pointless practice. Twain’s essay The War Prayer satirizes the customs of praying for safety and victory in war and for equating war with patriotism.

    Read More

More about Tim Meeker's Injustice In My Brother Sam Is Dead

Open Document