ipl-logo

To What Extent Does Winston Have Control Over His Fate In 1984

1012 Words5 Pages

Does Winston Have Control Over His Fate? Throughout 1984, Winston Smith commits many rebellious acts against the party, and while this should mean that Winston has control over his fate, in actuality, he does not. At first glance, it appears that Winston finds few hardships in resisting the party; however, as time progresses, it becomes more and more evident that the party is aware of everything that he is doing. Eventually, it becomes blatant that Winston cannot change society, nor what will happen to others, or to himself. As a result, it is evident that Winston has no control over his fate. Winston’s primary goal is to remove the power of the party, and his method of doing so is to maintain the hate for the party and commit acts that …show more content…

This is shown through O’Brien’s guidance throughout Winston’s years. As mentioned earlier, O’Brien reveals that he had been closely watching Winston for several years and this means that the Thought Police had suspected Winston of treason throughout the entire novel (Orwell 249, 259). Knowing this, O’Brien continues to depict himself as a friendly figure when giving Winston his address or making unnaturally intimate eye contact with Winston, only so that he can entrap him whenever he wants (Orwell, 17, 159). This demonstrates that O’Brien is the one who has absolute control over Winston’s fate, as he could have made Winston conform to the party years earlier, but instead chose to toy with him by acting as a comrade instead. While O’Brien’s ability to choose when Winston is arrested demonstrates his control over Winston’s fate, the act of penetrating his mind does as well. Winston says that his subconscious mind embodies his emotions, and so long as his emotions are impregnable, the party does not have full control (Orwell 166-167). However, as Winston believes in multiple concepts contradictory to the party, such as his love for Julia, and hatred of Big Brother, by forcing Winston to wholeheartedly follow the party, it shows that the party has overruled Winston’s subconscious mind, which was supposedly impregnable. As such, when Winston betrays Julia and says “He loved Big Brother”, it becomes clear that the party has obtained complete control of Winston’s mind (Orwell, 292, 298). This thorough dominance of Winston’s mind depicts that Big Brother runs a totalitarian society with absolute control, and that the outer party members are no longer considered humans. With this, it becomes evident that Winston has no control of what happens to

Show More
Related

  • Outline For 1984

    832 Words  | 4 Pages

    During the story of 1984 Winston reveals himself as a heroic figure. His willingness to fight against the untouchable party forces him to risk his own life in many ways. Even Winston thinking poorly of the party was a very punishable crime. Even when he is being punished for his crimes he keeps proving himself a hero as he wonders and pushes to discover why the society is being run the way it is. He is also very stubborn to the thoughts of the party.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Figurative Language In 1984 By George Orwell

    922 Words  | 4 Pages

    Big Brother, leader of the Party and the antagonist within this tale, has a constant watch over everyone in Oceania and leaves Winston to feel like a prisoner in his own home. The Party is the ruling force in Oceania, therefore

    Read More

  • Similarities Between 1984 And The Testing

    1323 Words  | 6 Pages

    Winston knew that his time would come when the thought police would finally catch him. He knew this since he committed thoughtcrime by writing in his journal and he didn’t like big brother. Knowing this information, he tried to eventually pry deep into the secrets of his world and stand out. However, this just ended up making him meet someone that eventually would be the person who tortured him. All this would happen because he was different and he couldn’t be himself or have a different personality than the rest.

    Read More

  • Winston's Power In 1984 By George Orwell

    1265 Words  | 6 Pages

    Whether it be true or not, O’Brien has him in exactly the right position. Winston becomes a follower of sorts underneath O’Brien, in which he can be fed any and all information that O’Brien deems necessary to further his master plan. Overall,

    Read More

  • Comparison Of Fear In 1984 And The Time Machine By H. G. Wells

    2740 Words  | 11 Pages

    The Party and O’ Brien wanted to break Winston’s spirit. The only way he knew how to do this was to use fear by destroying whatever strength Winston had. Fear can also brainwash a person into thinking something is right or something is wrong. For example, when he was released by O’Brien he believed in The Party’s teachings and beliefs. “forty years it had taken him to learn what kind of smile was hidden beneath the dark mustache…

    Read More

  • How Does Winston Exist In 1984

    211 Words  | 1 Pages

    1. Winston believes that the true way to defeat the Party is by the proles. He says that he knows that power lies within the proles and that power can be used to overthrow and defeat the Party. 2. To Winston, the most important thing for him is that he knows that the Brotherhood exists.

    Read More

  • Differences And Similarities Between 1984 And Mark Rothko's

    1411 Words  | 6 Pages

    The Party controls every part of life. By comparison,Winston and the Party have different views in terms of individuality. Winston would like to have individual thoughts but the Party will execute anyone for expressing any forms of individuality. Throughout Winston’s time at the Ministry of Truth he meets a women named Julia and falls in love with her. One day, Julia gives Winston a note saying I love you.

    Read More

  • Winston's Rebellion In 1984

    601 Words  | 3 Pages

    To develop a sense of freedom, Winston writes in his journal, ultimately committing thoughtcrime. For example, Winston writes, “To the future or to the past, to a time when thought is free, when men are different from one another and do not live alone—to a time when truth exists and what is done cannot be undone” (28). In writing this journal, it is visible that Winston is interested in rebellion. He wants to show the Party that he is doing something illegal and is able to get away with it. He demonstrates this in reading Goldstein’s book.

    Read More

  • 1984 Winston Smith Quote Analysis

    503 Words  | 3 Pages

    This quote shows that Winston has always felt guilty of his mother’s death as if he had been the reason she was killed. In other instances in the book it is almost like she is haunting his conscience, constantly appearing in his dreams, “Winston was dreaming of his mother” (page 31). This might be another reason why he was so determined to oppose, an obsession with wanting to avenge his mother. Winston fought hard against the government because he desperately craves to feel real emotion, he wants to experience love, to live knowing he accomplished something, despite knowing deep down the party would not allow accomplishments to survive, as they could erase him from history in the blink of an eye. “‘Does he [Big Brother] exist in the same way I exist?’ / ‘You do not exist,’ said O’Brien” (page 272).

    Read More

  • How Is Betrayal Shown In 1984

    773 Words  | 4 Pages

    In George Orwell’s novel 1984, protagonist Winston Smith struggles to maintain his individuality, beliefs, and values while being under the totalitarian government control. As a citizen, Winston secretly rebels against the ruling Party. Although he attempts to challenge the power of the Party, Winston encounters many characters that drive him to his demise, such as Charrington, O’Brien, and Julia. In addition, his own decisions lead him to a labyrinth of problems. Eventually, the Party accomplishes its goal: to brainwash Winston and all other citizens.

    Read More

  • Similarities Between 1984 And Fahrenheit 451

    860 Words  | 4 Pages

    As a result of Winston’s neglect of the rules, he was able to maintain his own perspective, as he attempted to defeat Big Brother’s ‘sinister plan’. “You’re a flaw in the pattern, Winston. You are a stain that must be wiped out….when finally you surrender to us, it must be of your own free will,” stated O’Brien (page 255). In the book, free will depicted the Ministry’s truthful judgments of the state of mind, which happened to correspond to Winston’s freedom of beliefs. When O’Brien was torturing Winston, he revealed Big Brother’s notions of simply destroying the rebelling mind of any person who had dared to testify against The Party’s core values.

    Read More

  • 1984 Winston's Desire For Change

    748 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Winston’s believes, liberation is an entity hidden behind a mist of futility, an endless cycle of failed uprisings caused by the insolence of the general masses. The cycle also represents the situation that Winston finds himself within, regardless of his awareness he is still paralyzed by the irrational animalistic instinct to cower in fear of the party’s promised punishment. Resulting in his apathy towards revolution which causes him to abstain from any true revolutionary undertaking; as a result, the cycle of despair continues infinitely. Moreover, the paradox may highlight the extent of Winston’s indoctrination by the party. Winston views the revolution as fantastical due to the Proles oblivious nature, which is an assumption that is made by Winson as a result of party propaganda, which states that all “proles and animals are free”.

    Read More

  • Manipulation Of Winston In George Orwell's '1984'

    750 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the book, 1984 by George Orwell, Winston is a creation of the Party as they know what he is thinking and control his every move by manipulating his environment. Winston is a fabricated rebel used to test the Party’s true power and strength; a simulated virus that must be destroyed by their defenses to ensure their victory over the people. The Party must be ready for any attack against their authority and Winston was the perfect invention. The Party plays games with Winston to instill the idea of being human in him. As they use him for training their members to purge their world of any insurgents, they also influence him for their own amusement.

    Read More

  • Comparing 1984 And The V For Vendetta And 1984

    1481 Words  | 6 Pages

    At the beginning of the novel, Winston made it prominent that he dissented Big Brother and his party’s idea. He wrote in his diary, in Book 1 Chapter 1, “DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER…” (Orwell 18). This shows that Winston dissented his country’s government and was willing to rebel for he knew deep inside that

    Read More

  • Examples Of Betrayal In 1984

    1190 Words  | 5 Pages

    It was not until O’Brien summoned Winston to Room 101, where he used the last string of hope Winston had—only able to function because of a vague feeling of trust—in order to finally and actually ostracize him. His initial “morbid self-isolation [comes] from shunning social contact due to anger toward the world,” (Diamond). When O’Brien speaks of essentially taking over the world through war and indoctrination as seen in the Ministry of Love, Winston simply refutes and expresses that alienation as such would eliminate the free will of mankind and is virtually impossible. The hope that Winston had for the Proles and the rest of humanity was obliterated time and time again with O’Brien’s torture. This repetitive destruction adds to the novels entirety as a desolate, dystopian novel.

    Read More

More about To What Extent Does Winston Have Control Over His Fate In 1984

Open Document