Transnational Mothering: Article Analysis
Firstly, transnational mothering gives women the feeling of mental instability that affects them emotionally due to the precarious work they are required to do. In Sedef Arat- Koç's article the concept of transnational mothering is defined as immigrant women coming into Canada as domestic workers by leaving their own children behind in their home country in order to look after the children of employers(Arat- Koç's, 364). The notion of transnational mothering is seen as a form of social reproduction that plays a major role in the health of immigrant women which leads them to subjective trauma. Through his article he shows the experiences of the immigrant women coping with long term periods of separation from their families and the psychological dimensions …show more content…
Additionally, it was not just powerful feelings of responsibility and guilt that made family separation painful for immigrant domestic workers, however it was a deprivation of the women's own needs for intimacy and support because they were doing this for their families back home and needed family encouragement to keep going. Transnational mothering is a case that illustrates the increase in the transnationalization of reproductive work that crystallizes the inhumanity of capitalist reproduction at the global level and to hide problems of the organization under a neo-liberal state. This relates to the weak welfare state and how the choice for some immigrant women to become employed as domestic workers is based on class privileges that employers take advantage of because employers hire vulnerable and underpaid immigrant workers. Arat- Koç implies the concept of precarious work of how these immigrant mothers are treated unfairly due to the rights which they are given and suffer mentally from the separation and neglect from their
Summary Of Canada's Immigration System Is No Kinder
1357 Words | 6 Pages, Jeffery Reitz emphasizes multiculturalism as a vital element to “[the promotion] of the integration of immigrants into mainstream society”, synonymous with “cultural freedom”. In fact, Reitz cites multiculturalism as one of four pillars vital to the successful social integration of immigrants. Today, the current denial of family sponsorship and reunification for Temporary Foreign Workers forces migrants to choose between life
Revolutionary Mothers Analysis
635 Words | 3 PagesIntroduction The American Revolution was a very long and extensive war that lasted from 1775 until 1783, and as a result America gained its independence. It is very imperative to highlight the significant role that women played during the American Revolution. During this era a woman was often portrayed as illiterate, child-bearing mother, and a homemaker.
Gender Biases In Barbara Kingsolver's The Bean Trees
799 Words | 4 PagesIn addition, to avoid responsibility, “soon after [hearing of the pregnancy] the boy’s father got transferred from Tucson and the whole family moved to Oakland, California” (89). Sandi recognizes her position as a poor single mother and challenges it. By working, Sandi provides for herself and her child, subsequently defying the stereotype that are the sole men providers in a woman’s
Portuguese Immigrant Family Analysis
1239 Words | 5 Pages1)The first article is called Portuguese Immigrant Families: The Impact of Acculturation this was written by MARIE MORRISON, M.A. and SUSAN JAMES, PH.D.. This article helps us understand what happens when some Portuguese families move to the United States and how they are able to be able to change adapt to the change in cultures. It also looks at how it affects their thinking. Morrison and James describes acculturations as “when groups of individuals having different cultures come into continuous, first-hand contact, with subsequent changes in the original culture pat- terns of either or both groups’’.
Separation And Reunification Among Immigrant Families, By Reyna Grande
809 Words | 4 PagesThe article “Making Up For the Lost Time: The Experience of Separation and Reunification Among Immigrant Families” by Carloa Suarez-Orozco et al. states that families who undergo the immigration process such as leaving to go to a new country causes separation between their children, emotionally, psychological, and behavioral. For instance, Grande’s father, Natalio left his family to work in the U.S. to provide for his family, Grande being at the age two years old and having no memory of him but the man behind the glass, was separated from her father at a young age. This indicates that while the Grande family was separated for a long period, they had all lost the connection they once had between them, the bond. Growing up, Grande’s parents were never around, her siblings, Mago and Carlos experienced separation at a young age.
Crooks Mental Health
1084 Words | 5 PagesThe mental health state of the various immigrants groups were wide-ranging. However, the groups were lumped together regardless of their varying culture backgrounds. The conclusion was that more specific research needs to done to address the diverse immigrant populations because the current is too limited to
Domestic Immigrant Workers Cleaning
911 Words | 4 PagesDomestica: Immigrant Workers Cleaning and Caring in the Shadows of Affluence is a powerful book by Pierrette Hondagneu-Sotelo, that exposes the everyday realities of undocumented female workers in Los Angeles, California. The purpose of this book is to challenge the reader to shape domestic policies that will bring basic principles of human rights and social justice into this invisible realm of domestic labor. Although domestic labor is clearly visible, this type of employment is treated as invisible because the employers refuse to view themselves as people that are hiring individuals to clean their homes. In addition, the employees being hired refuse to acknowledge domestic labor as a job because through patriarchal ideology house cleaning is attached to women, thus they view it as a type of hobby. By challenging the state of thought that patriarchy has produced, women will view domestic labor as what it truly is.
Exploratory Essay
1374 Words | 6 PagesMaternity leave is the one thing that characterises the overall stature of women in the workforce. This is because it is the backdrop alluding to the basic human rights in the workplace, and yet, is the main cause of segregation in the workforce, highlighting gender
African American Women
1430 Words | 6 PagesMany do not consider domestic labor as “work”. Women’s unpaid labor in the home maintains systems of oppression. One way unpaid domestic labor maintains systems of oppression is because men benefit from the domestic labor that women perform and they expect women to do it. It reenforces the idea that women are there to take care of the children
Essay On Mexican Migrant Women
665 Words | 3 PagesMigrant families now need dual incomes to be able to survive “...thus, women’s work is not simply secondary but equal to that of men.” (Zhao, 90) Women now play an integral in supporting their family.
Come Closer To Feminism For Everybody Analysis
659 Words | 3 PagesWomen from the Philippines, Mexico, Indonesia, Thailand and Korea depart their homes in the search for a better life for their children and family. Today women travel to wealthy countries like the United States, Germany and the United Kingdom take jobs as nannies leaving their children behind to be taken care by mother's, aunt and sometimes even orphanages. These women sacrifice the love they are expected to give to their children to provide material goods to ensure their survival and flourishing in today's society. These women sell their love for children in rich countries so that their own children can have a life similar to that of the children they learn to live in the absence of their own children. Love has become a good that is extracted from poor countries to that of the wealthy countries as described by Barbara Ehrenreich and Arlie Russell
Motherhood In The Yellow Wallpaper And I Stand Here Ironing
1619 Words | 7 PagesThe concept of motherhood and the role of women have existed since the beginning of time and throughout various points it has differ. There is no limit to what can be considered motherhood. To one person, motherhood might mean the act of raising children and taking care of their family, and to another; motherhood might be what defines them as a person. This is seen in Tillie Olsen’s short story “I Stand Here Ironing” and the “Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman. In both stories, the main characters were dealing with the struggles of motherhood and being a wife.
Gender Inequality In The Bell Jar
1804 Words | 8 PagesIn her conventional view, a woman must support her husband by creating an organized home and nurturing him. Women are not only in charge of doing the housework and childcare, but they have their own individual dreams they want to reach. It is discriminatory towards women when they live under the social expectations of being uneducated and a supported wife. From the textual support, it is evident that women struggle to reach their individual goals under a male-dominant society that require women to be
Essay On Social Reproduction
1088 Words | 5 PagesWhether reproducing workers or gender norms, social reproduction can be defined as the process of reproducing the capacity to continue working, leading to the reproduction of the pseudo-commodity known as labour power. The reproduction of this labour power is reliant upon unwaged, domestic labour to help replenish the labourer for the next day of work. Reproducing this worker, typically the male breadwinner, is reliant upon women’s unpaid labour, creating the nuclear family form. Armstrong believes social reproduction involves the processes of “socializing children, repressing sexuality, and instilling appropriate hierarchical relationships through the education of future workers” (Armstrong, [ ] , p. 74). Peck views social reproduction in a spherical configuration, distinguishing the multiple factors involved in reproducing people, such as education, training, the media, and biological procreation (Peck, [ ], p. 38).
Nancy Scheper's Analysis
118 Words | 1 PagesNancy Scheper-Hughes uses the term to call the pattern that women in the Alto do Cruzeiro differentiated infants to be kept from ones to die of neglect while delaying attachment to their own infant (342). Poverty, culture and political situations caused mortal neglect and affected their maternal emotions and their behaviors in different ways from ours. However, their mother instinct was just differently expressed, as NSH states, “mortal selective neglect and intense maternal attachment coexist” (356). Thus, the term signifies that we should recognize the cultural dimension, without judging their emotions, behaviors, and life through our own lens. Even maternal love, which is regarded as mother instinct, is differently constructed and formed
More about Transnational Mothering: Article Analysis
Summary Of Canada's Immigration System Is No Kinder
1357 Words | 6 PagesRevolutionary Mothers Analysis
635 Words | 3 PagesGender Biases In Barbara Kingsolver's The Bean Trees
799 Words | 4 PagesPortuguese Immigrant Family Analysis
1239 Words | 5 PagesSeparation And Reunification Among Immigrant Families, By Reyna Grande
809 Words | 4 PagesCrooks Mental Health
1084 Words | 5 PagesDomestic Immigrant Workers Cleaning
911 Words | 4 PagesExploratory Essay
1374 Words | 6 PagesAfrican American Women
1430 Words | 6 PagesEssay On Mexican Migrant Women
665 Words | 3 PagesCome Closer To Feminism For Everybody Analysis
659 Words | 3 PagesMotherhood In The Yellow Wallpaper And I Stand Here Ironing
1619 Words | 7 PagesGender Inequality In The Bell Jar
1804 Words | 8 PagesEssay On Social Reproduction
1088 Words | 5 PagesNancy Scheper's Analysis
118 Words | 1 Pages