In 1960 the brilliant Harper Lee wrote To Kill A Mockingbird, this book went on to win many awards and was even made into a movie. The book was set in a small town in Alabama called Maycomb in the early 1930’s. During the 1930’s African Americans were still fighting for their equal rights, this book showcases this time period and what it was like to be African-American and the horrible treatment they were faced with due to their skin color. In this coming of age story, a black man, Tom Robinson is accused of raping a white woman named Mayella Ewell. The story tells of the events that led to the trial, the trial and the aftermath of the trial as well. After Tom Robinson was arrested for the rape of Mayella Ewell, he is appointed for Atticus …show more content…
For example, in his closing statement, he says, “Mayella Ewell was beaten savagely by someone who led almost exclusively with his left.” This piece of evidence helps with Tom Robinson's case proving that whoever actually hit Mayella used his/her left hand to do so. This helps Mr.Robinson’s case by saying she was hit by someone who was clearly left-handed. In addition to that piece of evidence, Tom’s Lawyer also adds that “Tom Robinson now sits before you, having taken the oath with the only good hand he possesses-his right hand.” This solid piece of evidence is another valid reason there is no way that Tom could have been the one to hurt Mayella. Clearly, the evidence was given shows that whoever hit Mayella was definitely left hand and since Tom has no nerves in his left arm and cant even left it there is no way that he could’ve done it. Proving that Tom Robinson is indeed innocent and did not rape and hit Mayella …show more content…
In his argument, Atticus asks the question, “What was the evidence of her offense?” By asking this he is implying that Mayella’s whole defense is solely based on just her word, she has no actual proof that Tom is guilty other than what she is telling everyone. In addition, he also asks, “What did she do?”. By saying this he is meaning to ask what did Mayella do to lead to the so-called “rape”. He asks these rhetorical questions so it can leave the jury really to think about if they believe the story Mayella is telling. By asking these rhetorical questions it just further proves that Tom did not rape Mayella Ewell and that it is just a call for attention from a lonely
Mayella always looks at the judges and the court people whenever her father is asked about in a question and she gets nervous. Tom Robinson got a death sentence and it all could have been avoided if Mayella told the truth about her father. For this trial I believe that they each should have been questioned in different rooms and see if their stories match up or if Mayella would come clean since her father is not there. It is both Bob and Mayella Ewells faults for what happened to Tom and for more evidence Mayella had a black eye on her left eye and Tom Robinson's left hand is mangled and messed up. Evidence from text-¨I cant use my left hand at all.
The novel “To Kill a Mockingbird,” by Harper Lee, takes place in Maycomb, Alabama during the 1930s. Atticus Finch a lawyer takes on a case to defend a hard working african american man named Tom Robinson. Tom Robinson is accused of raping and beating a white women named Mayella Ewell. Atticus’s closing argument was effective towards the jury, throughout atticus’s speech he uses rhetoric appeals such as ethos, pathos, and logos.
Gentlemen, in the 30 years that I have been practising law in Maycomb, I have never seen a case so complicated, and so simple at the same time. Complicated because of the circumstances; a white woman’s word versus a black man’s word. Simple because of the facts; clearly no one in this courtroom is guilty besides the defendant himself, Tom Robinson. There is undoubtedly more evidence confirming the fact that Tom Robinson is guilty rather than innocent.
Preston Geerinck Per. 1 4/25/17 Mrs. Granahan-Smith Speech Analysis Atticus Finch of the novel To Kill a Mockingbird tackled the task of defending the case of Tom Robinson who was accused of raping Mayella Ewell.
Rapist Robinson Convicted MAYCOMB, AL, July 10- Negro Tom Robinson, 25, has been charged for rape by the Maycomb Court. Robert E. Lee ‘Bob’ Ewell, 50, the victim’s father Mayella Violet Ewell, 19, had accused Robinson of the rape of his daughter. The jury unanimously found Robinson guilty after an hour-long jury debate. This was despite the defense attorney, Mr Atticus Finch, 53, uncovering inconsistencies in the testimonies of witnesses Mr Heck Tate, Maycomb County sheriff, Mr Bob Ewell, father of the victim and Ms Mayella Ewell, the victim.
In To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, Tom Robinson’s innocence can be proven through Mayella's injuries, Bob’s history of neglect, and discrepancies between Bob and Mayelaa’s testimonies. First, Tom’s disability makes it impossible for him to have caused Mayella’s injuries. For example, Heck and Bob testified that all around her neck and the right side of her face is bruised. Tom could not have done this because his left hand is weak and mangled. Bob on the other hand is left-handed.
So this mean that his left arm is does not work. If you look at where on her body, she was beating by somebody left hand. Incidentally her father Bob Ewell is left handed and he was very angry at her. In short, Tom Robinson is not capable of beating Mayella Ewell with his left hand because Mayella Ewell when she take the witness stand, she changes her story all the time so Tom Robinson is not feel guilty at all so
Tom is helping Mayella Ewell with the door hinges when suddenly Mayella grabs him and kisses him. Tom, an African American man, could not do much for Mayella as she was a white woman, and pushing her would land him assault charges. Mayella is caught by her father Bob, who blames it all on Tom as rape for if Mayella was convicted she would be shunned by society. Bob then takes Tom to court, and despite all of the evidence saying that Tom was not guilty he was sentenced. Numerous factors showed Tom’s innocence such as his left hand being disabled, which made sure he could not have held her down while beating her.
To Kill a Mocking Bird Aristotle holds that anger is “a desire accompanied by pain for an imagined retribution on account of an imagined slighting inflicted by people who have no legitimate reason to slight oneself or one’s own.” (1-3). “Anger is a complex emotion since it embraces pain and pleasure; the pain is produced from injury while the desire of taking revenge is somehow results from the injury. Anger is a strong feeling of being upset or annoyed because of something wrong” (7) . It is also energy it can be positive or negative; if it is used positively, it creates a change in the world but if it is used negatively it can be devastating, the acknowledge that anger has both aspects the negative and the positive one.
Mayella did something that was extremely wrong in that time era, she kissed a black man. During the trial, Tom Robinson is asked to state what happened from his point of view, in chapter 19 of the novel he states “She says she never kissed a grown man before an’ she might as well kiss a ******. She says what her papa do to her don't count” (Lee 221). This is extremely important and alarming, no father should ever do something such as that. This means Bob Ewell has performed some kind of nasty act on Mayella before.
Then some people thought that Tom was innocent but the judge decided to make Tom go to prison. In the book it said that Mayella hugged and kissed Tom on the cheek. From this I can infer that Mayella is desperate and can get away with this because Tom Robinson is a black person. This reminds me of a couple southern movies I’ve watched where black people are always the first to suspect because of their color. Tom Robinson on trial for his life said Bob Ewell yelled “whore I’ll kill you” when he saw Mayella kiss Tom from the window.
Later in the text, during Tom Robinson’s testimony, he states “ She said she never kissed a grown man before an’ she might as well kiss a nigger. She says what her papa do to her don’t count,” This further confirmed that Bob Ewell has been mistreating Mayella and insinuated that he was assaulting her. This knowledge coupled with Bob Ewell’s known drinking habits suggests that he is capable of giving Mayella the injuries that he claimed came from Tom
To Kill a Mockingbird Argumentative Essay Racial equality and discrimination is a founding issue that has been spread throughout every part of the world, To Kill A Mockingbird was written and published by Harper Lee in 1960, this time was dominated by civil rights protests and some of the first hippie movements following the crushing reality of the Vietnam War, the 60s also saw the struggle against segregation and racial equality. It is no surprise that the extreme political conflict affecting her life and world would greatly impact her writing and influence how she perceived the world during the writing of To Kill a Mockingbird. the influence of the fight for racial inequality is shown greatly in her book as she depicts the everyday life
Tom was accused of raping a white woman who was Mayella Ewell, Mayella said he raped her while he was helping her with chores. She later on tells the readers that it was false allegations. The reason why she didn 't tell the truth at her first trial was because, Mayella was afraid of being embarrassed because she kissed a black male. She rather have an innocent man get charged with a crime than that. “However, Robinson was transferred from the state prison to Maycomb 's county jail on Saturday, two days before he stood trial on Monday, and Atticus had to defend him against a lynch mob”.
Harper Lee’s “To Kill a Mockingbird” is set sometime in the 1930s in Maycomb County Alabama. The story is told through the point of view of Scout Finch who lives with her father, Atticus, and brother, Jem. The kids like to play pretend with their friend Dill about the man who lives in a scary house down the road, Boo Radley. The kids come in a few close counters along the way during these games in which Atticus does not approve. Scouts’ father, a lawyer, is appointed by Judge Taylor to defend Mr. Tom Robinson, a black man accused of raping a young girl.