Transgender Canadians experience discrimination daily because their position in society is one made vulnerable by existing ideologies and the structure of Canadian society. This is especially true for transgender youth, who are beginning to develop their identities and values. The Canadian narrative normalizes heterosexuality and the gender binary of man/woman, excluding the people that do not fit within it like transgender people. This exclusion and discrimination results in inequalities of life quality, sense of belonging, safety, etc. The intersection of the services/structures of society and the dominant ideologies influence this inequality and often reinforce and perpetuate it. This essay will discuss the nature of transgender youth inequality …show more content…
Many students are denied the right to access bathrooms that correspond with their gender, and others are victims of (sexual) harassment, transphobia, and violence. Transgender youth have high levels of poor mental health and safety in Canada. A Canadian study (source) found that 70% of the youth reported sexual harassment, 2/3 reported self-harm, over 1/3 attempted suicide, and a range between 1/3 and 2/3 had serious thoughts of suicide (source). Transgender students reported a “generally lower connectedness to school” and low mental health. Those who felt a greater connection to their schools reported more stable mental health (source). Another study found that transgender youth are either unable or uncomfortable using school washrooms, leading to a decrease in their reported mental health and physical well-being (gender identity disparities). These experiences include the fear of being harassed or challenged on which washroom they use, leading to an avoidance of the facilities. This can lead to physical ailments like UTIs and dehydration, as students work around the need to use the washroom by hydrating less often and refusing to relieve themselves when the need arises. (identity, pg …show more content…
It states that should students be uncomfortable changing, trans students should be given alternative changing times instead of total exclusion from the sport or activity. Alternatively, the installation of a changing stall in the changeroom for any student to use is suggested if an earlier changing time cannot be given. This allows for a solution to the issue, as well as improves student security, since any student may use the stall to change in if they feel uncomfortable changing with
In their respective pieces about the transgender community, Mari Birghe’s piece falls short due to its lack of detailed examples and its heavy reliance on eliciting sympathy from the reader to persuade as well as its failure to see the other side of the argument while Elinor Burkett’s piece proves far superior due to its multitude of extensive examples in addition to its surplus of concessions. Burkett’s piece is stronger in part due to the surplus of concrete examples provided in contrast to Birghe’s meager examples. In Elinor Burketts’s piece, which states transgender women are not entirely female because of their previous male privilege, she intertwines many specific examples that help to prove her overall message. This is that transgender
It brings up the complication that if someone is not Trans and feels uncomfortable in their own restroom their discomfort is to be ignored. The biggest problem with this is that “If any of this makes a child uncomfortable, the administration's response is "too bad." According to the letter, a transgender student's discomfort must always be accommodated, but if another student feels similar discomfort, those concerns must always be ignored because the administration has pre-emptively deemed all "others' discomfort" unjustified. When a young female says she feels uncomfortable or even unsafe sharing bathrooms and locker rooms with males, she isn't being discriminatory, and her complaints shouldn't be dismissed as veiled bigotry by the same Education Department that has preached to schools the importance of creating environments where students feel secure. ”(Pruitt)
In the film “Growing Trans” in which PBS Frontline follows around eight transgender adolescence as they try to make a crucial decision within their family, friends, and even within themselves as they are reaching the puberty stage of life. The documentary supplies about young men and young women in which their ages ranging from nine to 19 years old the documentary provides us into seeing their feelings, thoughts, and own needs but importantly it gives us inside into the kid's main support system which is their parents and peer support group. Furthermore, there are many difficulties when it comes to growing up trans such as family members and even friends using the wrong pronouns or who cannot be able to accept their new identification. Equally
Canadians take pride in their health care system; however, most Canadians are unaware of the disparities that exist for transgender persons within health care. Being ridiculed, denied care, or treated unjustly because of a self-identification as transgender goes against the core values of the nursing profession (Canadian Nurses Association, 2009); despite this, ten percent of transgender participants in the Ontario Trans PULSE survey reported that they had experienced these demonstrations of prejudice when accessing emergency room services. This statistic may be lower than the reality due to transgender persons frequently avoiding the health care system (Bauer & Scheim, 2015). According to the Canadian Nurses Association (CNA) Code of Ethics (2009) nursing staff are expected to provide, “safe, compassionate, competent, and ethical care” (p. 3); however, due to lack of policies and lack of education nursing staff and physicians are detrimentally adding to the stressors of transgender life.
Cisgender and heteronormative privileges challenge those that do not fit into these categories, yet dare to be different which I will discuss throughout this paper. Since transgender people have begun to come out and talk about their gender identities, death rates have risen greatly. It is sad that we live in a society in which people have to live in fear for being different than others and expressing who they are. A difference should not get someone killed because we are not objects and should not be categorized as such. We do not all fit into the binary categories that have been opposed on us, why should those who standout be punished for what they have no control over.
LGBTQ (Lesbian, Gay, Transsexual) youth homelessness makes up only 5 to 7 percent of the general youth population, yet up to 40 percent of youth experiencing homelessness. Many LGBTQ youth face harassment, victimization, violence, social stigma, rejection, and discrimination in their families, schools, employment, and social settings. LGBTQ identified youth ages 13 to 17, provides important information regarding how LGBTQ young people experience life in their communities. Nearly half of LGBTQ youth (47 percent) surveyed they do not “fit in” in their community, while only 16 percent of non LGBTQ youth reported feeling that way. 63 percent stated that they will need to move to another part of the country in order to feel accepted.
The Stonewall Riots are said to mark the beginning of the modern LGBT rights movement, and it was largely initiated by transgender women of color. Over the next few decades, legislation would be enacted to aid the cause for equality. By 1977, trans athletes could play on the teams of their gender identities, and by 1993 anti-discrimination laws were extended to transpeople in Minnesota. In the 21st century alone, transpeople were getting invited to the White House, playing in college sports, and serving as judges, all without having to hide who they were (“Milestones in the American Transgender Movement”). Hardships are still all too common, unfortunately, but much progress has been made nonetheless, and the fight continues to this
To keep the educational opportunities equal for all sexes, including transgender, schools must allow transgender students to use the restroom they identify with. Doing otherwise would create a stigma attached to transgender students (since students could be initially unaware that the individual is transgender) causing their learning environment to become uncomfortable, hurting their studies. Under Title IX, the school isn’t allowed to treat G.G. differently because of his sex,
School victimization has been linked to a host of negative outcomes for LGBT youth, including poorer academic achievement, poor emotional health, refusal to go to school, and suicidal ideation (Russell, Ryan, Toomey, Diaz,& Sanchez, 2011; Szalcha & Westheimer, 2006). Though few studies have examined suicidality among transgender youth, Grossman and D’Augelli (2007) examined
The author's use of sharp words like "aggression" or "harassment" enhances the article's emotional appeal. Frass also uses a philosophy to set itself up as an honest source on the subject. She makes note of the fact that she is a transgender woman and a Smith College graduate, giving her first-hand experience with the discriminatory practises of female-only environments towards transgender people. Frass is building trust and positioning herself as a spokesperson for this issue by using her own
Educating and providing awareness about transgender identity may give people more empathy and understanding, decreasing their desire to harass and violate this population. The lecture slides mentioned that “packing” may be helpful for transgender men who may have to pee in a urinal, providing a penis appearance which may help them be safer in a men’s bathroom. Providing education about the facts and dismantling myths about sexual assault may disarm people from their worries about being assaulted due to having all-gender bathrooms. The documentary suggested that cisgender people should attempt to use the bathroom of the opposite sex so they can begin to understand the social “confrontation” that transgender people experience when needing to use the bathroom in public (Mateik, 2014). I went to Pride in Seattle two weeks ago, and even in a liberal, LGBTQ+-friendly space, I still felt very uncomfortable, like I was committing a moral and social crime when I used the opposite-sex bathroom.
The Risk of Choice Though we may not agree on wither or not transgender individuals should be able to choose what restroom they use, we can agree that there is at least one big issue that comes to play when allowing the transgender community to choose their preferred bathroom: sexual harassment. Many activists have urged that transgender people should be able to go to which ever bathroom they feel more comfortable in; now although it sounds like a nice idea, it doesn’t work because there are people out there who do stupid things for their own gain; allowing this bathroom policy to pass would only make it easier for sexual predators to harass and abuse the public. One of the many examples of sexual predators using these bathroom rights for
Transgender is the term used to describe an individual whose gender identity does not align with their sex assigned at birth. The documentary, “Growing up Trans”, is a sensitive clip to watch about young youths who attempt to navigate family, friends, gender, and the medical decisions they face at puberty. “Growing up Trans” focuses mainly on transitioned young youths. The transgender youth from the documentary links to many theories from chapter eight. Theories such as socialization, gender, sexuality, homophobia, transphobia, and microaggression are associated with “Growing up Trans”.
A male can not go into a female toilet but this program is allowing them to go in the opposite sex privacy areas. But at every school there are different rules e.g. Some schools might allow if you have the opposite sex clothes on thats the change room and toilets you go in. Some schools might have it that you go in the same toilets until it has been changed on your birth
Gender neutral bathrooms will always be a topic of discussion in everyone lives, however the emotional and economic toll the restrooms would have on others could change someone’s life for the worse. If transgender male and females used their biological corresponding gender facilities, we could lessen those tolls to a minimum. The IOC has tried effortlessly to expand the opportunities for transgender athletes, but just reducing the amount of hormones in the athlete cannot change that they will always have an advantage over non-transgender competitors. One may see the tenacity and the empowerment of transgender movements unnecessary and annoying, but hopefully in future, everyone will see that these peoples stories should inspire others to stand up for what they believe